A systematic review and meta-analysis of major blood protein biomarkers that predict unfavorable outcomes in severe traumatic brain injury.

INTRODUCTION: Severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) presentation and late clinical outcomes are usually evaluated by the Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended (GOS-E), which lacks strong prognostic predictability. Several blood biomarkers have been linked to TBI, such as Tau, GFAP, UCH-L1, S-100B, and NSE. Clinical values of TBI biomarkers have yet to be evaluated in a focused multi-study meta-analysis. We reviewed relevant articles evaluating potential relationships between TBI biomarkers and both early and 6-month outcomes. METHODS: All PubMed article publications from January 2000 to November 2023 with the search criteria "Protein Biomarker" AND "Traumatic Brain Injury" were included. Amongst all comparative studies, the sensitivity means and range values of biomarkers in predicting CT Rotterdam scores, ICU admission in the early period, or predicting GOS-E < 4 at the 6-month period were calculated from confusion matrices. Sensitivity values were modeled for each biomarker across studies and compared statistically for heterogeneity and differences. RESULTS: From the 65 articles that met the criteria, 13 were included in this study. Six articles involved early-period TBI outcomes and seven involved 6-month outcomes. In the early period TBI outcomes, GFAP had a superior sensitivity to UCH-L1 and S-100B, and similar sensitivity to the CT Rotterdam score. In the 6-month period TBI outcomes, total Tau and NSE both had significant interstudy heterogeneity, making them inferior to GFAP, phosphorylated Tau, UCH-L1, and S-100B, all four of which had similar sensitivities at 75 %. This sensitivity range at 6-month outcomes was still relatively inferior to the CT Rotterdam score. Total Tau did not show any prognostic advantage at six months with GOS-E < 4, and phosphorylated Tau was similar in its sensitivity to other biomarkers such as GFAP and UCH-L1 and still inferior to the CT Rotterdam score. CONCLUSION: This data suggests that TBI protein biomarkers do not possess better prognostic value with regards to outcomes.

Evaluation of Retrospective Patient Preference on Extent of Resection of Nonfunctioning Pituitary Adenomas.

BACKGROUND: Neurosurgeons treat nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas by surgical resection. Based on the adherence of the tumor to the normal pituitary gland, operative risks may include hormone replacement therapy for postoperative hypopituitarism with gross total resection that injures the gland or recurrent tumor with subtotal resection and purposeful avoidance of gland manipulation. None of the patients presented in this article had a preoperative preference regarding extent of resection. This study aimed to evaluate postoperative patient preferences regarding extent of resection. METHODS: Adult patients who underwent resection of adenomas between 2015 and 2023 were retrospectively reviewed and surveyed. After surgery, participating patients were asked for their preference regarding 100% tumor resection with lifelong daily hormone replacement therapy versus 90% tumor resection with a chance of recurrence in the hypothetical situation where the neurosurgeon encounters tumor adherent to the normal gland. RESULTS: Of the 73 patients included, 54 (74.0%) responded to the survey, with the majority (36 [66.7%]) preferring 90% resection with the chance of tumor recurrence. Tumor recurrence (odds ratio 2.3, 95% confidence interval 2.1-2.5, P = 0.03) and steroid avoidance (odds ratio 2.2, 95% confidence interval 2.0-2.4, P = 0.04) were the 2 variables that were significant predictors of patient preference in multivariate regression analysis. CONCLUSIONS: Although patients may not have the preoperative insight or experience to have a strong conviction regarding the extent of adenoma resection, the consequences following surgery clearly influence their preference. Most patients in our study, including patients with gross total resection and especially patients who experienced side effects of steroid therapy, preferred subtotal resection with the chance of tumor recurrence over hormone replacement therapy.