Toxicity assessment of a tebuconazole-based fungicide on the embryo-larval development of the common south American toad Rhinella arenarum.

Agrochemicals cause diverse effects on aquatic communities, and amphibian species are particularly threatened due the high susceptibility to contamination. Present study evaluates the toxicity of a widely used fungicide tebuconazole (Trigal®) by the assessment of mortality and developmental alterations at acute, subchronic, and chronic exposure during the embryo-larval development of the South American toad Rhinella arenarum. Also, the sensitivity of the different embryonic stages was evaluated with 24-h pulse exposure treatments. The results demonstrated that larvae were more sensitive than embryos at acute exposure (LC50-24 and 96 h = 74.62, 31.92 mg/L and 24.27, 16.81 mg/L for embryos and larvae, respectively). Nevertheless, embryos toxicity increased significantly achieving a sensitivity very similar to larvae at chronic exposure (LC50-168 and 504 h = 13.31, 4.35 mg/L and 14.47, 6.83 mg/L for embryos and larvae, respectively). Embryos exhibited several sublethal effects from 5 mg/L at 96 h onwards, such as delayed development, reduce body size, edemas, tail/axial flexures, weakness, and absence of movements. The teratogenic index at 96 h was 10.13, indicating the severe teratogenic potential of the fungicide. 24-h pulse exposure treatments showed an increased sensitivity in intermediate stages as S.11, S.18, S20, and S.23 (NOEC-96 h = 100, 200, 75, and 20 mg/L, respectively), while stage S.25 was the most sensitive to the fungicide (NOEC-96 h = 5 mg/L). About metamorphic process, tebuconazole caused an acceleration of metamorphosis at the lowest concentration (0.001 mg/L), but also an increase in mortality and in addition, significant differences in the weight in all treatments. The results obtained throughout this work indicate that tebuconazole cause several adverse effects in Rhinella arenarum embryo-larval development.

Acute, chronic and neurotoxic effects of dimethoate pesticide on Rhinella arenarum throughout the development.

Among the factors implicated in amphibian global decline, agrochemicals have been gaining increasing attention. In order to evaluate the toxicity of a dimethoate-based insecticide on the early development of an autochthonous amphibian, Rhinella arenarum, continuous and 24 h pulse exposure bioassays were carried out. Lethal and sublethal effects, neurotoxicity and the ecological risk were assessed. Results demonstrate that larvae were more sensitive than embryos with 504 h-LC50 of 12.82 and 16.38 mg L-1, respectively. 24 h pulse experiments showed a high toxicity increment at early embryonic stages, while the sensitivity at later stages was high and constant. Dimethoate caused teratogenesis and several sublethal effects as morphological and behavioral alterations but also disruption in the metamorphic process. About neurotoxicity, dimethoate inhibited the activity of butyrylcholinesterase at 0.5 and 1 mg L-1 exposed larvae. The results obtained in this study as the risk assessment revealed that dimethoate represents a hazard on Rhinella arenarum survival and development but also a potential risk for the continuity of the populations of this species in agroecosystems.

Characterization of acute toxicity, genotoxicity, and oxidative stress of dimethoate in Rhinella arenarum larvae.

There is a great concern worldwide about the global decline of amphibians, particularly by agrochemical pollution. The aim of this study was to assess oxidative stress and genotoxicity of a commercial formulation of the insecticide dimethoate in Rhinella arenarum larvae, using sublethal biomarkers. The 24- and 96-h LC50 values of dimethoate to R. arenarum were 48.81 and 38.86 mg L-1, while the 96-h no observed effect concentration (NOEC) value was 20 mg L-1. For sublethal biomarker assays, R. arenarum larvae were exposed to 1.25, 2.5, and 5% of the 96-h NOEC (0.25, 0.5, and 1 mg L-1 dimethoate, respectively). After 96 h of exposure, inhibition of catalase (CAT) and glutathione S-transferase (GST) activities were registered. Also, an increased superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity was observed in larvae exposed to the highest concentration (1 mg L-1). Lipid peroxidation by increased thiobarbituric acid reactive substance levels in larvae exposed to 0.5 and 1 mg L-1 was detected. No differences in micronuclei frequency between treatments and negative control were observed. These results demonstrate the oxidative toxicity of dimethoate at sublethal concentrations in Rhinella arenarum larvae. The disruption of defense mechanisms may contribute to a deleterious impact on amphibian populations from habitats exposed to this organophosphorus insecticide.

Developmental Toxicity Assessment of a Chlorothalonil-Based Fungicide in a Native Amphibian Species.

The toxicity of a commercial formulation of the fungicide chlorothalonil in sensitive stages of the native amphibian Rhinella arenarum (Ra) was assessed by means continuous treatments from embryo and larval development and 24-h pulse exposures evaluating acute and chronic lethal and sublethal effects and stage-dependent sensitivity. A risk assessment of chlorothalonil in Ra development also was performed. The results of continuous exposure in embryos showed a significant toxicity increase with exposure time, whereas sensitivity of larvae remained relatively constant through time (24 and 504-h LC50 = 0.86 and 0.04 mg L-1, and 0.37 and 0.34 mg L-1 for embryos and larvae respectively). Embryos exhibited several sublethal effects, such as delayed development, tail/axial flexures, edemas, and behavioral alterations. The 96-h NOEC values for lethal and sublethal effects were 0.025 and 0.01 mg L-1 respectively, so the 96-h Teratogenic Index was 2.5, which indicates the severe teratogenic potential of the fungicide. For 24-h pulse exposure experiments, S.21 and S.23 were the most sensitive stages for lethality (504-h NOEC = 0.05 mg L-1), whereas earlier stages exhibited severe morphological alterations. The results obtained in this study and the ecological risk evaluation highlight the severe toxicity of chlorothalonil threatening the continuity of Ra populations.

Oxidative stress and genotoxicity in Rhinella arenarum (Anura: Bufonidae) tadpoles after acute exposure to Ni-Al nanoceramics.

The employ of nanomaterials (NMs) has exponentially grown due to the large number of technological advances in industrial, pharmaceutical and medical areas. That is the case of alumina (Al) nanoparticles which are extensively employed as support in heterogeneous catalysis processes. However, these NMs can cause great toxicity because of their ubiquitous properties, such as extremely small size and high specific surface area. So, it is required to assess the potential deleterious effects of these NMs on living organisms. In the present study, we analyze the oxidative stress and genotoxic potential of a nanoceramic catalyst Ni/-Al2O3 (NC) and the NMs involved in their synthesis, -Al2O3 support (SPC) and NiO/-Al2O3 precursor (PC) on Rhinella arenarum larvae. Biomarkers of oxidative stress and genotoxic damage were measured in tadpoles exposed to 5 and 25 mg/L of each NMs for 96 h. The results indicated an inhibition of catalase activity in tadpoles exposed to both concentrations of PC and to 25 mg/L of SPC and NC. Moreover, both exposure concentrations of PC and NC significantly inhibited superoxide dismutase activity. Exposure to the three NMs caused inhibition of glutathione S-transferase activity, but there were no significant variations in reduced glutathione levels. Oxidative stress damage (lipid peroxidation) was observed in tadpoles treated with 25 mg/L PC, while the other treatments did not produce alterations. The MNs frequency significantly increased in larvae exposed to 25 mg/L PC indicating irreversible genotoxic damage. The results show that these NMs exert genotoxic effects and antioxidant defense system disruption in R. arenarum larvae.

Toxicity characterization and environmental risk assessment of Mancozeb on the South American common toad Rhinella arenarum.

Agricultural activity, especially the increasing use of pesticides, is considered one of the main reasons for the decline of amphibian populations. Mancozeb (MCZ) is one of the most used fungicides worldwide, despite its ancient use and toxicity demonstrated in different taxa. However, there is limited information about the effects of MCZ in amphibians, which are keystones of riparian ecosystems. For species conservation purposes, it is essential to identify the most sensitive developmental period(s) of a given species to a xenobiotic. We evaluated the toxicity of a commercial fungicide of mancozeb, (80% active ingredient) on the early development of the common South American toad Rhinella arenarum (Anura, Bufonidae). Embryos from early blastula (S.4) and larvae from complete operculum (S.25) stages were exposed to a wide range of MCZ concentrations during acute, subchronic and chronic exposure (up to 504 h) periods. The toxicity profiles for lethal and sublethal effects were performed. At all exposure times, MCZ was more toxic to embryos, for instance, NOEC 504 h were 0.01 and 0.05 mg MCZ/L for embryos and larvae, respectively. Thus, embryo sensitivity was 5-fold higher than larvae. A Teratogenic Index of 14 indicated the significant teratogenic potential of this fungicide. Among sublethal effects, embryos exhibited a wide range of abnormalities with high incidence. The ecological risk assessment demonstrated that the estimated Risk Quotient value for Rhinella arenarum embryos at chronic exposure was higher than the Level of Concern value, which warns about the potential risk of MCZ for this native species.

Lethality, neurotoxicity, morphological, histological and cellular alterations of Ni-Al nanoceramics on the embryo-larval development of Rhinella arenarum.

Alumina nanoparticles (NP-Al2O3) are widely used but their environmental effects are unknown, so they can become potentially dangerous. The aim of this study was to evaluate the toxicity of a nanoceramic catalyst Ni/γ-Al2O3 (NC) and NPs involved in their synthesis, γ-Al2O3 support (SPC) and NiO/γ-Al2O3 precursor (PC) on Rhinella arenarum embryo-larval development. The NPs toxicity significantly increased over time obtaining a similar sensitivity to PC and NC (336 h-LC50 = 4.03 and 5.11 mg/L respectively) and very low sensitivity to SPC (336 h-LC50 = 90.83 mg/L). Embryos exposed to SPC and PC exhibited general underdevelopment, axial flexures and behavioral alterations. Pharyngeal and intestinal epithelia alterations at the level of cell surface as dissociation, apoptosis and numerous lysosomes were observed at light and transmission electronic microscopy. Images of scanning electron microscope with backscattered electron detector revealed the presence of nickel in the intestinal epithelium. The increased toxicity of PC could be due to the presence of Ni as oxide which could interfere with vital functions such as breathing and feeding. Taking into account the exponential production and use of these NPs it is expected that their pollution levels will considerably increase and amphibians will be more exposed and at higher risk.

Differential sensitivity of developmental stages of the South American toad to a fungicide based on fludioxonil and metalaxyl-M.

Agricultural fungicide application in Argentina has increased twice since 2008, with Maxim® XL (2.5% fludioxonil +1% metalaxyl-M) as one of the most used fungicide formulation. The toxicity of this pesticide on Rhinella arenarum was assessed by means of continuous (from embryo and larval development) and 24-h pulse exposure standardized bioassays. Lethality was concentration- and exposure time-dependent. Maxim® XL caused a progressive lethal effect along the bioassays with higher toxicity on embryos than larvae, obtaining 50% lethal concentrations at 96, 336, and 504 h of 10.85, 2.89, and 1.71 mg/L for embryos, and 43.94, 11.79, and 5.76 mg/L for larvae respectively. Lethal 504-h no observed effect concentration values for embryos and larvae were 1 and 2.5 mg/L respectively. A stage-dependent toxicity of Maxim® XL was also demonstrated within the embryo development, with early stages more sensitive than the later ones, and blastula as the most sensitive developmental stage. The risk quotients obtained for chronic risk assessment determined a potential threat for the survival and continuity of R. arenarum populations under these conditions. The results indicate that the levels of the fungicide reaching amphibian habitats could be risky for the early development of this amphibian species. This study also emphasizes the necessity to evaluate the chronic effects of fungicides in pesticide risk assessment.

Monitoring the ecotoxicity of γ-Al2O3 and Ni/γ-Al2O3 nanomaterials by means of a battery of bioassays.

The increasing application of nanoparticles (NPs) to a variety of new technologies has become a matter of concern due to the potential toxicity of these materials. Many questions about the fate of NPs in the environment and the subsequent impact on ecosystems need to be answered. The aim of this work was to evaluate the ecotoxicity of two alumina-based nanoceramics, γ-Al2O3 (NC) and Ni/ γ-Al2O3 (NiNC) by means of three different standardized tests: Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD5), bioassay with luminescent bacteria (Vibrio fischeri; Microtox), and bioassay on amphibian larvae (Rhinella arenarum) (AMPHITOX). BOD5 values of a very biodegradable mixture (glucose/glutamic acid) decreased with the addition of NiNC(43.8%) and NC (31.6%) with respect to control samples (52.9%). Microtox test results indicated that NiNC presents higher toxicity than NC, with EC50s values of 16.1% and 29.9% respectively; a reduced toxicity was observed, however, in presence of organic matter, thus obtaining EC50s of 37.8% and 19.4%. The results of AMPHITOX test showed a significant increase in the toxicity of both substances over time, the NiNC toxicity being greater than that of NC. The values of 96h-LC50 and 504h-LC50 determined for NiNC were 1.58 and 0.83mg/L, respectively, and 14.5 and 10.5mg/L for NC samples. Amphibian larvae exhibited collapsed cavities, edema, axial flexures, and behavioral alterations as hyperkinesia and reduced movements. These results evidence the vulnerability of wildlife to xenobiotics and the need to develop specific standardized ecotoxicity tests in order to help environmental sustainability and natural species conservation.

Effects of a fungicide formulation on embryo-larval development, metamorphosis, and gonadogenesis of the South American toad Rhinella arenarum.

Sublethal toxicity of the formulated fungicide Maxim(®) XL on embryonic, larval and juvenile development of Rhinella arenarum was evaluated by means of standardized bioassays. Maxim(®) XL, one of the most used fungicides in Argentina, is based on a mixture of two active ingredients: Fludioxonil and Metalaxyl-M. Maxim(®) XL exposure induced severe sublethal effects on the embryos, expressed as general underdevelopment, axial flexures, microcephaly, cellular dissociation, abnormal pigmentation, underdeveloped gills, marked edema and wavy tail. As the embryo development advanced, alterations in behavior as spasmodic contractions, general weakness and inanition were observed. Maxim(®) XL did not affect neither the time required to complete metamorphosis nor sex proportions, but gonadal development and differentiation were impaired. Gross gonadal analysis revealed a significant proportion of exposed individuals with underdevelopment of one or both gonads. Histological analysis confirmed that 18% and 10% of the individuals exposed to 0.25 and 2mg/L Maxim(®) XL, respectively, exhibited undifferentiated gonads characterized by a reduced number (or absence) of germ cells. Taking into account the risk evaluation performed by means of Hazard Quotients, this fungicide could be a threat to R. arenarum populations under chronic exposure. This study represents the first evidence of toxic effects exerted by Maxim(®) XL on amphibians. Finally, our findings highlight the properties of this fungicide that might jeopardize non-target living species exposed to it in agricultural environments.

Developmental toxicity of bisphenol A diglycidyl ether (epoxide resin badge) during the early life cycle of a native amphibian species.

Bisphenol A diglycidyl ether (BADGE) is used in packaging materials, in epoxy adhesives, and as an additive for plastics, but it is also a potential industrial wastewater contaminant. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the adverse effects of BADGE on Rhinella arenarum by means of standardized bioassays at embryo-larval development. The results showed that BADGE was more toxic to embryos than to larvae at all exposure times. At acute exposure, lethality rates of embryos exposed to concentrations of 0.0005 mg/L BADGE and greater were significantly higher than rates in the vehicle control, whereas lethality rates of larvae were significantly higher in concentrations of 10 mg/L BADGE and greater. The toxicity then increased significantly, with 96-h median lethal concentrations (LC50s) of 0.13 mg/L and 6.9 mg/L BADGE for embryos and larvae, respectively. By the end of the chronic period, the 336-h LC50s were 0.04 mg/L and 2.2 mg/L BADGE for embryos and larvae, respectively. This differential sensitivity was also ascertained by the 24-h pulse exposure experiments, in which embryos showed a stage-dependent toxicity, with blastula being the most sensitive stage and S.23 the most resistant. The most important sublethal effects in embryos were cell dissociation and delayed development, whereas the main abnormalities observed in larvae related to neurotoxicity, as scare response to stimuli and narcotic effect. Environ Toxicol Chem 2016;35:3031-3038. © 2016 SETAC.

Combined endosulfan and cypermethrin-induced toxicity to embryo-larval development of Rhinella arenarum.

The combined effects of two widely used pesticides, endosulfan and cypermethrin, on survival of embryo-larval development of the South American toad (Rhinella arenarum) were examined. The toxicity bioassays were performed according to the AMPHITOX test. Embryos and larvae were exposed to mixtures of these pesticides at equitoxic ratios from acute or chronic exposure to evaluate interaction effects. The results were analyzed using both Marking's additive index and combination index (CI)-isobologram methods. Acute (96-h) and intermediate (168-h) toxicity of endosulfan-cypermethrin mixtures remained almost constant for larvae and embryos, but when exposure duration was increased, there was a significant elevation in toxicity, obtaining chronic (240-h) no-observed-effect concentrations (NOEC) values of 0.045 and 0.16 mg/L for embryos and larvae, respectively. These are environmentally relevant concentrations that reflect a realistic risk of this pesticide mixture to this native amphibian species. The toxicity increment with the exposure duration was coincident with the central nervous system development on embryos reaching the larval period, the main target organ of these pesticides. The interactions of the pesticide mixtures at acute and chronic exposure were antagonistic for embryo development (CI > 1), and additive (CI = 1) for larvae, while chronic exposure interactions were synergistic (CI < 1) for both developmental periods. Data indicated that endosulfan-cypermethrin mixtures resulted in different interaction types depending on duration and developmental stage exposed. As a general pattern and considering conditions of overall developmental period and chronic exposure, this pesticide mixture usually applied in Argentine crop fields is synergistic with respect to toxicity for this native amphibian species.

Comparative sensitivity among early life stages of the South American toad to cypermethrin-based pesticide.

Cypermethrin is one of the most widely used pesticides due to its low mammalian and bird toxicity, but it is extremely toxic to aquatic organisms. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the toxicity of a commercial formulation of cypermethrin on the embryo-larval development of Rhinella arenarum. An ecological risk assessment based on the hazard quotient (HQ) approach was performed. The results showed that cypermethrin toxicity was stage-dependent and dramatically increased during the larval period. Thus, larvae were more sensitive than embryos, obtaining at the end of the experiment a 336-h median lethal concentration (LC50) of 0.65 µg cypermethrin/L. Cypermethrin exposure caused morphological abnormalities such as general underdevelopment, edema, gill malformations, and behavioral alterations as hyperkinesia and spasmodic contractions. The 168-h teratogenic index was 5, implying a high risk for embryos to be malformed in the absence of significant embryonic lethality. Based on the results of the toxicity effects and the ecological risk assessed (HQ for chronic exposure > level of concern), this pesticide should be considered as a direct (effects on survival) or indirect (severe sublethal effects) risk for conservation purposes of this amphibian in agroecosystems.

Differential uptake of endosulfan in the South American toad under sublethal exposure.

Agroecosystems are usually polluted with a wide variety of contaminants with pesticides being very frequently detected. Endosulfan, an organochlorine pesticide, has been shown to cause both lethal and sublethal effects on aquatic organisms such as amphibians and especially on its early developmental stages. In this context, the aim of this study was to evaluate the uptake of environmentally relevant concentrations of endosulfan and its correlation with differential sensitivity in the early development stages of the common South American toad, Rhinella arenarum. Embryos and larvae were exposed to sublethal concentrations of endosulfan for several periods of exposures. According to the developmental stage at which they were exposed, the uptake rate was different. Bioconcentration factors (BCFs) for embryos significantly decreased with exposure time and concentration (p < 0.05) reaching a BCF of ≤1679 for embryos at 96 h of exposure to 0.001 mg endosulfan L(-1). BCFs for larvae significantly increased with exposure time (p < 0.05) obtaining a maximum of 40 at 504 h. In our previous study, we reported that embryos were less sensitive to the effects of endosulfan than larvae, which is in line with the main tendency of embryos to bioconcentrate endosulfan as observed in this study.

Toxicity of endosulfan on embryo-larval development of the South American toad Rhinella arenarum.

Endosulfan is a widely used pesticide despite its extreme toxicity to a variety of taxa and its worldwide ban. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the acute and chronic toxicity of endosulfan on the embryonic-larval development of the common South American toad Rhinella arenarum. The results showed that lethal and sublethal effects increased with concentration and exposure time. The sensitivity to endosulfan increased during the larval period, the complete operculum stage (S.25) being the most sensitive (504-h median lethal concentration [LC50] = 0.01 mg endosulfan/L; 10% lethal concentration [LC10] = 0.004 mg endosulfan/L). Endosulfan exposure caused morphological abnormalities such as general underdevelopment, edema, gill malformations, and cellular dissociation as well as neurotoxicity. Our results also showed that larvae exposed to concentrations of 0.005 mg endosulfan/L and 0.01 mg endosulfan/L completed metamorphosis earlier than controls, but with underdevelopment. The 240-h teratogenic index was 6.13, implying a high risk for embryos to be malformed in the absence of significant embryonic lethality. Because the hazard quotients for chronic exposure were over 1, the level of concern value and toxicity endpoints obtained in the present study for R. arenarum occurred at concentrations lower than the levels of endosulfan reported in the environment, this pesticide should be considered a potential risk for this species.

Sublethal effects of atrazine on embryo-larval development of Rhinella arenarum (Anura: Bufonidae).

Atrazine (ATR), one of the most widely used herbicides in the world, affects not only target organisms but also the biota in general. Here, the teratogenic and neurotoxic effects of ATR on Rhinella arenarum (South American toad) embryos, and larvae were evaluated by means of standardized bioassays during acute and chronic exposures. The herbicide had a significant incidence of malformations, with a Teratogenic Index (TI) of 3.28. The main effects were delayed development, reduced body size, microcephaly, axial flexures, wavy tail and edema. In addition, delayed development, reduced development of forelimbs, and edema were recorded at metamorphosis stages. Scanning electron microscopy allowed observing different degrees of cellular dissociation and persistent cilliar cells in specific regions like the adhesive structure and tail fin. Results obtained by ATR 24 h pulse exposures at six developmental stages pointed out blastula as the most susceptible developmental stage both for immediate and delayed adverse effects. A noteworthy recovery capacity from acute toxic effects was recorded from the neural plate stage onwards. Regarding neurotoxic effects, abnormal, and erratic swimming and spasmodic contractions were recorded. Both the teratogenic and neurotoxic effects reported in this study demonstrate the importance of evaluating sublethal effects in non-target organisms as they could imply reduced fitness of individuals and eventually a population decline. The Hazard Quotients (HQ) for ATR ranged from 0.14 to 10.80, and the fact that some of these values are above USEPA's level of concern indicate that ATR is likely a risk to R. arenarum.

Comparative susceptibility to atrazine of three developmental stages of Rhinella arenarum and influence on metamorphosis: non-monotonous acceleration of the time to climax and delayed tail resorption.

Acute and subchronic toxicity of atrazine was evaluated in embryos (stage 4) and in premetamorphosis (stage 25) and prometamorphosis (stage 38-39) larvae of the common South American toad Rhinella arenarum (Anura: bufonidae). The influence of atrazine on the last stages of metamorphosis was also examined by exposing prometamorphosis larvae until completion of metamorphosis. Results obtained revealed that larvae in premetamorphosis are more sensitive than larvae in prometamorphosis and that these are, in turn, more sensitive than embryonic stages. Indeed, concentrations of atrazine as high as 30 mg/L had little effects on embryonic stages, the embryos surviving and developing in a similar manner as controls. LC50s of premetamorphosis larvae equaled 27.16, 7.03 and 2.32 mg/L of atrazine after 4, 14 and 21 days of exposure, respectively, compared to LC50s values of 18.27 and 14.43 mg/L after 14 and 21 days of exposure for larvae in prometamorphosis. In experiments with premetamorphosis larvae, the range of tested concentrations was extended to very low concentrations (down to 0.0001 mg/L) to examine whether recent findings of greater mortality at lower doses than at higher doses were also observed in R. arenarum but no such pattern was found. Exposure of prometamorphosis larvae to concentrations of atrazine of 10 mg/L and above widely prevented completion of metamorphosis and caused important mortality. Alternatively, whereas all animals eventually completed metamorphosis when exposed to concentrations of atrazine between 0.1 and 5 mg/L, the timings of metamorphosis were altered starting from 0.1 mg/L, the lowest concentration tested. Indeed, a significant decrease in the time needed for 50% of the larvae to reach the metamorphic climax (stage 42) was observed within this range of atrazine concentrations, the response presenting a U-shaped non-monotonic dose-response curve. Larvae exposed to these concentrations of atrazine also needed significantly more time for completing tail resorption, this effect being equivalent at all concentrations. Overall, the combination of these two different facets of atrazine influence on metamorphosis resulted in a significant acceleration of metamorphosis at 1 mg/L and a significant increase in the duration of metamorphosis at 5 mg/L, whereas no significant difference was observed with 0.1 mg/L.