Noradrenergic modulation of functional selectivity in the cat visual cortex: an in vivo extracellular and intracellular study.

In vitro intracellular studies have shown that norepinephrine modulates cellular excitability and synaptic transmission in the cortex. Based on these effects, norepinephrine has been proposed to enhance the signal-to-noise ratio and to improve functional selectivity by potentiating strong synaptic responses and reducing weak ones. Here we have studied the functional effects of iontophoretic applications of norepinephrine during in vivo extracellular and intracellular recordings from neurons of the primary visual cortex of kittens and adult cats. Analysis of extracellular data concentrated on norepinephrine-induced changes in spontaneous and evoked activities, in signal-to-noise ratio, and in orientation and direction selectivity. Analysis of the intracellular data concentrated on actions of norepinephrine on spike firing accommodation, which has been shown to be reduced by norepinephrine in vitro, and on synaptic responses. Application of norepinephrine resulted in a depression of both spontaneous and evoked spiking activity. However, no systematic change in signal-to-noise ratio was observed. The suppressive effect of norepinephrine was exerted with no significant sharpening of direction or orientation selectivity tuning. The overall reduction in visual activity by norepinephrine affected the orientation tuning curves in a way compatible with a divisive effect, that is a normalization or gain control with no change in tuning width. Norepinephrine applied during intracellular recordings reduced the visually evoked depolarizing potentials whereas no change in the responsiveness of the cell to current-induced depolarizations was observed. In conditions of optimal visual stimulation which produced large depolarizations of several hundreds of milliseconds and sustained repetitive firing comparable to that obtained by direct current injection, we were unable to observe a facilitation of the evoked responses by norepinephrine as it would be expected from the well-documented increase in excitability induced by norepinephrine in vitro. In conclusion, from these results we suggest that norepinephrine released in the primary visual cortex primarily reduces the level of cortical activation by afferent signals, without affecting the cortical functional selectivity nor increasing the signal-to-noise ratio.

Acetylcholine-dependent induction and expression of functional plasticity in the barrel cortex of the adult rat.

The involvement of acetylcholine (ACh) in the induction of neuronal sensory plasticity is well documented. Recently we demonstrated in the somatosensory cortex of the anesthetized rat that ACh is also involved in the expression of neuronal plasticity. Pairing stimulation of the principal whisker at a fixed temporal frequency with ACh iontophoresis induced potentiations of response that required re-application of ACh to be expressed. Here we fully characterize this phenomenon and extend it to stimulation of adjacent whiskers. We show that these ACh-dependent potentiations are cumulative and reversible. When several sensori-cholinergic pairings were applied consecutively with stimulation of the principal whisker, the response at the paired frequency was further increased, demonstrating a cumulative process that could reach saturation levels. The potentiations were specific to the stimulus frequency: if the successive pairings were done at different frequencies, then the potentiation caused by the first pairing was depotentiated, whereas the response to the newly paired frequency was potentiated. During testing, the potentiation of response did not develop immediately on the presentation of the paired frequency during application of ACh: the analysis of the kinetics of the effect indicates that this process requires the sequential presentation of several trains of stimulation at the paired frequency to be expressed. We present evidence that a plasticity with similar characteristics can be induced for responses to stimulation of an adjacent whisker, suggesting that this potentiation could participate in receptive field spatial reorganizations. The spatial and temporal properties of the ACh-dependent plasticity presented here impose specific constraints on the underlying cellular and molecular mechanisms.

A neuronal analogue of state-dependent learning.

State-dependent learning is a phenomenon in which the retrieval of newly acquired information is possible only if the subject is in the same sensory context and physiological state as during the encoding phase. In spite of extensive behavioural and pharmacological characterization, no cellular counterpart of this phenomenon has been reported. Here we describe a neuronal analogue of state-dependent learning in which cortical neurons show an acetylcholine-dependent expression of an acetylcholine-induced functional plasticity. This was demonstrated on neurons of rat somatosensory 'barrel' cortex, whose tunings to the temporal frequency of whisker deflections were modified by cellular conditioning. Pairing whisker stimulation with acetylcholine applied iontophoretically yielded selective lasting modification of responses, the expression of which depended on the presence of exogenous acetylcholine. Administration of acetylcholine during testing revealed frequency-specific changes in response that were not expressed when tested without acetylcholine or when the muscarinic antagonist, atropine, was applied concomitantly. Our results suggest that both acquisition and recall can be controlled by the cortical release of acetylcholine.

Activity-dependent regulation of receptive field properties of cat area 17 by supervised Hebbian learning.

Most algorithms currently used to model synaptic plasticity in self-organizing cortical networks suppose that the change in synaptic efficacy is governed by the same structuring factor, i.e., the temporal correlation of activity between pre- and postsynaptic neurons. Functional predictions generated by such algorithms have been tested electrophysiologically in the visual cortex of anesthetized and paralyzed cats. Supervised learning procedures were applied at the cellular level to change receptive field (RF) properties during the time of recording of an individual functionally identified cell. The protocols were devised as cellular analogs of the plasticity of RF properties, which is normally expressed during a critical period of postnatal development. We summarize here evidence demonstrating that changes in covariance between afferent input and postsynaptic response imposed during extracellular and intracellular conditioning can acutely induce selective long-lasting up- and down-regulations of visual responses. The functional properties that could be modified in 40% of cells submitted to differential pairing protocols include ocular dominance, orientation selectivity and orientation preference, interocular orientation disparity, and the relative dominance of ON and OFF responses. Since changes in RF properties can be induced in the adult as well, our findings also suggest that similar activity-dependent processes may occur during development and during active phases of learning under the supervision of behavioral attention or contextual signals. Such potential for plasticity in primary visual cortical neurons suggests the existence of a hidden connectivity expressing a wider functional competence than the one revealed at the spiking level. In particular, in the spatial domain the sensory synaptic integration field is larger than the classical discharge field. It can be shaped by supervised learning and its subthreshold extent can be unmasked by the pharmacological blockade of intracortical inhibition.

Activity-dependent regulation of 'on' and 'off' responses in cat visual cortical receptive fields.

1. A supervised learning procedure was applied to individual cat area 17 neurons to test the possible role of neuronal co-activity in controlling the plasticity of the spatial 'on-off' organization of visual cortical receptive fields (RFs). 2. Differential pairing between visual input evoked in a fixed position of the RF and preset levels of postsynaptic firing (imposed iontophoretically) were used alternately to boost the 'on' (or 'off') response to a 'high' level of firing (S+ pairing), and to reduce the opponent response (respectively 'off' or 'on') in the same position to a 'low' level (S- pairing). This associative procedure was repeated 50-100 times at a low temporal frequency (0.1-0.15 s-1). 3. Long-lasting modifications of the ratio of 'on-off' responses, measured in the paired position or integrated across the whole RF, were found in 44 % of the conditioned neurons (17/39), and in most cases this favoured the S+ paired characteristic. The amplitude change was on average half of that imposed during pairing. Comparable proportions of modified cells were obtained in 'simple' (13/27) and 'complex' (4/12) RFs, both in adult cats (4/11) and in kittens within the critical period (13/28). 4. The spatial selectivity of the pairing effects was studied by pseudorandomly stimulating both paired and spatially distinct unpaired positions within the RF. Most modifications were observed in the paired position (for 88 % of successful pairings). 5. In some cells (n = 13), a fixed delay pairing procedure was applied, in which the temporal phase of the onset of the current pulse was shifted by a few hundred milliseconds from the presentation or offset of the visual stimulus. Consecutive effects were observed in 4/13 cells, which retained the temporal pattern of activity imposed during pairing for 5-40 min. They were expressed in the paired region only. 6. The demonstration of long-lasting adaptive changes in the ratio of 'on' and 'off' responses, expressed in localized subregions of the RF, leads us to suggest that simple and complex RF organizations might be two stable functional states derived from a common connectivity scheme.

Synaptic origin and stimulus dependency of neuronal oscillatory activity in the primary visual cortex of the cat.

1. We have studied the oscillatory activity of single neurons (91 recorded extracellularly and 76 intracellularly) in the primary visual cortex of cats and kittens to characterize its origins and its stimulus dependency. A new method for the detection of oscillations was developed in order to maximize the range of detectable frequencies in both types of recordings. Three types of activity were examined: spontaneous background activity, responses to intracellular current steps and visual responses. 2. During spontaneous activity, persistent oscillatory activity was very rare in both types of recordings. However, when intracellular records were made using KCl-filled micropipettes, spontaneous activity appeared rhythmic and contained repeated depolarizing events at a variety of frequencies, suggestive of tonic periodic inhibitory input normally masked at resting potential. 3. Patterns of firing activity in response to intracellular current steps allowed us to classify neurons as regular spiking, intrinsically bursting, and fast-spiking types, as described in vitro. In the case of rhythmically firing cells, the spike frequency increased with the amount of injected current. Subthreshold current-induced oscillations were rarely observed (2 out of 76 cells). 4. Visual stimulation elicited oscillations in one-third of the neurons (55 out of 167), predominantly in the 7-20 Hz frequency range in 93% of the cases. Rhythmicity was observed in both simple and complex cells, and appeared to be more prominent at 5 and 6 weeks of age. 5. Intracellular recordings in bridge mode and voltage clamp revealed that visually evoked oscillations were driven by synaptic activity and did not depend primarily on the intrinsic properties of recorded neurons. Hyperpolarizing the membrane led to an increase in the size of the rhythmic depolarizing events without a change in frequency. In voltage-clamped cells, current responses showed large oscillations at the same frequency as in bridge mode, independently of the actual value of the holding potential. 6. In fourteen intracellularly recorded neurons, oscillations consisted of excitatory events that could be superimposed on a depolarizing or a hyperpolarizing slow wave. In two other neurons, visual responses consisted of excitatory and inhibitory events, alternating with a constant phase shift. 7. Drifting bars were much more efficient in evoking oscillatory responses than flashed bars. Except in three cells, the frequency of the oscillation did not depend on the physical characteristics of the stimulus that were tested (contrast, orientation, direction, ocularity and position in the receptive field). No significant correlation was found between the intensity of the visual response and the strength of the rhythmic component. 8. Although it cannot be excluded that the dominant frequency of oscillations might be related to the type of anaesthetics used, no correlation was found between local EEG and the oscillatory activity elicited by visual stimulation. 9. We conclude that the oscillations observed in the present work are generated by synaptic activity. It is likely that they represent an important mode of transmission in sensory processing, resulting from periodic packets of synchronized activity propagated across recurrent circuits. Their relevance to perceptual binding is further discussed.

Differential effects of acetylcholine on neuronal activity and interactions in the auditory cortex of the guinea-pig.

During normal brain operations, cortical neurons are subjected to continuous cholinergic modulations. In vitro studies have indicated that, in addition to affecting general cellular excitability, acetylcholine also modulates synaptic transmission. Whether these cholinergic mechanisms lead to a modulation of functional connectivity in vivo is not yet known. Herein, the effects were studied of an iontophoretic application of acetylcholine and of the muscarinic agonist, carbachol, on the ongoing activity and co-activity of neurons simultaneously recorded in the auditory cortex of the anaesthetized guinea-pig. Iontophoresis of cholinergic agonists mainly affected the spontaneous firing rates of auditory neurons, affected autocorrelations less (in most cases their central peak areas were reduced), and rarely affected cross-correlations. These findings are consistent with cholinergic agonists primarily affecting the excitability of cortical neurons rather than the strength of cortical connections. However, when changes of cross-correlations occurred, they were usually not correlated with concomitant changes in average firing rates nor with changes in autocorrelations, which suggests a secondary cholinergic effect on specific cortico-cortical or thalamo-cortical connections.

Possible involvement of neuromodulatory systems in cortical Hebbian-like plasticity.

Plasticity of neuronal covariances (functional plasticity) is controlled by behavior (Ahissar et al (1992) Science 257, 1412-1415). Whether this behavioral control involves neuromodulatory systems was tested by examining the effect of acetylcholine (ACh) and noradrenaline (NE) on functional plasticity in anesthetized animals and by comparing the effects of these neuromodulators in an anesthetized preparation to that of behavior in awake animals. Local ionotophoretic applications of these drugs during manipulations of activity covariance in guinea pig auditory cortex did not mimic the behavioral control of functional plasticity that was previously observed in awake monkeys. Thus, the hypotheses according to which these neuromodulators control functional plasticity independent of their concentration and time of release were not supported by our data. The significant plasticity induced nevertheless, by some of the conditionings in the presence of ACh and NE, suggests that factors, other than those that were experimentally controlled, could regulate this plasticity. These factors could be among others the timing of drug(s) applications relative to the conditioning time, the local concentrations of the drug(s) and/or the site of application with respect to the relevant synapses.

Temporal constraints in associative synaptic plasticity in hippocampus and neocortex.

We present comparative experimental evidence for the induction of synaptic potentiation and depression in organotypic cultures of hippocampus and in visual cortex in vitro and in vivo. The effects of associative pairings on the efficacy of synaptic transmission are analyzed as a function of the temporal delay between presynaptic activity and post-synaptic changes imposed in membrane potential. Synchronous association at a low temporal frequency (< 0.5 Hz) between presynaptic input and postsynaptic depolarization resulted in homosynaptic potentiation of functionally identified postsynaptic potentials in the three types of preparation. Synchronous pairing of afferent activity with hyperpolarization of the postsynaptic cell resulted in homosynaptic depression in visual cortex in vivo and in vitro. An associative form of depression was induced in hippocampus when the test input was followed repeatedly with a fixed-delay postsynaptic depolarization imposed either by intracellular current injection or synaptically. The latter process might play a significant role in heterosynaptic plasticity in visual cortex in vivo and in vitro, if it is assumed that associative depression still operates in visual cortex a few seconds after the initial surge of calcium in the postsynaptic cell. We conclude that the precise timing between presynaptic activity and polarization changes in postsynaptic membrane potential up- and down-regulates the efficacy of active pathways.

A multi-electrode array for combined microiontophoresis and multiple single-unit recordings.

A remotely controlled multi-electrode array, equipped with a combined electrode (CE) and 3 regular tungsten-in-glass electrodes (TEs) is described. The CE enables ejection of different neuroactive substances from 6 barrels and recording of single-unit activity from the etched tungsten rod placed in the central glass capillary. The CE is prepared with standard tungsten rod, glass-capillaries, and regular micropipette pullers. Such CEs possess a good stiffness-flexibility balance, length, easy cell isolation, high stability of recordings, effective ejection properties, and ability to survive penetration of dura. The efficiency of a 4-electrode array, including the CE, was tested by recording the effects of extracellularly ejected drugs (glutamate, acetylcholine and atropine) on single neurons in the auditory cortex of anesthetized guinea pigs. Induced modifications of single-neuron firing patterns and evoked responses were in agreement with the known effects of individual and combined applications of these drugs. Using this multi-electrode array and spike sorting techniques, the pharmacological environment of up to 12 simultaneously recorded cells can be modulated, and its effect on single neurons and on their interactions can be monitored at distances of up to 900 microns from the CE's tip.

Synaptic origin of rhythmic visually evoked activity in kitten area 17 neurones.

Rhythmic patterns in neuronal activity in response to moving stimuli were observed in 28% of cells recorded extracellularly or intracellularly in area 17 of 4-16 week old anaesthetized and paralysed kittens. In both recording modes, oscillation frequencies ranged between 7 and 71 Hz, and were confined for 88% of cells in the 7-20 Hz band of the spectrum. A comparative study of firing autocorrelograms) and subthreshold activity (autocorrelation functions) indicates that the regularity of discharge stemmed from visually evoked oscillations of membrane potential at the same frequency. These oscillations are shown to result from extrinsic excitatory activity, since their amplitude, but not their frequency, depends on the resting membrane potential. The dependency on stimulus configuration supports the hypothesis that oscillations in neuronal output are dictated by periodic activity in afferent circuits selectively recruited by different attributes of the visual input which are not exclusively processed at the cortical level.

Cellular analogs of visual cortical epigenesis. I. Plasticity of orientation selectivity.

A differential pairing procedure was applied in vivo to individual neurons in the primary visual cortex of anesthetized paralyzed cats, in order to produce changes in their relative orientation preference. While we recorded from a single cell, its visual response to a light bar was driven iontophoretically to a "high" level when stimulating with an initially nonpreferred orientation (S+), and alternately reduced to a "low" level when stimulating with the preferred orientation (S). This associative procedure was devised to test the possible role of neuronal coactivity in controlling the plasticity of orientation selectivity. Among 87 cells tested, 35 (40%) showed significant long-lasting changes, either in the relative orientation preference for the two "paired" stimuli S+ and S-, in the global orientation tuning profile, or in both. Measurements of relative orientation preference demonstrated significant effects in 27 cells (31%), all in favor of the positively reinforced orientation (S+). Modifications of orientation selectivity (studied over the entire orientation spectrum in 45 of the conditioned cells) usually consisted (21 out of 25 modified cells) of a competitive reorganization of the orientation tuning curve: the preferred orientation shifted toward S+, and a loss of relative visual responsiveness was observed for orientations close to the negatively reinforced orientation (S-). The largest changes were found in deprived kittens at the peak of the critical period, although the probability of inducing a significant change studied during the first year of postnatal life was independent of age. These functional modifications demonstrated at the cellular level are analogous to those induced by a global manipulation of the visual environment, when only a restricted spectrum of orientations is experienced during the critical period. Our results support the hypothesis that covariance levels between pre- and postsynaptic activity determine the sign and the amplitude of the modification of efficacy of cortical synapses.

Cellular analogs of visual cortical epigenesis. II. Plasticity of binocular integration.

Two differential pairing procedures were applied in the primary visual cortex of anesthetized and paralyzed kittens and cats, to produce changes in ocular dominance and interocular orientation disparity (IOD) during the time of recording of a single neuron. A first experiment was devised to demonstrate plasticity in the balance of monocular responses. The visual activity of the cell was driven iontophoretically to either a "high" or a "low" level, depending on the ocularity of the visual stimulation. Ocular dominance measurements before and after pairing revealed significant long-lasting changes in 33% of cases. Relative ocular preference shifted in most cases (87.5%) in favor of the reinforced eye. Similar proportions of significant changes were observed in kitten and adult cortex. The amplitude of the functional modifications was not significantly related with age, although the largest changes in ocular dominance were recorded at the peak of the critical period. The second experiment more specifically addressed the plasticity of binocular interaction. The activity of a binocular cell was driven iontophoretically to either a "high" or a "low" level, depending on the orientation disparity between two oriented stimuli, presented simultaneously and separately in the receptive field of each eye. Significant long-lasting changes in binocular responses were induced in 40% of cases. The relative IOD preference generally shifted (67%) in favor of the reinforced disparity. In half of the modified cells, functional changes were expressed only in the dichoptic viewing condition used during the pairing procedure. These functional modifications of binocular integration, demonstrated at the cellular level, are analogous to those induced by global manipulations of the visual environment (Hubel and Wiesel, 1970; Shinkman and Bruce, 1977). They are interpreted as evidence for synaptic plasticity. Our results support the hypothesis that covariance levels between pre- and postsynaptic activities determine the sign and the amplitude of changes in synaptic efficacy.

Exponential data-analysis of passive-avoidance behavior in rats and mice.

Data obtained with the passive-avoidance task are usually presented as the median values of the latencies to respond. In an earlier publication we described a better way of presenting such data based on the observation that the complement of the cumulative distribution of step-through latencies can be closely fitted by a simple exponential function. Thus the "step-through rate constant" (STRC) is concise and accurate quantitative description of population behavior in this test. In this paper we present two examples of the application of this procedure. In the first, variation in the interval between training and testing in rats changes the STRCs of the different groups. In the second (based on data published by Flood et al.) administration of cycloheximide is seen to partition the experimental population of mice into two subgroups with different STRCs.

A cellular analogue of visual cortical plasticity.

Neuronal activity plays an important role in the development of the visual pathway. The modulation of synaptic transmission by temporal correlation between pre- and postsynaptic activity is one mechanism which could underly visual cortical plasticity. We report here that functional changes in single neurons of area 17, analogous to those known to take place during epigenesis of visual cortex, can be induced experimentally during the time of recording. This was done by a differential pairing procedure, during which iontophoresis was used to artificially increase the visual response for a given stimulus, and to decrease (or block) the response for a second stimulus which differed in ocularity or orientation. Long-term modifications in ocular dominance and orientation selectivity were produced in 33% and 43% of recorded cells respectively. Neuronal selectivity was nearly always displaced towards the stimulus paired with the reinforced visual response. The largest changes were obtained at the peak of the critical period in normally reared and visually deprived kittens, but changes were also observed in adults. Our findings support the role of temporal correlation between pre- and postsynaptic activity in the induction of long-lasting modifications of synaptic transmission during development, and in associative learning.

A novel method for quantifying passive-avoidance behavior based on the exponential distribution of step-through latencies.

In the extensive literature dealing with the one-trial passive-avoidance task the data are usually represented by the median latency to respond. We propose here a novel representation and analysis of passive-avoidance data which is based on the observation that the complement of the cumulative distribution of step-through latencies (i.e., the fraction of animals remaining in the safe compartment) decays exponentially with time from the onset of the trial. A remarkably close fit of this complementary distribution is seen when the best-fitting straight line is drawn through the data points plotted on semilog coordinates. The slope of this line k, which we call "the step-through rate constant," (or alternatively, the T1/2 which is equal to 0.69/k) provides an accurate description of the population behavior as a whole in most cases. In view of the exponential distribution of passive-avoidance data this treatment appears to be more appropriate than the widely-used measures of central tendency, the median and mean. It is applicable to research on the effects of drugs on passive-avoidance memory, and probably appropriate to other behavioral paradigms and species.