Clock-drawing: is it the ideal cognitive screening test?

OBJECTIVE: The clock-drawing test has achieved widespread clinical use in recent years as a cognitive screening instrument and a significant amount of literature relates to its psychometric properties and clinical utility. This review aims to synthesize the available evidence and assess the value of this screening test according to well-defined criteria. DESIGN: A Medline and Psycho-info literature search of all languages was done from 1983 to 1998 including manual cross-referencing of bibliographies. A brief summary of all original scoring systems is provided as well as a review of replication studies. Psychometric data including correlations with other cognitive tests were recorded. Qualitative aspects of the test are also described. RESULTS: Among published studies, the mean sensitivity (85%) and specificity (85%) of the clock-drawing test are impressive. Correlations with the Mini-Mental State Examination and other cognitive tests was high, generally greater than r = 0.5. High levels of inter-rater and test-re-test reliability and positive predictive value are recorded and despite significant variability in the scoring systems, all report similar psychometric properties. The clock test also shows a sensitivity to cognitive change with good predictive validity. CONCLUSIONS: The clock-drawing test meets defined criteria for a cognitive screening instrument. It taps into a wide range of cognitive abilities including executive functions, is quick and easy to administer and score with excellent acceptability by subjects. Together with informant reports, the clock-drawing test is complementary to the widely used and validated Mini-Mental State Examination and should provide a significant advance in the early detection of dementia and in monitoring cognitive change. A simple scoring system with emphasis on the qualitative aspects of clock-drawing should maximize its utility.

Differential pharmacokinetics of lithium in elderly patients.

The pharmacotherapeutic use of lithium in the elderly as acute and maintenance therapy in bipolar disorder and augmentation therapy for major depression is well documented. Differences in the response to lithium are explained, in part, by the effect of age-related physiological changes, comorbid conditions, and concurrent medications on the pharmacokinetics of lithium in the elderly. The pharmacokinetic profile of lithium has been studied for many years, primarily in younger adult populations. Lithium pharmacokinetics may be influenced by a number of factors including age. It was first noted several years ago that elderly individuals required lower doses of lithium to achieve serum concentrations similar to those observed in younger adults. This is due to the combination of a reduced volume of distribution and reduced renal clearance. The composition of the human body changes with aging producing an increase in body fat, a decrease in fat-free mass and a decrease in total body water. Lithium clearance decreases as the glomerular filtration rate decreases with increasing age. The effects of other medical conditions in the elderly on the pharmacokinetics of lithium are less well delineated. Reduced lithium clearance is expected in patients with hypertension, congestive heart failure or renal dysfunction. Larger lithium maintenance doses are required in obese compared with non-obese patients. The most clinically significant pharmacokinetic drug interactions associated with lithium involve drugs which are commonly used in the elderly. Thiazide diuretics, ACE inhibitors, and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs can increase serum lithium concentrations. The tolerability of lithium is lower in the elderly. Neurotoxicity clearly occurs in the elderly at concentrations considered 'therapeutic' in general adult populations. There are no placebo-controlled randomised trials of lithium in old age and recommendations for clinical use are based on extrapolations from pharmacokinetic studies, anecdotal reports from mixed age populations and clinical experience in old age psychiatry. Serum concentrations of lithium need to be markedly reduced in the elderly population and particularly so in the very old and frail elderly.

The nature and management of mania in old age.

Mania in old age represents a syndrome involving affective vulnerability in association with neurologic lesions that affect specific areas of the brain. Most patients suffering from mania in late life have converted to bipolarity later in life after many years and often repeated episodes of depression or else have developed mania in association with specific neurologic insults, particularly cerebrovascular disease (vascular mania). The outcome is generally worse in mania than in depression with higher prevalence of cognitive dysfunction, persistent symptoms, and greater mortality. The management of elderly bipolar patients with mood stabilizers reflects the experience with a mixed age population primarily involving the use of lithium carbonate and valproate in appropriately adjusted dosages and serum levels, with valproate having an edge on better tolerability. The use of neuroleptics is often unavoidable in initial stabilization, and electroconvulsive therapy can be life-saving in severely overactive or refractory patients.

The effectiveness of antidepressants in elderly depressed outpatients: a prospective case series study.

BACKGROUND: This study examined the effectiveness of antidepressants in a group of elderly depressed outpatients by assessing depression prevalence and recording adverse events over time. METHOD: A prospective practice-based observational study (1991-1994) included consecutive outpatients at least 65 years of age with a DSM-III-R diagnosis of major affective disorder and who were prescribed antidepressant medications. Depressive symptoms were examined over time (stage 1 = 0 to 2 months; stage 2 = 2 to 6 months; stage 3 = 6 months to 2 years) with the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS). The cutoff scores of MADRS <18 and MADRS > or =18 were used in survival statistics. Adverse events were recorded systematically. RESULTS: A total of 213 patients were seen over 2677 visits (mean +/- SD age = 75.5+/-6.1 years). MADRS scores for 85.8% of patients declined to below 18 within the first 2 months of antidepressant treatment. MADRS scores were above 18 for 37.3% of patients after 6 months and for 37.1% after 2 years. The mean time to decline in MADRS scores to below 18 in stage 1 was 36.1 days, and there was a significant difference between the antidepressant classes (log rank = 8.3, df = 3, p = .04), with tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) and monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs)/reversible inhibitors of monoamine oxidase A (RIMAs) having shorter times to response. The mean time to reach scores above cutoff during stage 2 was 144.3 days (log rank = 5.7, df = 3, p = .13) and during stage 3, 538.6 days (log rank = 9.8, df = 3, p = .02). Patients receiving TCAs and MAOIs/RIMAs had longer durations of MADRS scores below cutoff during stage 3 than those taking atypical antidepressants and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. All antidepressant classes reported similar adverse event profiles. CONCLUSION: This study systematically examined antidepressant effectiveness in a prospective design. TCAs and MAOIs/RIMAs were shown to be superior in effectiveness during 2 of the 3 treatment stages.

Bipolar disorder in old age.

OBJECTIVE: To review the classification, clinical characteristics, and epidemiology of bipolar disorders in old age with a special focus on neurologic comorbidity, high mortality, and management. QUALITY OF EVIDENCE: Most available data is gleaned from retrospective chart reviews and cohort studies. Treatment recommendations are based on evidence from younger populations and a few anecdotal case reports and series involving elderly people. MAIN MESSAGE: While relatively rare in the community setting, mania in old age frequently leads to hospitalization. It is associated with late-onset neurologic disorders (especially cerebrovascular disease) involving the right hemisphere and orbitofrontal cortex. Prognosis is relatively poor; morbidity and mortality rates are high. Management of bipolarity includes cautious use of mood stabilizers, especially lithium and divalproex. CONCLUSIONS: Mania in old age should trigger a careful assessment of underlying neurologic disease, especially cerebrovascular disease. Close clinical follow up is essential.

Refining the MAOI diet: tyramine content of pizzas and soy products.

BACKGROUND: Continuous refinement of the monoamine oxidase inhibitor (MAOI) diet has resulted in much reduced and simplified recommendations that attempt to balance safety and practicality. In the spirit of evidence-based practice, dietary restrictions should be based on carefully documented case reports and valid tyramine analyses. Residual concerns have focused on combination foods such as pizza and a variety of soy products. We determined the tyramine content of pizzas and a variety of soy products in order to refine dietary recommendations for use with MAOIs. METHOD: High-pressure liquid chromatography analysis of tyramine content was performed on a variety of pizzas, soy sauces, and other soybean products. A tyramine level of 6 mg or less was considered safe. RESULTS: No significant tyramine levels were found in any of the pizzas, including those with double pepperoni and double cheese. Marked variability was found in soy products, including clinically significant tyramine levels in tofu when stored for a week and high tyramine content in one of the soy sauces. CONCLUSION: Pizzas from large chain commercial outlets are safe for consumption with MAOIs. However, caution must be exercised if ordering pizzas from smaller outlets or gourmet pizzas known to contain aged cheeses. All soybean products should be avoided, especially soy sauce and tofu. Individualized counseling and continuous surveillance of compliance are still essential.

The use of clock tests in schizophrenia.

Though clock drawing tests are well recognized as measures of cognitive function, there is little data on the performance of patients with schizophrenia. We compared 24 patients with schizophrenia to 24 healthy, age-matched controls on clock drawing, copying, and reading. Patients with schizophrenia performed significantly worse on clock drawing and copying despite the fact that the groups had similar scores on the MMSE. Worse performance was associated with higher scores on the BPRS. Clock drawing and copying may be useful for the assessment of cognition in schizophrenia, and the monitoring of cognitive changes associated with antipsychotic medication.

Clock tests in depression, Alzheimer's disease, and elderly controls.

OBJECTIVE: While clock-drawing tests are commonly used to screen for cognitive impairment in the elderly, little is known about the performance of elderly depressives. METHODS: We compared thirty-three patients with major depression to forty-two Alzheimer's disease and thirty age-matched controls on clock-drawing, copying, and reading. RESULTS: Patients with Alzheimer's disease had significantly lower scores on clock-drawing, copying, and reading than patients with depression or the controls (p < 0.05). Patients with depression did not differ significantly from controls on quantitative scores or qualitative errors. CONCLUSIONS: Clock tests may be useful for identifying depressed patients with underlying dementia.

Fuzzy logic pharmacokinetic modeling: application to lithium concentration prediction.

INTRODUCTION: We hypothesized that fuzzy logic could be used for pharmacokinetic modeling. Our objectives were to develop and evaluate a model for predicting serum lithium concentrations with fuzzy logic. METHODS: Steady-state pharmacokinetic data had been previously collected in 10 elderly patients (age range, 67 to 80 years) with depression who were receiving lithium once daily. Each patient had serial serum lithium concentration determinations over one 24-hour period. The resulting 137 data sets initially consisted of five input variables (age, weight, serum creatinine, lithium dose, and time since last dose) and one output variable (serum lithium concentration; range, 0.2 to 1.24 mmol/L). RESULTS: A fuzzy rulebase was created with 87 randomly chosen data sets, and predictions of serum lithium concentration were made on the basis of the remaining 50 data sets. All of the input variables except age and weight were identified as contributing to the fuzzy logic model. The average magnitude of the error in the predictions was 0.13 mmol/L (root mean squared error) with a bias (mean of the prediction errors) of 0.03 mmol/L. CONCLUSIONS: This study indicates that the use of fuzzy logic for pharmacokinetic modeling of lithium for serum concentration predictions is feasible.

Tap (draft) beer and monoamine oxidase inhibitor dietary restrictions.

OBJECTIVE: Traditional monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) continue to play an important role in the management of a wide variety of clinical conditions. Accordingly, a practical and safe approach to MAOI dietary restrictions remains an essential component of patient management. METHOD: In an effort to refine MAOI dietary recommendations, we report a case of hypertensive crisis following the consumption of a modest amount of tap beer. RESULTS: A well-documented case report involving tap (draft) beer consumed while on an MAOI supports an earlier study, which recommended that all tap beers be restricted on MAOI diets. The 2 cases were remarkably similar in terms of the offending substance, quantity consumed, and subsequent reaction. CONCLUSIONS: As a result of recent tyramine analyses and 2 well-documented case reports, all tap (draft) beers should now be absolutely restricted on MAOI diets because they represent a very significant risk at modest levels of consumption.

Gradual discontinuation of lithium augmentation in elderly patients with unipolar depression.

Recently, the therapeutic benefit of lithium augmentation in old age has come into question. These data, in light of the documented high incidence of side effects after lithium use in elderly patients, resulted in the design of a prospective, placebo-controlled lithium augmentation withdrawal study in elderly patients with unipolar depression. Twelve eligible geriatric patients (10 women and 2 men; mean [+/-SD] age, 76.2 +/- 5.7 years) with DSM-III-R unipolar depression receiving adjunct lithium therapy were randomized to receive continued lithium augmentation or matching placebo (withdrawal rate 150 mg/day/wk). At each clinic visit, patients were assessed for depression (Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale and Geriatric Depression Rating Scale) and lithium-induced toxicities (a 21-item side-effect checklist, renal and thyroid biochemistry). Over the 2-year observation period, the placebo group reported a decrease in composite 21-item side-effect score and specific lithium toxicities (e.g., urinary urgency, hand tremor, and renal/thyroid abnormalities). Two patients in the lithium maintenance group had a recurrence of depression at 61 and 96 weeks, respectively, immediately after a stressful life event (cerebrovascular accident [CVA] or death of spouse), and two patients had a recurrence in the placebo group at 7 and 92 weeks, respectively, without any apparent changes in life stresses. No other prognostic risk factors for recurrence were identified. Depression that recurred in patients who were receiving placebo was relatively resistant to reinstitution of lithium augmentation therapy. In otherwise stable geriatric patients with unipolar depression, the documented benefits of reduced side effects should be weighed against the risk of recurrence and subsequent lithium resistance before withdrawal of lithium augmentation.

Treatment of elderly institutionalized bipolar patients with clozapine.

In an open trial, clozapine was used to treat 3 elderly (mean age 72 +/- 2.5 years) institutionalized male patients with bipolar I disorder, most recent episode manic, severe with psychotic features. All patients were refractory or intolerant of treatment with lithium, valproate, benzodiazepines, and traditional neuroleptics both alone and in combination. Response to clozapine was determined using the Severity of Illness score on the Clinical Global Impression (CGI) scale (1 = normal, not at all ill, 7 = among the most extremely ill). Pre-clozapine severity of illness scores on the CGI averaged 6.33 +/- 0.6; post-clozapine CGI scores averaged 2.0 +/- 1.0 (t = 13.00, df = 2, p < .01). The therapeutic dosage of clozapine varied (range = 25-112.5 mg/day). There were no significant drops in granulocyte counts. Followup revealed sustained improvement over an average of 11 months. These dramatic results suggest that clozapine may be an effective alternative treatment for similar patients and that prospective trials are warranted.

Neurologic comorbidity and mania in old age.

This review focuses on the clear association of a wide range of neurological disorders with the clinical phenomenon of mania in old age. The nature of these neurologic disorders is described and discussed. The significance of this association in the context of premorbid vulnerability to mood disorders, late age of onset, and high mortality at follow-up is discussed and integrated into a comprehensive model for the understanding of mania in old age. The author outlines future research directions that may enhance our understanding of mania in old age, as well as in younger age groups.

Disinhibition syndromes, secondary mania and bipolar disorder in old age.

BACKGROUND: The neurological literature concerning disinhibition syndromes and secondary mania has run in parallel to clinical reports of bipolar disorder in old age. METHODS: A critical review was conducted of both the neurological and geriatric psychiatry literature in an attempt to integrate the two streams. RESULTS: Disinhibition syndromes include lateralization to the right hemisphere and localization of lesions to the orbito-frontal and basotemporal cortex involving limbic and frontal connections (orbito-frontal circuit). Mania in old age is associated with late onset, heterogeneous neurological disorders and poor outcome. CONCLUSION: Bipolar disorders in old age may be understood in the context of affective vulnerability influenced by a specific neurobiologic substrate. LIMITATIONS: The clinical literature consists predominantly of small case series and anecdotal reports. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Improved understanding of these syndromes may elucidate the pathogenesis and etiology of bipolar disorders and the neuropsychiatric syndromes affecting mood, motivation and behavioural disinhibition.

The efficacy, safety and tolerability of antidepressants in late life depression: a meta-analysis.

BACKGROUND: To determine the efficacy, safety and tolerability of antidepressants in depressed elderly patients. METHODS: Search for randomized controlled double-blind studies evaluating atypical antidepressants (ATYPs), reversible inhibitors of monoamine oxidase-A, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and tricyclic antidepressants in moderate/severe depressed patients > or = 60 years for > or = four weeks. The random effects model (single-arm; comparative) was used to aggregate efficacy, safety and dropout. RESULTS: No difference in single-arm aggregation of outcomes for four antidepressant classes. Comparative analyses showed no statistical difference between outcomes, except SSRIs had a higher response rate than ATYPs. CONCLUSION: Elderly show no differences in antidepressant class outcomes. LIMITATIONS: Heterogeneity and lack of power. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: There is little advantage for antidepressant classes over another in the aged.

Revolutionary versus evolutionary change: the experience of a university hospital department of psychiatry.

In the spring of 1991, the Department of Psychiatry at Sunnybrook Health Science Centre chose to undergo a major reorganization in an attempt to better meet the needs of patients as well as the academic and research requirements of the University of Toronto. This brief report describes the circumstances leading up to the decision to make a "revolutionary" change, the department's experiences during the period of radical change and the impacts of the change process.

Tyramine content of previously restricted foods in monoamine oxidase inhibitor diets.

Traditional monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) remain an important class of drugs for a variety of psychiatric conditions, including depressive illnesses, anxiety, and eating disorders. It was the objective of this study to refine the MAOI diet by determining the tyramine content of a variety of untested and "controversial" foods that continue to appear on MAOI diet-restricted food lists. A secondary objective of the study was to evaluate the effect of freshness on the tyramine content of some foods. Fifty-one food samples were evaluated for tyramine content by liquid chromatography. Food samples included a selection of sausages, beverages, sliced meat products, including chicken liver, and some fruits, including raspberries, bananas, and banana peels. Foods that were found to have dangerously high concentrations of tyramine (> or = 6 mg/serving) included chicken liver aged 9 days (63.84 mg/30 g), air-dried sausage (7.56 g/30 g), soy sauce (0.941 mg/ml), and sauerkraut (7.75 mg/250 g). Of the foods analyzed in this study, only those with high tyramine content per serving should continue to be absolutely restricted. All other foods are either safe for consumption or safe in moderation. The data provided should be combined with the data from other similar analytical studies to develop a list of foods that should be absolutely restricted. A more accurate list of restricted foods may enhance patient dietary compliance.

The making of a user friendly MAOI diet.

BACKGROUND: Many monoamine oxidase inhibitor (MAOI) diets are considered to be excessively restrictive and founded on poor scientific evidence. We present a safe and practical MAOI diet based on the related clinical and analytic data. METHOD: We used a critical review of the literature and our own tyramine assay results to categorize foods to be restricted absolutely, taken in moderation only, or unrestricted. RESULTS: We recommend that users avoid aged cheese; aged or cured meats (e.g., air-dried sausage); any potentially spoiled meat, poultry, or fish; broad (fava) bean pods; Marmite concentrated yeast extract; sauerkraut; soy sauce and soy bean condiments; and tap beer. Wine and domestic bottled or canned beer are considered safe when consumed in moderation. Other foods not mentioned are considered unrestricted. CONCLUSION: The concerns about perpetuating an overly restrictive MAOI diet include the avoidance by prescribers of a potentially useful treatment option, excessive limitations on lifestyle for patients, and increased risk to patients secondary to noncompliance with the diet. We propose an MAOI diet that has a solid scientific and clinical basis and that is, above all, practical.