360-degree evaluations of plastic surgery resident accreditation council for graduate medical education competencies: experience using a short form.

BACKGROUND: The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education has asked training programs to develop methods to evaluate resident performance, using competencies essential for outcomes. METHODS: A two-page form was completed by 12 surgeons and 28 nurses and clinical staff directly involved in plastic surgery patient care (n = 40), evaluating University of Kentucky plastic surgery residents at each level of training (n = 6). There were eight groups of health care professionals among the 40. Six Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education competencies were rated, with technical/operative skills added as a subset of patient care. Hierarchical cluster analysis was used to determine similarity of rating profiles of the rating groups; Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance delineated the way in which the participants used the competencies to make their selections by asking them whether they would choose the resident for future surgical care. RESULTS: Rating profiles revealed two clusters of raters. In one cluster were nurses assigned to an ambulatory surgery center, faculty, residents, and an intern (the surgeons' cluster; n = 15); in the second cluster were other nurses and clinical staff (nurses' cluster; n = 25). The nurses' cluster was found to rate residents more positively, and the surgeons' cluster more often cited areas for improvement. Specific competencies deemed important to each group were identified. CONCLUSIONS: Resident performance is rated differently by health care professionals, in two distinct groups. Based on this clustered arrangement, the resident is able quarterly to enjoy two, independent, formative assessments, potentially over 6 years of integrated training.

Role of recombinant tissue plasminogen activator in free flap salvage.

The use of recombinant tissue plasminogen activator (rTPA) in microvascular surgery has been previously reported, but no consensus exists regarding its indications, dose, efficacy, or safety. The records of all patients undergoing free tissue transfer at one institution between 2000 and 2005 were reviewed. Patients requiring reexploration for pedicle thrombosis were identified. Chi-square and the two-sided Fisher's exact tests were used to compare differences between the two groups. Two hundred seventy-five free flaps were performed in 259 patients. In 27 cases (10 percent), reexploration for impending failure was performed, and pedicle thrombosis was observed in 22 cases. In 15 cases, rTPA was administered. Ten of these flaps (67 percent) were successfully salvaged, compared to 2/7 (29 percent) in the no-rTPA group. Heparin was used in 12 patients but was not associated with a higher salvage rate. These findings suggest that the isolated perfusion of rTPA in the salvage of the failing free flap may be more effective than anastomotic revision alone and should be considered when vascular thrombosis is encountered on reexploration of the failing free flap.

Breast reduction as an alternative treatment option for early breast cancer in women with macromastia.

Macromastia has been considered a relative contraindication to breast conservation therapy because of difficulties with postoperative radiation therapy and cosmesis. This study evaluates the feasibility of the inferior pedicle reduction mammaplasty as a component of breast conservation therapy for patients with early breast cancer. A retrospective review identified 6 patients with macromastia receiving oncologic treatment of breast cancer and simultaneous breast reduction. Mean age was 43.5 +/- 8.7 (mean +/- SD) years, and all breast cancers were stage I or II, averaging 2.3 +/- 1.5 cm in size. All patients underwent a Wise-pattern inferior pedicle breast reduction after cancer extirpation and received postoperative radiation as part of their treatment. They were evaluated for postoperative complications, esthetic outcome of the breasts, and local recurrence. Patients in this series were followed for an average of 30.3 months, with no significant postoperative complications and recurrences. Breast reduction incisions healed primarily and adjuvant radiation was completed without a delay. All patients were pleased with the esthetic result and had improvement of their symptoms related to macromastia. Thus, we believe that breast reduction is a reasonable and safe option for early breast cancer patients with macromastia who desire breast conservation therapy. Our combined oncologic and reconstructive approach may improve the outcome of this group of patients with early breast cancers.

Modern surgical treatment of complex facial fractures: a 6-year review.

Open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) with refined titanium plates and screws have revolutionized the surgical treatment of complex facial fractures, but its outcome remains relatively unknown. The purpose of this study is to review the results of modern surgical treatment of complex facial fractures involving at least two of the three zones of the face. From 1996 to 2002, 54 consecutive patients (41 males, 13 females; age 5-74 years) with complex facial fractures were treated by the plastic surgery service in our institution. All patients had their fractures repaired within 10 days after injury. ORIF of the fractures was performed through standard surgical approaches for the upper, middle, or lower face in a preferred sequence. Multiple rigid fixations were completed with current titanium plates and screws. Postoperative functional problems, residual cosmetic deformities, and reoperations for any complications in each patient were evaluated. All patients have been followed for up to 5 years. Overall, of the 54 consecutive patients in this study, 8 (14.8%) patients had postoperative functional problems, and 7 (13.0%) developed variable postoperative cosmetic deformities. Only nine (16.7%) patients underwent a subsequent reoperation for correction of the functional or cosmetic concern. Thus, we believe that modern surgical treatment of complex facial fractures by way of open treatment and rigid fixation with refined titanium plates and screws has resulted in overall good to excellent outcomes and a relatively low postoperative complication rate.

Microvascular free flap reconstruction in pediatric lower extremity trauma: a 10-year review.

BACKGROUND: Limb-threatening wounds of the adult distal lower extremity pose a challenge to the microvascular surgeon and are the subject of a sizable body of literature. The microsurgical management of these injuries in the pediatric population has some unique features but has not previously been the subject of a separate study. METHODS: A review was performed of all pediatric patients (<18 years of age) who received lower extremity free flaps for trauma at the University of Kentucky Medical Center between 1992 and 2002. Charts were reviewed and patients were contacted via telephone and given a standardized questionnaire. Logistic regression was used to identify factors predictive of worse outcome or complications. RESULTS: Twenty-six patients (28 flaps) met the selection criteria. The most common mechanism of injury was all-terrain vehicle accidents (n = 6), followed by motorcycle accidents, lawnmower injuries, and gunshot wounds. The latissimus dorsi muscle flap was chosen in 15 cases, with four other muscle flaps chosen for the remaining 13 cases. There were 12 Gustillo 3B or 3C fractures of the tibia. External fixation was used in 10 cases and internal fixation was used in two. Four patients had a bone gap greater than 4 cm. Three were successfully treated with distraction osteogenesis. The postoperative complication rate was 62 percent, with infection and partial skin graft loss being the most common complications. Three flaps were lost. Growth disturbances were seen in two patients. Patients receiving free flaps within 7 days after injury were seen to have a statistically significant lower rate of complications than those undergoing the procedure beyond the first week. Follow-up ranged from 2 to 11 years, with a mean follow-up of 4.5 years. All limbs were successfully salvaged, and all patients were ambulatory at the time of the survey. CONCLUSIONS: There is a significant role for the microvascular surgeon in the management of limb-threatening injuries in children. If the unique features of this population are taken into consideration, a high rate of limb salvage and good function can be expected.