Specific antibody responses by high- and low-density human peripheral blood B cells: T-helper cells and T-cell replacing factor (TRF) act on different B-cell subpopulations.

Antibody production to influenza A strain virus X31 (H3N2) was measured in cultures of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) stimulated with either antigen (X31) or pokeweed mitogen (PWM). With some donors, X31 antibody was produced in response to antigenic stimulation, but not as part of the polyclonal response to PWM, suggesting that antigen and PWM may be acting on different B-cell subpopulations. To test this hypothesis, T-cell depleted PBMC (E-) cells were fractionated on discontinuous Percoll gradients and assayed for antibody production in response to antigen or PWM. Fraction I (FrI = SG less than 1.070) cultured in the presence of T cells responded well to PWM, but not at all to X31. FrII (1.070 less than SG less than 1.075) and FrIII (SG greater than 1.075) cultured in the presence of T cells both responded well to X31, but only the medium-density B cells (FrII) were able to make specific antibody when T cells were replaced with T-cell replacing factor (TRF). Specific X31 antibody responses by medium- and high-density B cells (FrII and FrIII) were suppressed equally by the addition of allogeneic T-suppressor (Ts) cells. When allo-activated Ts cells were inactivated by irradiation, allogeneic T-helper (Th) cells were able to collaborate with both FrII and FrIII B cells in specific antibody responses to X31. Since TRF was not able to substitute for T cells in specific antibody responses by FrIII B cells, this result shows that allogeneic T-cell help was not mediated by non-specific 'allogeneic effect' factors and apparently requires cognate T cell-B cell interactions.

Antigen-specific suppression of human antibody responses by allogeneic T cells. III. Role of the major histocompatibility complex.

Specific antibody responses obtained in vitro from human blood mononuclear cells (PBM) were profoundly suppressed by allogeneic T cells. Experiments carried out with combinations of cells from HLA identical siblings, and HLA identical but unrelated donors, showed that suppression depended upon HLA incompatibility between responding PBM and allogeneic Ts. In order to map the specific HLA loci concerned, a series of experiments were undertaken using combinations of cells from a large number of HLA typed donors. Significant suppression was found to occur in every combination of HLA incompatible cells tested, including those with nonidentity at HLA-A, B, DR, A and DR, or B and DR, suggesting that suppression can be generated by nonidentity at class I or class II loci. With some HLA-A homozygous donors, however, a dominant role for class I (HLA-A) antigens was indicated by the finding of one-directional suppression in combinations where the HLA-A locus was seen as foreign by one partner only (A3,----A2,3; and A2----A2,26). Similar one-directional suppression was also seen with cells from a pair of siblings who were HLA identical except for a single A locus antigen arising from an HLA-A/B recombination (A3,----A3,1). These results indicate an important, but not exclusive role for class I MHC antigens in the activation of allogeneic Ts. The way in which this occurs is unknown, but one possibility is that it results from the activation of normal antigen-specific Ts by the interaction of their receptors for self-MHC with cross-reacting alloantigens.

Antigen-specific suppression of human antibody responses by allogeneic T cells. II. Cell interactions involved in the generation of suppression.

Specific antibody responses to influenza virus were obtained in vitro from human blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). Antibody production in these cultures was profoundly suppressed by the addition of allogeneic T cells with the surface phenotype Leu2a+ (CD8+), Leu8-. Suppression by allogeneic T suppressor (Ts) cells required interactions only between T-depleted B (E-) cells and allogeneic Leu2a+. No evidence was obtained for T-T cell interactions, or for Ts inducer cells similar to those described for nonspecific antibody responses to pokeweed mitogen. Moreover, allogeneic E+, or allogeneic Leu2a+ cells were able to suppress specific antibody responses by E- cells when help was provided by T cell-replacing factor showing that the target of suppression was the responding E- cells, and not T helper cells. In contrast to allogeneic T cells, allogeneic E- cells did not suppress antibody production when added to cultures of unfractionated PBMC (E- + E+). That is, Ts cells activated to allogeneic E- were unable to suppress antibody production by the syngeneic E- cells present in the same culture tube. This result shows that alloactivated Ts cells were specific for the allogeneic E- target cells, and that suppression was not mediated by nonspecific allogeneic effects. Allogeneic Ts cells therefore differ from Ts cells in pokeweed mitogen responses by their specificity, and by their activation in the absence of Ts inducer cells.

Antigen-specific suppression of human antibody responses by allogeneic T cells. I. Frequency and antigen specificity of allogeneic suppressor T cells and their role in major histocompatibility complex-controlled genetic restriction.

Specific antibody responses to influenza virus were obtained in vitro from human blood mononuclear cells (PBM). The addition of allogeneic T cells to responding PBM profoundly suppressed antigen-induced antibody responses, but had no effect on pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-induced polyclonal Ig formation. This raised the possibility that suppression by allogeneic T cells may result from the activation of antigen-specific T suppressor (Ts) cells rather than nonspecific allogeneic effects. The frequency of allogeneic Ts in PBM from a number of different donors, estimated in a series of limiting dilution analyses, was found to range from 0.8 X 10(-5) to 4.5 X 10(-5), which is more typical of antigen-specific than alloreactive T cells. By adding limiting numbers of allogeneic T cells to antibody-forming cultures stimulated simultaneously with two non-cross-reacting antigens (influenza A and B strain viruses A/X31 and B/HK), it was possible to demonstrate suppression of the response to one antigen, but not the other, in the same culture well. Moreover, the frequency of wells in which the response to both antigens was suppressed was not significantly different from that predicted from the calculated frequency of specific allogeneic Ts. These results show that allogeneic suppression was antigen specific, and was not due to non-specific allogeneic effects. By separating T cell preparations into Leu-3a+ (helper) and Leu-2a+ (suppressor/cytotoxic) T cell subsets, suppression was shown to be mediated by a radiosensitive Leu-2a+ T cell. The removal of Leu-2a+ cells from T cell preparations abrogated the suppressor effect and permitted T cell collaboration with B cells, across an HLA-A, -B, and -DR barrier. This result shows that in at least some combinations, suppression rather than major histocompatibility complex restriction is the reason for the failure of allogeneic T and B cells to collaborate in T cell-dependent antibody responses.