Fitting models for the joint action of two drugs using SAS.

Combinations of drugs are increasingly being used for a wide variety of diseases and conditions. A pre-clinical study may allow the investigation of the response at a large number of dose combinations. In determining the response to a drug combination, interest may lie in seeking evidence of 'synergism', in which the joint action is greater than the actions of the individual drugs, or of 'antagonism', in which it is less. Two well-known response surface models representing no interaction are Loewe additivity and Bliss independence, and Loewe or Bliss synergism or antagonism is defined relative to these. We illustrate an approach to fitting these models for the case in which the marginal single drug dose-response relationships are represented by four-parameter logistic curves with common upper and lower limits, and where the response variable is normally distributed with a common variance about the dose-response curve. When the dose-response curves are not parallel, the relative potency of the two drugs varies according to the magnitude of the desired effect and the models for Loewe additivity and synergism/antagonism cannot be explicitly expressed. We present an iterative approach to fitting these models without the assumption of parallel dose-response curves. A goodness-of-fit test based on residuals is also described. Implementation using the SAS NLIN procedure is illustrated using data from a pre-clinical study.

Implementation of a Bayesian adaptive design in a proof of concept study.

With increased costs of drug development the need for efficient studies has become critical. A key decision point on the development pathway has become the proof of concept study. These studies must provide clear information to the project teams to enable decision making about further developing a drug candidate but also to gain evidence that any effect size is sufficient to warrant this development given the current market environment. Our case study outlines one such proof of concept trial where a new candidate therapy for neuropathic pain was investigated to assess dose-response and to evaluate the magnitude of its effect compared to placebo. A Normal Dynamic Linear Model was used to estimate the dose-response--enforcing some smoothness in the dose-response, but allowing for the fact that the dose-response may be non-monotonic. A pragmatic, parallel group study design was used with interim analyses scheduled to allow the sponsor to drop ineffective doses or to stop the study. Simulations were performed to assess the operating characteristics of the study design. The study results are presented. Significant cost savings were made when it transpired that the new candidate drug did not show superior efficacy when compared placebo and the study was stopped.

A Bayesian design and analysis for dose-response using informative prior information.

We wish to use prior information on an existing drug in the design and analysis of a dose-response study for a new drug candidate within the same pharmacological class. Using the Bayesian methodology, this prior information can be used quantitatively and the randomization can be weighted in favor of the new compound, where there is less information. An Emax model is used to describe the dose-response of the existing drug. The estimates from this model are used to provide informative prior information used for the design and analysis of the new study to establish the relative potency between the new compound and the existing drug therapy. The assumption is made that the data from previous trials and the new study are exchangeable. The impact of departures from this assumption can be quantified through simulations and by assessing the operating characteristics of various scenarios. Simulations show that relatively modest sample sizes can yield informative results about the magnitude of the relative potency using this approach. The operating characteristics are good when assessing model estimates against clinically important changes in relative potency.