Estimation of the consumption of cold tap water for microbiological risk assessment: an overview of studies and statistical analysis of data.

The volume of cold tap water consumed is an essential element in quantitative microbial risk assessment. This paper presents a review of tap water consumption studies. Study designs were evaluated and statistical distributions were fitted to water consumption data from The Netherlands, Great Britain, Germany and Australia. We conclude that the diary is to be preferred for collecting water consumption data. If a diary is not feasible, a 24 h recall would be the best alternative, preferably repeated at least once. From the studies evaluated, the mean daily consumption varies from 0.10 L to 1.55 L. No conclusions could be drawn regarding the effects of season, age and gender on tap water consumption. Physical activity, yearly income and perceived health status were reported to influence water consumption. Comparison of the different statistical probability distribution functions of the datasets demonstrated that the Poisson distribution performed better than the lognormal distribution as suggested by Roseberry and Burmaster. For quantitative microbiological risk assessment (QMRA) it is recommended to use country-specific consumption data and statistical distributions, if available. If no country specific data are available we recommend to use the Australian distribution data from the Melbourne diary study (Poisson, lambda=3.49 glasses/d) as a conservative estimate.

Dietary intake and domestic food preparation and handling as risk factors for gastroenteritis: a case-control study.

Cases of gastroenteritis were examined to identify if dietary intake prior to an episode and food-handling and storage practices in the home were risk factors for illness. Cases and controls completed a dietary questionnaire after an event or when well, and questionnaires concerning food-handling, storage and general food-hygiene practices. Comparing cases to themselves when well. subjects were more likely to have eaten cold sliced salami, fried rice and foods cooked elsewhere, and to have had a baby in nappies in the house (OR 1.52-6.24, P< or =0.01). Cases compared to non-cases were more likely to have bought frozen poultry, have eaten foods cooked elsewhere and to have had a baby in nappies in the house (OR 1.44-2.05, P< or = 001). Although food-handling and storage practices are considered important, we were unable to detect an association in this study.

Failure to detect norovirus in a large group of asymptomatic individuals.

Noroviruses are a major cause of both sporadic and epidemic gastroenteritis in humans, but the mechanisms by which norovirus circulates within the community are poorly understood. In this study, we examined the hypothesis that asymptomatic people act as a reservoir for norovirus. Faecal specimens from 399 asymptomatic individuals were tested for norovirus by reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) methodology, and no norovirus was detected. The failure to detect norovirus was not apparently due to the test sample being resistant to norovirus infection, nor to the presence of PCR inhibitors in the test sample. The findings suggest that, if norovirus is carried by asymptomatic people, the carriage rate is very low; the upper bound (95% confidence interval, binomial distribution) of the carriage rate was only 0.8%. Thus, it is unlikely that asymptomatic people are an important reservoir for norovirus.

Case-control studies of sporadic cryptosporidiosis in Melbourne and Adelaide, Australia.

Few studies have assessed risk factors for sporadic cryptosporidiosis in industrialized countries, even though it may be numerically more common than outbreaks of disease. We carried out case-control studies assessing risk factors for sporadic disease in Melbourne and Adelaide, which have water supplies from different ends of the raw water spectrum. In addition to examining drinking water, we assessed several other exposures. 201 cases and 795 controls were recruited for Melbourne and 134 cases and 536 controls were recruited for Adelaide. Risk factors were similar for the two cities, with swimming in public pools and contact with a person with diarrhoea being most important. The consumption of plain tap water was not found to be associated with disease. This study emphasizes the need for regular public health messages to the public and swimming pool managers in an attempt to prevent sporadic cryptosporidiosis, as well as outbreaks of disease.

The rate of gastroenteritis in a large city before and after chlorination.

There is conflicting evidence about the contribution of drinking water to endemic community gastroenteritis in water supplies which meet conventional microbiological standards with some studies reporting associations between drinking water and endemic disease and others finding no evidence that water is implicated in disease. This study reports the results of an ecological study investigating the effect on community gastroenteritis of chlorinating a city of over 3 million people in the mid 1970s. Prior to chlorination faecal coliforms were regularly identified in the water. Admissions for gastroenteritis and attendances to the Emergency Department of the Royal Children's Hospital, Melbourne's major children's hospital, were measured between 1974 and 1980 inclusive and the influence of chlorination on rates of gastroenteritis was examined. No statistically significant difference was found in the number of admissions or emergency department visits before and after chlorination of the water supply. The study highlights the need for caution when interpreting the relationships between drinking water and gastroenteritis. The result suggests that water was not a dominant contributor to the burden of gastrointestinal disease in the community despite faecal coliforms being present in the water supply. It indicates the need for caution when attributing significant illness to drinking water when there have been only small changes in water quality without first stringently reviewing the studies methodology and understanding their limitations.

A randomized, blinded, controlled trial investigating the gastrointestinal health effects of drinking water quality.

A double-blinded, randomized, controlled trial was carried out in in Melbourne, Australia, to determine the contribution of drinking water to gastroenteritis. Melbourne is one of the few major cities in the world that draws drinking water from a protected forest catchment with minimal water treatment (chlorination only). Six hundred families were randomly allocated to receive either real or sham water treatment units (WTUs) installed in their kitchen. Real units were designed to remove viruses, bacteria, and protozoa. Study participants completed a weekly health diary reporting gastrointestinal symptoms during the 68-week observation period. There were 2,669 cases of highly credible gastroenteritis (HCG) during the study (0.80 cases/person/year). The ratio of HCG episode rates for the real WTU group compared to the sham WTU group was 0.99 (95% confidence interval, 0.85-1.15, p = 0.85). We collected 795 fecal specimens from participants with gastroenteritis, and pathogens were not more significantly common in the sham WTU group. We found no evidence of waterborne disease in Melbourne. The application of this methodology to other water supplies will provide a better understanding of the relationship between human health and water quality.

Water fluoridation, osteoporosis, fractures--recent developments.

BACKGROUND: Optimal (1ppm) water fluoridation is seen as the most socially equitable way to prevent dental caries, however concerns about the safety of fluoridation are periodically raised. METHODS: Research on effects on bone published since the 1991 National Health and Medical Research Council report on water fluoridation was reviewed. RESULTS: Thirty-three studies were identified. Adverse effects in animal feeding studies were only seen at doses much greater than those currently used in artificial water fluoridation. The majority of animal studies showed no effect or a beneficial effect of low fluoride doses. The results of ecological studies were conflicting. One of the two cohort studies showed an increase in fracture incidence at fluoride levels four times greater than optimal water fluoridation and the other showed no effect after 20 years' optimal fluoridation. The cross-sectional studies showed a favourable effect on bone mineral density. The clinical trials predominantly showed increased bone density in several sites associated with fluoride treatment of 9-22.6mg fluoride per day for one-four years. CONCLUSION: These studies provide a substantial body of evidence that fluoride at up to 1ppm does not have an adverse effect on bone strength, bone mineral density or fracture incidence.

Methods used to maintain a high level of participant involvement in a clinical trial.

OBJECTIVES: To describe the strategies adopted to maintain high level participation throughout a community based clinical trial, and the reasons given by participants for why they participated in the study. DESIGN: Observational study. SETTING: Community based clinical trial in Melbourne, Australia that ran for 68 weeks and involved 2811 community based individuals from 600 families. A high level of commitment was required of the families; each participant completed a Health Diary each week of the 68 week study, as well as answering numerous other questionnaires, and providing faecal and blood samples. MAIN RESULTS: Only 41 of the 600 families withdrew from the study; the majority of these families withdrew because they sold their home and moved from the study area. The completion rate of Health Diaries averaged 90.7% over the 68 weeks of data collection. Of the 559 families who completed the study, 524 (93.7%) completed the Participation Questionnaire. The statement that received the highest rating for why families enrolled in the study was they thought the study was researching an important community issue. The statements that received the highest ratings for why families continued to participate in the study was the family being kept well informed about the study's progress and that the study was well run. CONCLUSIONS: The low numbers of withdrawals and the high level of participation throughout the study suggests the strategies of (a) having a non-aggressive recruitment method, (b) maintaining regular contact with the participants and (c) ensuring participants were kept well informed of the study's progress and constantly encouraged to continue participation were successful. The results also suggest people involve themselves in research because they perceive it to be of value to the community, not simply for personal gain. They indicated that they maintained their participation because it was a well run study and they were kept well informed throughout the study.

Changes in the incidence of gastroenteritis and the implementation of public water treatment.

There are few data available on the incidence of endemic waterborne disease in the developed world. This study aims to determine if there was a measurable decline in gastroenteritis related faecal specimens following the introduction of water treatment. The rate of faecal specimens for gastroenteritis was obtained for 17 communities one year before and after the introduction of water treatment in two states of Australia between 1992 and 1996. Of these 17 systems, 10 had filtration added to existing disinfection, while seven had both disinfection and filtration or disinfection alone added to no existing treatment. The rate of faecal sampling varied from a reduction of 55% to an increase of 198%. Large changes in water quality parameters occurred following treatment but there was no significant correlation between these changes and changes in the rate of faecal specimens. In this study there was no consistent change in gastrointestinal related faecal specimens despite marked changes in water quality. This suggests that the reduction in endemic gastrointestinal disease as a result of the introduction of water treatment was small as a percentage of all gastroenteritis. However, water treatment remains essential to protecting public health.

An outbreak of cryptosporidiosis in an urban swimming pool: why are such outbreaks difficult to detect?

OBJECTIVE: To describe an outbreak of Cryptosporidium gastroenteritis in a swimming pool in Melbourne in early 1998 that was not detected through routine surveillance, and discuss difficulties in identifying such outbreaks. METHODS: The Water Quality Study (WQS) was a large community-based study of gastroenteritis. Following suspicion of an outbreak of cryptosporidiosis within the study group, due to pool "X", a nested case control study was performed. Each case of Cryptosporidium gastroenteritis was matched with six controls and data from weekly Health Diaries from the WQS were reviewed. The Department of Human Services also instigated active surveillance among patrons at pool "X" using a systematic sample of 50 people from the pool's swim-school enrollment list. RESULTS: There were seven cases of Cryptosporidium gastroenteritis in the case control study. Five cases and eight controls swam at pool "X" during the outbreak period. The adjusted odds of developing cryptosporidial diarrhoea if an individual swam at pool "X" was 34.5 (CI 2.3-2548). DHS identified another 11 laboratory confirmed cases associated with pool "X" as well as cases not linked to pool "X". 125 cases were identified throughout Melbourne with the suspected involvement of seven swimming pools. CONCLUSIONS: Despite a high odds ratio of developing cryptosporidiosis this outbreak was not detected by routine surveillance methods. Current outbreak detection methods lack sensitivity, specificity or timeliness. IMPLICATIONS: Improved surveillance systems are required if outbreaks of gastroenteritis are to be detected early so an intervention can be instigated to reduce the amount of subsequent illness.

Prevalence of enteric pathogens among community based asymptomatic individuals.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: The objective of this study was to describe the prevalence of pathogenic microorganisms in asymptomatic individuals in a community study in Melbourne, Australia. METHODS: The study population was a subset of 2803 individuals participating in the Water Quality Study; a community based randomized trial. Faecal specimens (1091) were collected over a 3-month period from asymptomatic individuals. Specimens were tested for a range of bacteria including Salmonella, Shigella and Campylobacter species. Rotavirus and adenovirus were detected using a Rota-Adeno latex kit, and protozoa were detected using a permanent stain (modified iron-haemotoxylin). RESULTS: Twenty-eight known pathogens were identified from the 1091 faecal specimens, a total carriage rate of 2.6%. Giardia species were present in 18 specimens (1.6%), Salmonella in four (0.4%), Campylobacter in one (0.1%), Cryptosporidium in four (0.4%) and adenovirus in one (0.1%). Blastocystis hominis was found in 65 specimens. The median age of those without a pathogen was 12.5 years compared with 6.6 years for those with a pathogen (P=0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Except for Giardia, pathogens were rarely found in asymptomatic individuals in the community. The prevalence of pathogens was higher in children than adults.

Risk science and communication issues and challenges for food: an Australian perspective.

From any perspective, whether it be Australia or other countries, the issue of risk and food is one that includes all sectors of the community. The expansion of information technology and globalisation is making society as a whole more knowledgeable and expectant of safer foods with minimal risk. There is risk in everything and the basis of risk science is one that involves a number of established steps such as risk assessment, management and communication. The evolution of food technology, production and dietary habits, together with changes in trade, will no doubt raise new safety issues and governments need to be abreast of risk science to assess such changes.

Fecal colonization with vancomycin-resistant enterococci in Australia.

To assess the rate of fecal vancomycin-resistant enterococci (VRE) colon ization in Austalia, we examined specimens from 1,085 healthy volunteers. VRE was cultured from 2(0.2%) of 1,085 specimens; both were vanB Enter ococcus faecium, identical by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, but with a pattern rare in Melbourne hospitals.

Determinants of antibodies to Cryptosporidium infection among gay and bisexual men with HIV infection.

A cross-sectional serosurvey for markers of prior Cryptosporidium infection was conducted among homosexual or bisexual males infected with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV); of 262 individuals approached, 236 (90%) agreed to participate. Serological response to two Cryptosporidium antigens was measured using a Western blot assay. The intensity or detection of serological responses to two Cryptosporidium antigens was not associated with CD4 cell counts or tap water consumption. A number of sexual practices were related to increased serological response for only the 27-kDa marker, including having had sex within the past 2 years, having anal sex and having had a larger number of sex partners during the past 2 years. Attending a spa or sauna was related to serological response to both the 27-kDa and 17-kDa markers. Based on these results, activities related to sexual activity appear to be a significant risk factors for prior Cryptosporidium infection.