Lactate efflux and the neuroenergetic basis of brain function.

In the unstimulated brain energy is primarily supplied by the oxidation of glucose. However the oxygen-to-glucose index (OGI), which is the ratio of metabolic rates of oxygen to glucose, CMR(O2)/CMR(glc), diverges from the theoretical value of 6 as activity is increased. In vivo measurements of brain lactate show its concentration to increase with stimulation. The decreasing OGI with stimulation had led to the suggestion that activation, unlike resting activity, is supported by anaerobic glycolysis. To date a unifying concept that accommodates glucose oxidation at rest with lactate generation and OGI decrease during stimulation of brain is lacking. Furthermore, energetics that change with increasing activity are not consistent with a neuroenergetic model that has been proposed from 1-(13)C-glucose MRS experiments. That model, based upon in vivo MRS measurements and cellular studies by Pellerin and Magistretti, showed that glutamate neurotransmitter cycling was coupled to glucose oxidation over a wide range of brain activities from rest down to deep anesthesia. Here we reconcile these paradoxical observations by suggesting that anaerobic glucose consumption (which can provide energy rapidly) increases with activation to meet the power requirements of millisecond neuronal firing. It is proposed, in accord with our neuroenergetic model, that the extra glucose mobilized rapidly for glial clearance of glutamate, is not needed for the oxidative processes that are responsible for neuronal firing and glutamate release, and consequently it is effluxed as lactate. A stoichiometric relation between OGI and lactate concentration is derived from the neuroenergetic model, showing that the enhanced glucose uptake during activation is consistent with neuronal activity being energetically supported by glucose oxidation.

Cerebral energetics and the glycogen shunt: neurochemical basis of functional imaging.

Positron-emission tomography and functional MRS imaging signals can be analyzed to derive neurophysiological values of cerebral blood flow or volume and cerebral metabolic consumption rates of glucose (CMR(Glc)) or oxygen (CMR(O(2))). Under basal physiological conditions in the adult mammalian brain, glucose oxidation is nearly complete so that the oxygen-to-glucose index (OGI), given by the ratio of CMR(O(2))/CMR(Glc), is close to the stoichiometric value of 6. However, a survey of functional imaging data suggests that the OGI is activity dependent, moving further below the oxidative value of 6 as activity is increased. Brain lactate concentrations also increase with stimulation. These results had led to the concept that brain activation is supported by anaerobic glucose metabolism, which was inconsistent with basal glucose oxidation. These differences are resolved here by a proposed model of glucose energetics, in which a fraction of glucose is cycled through the cerebral glycogen pool, a fraction that increases with degree of brain activation. The "glycogen shunt," although energetically less efficient than glycolysis, is followed because of its ability to supply glial energy in milliseconds for rapid neurotransmitter clearance, as a consequence of which OGI is lowered and lactate is increased. The value of OGI observed is consistent with passive lactate efflux, driven by the observed lactate concentration, for the few experiments with complete data. Although the OGI changes during activation, the energies required per neurotransmitter release (neuronal) and clearance (glial) are constant over a wide range of brain activity.

Flux control in the rat gastrocnemius glycogen synthesis pathway by in vivo 13C/31P NMR spectroscopy.

To determine the relative contributions of glucose transport/hexokinase, glycogen synthase (GSase), and glycolysis to the control of insulin-stimulated muscle glycogen synthesis, we combined 13C and 31P NMR to quantitate the glycogen synthesis rate and glucose 6-phosphate (G-6-P) levels in rat (Sprague-Dawley) gastrocnemius muscle during hyperinsulinemia at euglycemic (E) and hyperglycemic (H) glucose concentrations under thiopental anesthesia. Flux control was calculated using metabolic control analysis. The combined control coefficient of glucose transport/hexokinase (GT/Hk) for glycogen synthesis was 1.1 +/- 0.03 (direct measure) and 1.14-1.16 (calculated for a range of glycolytic fluxes), whereas the control coefficient for GSase was much lower (0.011-0.448). We also observed that the increase in in vivo [G-6-P] from E to H (0.22 +/- 0.03 to 0.40 +/- 0.03 mM) effects a supralinear increase in the in vitro velocity of GSase, from 14.6 to 26.1 mU. kg(-1). min(-1) (1.8-fold). All measurements suggest that the majority of the flux control of muscle glycogen synthesis is at the GT/Hk step.

13C NMR of intermediary metabolism: implications for systemic physiology.

The study of intermediary metabolism in biomolecules has been given new directions by recent experiments in human muscle and brain by 13C NMR. Labeled substrates, generally glucose, have enabled the fluxes to be determined in vivo, whereas the naturally abundant 13C has enabled concentrations to be measured. In muscle the glycogen synthesis pathway has been measured and the flux control determined by metabolic control analysis of data, which shows that this pathway is mainly responsible for insulin-stimulated glucose disposal and that a deficiency in the glucose transporter in the pathway is responsible for hyperglycemia in non-insulin-dependent diabetics. From a physiological point of view the most surprising result was that the heavily regulated allosteric enzyme, glycogen synthase, does not control flux but is needed to maintain homeostasis during flux changes. This novel role for a phosphorylated allosteric enzyme is proposed to be a general phenomenon in metabolic and signaling pathways, which physiologically link different cellular activities. In human and rat brains 13C NMR measurements of the flow of labeled glucose into glutamate and glutamine simultaneously determine the rate of glucose oxidation and glutamate neurotransmitter cycling and reveal a 1:1 stoichiometry between the two fluxes. Implications for the interpretation of functional imaging studies and for psychology are discussed. These results demonstrate how intermediary metabolism serves to connect biochemistry with systemic physiology when measured and analyzed by in vivo NMR methods.

The "glycogen shunt" in exercising muscle: A role for glycogen in muscle energetics and fatigue.

Stimulated by recent (13)C and (31)P NMR studies of exercising muscle, we propose a model of the energetics of contraction. Previous studies of energetics have followed energy consumption. However, the rapidity of contraction, in 10-40 msec, requires that energy be delivered rapidly, so that the muscle has power requirements of rapid energy expenditure that are ultimately met by the slower averaged consumption of carbon and oxygen from blood. We propose that energy is supplied in milliseconds by glycogenolysis and that between contractions, glycogenesis refills the pools. The energy for glycogenesis is supplied by oxidative phosphorylation. This mechanism utilizes the rapid conversion of glycogen phosphorylase, the "fight-or-flight" enzyme, to its active form. Lactate is necessarily generated by this pathway to serve as a time buffer between fast and slow energy needs, which resolves the paradoxical generation of lactate in well oxygenated tissue. Consequences of the glycogen shunt are compatible with numerous biochemical and physiological experiments. The model provides a possible mechanism for muscle fatigue, suggesting that at low but nonzero glycogen concentrations, there is not enough glycogen to supply millisecond energy needs.

In vivo (13)C NMR measurement of neurotransmitter glutamate cycling, anaplerosis and TCA cycle flux in rat brain during.

The aims of this study were twofold: (i) to determine quantitatively the contribution of glutamate/glutamine cycling to total astrocyte/neuron substrate trafficking for the replenishment of neurotransmitter glutamate; and (ii) to determine the relative contributions of anaplerotic flux and glutamate/glutamine cycling to total glutamine synthesis. In this work in vivo and in vitro (13)C NMR spectroscopy were used, with a [2-(13)C]glucose or [5-(13)C]glucose infusion, to determine the rates of glutamate/glutamine cycling, de novo glutamine synthesis via anaplerosis, and the neuronal and astrocytic tricarboxylic acid cycles in the rat cerebral cortex. The rate of glutamate/glutamine cycling measured in this study is compared with that determined from re-analysis of (13)C NMR data acquired during a [1-(13)C]glucose infusion. The excellent agreement between these rates supports the hypothesis that glutamate/glutamine cycling is a major metabolic flux ( approximately 0.20 micromol/min/g) in the cerebral cortex of anesthetized rats and the predominant pathway of astrocyte/neuron trafficking of neurotransmitter glutamate precursors. Under normoammonemic conditions anaplerosis was found to comprise 19-26% of the total glutamine synthesis, whilst this fraction increased significantly during hyperammonemia ( approximately 32%). These findings indicate that anaplerotic glutamine synthesis is coupled to nitrogen removal from the brain (ammonia detoxification) under hyperammonemic conditions.

Functional imaging studies: linking mind and basic neuroscience.

OBJECTIVE: The imaging of brain activity with positron emission tomography (PET) and functional magnetic resonance imaging has assumed a central position in psychiatry. Functional imaging signals arise from changes in the neurophysiological parameters of glucose and oxygen consumption mediated by blood flow. METHOD: Recent in vivo (13)C nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) neurochemical studies have established a quantitative coupling between the rates of glucose oxidation and glutamate neurotransmitter flux in rats and humans, thereby linking measured neurophysiological parameters to brain function. RESULTS: These results show that in the awake, resting, and unstimulated states, 70%-80% of brain energy consumption is devoted to the same glutamate/glutamine neurotransmitter signaling as are the small percentages stimulated by tasks. Furthermore, in anesthetized animals, in which unstimulated activity is reduced, the total signal rather than a particular increment is required for a response. CONCLUSIONS: On this basis, the total signal, as well as the difference in the signal, measures cortical neurotransmitter flux. The total signal in a region therefore contains valuable information about required brain activity. Although signal change is often more easily measured, certain PET and (13)C NMR methods can quantify total regional signal activity and thereby provide another measure of neurotransmitter activity.

Spectroscopic contributions to the understanding of hemoglobin function: implications for structural biology.

Structural biology is based on the assumption that structural determinations will explain macromolecular function. To examine the basis of these proposals, the structure/function connections in hemoglobin have been examined. Presently the Monod, Wyman, Changeux (MWC) model of hemoglobin function has great validity. In this model, ligand-binding affinities are linked to quaternary structure, and it has been shown that the model describes the function accurately to a high first approximation. To see how this understanding developed, we review two sets of experimental studies in 1970-71 that supported the applicability of MWC to hemoglobin oxygen binding. One set of data from NMR and ligand binding kinetics supported the quaternary-linked nature of binding required by the MWC model. The other approach, by Perutz, proposed a structural basis for MWC, by suggesting that in one quaternary structure the binding of oxygen broke a salt bridge that caused a lowered quaternary-linked affinity. However, experiments since that time, mostly by X-ray crystallography of deoxygenated hemoglobin, have failed to show salt bridges breaking upon ligation, whereas affinities have remained low. This pattern of results shows that the small energies responsible for ligand-binding affinities and reaction rates have not been identified by discrete structural features. Rather, thermodynamic and kinetic data from a variety of spectroscopic studies have played the central role in establishing the MWC model for hemoglobin.

Assessment and discrimination of odor stimuli in rat olfactory bulb by dynamic functional MRI.

Dynamic blood oxygenation level-dependent functional MRI was applied at 7 T in the rat olfactory bulb (OB) with pulsed delivery of iso-amyl acetate (IAA) and limonene. Acquisition times for single-slice and whole OB data were 8 and 32 s, respectively, with spatial resolution of 220 x 220 x 250 micrometer. On an intrasubject basis, short IAA exposures of 0.6 min separated by 3.5-min intervals induced reproducible spatial activity patterns (SAPs) in the olfactory nerve layer, glomerular layer, and external plexiform layer. During long exposures ( approximately 10 min), the initially dominant dorsal SAPs declined in intensity and area, whereas in some OB regions, the initially weak ventral/lateral SAPs increased first and then decreased. The SAPs of different concentrations were topologically similar, which implies that whereas an odor at various concentrations activates the same subsets of receptor cells, different concentrations are assessed and discriminated by variable magnitudes of laminarspecific activations. IAA and limonene reproducibly activated different subsets of receptor cells with some overlaps. Whereas qualitative topographical agreement was observed with results from other methods, the current dynamic blood oxygenation level-dependent functional MRI results can provide quantitative SAPs of the entire OB.

In vivo nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy studies of the relationship between the glutamate-glutamine neurotransmitter cycle and functional neuroenergetics.

In this article we review recent studies, primarily from our laboratory, using 13C NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance) to non-invasively measure the rate of the glutamate-glutamine neurotransmitter cycle in the cortex of rats and humans. In the glutamate-glutamine cycle, glutamate released from nerve terminals is taken up by surrounding glial cells and returned to the nerve terminals as glutamine. 13C NMR studies have shown that the rate of the glutamate-glutamine cycle is extremely high in both the rat and human cortex, and that it increases with brain activity in an approximately 1:1 molar ratio with oxidative glucose metabolism. The measured ratio, in combination with proposals based on isolated cell studies by P. J. Magistretti and co-workers, has led to the development of a model in which the majority of brain glucose oxidation is mechanistically coupled to the glutamate-glutamine cycle. This model provides the first testable mechanistic relationship between cortical glucose metabolism and a specific neuronal activity. We review here the experimental evidence for this model as well as implications for blood oxygenation level dependent magnetic resonance imaging and positron emission tomography functional imaging studies of brain function.

Determination of the rate of the glutamate/glutamine cycle in the human brain by in vivo 13C NMR.

Recent 13C NMR studies in rat models have shown that the glutamate/glutamine cycle is highly active in the cerebral cortex and is coupled to incremental glucose oxidation in an approximately 1:1 stoichiometry. To determine whether a high level of glutamatergic activity is present in human cortex, the rates of the tricarboxylic acid cycle, glutamine synthesis, and the glutamate/glutamine cycle were determined in the human occipital/parietal lobe at rest. During an infusion of [1-13C]-glucose, in vivo 13C NMR spectra were obtained of the time courses of label incorporation into [4-13C]-glutamate and [4-13C]-glutamine. Using a metabolic model we have validated in the rat, we calculated a total tricarboxylic acid cycle rate of 0.77 +/- 0.07 micromol/min/g (mean +/- SD, n = 6), a glucose oxidation rate of 0.39 +/- 0.04 micromol/min/g, and a glutamate/glutamine cycle rate of 0.32 +/- 0.05 micromol/min/g (mean +/- SD, n = 6). In agreement with studies in rat cerebral cortex, the glutamate/glutamine cycle is a major metabolic flux in the resting human brain with a rate approximately 80% of glucose oxidation.

Stimulated changes in localized cerebral energy consumption under anesthesia.

Focal changes in the cerebral metabolic rate of glucose utilization (CMRglc) are small (10-40%) during sensory activation in awake humans, as well as in awake rodents and primates (20-50%). They are significantly larger (50-250%) in sensory activation studies of anesthetized rats and cats. Our data, in agreement with literature values, show that in the resting anesthetized state values of CMRglc are lower than in the resting nonanesthetized state whereas the final state values, reached upon activation, are similar for the anesthetized and nonanesthetized animals. The lower resting anesthetized state values of CMRglc explain why the increments upon activation from anesthesia are larger than when starting from the nonanesthetized conditions. Recent 13C NMR measurements in our laboratory have established a quantitative relationship between the energetics of glucose oxidation, CMRglc (oxidative), and the flux of the glutamate/gamma-aminobutyric acid/glutamine neurotransmitter cycle, Vcycle. In both the resting awake value of CMRglc(oxidative), and its increment upon stimulation, a large majority (approximately 80%) of the brain energy consumption is devoted to Vcycle. In the differencing methods of functional imaging, it is assumed that the incremental change in the measured signal represents the modular activity that supports the functional response. However, the same amount of activity must be present during the response to stimulation, irrespective of the initial basal state of the cortex. Thus, whereas the incremental signals of DeltaCMRglc can localize neurotransmitter activity, the magnitude of such activity during the response is represented by the total localized CMRglc, not the increment.

NMR of glycogen in exercise.

Natural-abundance 13C NMR spectroscopy is a non-invasive technique that enables in vivo assessments of muscle and/or liver glycogen concentrations. Over the last several years, 13C NMR has been developed and used to obtain information about human glycogen metabolism with diet and exercise. Since NMR is non-invasive, more data points are available over a specified time course, dramatically improving the time resolution. This improved time resolution has enabled the documentation of subtleties of muscle glycogen re-synthesis following severe glycogen depletion that were not previously observed. Muscle and liver glycogen concentrations have been tracked in several different human populations under conditions that include: (1) muscle glycogen recovery from intense localized exercise with normal insulin and with insulin suppressed; (2) muscle glycogen recovery in an insulin-resistant population; (3) muscle glycogen depletion during prolonged low-intensity exercise; (4) effect of a mixed meal on postprandial muscle and liver glycogen synthesis. The present review focuses on basic 13C NMR and gives results from selected studies.

Functional energy metabolism: in vivo 13C-NMR spectroscopy evidence for coupling of cerebral glucose consumption and glutamatergic neuronalactivity.

The use of in vivo 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) has established the pathways of functional interaction between neurons and astrocytes in the mammalian brain and enabled quantitation of these fluxes. A mathematical model of glutamate, glutamine and ammonia metabolism in the brain has been developed, under the constraints of carbon and nitrogen mass balance, allowing the direct and quantitative comparison of in vivo 13C- and 15N-NMR data. Using this model and 13C-NMR data, the authors have separated the neurotransmitter cycling and detoxification components of glutamine synthesis by measuring the rate of glutamine synthesis under normal and hyperammonaemic conditions in the rat brain cortex in vivo. In addition, the simultaneous measurement of the rates of oxidative glucose metabolism and glutamate neurotransmitter cycling in the rat brain cortex has shown that over a range of EEG activity (from isoelectric up to near-resting levels) the stoichiometry between glucose metabolism and glutamate cycling is close to 1:1. Under mild anesthesia, cortical glucose oxidation coupled to glutamatergic synaptic activity accounts for over 80% of total glucose oxidation. Previously, changes in cerebral glucose metabolism have been taken to indicate alterations in functional activity. These recent in vivo results demonstrate, however, that those changes are, in fact, quantitatively coupled to the crux of functional activity, neurotransmitter release. These findings bear upon a number of hypotheses concerning the neurophysiological basis of brain functional imaging methods.

15N-NMR spectroscopy studies of ammonia transport and glutamine synthesis in the hyperammonemic rat brain.

Ammonia transport and glutamine synthesis were studied in the hyperammonaemic rat brain in vivo using 15N-NMR spectroscopy at a plasma ammonia level of approximately 0.39 mM raised via an intravenous [15N]-ammonium acetate infusion. The initial slope of the time course of the summed cerebral 15N-labelled metabolites was used to determine the rate of ammonia net transport during hyperammonemia as 0.13 +/- 0.02 micromol/min/g (mean +/- SD; n = 5). Based on the total accumulation of glutamine and the 1:2 stoichiometric relationship between fluxes of four-carbon skeletons and nitrogen atoms, the rate of de novo glutamine synthesis through anaplerosis and subsequent glutamate dehydrogenase action was calculated to be 0.065 +/- 0.01 micromol/min/g. The rate of total glutamine synthesis was estimated to be 0.20 +/- 0.06 micromol/min/g (n = 5) by fitting the [5-15N]glutamine time course to a previously described model of glutamate-glutamine cycling between astrocytes and neurones. A large dilution was also observed in [2-15N]glutamine, which supports the glutamate-glutamine cycle as being an important pathway for neuronal glutamate repletion in vivo.

Interpreting functional imaging studies in terms of neurotransmitter cycling.

Functional imaging experiments, in particular positron-emission tomography and functional magnetic resonance imaging, can be analyzed either in psychological terms or on the basis of neuroscience. In the usual psychological interpretation, stimulations are designed to activate specific mental processes identified by cognitive psychology, which are then localized by the signals in functional imaging experiments. An alternate approach would be to analyze experiments in terms of the neurobiological processes responsible for the signals. Recent in vivo 13C NMR measurements of the glutamate-to-glutamine neurotransmitter cycling in rat and human brains facilitate a neuroscientific interpretation of functional imaging data in terms of neurobiological processes since incremental neurotransmitter flux showed a 1:1 stoichiometry with the incremental rate of glucose oxidation. Because functional imaging signals depend on brain energy consumption, a quantitative relationship can be established between the signal (S) and the specific neurochemical cerebral neurotransmitter activity (N) of glutamate-to-glutamine neurotransmitter cycling. The quantitation of neuronal activity proposed has implications for the psychological design and interpretation of functional imaging experiments. Measurements of the neurotransmitter cycling flux at rest in functional imaging experiments suggest that performing cognitive tasks and sensory stimulations increases neurotransmitter cycling by only 10-20%. Therefore it cannot be assumed that reference state activities are negligible, nor that they are constant during stimulation.

A model for the regulation of cerebral oxygen delivery.

On the basis of the assumption that oxygen delivery across the endothelium is proportional to capillary plasma PO2, a model is presented that links cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen utilization (CMRO2) to cerebral blood flow (CBF) through an effective diffusivity for oxygen (D) of the capillary bed. On the basis of in vivo evidence that the oxygen diffusivity properties of the capillary bed may be altered by changes in capillary PO2, hematocrit, and/or blood volume, the model allows changes in D with changes in CBF. Choice in the model of the appropriate ratio of Omega identical with (DeltaD/D)/(DeltaCBF/CBF) determines the dependence of tissue oxygen delivery on perfusion. Buxton and Frank (J. Cereb. Blood Flow. Metab. 17: 64-72, 1997) recently presented a limiting case of the present model in which Omega = 0. In contrast to the trends predicted by the model of Buxton and Frank, in the current model when Omega > 0, the proportionality between changes in CBF and CMRO2 becomes more linear, and similar degrees of proportionality can exist at different basal values of oxygen extraction fraction. The model is able to fit the observed proportionalities between CBF and CMRO2 for a large range of physiological data. Although the model does not validate any particular observed proportionality between CBF and CMRO2, generally values of (DeltaCMRO2/CMRO2)/(DeltaCBF/CBF) close to unity have been observed across ranges of graded anesthesia in rats and humans and for particular functional activations in humans. The model's capacity to fit the wide range of data indicates that the oxygen diffusivity properties of the capillary bed, which can be modified in relation to perfusion, play an important role in regulating cerebral oxygen delivery in vivo.

Dynamic mapping at the laminar level of odor-elicited responses in rat olfactory bulb by functional MRI.

We have applied functional MRI (fMRI) based on blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) image-contrast to map odor-elicited olfactory responses at the laminar level in the rat olfactory bulb (OB) elicited by iso-amyl acetate (10(-2) dilution of saturated vapor) with spatial and temporal resolutions of 220x220x1,000 micro(m) and 36 s. The laminar structure of the OB was clearly depicted by high-resolution in vivo anatomical MRI with spatial resolution of 110x110x1,000 micro(m). In repeated BOLD fMRI measurements, highly significant (P < 0.001) foci were located in the outer layers of both OBs. The occurrence of focal OB activity within a domain at the level of individual glomeruli or groups of glomeruli was corroborated on an intra- and inter-animal basis under anesthetized conditions with this noninvasive method. The dynamic studies demonstrated that the odor-elicited BOLD activations were highly reproducible on a time scale of minutes, whereas over tens of minutes the activations sometimes varied slowly. We found large BOLD signal (DeltaS/S = 10-30%) arising from the olfactory nerve layer, which is devoid of synapses and composed of unmyelinated fibers and glial cells. Our results support previous studies with other methods showing that odors elicit activity within glomerular layer domains in the mammalian OB, and extend the analysis to shorter time periods at the level of individual glomeruli or groups of glomeruli. With further improvement, BOLD fMRI should be ideal for systematic analysis of the functional significance of individual glomeruli in olfactory information encoding and of spatiotemporal processing within the olfactory system.