Differential inhibition of collagenase and interleukin-1alpha gene expression in cultured corneal fibroblasts by TGF-beta, dexamethasone, and retinoic acid.

PURPOSE: Expression of the genes for collagenase and interleukin-1alpha (IL-1alpha) are induced as stromal cells become activated to the repair fibroblast phenotype after injury to the cornea. This investigation examines the mechanisms whereby expression of these genes is inhibited by transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta), dexamethasone (DEX), or retinoic acid (RET A). METHODS: A model of freshly isolated cultures of corneal stromal cells and early passage cultures of corneal fibroblasts was used in these studies. This model reproduces the events of stromal cell activation in the corneal wound. RESULTS: In early passage cultures of corneal fibroblasts, expression of collagenase is under obligatory control by autocrine IL-1alpha. IL-1alpha controls its own expression through an autocrine feedback loop that is dependent on transcription factor NF-kappaB. TGF-beta, DEX, and RET A were each effective inhibitors of collagenase gene expression in these cells. Furthermore, these agents have the capacity to inhibit expression of IL-1alpha and this was correlated with their ability to affect DNA-binding activity of NF-kappaB. However, TGF-beta, DEX, and RET A were also effective inhibitors of the low level of collagenase expressed by freshly isolated corneal stromal cells that cannot express IL-1alpha. CONCLUSIONS: In cells with an active IL-1alpha autocrine loop there are at least two distinct signaling pathways by which collagenase gene expression can be modulated. The results of this study demonstrate that TGF-beta, DEX, and RET A differentially inhibit collagenase and IL-1alpha gene expression. This information will be useful in the design of therapeutic modalities for fibrotic disease in the cornea and other parts of the eye.

Regulation of gelatinase B production in corneal cells is independent of autocrine IL-1alpha.

PURPOSE: The matrix metalloproteinase gelatinase B is synthesized by cells at the leading edge of the corneal epithelium migrating to heal a wound. Recent data from the authors' laboratory suggest that excessive synthesis contributes to repair defects. The goal of the study reported here was to investigate mechanisms controlling gelatinase B production by corneal epithelial cells. METHODS: Freshly isolated cultures of corneal epithelial cells and early passage stromal fibroblasts from rabbit were used for these studies. RESULTS: In a previous study, it was found that the cytokine interleukin (IL)-1alpha is released into the culture medium of corneal epithelial cells more efficiently when they are plated at low density with limited cell-cell contact than when plated at high density. In this study, we show that production of gelatinase B by these cells is similarly affected by cell plating density. However, it is further demonstrated that these two events are not dependent on one another but occur in parallel: IL-1alpha does not regulate gelatinase B production (synthesis), nor was there evidence that any other secreted autocrine cytokine acts as mediator. Instead, our data suggest that gelatinase B production is downregulated directly by high cell density and indicate a connection to the level of protein kinase C activity. Nevertheless, the anticancer agent suramin, which blocks collagenase synthesis by interfering with autocrine cytokine-receptor interactions, still inhibits synthesis of gelatinase B. CONCLUSIONS: Unlike collagenase synthesis by corneal stromal fibroblasts, production (synthesis) of gelatinase B does not appear to be controlled by secreted autocrine cytokines but can still be inhibited by suramin. Suramin may make an effective therapeutic agent for controlling pathologic overproduction of gelatinase B in corneal ulcers.

AP-2alpha transcription factor is required for early morphogenesis of the lens vesicle.

AP-2 transcription factors are a family of retinoic acid-responsive genes, which are involved in complex morphogenetic processes. In the current study, we determine the requirement for AP-2alpha in early morphogenesis of the eye by examining the nature of the ocular defects in AP-2alpha null and chimeric mice. AP-2alpha null embryos exhibited ocular phenotypes ranging from a complete lack of eyes (anophthalmia) to defects in the developing lens involving a persistent adhesion of the lens to the overlying surface ectoderm. Two genes involved in lens development and differentiation, Pax6 and MIP26 were also misexpressed. AP-2alpha mutants also exhibited defects in the optic cup consisting of transdifferentiation of the dorsal retinal pigmented epithelium into neural retina and the absence of a defined ganglion cell layer. Newly generated chimeric embryos consisting of a population of AP-2alpha-/- and AP-2alpha+/+ cells exhibit ocular defects similar to those seen in the knockout embryos. Immunolocalization of AP-2 proteins (alpha, beta, and gamma) to the normal developing eye revealed both unique and overlapping expression patterns, with AP-2alpha expressed in a number of the ocular tissues that exhibited defects in the mutants, including the developing lens where AP-2alpha is uniquely expressed. Together these findings demonstrate a requirement for AP-2alpha in early morphogenesis of the eye.

Frog PNKT-4B cells express specific extracellular matrix-degrading enzymes and cytokines correlated with an invasive phenotype.

A temperature-dependent metastatic phenotype reported for a frog cell line, PNKT-4B, provided a means for studying potential mediators of cell-matrix interaction involved in metastatic invasion. Zymography revealed that these cells secreted enzyme species with properties and characteristics of mammalian metalloproteinases: collagenase, stromelysin, gelatinase A, and gelatinase B. These enzymes were produced by PNKT-4B cultures maintained at both invasive-permissive (28 degrees C), and invasion-restrictive (20 degrees C) temperatures. However, under the invasive-permissive culture condition cells produced more of the putative gelatinase B and A enzymes. In addition, an activated form of gelatinase A was produced only in invasion-permissive cultures. DNA synthesis bioassays (Mv1Lu cell line and mouse thymocytes) to detect growth promoting and/or inhibitory cytokines, revealed that PNKT-4B cultures kept at 28 degrees C released significantly higher levels of stimulatory (interleukin-1-like) and latent inhibitory (transforming growth factor-beta-like) substances into the medium compared to 20 degrees C cultures. Pre-absorption of media samples with heparin-sepharose indicated a second stimulatory cytokine as well. A corneal fibroblast bioassay that tests for mediators of collagenase synthesis, detected a stimulatory substance whose activity was greatly reduced in the presence of interleukin-1 receptor antagonist protein. Collagenase stimulatory activity present in 28 degrees C culture medium was significantly higher than equal samples from 20 degrees C cultures. These studies provide a molecular correlation between release of cytokines with properties of the metastatic phenotype seen in vivo. They further provide some of the first characterizations of frog MMPs and cytokines, which are likely to be involved in other tissue remodeling events.

Repair phenotype in corneal fibroblasts is controlled by an interleukin-1 alpha autocrine feedback loop.

PURPOSE: To explore the role of autocrine interleukin-1 alpha (IL-1 alpha) as a central regulator of the repair phenotype in corneal fibroblasts. METHODS: Disruption of the actin cytoskeleton with cytochalasin B (CB), which mimics changes in shape that occur in repair tissues, was used to stimulate repair gene expression in early-passage fibroblasts. Changes in expression of IL-1 alpha, IL-8, collagenase, and ENA-78 were determined by Northern blot analysis, radioimmunoassay, and an enzyme-amplified sensitivity immunoassay (EASIA). Expression of repair genes was also examined in repair fibroblasts, isolated from healing, penetrating keratectomy wounds in rabbits. RESULTS: Blocking IL-1 alpha activity prevented both constitutive and stimulated increases in synthesis of IL-8 and collagenase in early-passage cultures of corneal fibroblasts, demonstrating the role of IL-1 alpha as a necessary intermediate for expression of these genes. Evidence is also presented that the IL-1 alpha autocrine controls expression of an IL-8 related factor, ENA-78. Unlike early-passage fibroblasts, fibroblasts freshly isolated from the uninjured cornea did not express IL-1 alpha. However, fibroblasts freshly isolated from remodeling corneal repair tissue 3 weeks after injury were found to express substantial levels of IL-1 alpha, regulated through an autocrine feedback loop. Neutralization experiments demonstrated that the IL-1 alpha autocrine is largely responsible for controlling both collagenase and IL-8 synthesis in repair fibroblasts, as it is in early-passage fibroblasts. CONCLUSIONS: These findings provide evidence that activation of an autocrine IL-1 alpha feedback loop is an important mechanism by which fibroblasts adopt a repair phenotype during remodeling of the cornea.

Regulation of paracrine cytokine balance controlling collagenase synthesis by corneal cells.

PURPOSE: Classic studies have demonstrated that corneal epithelial cell density in culture can alter the balance of stimulatory and inhibitory cytokines controlling the elaboration of collagenolytic activity by co-cultured stromal cells. The current study attempts to bring the understanding of this mechanism to a molecular level. METHODS: A rabbit primary corneal cell culture model was used. RESULTS: Using molecular probes that bind to and neutralize specific cytokines, a major stimulator for stromal cell collagenase synthesis released by corneal epithelial cells into culture medium was identified as interleukin-1 alpha (IL-1 alpha), and a secondary stimulator was characterized as a heparin-binding cytokine. An inverse relationship between net collagenase stimulatory activity and epithelial cell plating density was demonstrated. In contrast, the release of inhibitory activity for IL-1-stimulated collagenase synthesis was not subject to the cell density effect. Direct measurement of IL-1 alpha protein levels revealed that this cytokine was released much more efficiently on a per cell basis when cells were plated at low density than when they were plated at high density. The effect was not caused by greater cell lysis at low cell density and was mediated only partially by changes at the IL-1 alpha synthesis level. CONCLUSIONS: These data provide evidence that epithelial cells release stimulatory cytokines for collagenase expression more efficiently when they have limited contact with their neighbors and that this has important consequences for the overall paracrine cytokine balance controlling collagenase synthesis. Alteration of the paracrine cytokine balance by changes in cell contact may be an important means for regulating epithelial-stromal interactions involved in corneal development and repair.

Perspectives on eye development.

The lens of the vertebrate eye was the classic model used to demonstrate the concepts of inductive interactions controlling development. However, it is in the Drosophila model that the greatest progress in understanding molecular mechanisms of eye development have most recently been mode. This progress can be attributed to the power of molecular genetics, an approach that was once confined to simpler systems like worms and flies, but is now becoming possible in vertebrates. Thus, the use of transgenic and knock-out gene technology, coupled with the availability of new positional cloning methods, has recently initiated a surge of progress in the mouse genetic model and has also led to the identification of genes involved in human inherited disorders. In addition, gene transfer techniques have opened up opportunities for progress using chick, Xenopus, and other classic developmental systems. Finally, a new vertebrate genetic model, zebrafish, appears very promising for molecular studies. As a result of the opportunities presented by these new approaches, eye development has come into the limelight, hence the timeliness of this focus issue of Developmental Genetics. In this introductory review, we discuss three areas of current work arising through the use of these newer genetic approaches, and pertinent to research articles presented herein. We also touch on related studies reported at the first Keystone Meeting on Ocular Cell and Molecular Biology, recently held in Tamarron Springs, Colorado, January 7-12, 1997.

Role of serum amyloid A as an intermediate in the IL-1 and PMA-stimulated signaling pathways regulating expression of rabbit fibroblast collagenase.

The matrix metalloproteinase collagenase is expressed by resident tissue cells only when needed for biological remodeling. Exogenous addition of inflammatory and growth-promoting cytokines stimulates collagenase expression in early passage fibroblast cultures. In addition, the signal for collagenase expression in response to phorbol-12 myristate-13 acetate (PMA) or to agents which alter cell shape in early passage fibroblast cultures is routed extracellularly to an autocrine cytokine intermediate, IL-1 alpha. Importantly, fibroblasts, when freshly isolated from the tissue, are not competent for IL-1 alpha gene expression and, therefore, cannot produce collagenase in response to shape change agents. However, they do make a small amount of collagenase in response to PMA via an IL-1-independent pathway that has not been further characterized. In this paper, we investigate the role of a second autocrine, serum amyloid A3 (SAA3), in IL-1-dependent and -independent collagenase gene expression. We demonstrate that SAA3 is required for effective stimulation of collagenase expression by either exogenous or endogenous IL-1. Furthermore, while freshly isolated fibroblasts cannot express IL-1 alpha they can express SAA3, and this autocrine mediator acts independently of IL-1 alpha to control the low level of collagenase expression that can be stimulated by PMA. These results provide further evidence for a newly emerging paradigm of collagenase regulation which emphasizes the requirement for extracellular routing of signals. They also suggest that SAA3 might be utilized independently of IL-1 alpha to control tissue remodeling in vivo.

Competence for collagenase gene expression by tissue fibroblasts requires activation of an interleukin 1 alpha autocrine loop.

The enzyme collagenase (EC 3.4.24.7), a key mediator in biological remodeling, can be induced in early-passage fibroblasts by a wide variety of agents and conditions. In contrast, at least some primary tissue fibroblasts are incompetent to synthesize collagenase in response to many of these stimulators. In this study, we investigate mechanisms controlling response to two of the conditions in question: (i) trypsin or cytochalasin B, which disrupt actin stress fibers, or (ii) phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA), which activates growth factor signaling pathways. We demonstrate that collagenase expression stimulated by trypsin or cytochalasin B is regulated entirely through an autocrine cytokine, interleukin 1 alpha (IL-1 alpha). The IL-1 alpha intermediate also constitutes the major mechanism by which PMA stimulates collagenase expression, although a second signaling pathway(s) contributes to a minor extent. Elevation of the IL-1 alpha level in response to stimulators is found to be sustained by means of an autocrine feedback loop in early-passage fibroblast cultures. In contrast, fibroblasts freshly isolated from the tissue are incompetent to activate and sustain the IL-1 alpha feedback loop, even though they synthesize collagenase in response to exogenous IL-1. We conclude that this is the reason why tissue fibroblasts are limited, in comparison with subcultured fibroblasts, in their capacity to synthesize collagenase. Activation of the IL-1 alpha feedback loop, therefore, seems likely to be an important mechanism by which resident tissue cells adopt the remodeling phenotype.

A corneal epithelial inhibitor of stromal cell collagenase synthesis identified as TGF-beta 2.

PURPOSE: To determine the molecular mechanisms whereby substances released by corneal epithelial cells act to inhibit the elaboration of collagenolytic activity by corneal stromal cells and to determine whether inhibitory activity might be mediated by interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1ra) or transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta. METHODS: Conditioned media were generated from primary cultures of rabbit corneal epithelial cells, from passaged cultures of rabbit corneal stromal fibroblasts, and from cells of the rabbit corneal epithelial cell line, SIRC. Pure populations of stromal cells were isolated from rabbit cornea and used directly for bioassay of the conditioned media to detect substances that inhibit collagenase synthesis. The mink lung epithelial cell line, Mv1Lu, was used for bioassay of TGF-beta-like activity. The addition of specific neutralizing antisera to bioassays allowed an assessment of the contribution of each isoform to the net regulatory activity. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction and Northern blot analysis were employed to detect the presence of IL-1ra or TGF-beta mRNA species in cells from cultures used to generate conditioned media. RESULTS: Both stimulatory and inhibitory substances that regulate the synthesis of stromal cell collagenase are released by corneal epithelial cells in primary culture. In contrast, only stimulatory activity is produced by corneal fibroblasts or SIRCs. MRNAs for a TGF-beta isoform, TGF-beta 2, and IL-1ra were identified in epithelial cells. Stromal fibroblasts also expressed TGF-beta 2 mRNA, but no evidence was found for expression of TGF-beta 3 mRNA in any of the three cell types. TGF-beta 2 is released by epithelial cells in both active and latent forms. This cytokine mediates the major portion of the net inhibitory activity against stromal cell collagenase synthesis produced by corneal epithelial cells. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates the expression of TGF-beta 2 and IL-1ra by corneal epithelial cells in culture. It is the TGF-beta 2 that acts as the major inhibitor of collagenase synthesis by corneal stromal cells in culture. However, IL-1ra and TGF-beta 2 are likely to play important roles in epithelial-mesenchymal interactions regulating corneal development, homeostatic maintenance, and repair.

Interleukin 1 alpha mediates collagenase synthesis stimulated by phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate.

Stimulation of collagenase expression in cultures of normal diploid fibroblasts by the tumor promotor phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) occurs secondarily to synthesis of unknown intermediary proteins. We have investigated the hypothesis that a form of the cytokine interleukin 1 (IL-1) is one intermediate controlling PMA-stimulated collagenase expression. Treatment with an IL-1 receptor antagonist inhibits the constitutive synthesis of collagenase in early passage fibroblast cultures from rabbit. Radioimmunoassay demonstrates that, of the two known IL-1 forms, IL-1 alpha and IL-1 beta, only IL-1 alpha is synthesized and released into the medium of corneal fibroblast cultures. PMA treatment of cells increases the level of IL-1 alpha mRNA; this occurs prior to the increase in collagenase mRNA and corresponds with increased synthesis and release of IL-1 alpha protein. Neutralizing antiserum to IL-1 alpha inhibits constitutive collagenase synthesis. Reagents that inhibit the activity of IL-1 alpha (IL-1 receptor antagonist or neutralizing antibody) also inhibit the PMA-mediated stimulation of collagenase synthesis. These results indicate that constitutive and PMA-stimulated expression of collagenase is regulated through an IL-1 alpha intermediate. In vivo, regulation of the lytic phase of tissue remodeling through the IL-1 alpha intermediate may ensure the recruitment of cells adjacent to the one that received the initial stimulus.