Evaluation of post-PCR purification methods and subsequent optimisation of the MinElute® PCR Purification Kit for low input DNA samples amplified with PowerPlex® 21.

Weak and partial DNA profiles are commonly encountered within forensic casework due to amplification of low DNA input samples. One option for increasing allelic detection in such samples is the purification of amplified PCR product using commercially available column-based methods. In this study, four commercially available post-PCR purification methods, QIAGEN MinElute®, Independent Forensics Amplicon™ Rx, Millipore Microcon® and Thermo Fisher Scientific ExoSAP-IT™ were evaluated, comparing the quality of PowerPlex® 21 DNA profiles produced to the standard DNA profile generated prior to purification. An increased detection of alleles above the analytical threshold was observed following purification with the MinElute®, Amplicon™ Rx and Microcon® methods, allowing informative DNA profiles to be recovered using as little as 8 pg DNA. However, post-PCR purification using the ExoSAP-IT™ kit was unsuccessful, with no alleles detected above analytical threshold in samples with ≤16 pg DNA. The MinElute® kit was selected for optimisation on the basis of DNA profile quality, including increased detection of alleles and minimal artefacts. The MinElute® method was optimised by evaluating the number of washes and final elution buffer volume, resulting in a further increase in detection of alleles by reducing the elution buffer volume. Overall, this study showed that PowerPlex® 21 DNA profiles from low input DNA can be successfully enhanced by employing the MinElute® post-PCR purification method.

Interpretation and reporting considerations of low-level DNA profiles following MinElute® purification of PowerPlex® 21 amplified products.

The generation of high-quality DNA profiles from trace amounts of DNA continues to be an issue in forensic casework. Several methods have been proposed over the years to increase recovery rates for low input DNA, including purification of PCR products, an increase in PCR cycle numbers and increasing injection time or voltage during electrophoresis. In this study, the characteristics of DNA profiles generated using QIAGEN MinElute® purification of Promega PowerPlex® 21 amplified products for low DNA input samples, ranging from 80 pg down to 4 pg, were evaluated. MinElute® purification was found to be a simple, effective and time efficient method, which can greatly improve the resolution of amplified PCR products, recovering 100% of donor concordant alleles from as little 16 pg of input template DNA and generating sufficient allelic information for interpretation from as low as 4 pg inputs. However, as is commonly observed with low template DNA samples, the results exhibited extensive disparity in the effects of stochastic variation in amplification, including increased heterozygote peak height imbalance, stutter ratios and instances of allelic drop-in and drop-out, both within and between replicates. As such, it is important that the extent and variability of these stochastic effects are appropriately incorporated in the development of robust profile interpretation guidelines for DNA profiles generated from purified PCR products.