Estrogen and the brain: beyond ER-alpha and ER-beta.

17beta-Estradiol is a greatly under-appreciated neural growth and trophic factor for the mammalian brain of all ages. Like other growth factors, such as the neurotrophins, 17beta-estradiol influences neurogenesis, neuronal differentiation, and neuronal survival of its targets throughout life. Estrogen elicits developmentally regulated differentiative effects, which are not normally seen in the adult brain. However, re-expression of this developmental response occurs in the adult, following loss of trophic support, whether induced by estrogen deprivation or brain injury. In addition to the classical intranuclear estrogen receptors (ER) ER-alpha and ER-beta, we have recently identified a novel, plasma membrane-associated, putative ER that is neither ER-alpha nor ER-beta, which we have designated 'ER-X'. ER-X is a developmentally regulated estrogen-binding protein, present in wild-type, ER-alpha gene-disrupted (alphaERKO) and ER-alpha null mice, which is re-expressed following ischemic brain injury. The preferred ligand of ER-X is 17alpha-estradiol. Although ER-X shares some homology with the C-terminus of ER-alpha, it is not an alternative splicing variant and may be a new gene. While ER-X appears to mediate 17alpha- and 17beta-estradiol activation of the MAPK cascade, ER-alpha, in contrast, is inhibitory to its activation. Estradiol activation of MAPK/ERK may be particularly relevant for neuroprotection during aging and Alzheimer's disease.

Estradiol (E2) elicits SRC phosphorylation in the mouse neocortex: the initial event in E2 activation of the MAPK cascade?

In neocortical explants, E2 activates various signaling components of the MAPK cascade, including B-Raf and MAPK kinase-dependent ERK, suggesting a possible role in the differentiative actions of E2 in the brain. To further characterize the signaling pathways activated by E2, we determined whether c-Src, a member of the Src family of nonreceptor tyrosine kinases and an important modulator of both the MAPK cascade and neuronal differentiation, may play a role in E2 signaling. The present studies show for the first time in the brain that E2 elicits phosphorylation of c-Src on three functionally critical tyrosine residues (Y220, Y423, and Y534), and that this phosphorylation occurs despite disruption of ER alpha (in ER knockout mice). PP2, a Src family kinase inhibitor, suppressed not only E2-induced phosphorylation of c-Src, but ERK phosphorylation as well, suggesting that c-Src may be an upstream regulator of E2 signaling. E2-induced phosphorylation of c-Src is associated with increased tyrosine phosphorylation of Shc, increased association of Shc with Grb2, and induction of Ras, but not Rap1, activation. Together, these data provide evidence that E2 activates a novel c-Src-dependent signal transduction pathway in the developing brain.

Novel sites and mechanisms of oestrogen action in the brain.

We are investigating novel, non-transcriptionally mediated mechanisms that may contribute to the differentiative effects of oestrogen in developing forebrain neurons. Recent findings in the cerebral cortex document that 17 alpha- and 17 beta-oestradiol elicit rapid and sustained activation of the Ras-Raf-MAP kinase cascade, a major growth factor signalling pathway. Using oestrogen receptor (ER) alpha knockout (ERKO) mice, we addressed the identity of the receptor mediating activation of the MAP kinase cascade. 17 beta-oestradiol increased B-Raf activity and MEK-dependent ERK phosphorylation in explants of wild-type and ERKO cerebral cortex. Although neither the ER alpha-selective ligand, 16 alpha-iodo-17 beta-oestradiol (16 alpha-IE2) nor the ER beta-selective ligand, genistein, elicited ERK phosphorylation, as little as 0.1 nM 17 beta-oestradiol did so. Moreover, 16 alpha-IE2 acted as an inhibitory modulator of ERK activation, and the ER antagonist ICI 182 780 blocked oestradiol action only in wild-type cultures. These data suggest that neither ER alpha nor ER beta mediate activation of the MAP kinase cascade. A putative, novel, oestradiol-sensitive and ICI 182 780-insensitive receptor, designated ER-X may, rather, be involved. Association of ER-X with flotillin, the neuronal homologue of the caveolar protein, caveolin, places ER-X within plasma membrane caveolae and supports the hypothesis that a membrane-associated ER may mediate rapid oestrogen activation of the MAP kinase cascade.

Estrogen-induced activation of the mitogen-activated protein kinase cascade in the cerebral cortex of estrogen receptor-alpha knock-out mice.

We have shown previously in the developing cerebral cortex that estrogen elicits the rapid and sustained activation of multiple signaling proteins within the mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase cascade, including B-Raf and extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK). Using estrogen receptor (ER)-alpha gene-disrupted (ERKO) mice, we addressed the role of ER-alpha in mediating this action of estrogen in the brain. 17beta-Estradiol increased B-Raf activity and MEK (MAP kinase/ERK kinase)-dependent ERK phosphorylation in cerebral cortical explants derived from both ERKO and their wild-type littermates. The ERK response was stronger in ERKO-derived cultures but, unlike that of wild-type cultures, was not blocked by the estrogen receptor antagonist ICI 182,780. Surprisingly, both the ER-alpha selective ligand 16alpha-iodo-17beta-estradiol and the ER-beta selective ligand genistein failed to elicit ERK phosphorylation, suggesting that a different mechanism or receptor may mediate estrogen-induced ERK phosphorylation in the cerebral cortex. Interestingly, the transcriptionally inactive stereoisomer 17alpha-estradiol did elicit a strong induction of ERK phosphorylation, which, together with the inability of the ER-alpha- and ER-beta-selective ligands to elicit ERK phosphorylation, and of ICI 182,780 to block the actions of estradiol in ERKO cultures, supports the hypothesis that a novel, estradiol-sensitive and ICI-insensitive estrogen receptor may mediate 17beta-estradiol-induced activation of ERK in the brain.

Novel mechanisms of estrogen action in the brain: new players in an old story.

Estrogen elicits a selective enhancement of the growth and differentiation of axons and dendrites (neurites) in the developing brain. Widespread colocalization of estrogen and neurotrophin receptors (trk) within estrogen and neurotrophin targets, including neurons of the cerebral cortex, sensory ganglia, and PC12 cells, has been shown to result in differential and reciprocal transcriptional regulation of these receptors by their ligands. In addition, estrogen and neurotrophin receptor coexpression leads to convergence or cross-coupling of their signaling pathways, particularly at the level of the mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase cascade. 17beta-Estradiol elicits rapid (within 5-15 min) and sustained (at least 2 h) tyrosine phosphorylation and activation of the MAP kinases, extracellular-signal regulated kinase (ERK)1, and ERK2, which is successfully inhibited by the MAP kinase/ERK kinase 1 inhibitor PD98059, but not by the estrogen receptor (ER) antagonist ICI 182,780 and also does not appear to result from estradiol-induced activation of trk. Furthermore, the ability of estradiol to phosphorylate ERK persists even in ER-alpha knockout mice, implicating other estrogen receptors such as ER-beta in these actions of estradiol. The existence of an estrogen receptor-containing, multimeric complex consisting of hsp90, src, and B-Raf also suggests a direct link between the estrogen receptor and the MAP kinase signaling cascade. Collectively, these novel findings, coupled with our growing understanding of additional signaling substrates utilized by estrogen, provide alternative mechanisms for estrogen action in the developing brain which could explain not only some of the very rapid effects of estrogen, but also the ability of estrogen and neurotrophins to regulate the same broad array of cytoskeletal and growth-associated genes involved in neurite growth and differentiation. This review expands the usually restrictive view of estrogen action in the brain beyond the confines of sexual differentiation and reproductive neuroendocrine function. It considers the much broader question of estrogen as a neural growth factor with important influences on the development, survival, plasticity, regeneration, and aging of the mammalian brain and supports the view that the estrogen receptor is not only a ligand-induced transcriptional enhancer but also a mediator of rapid, nongenomic events.

Estrogen-induced activation of mitogen-activated protein kinase in cerebral cortical explants: convergence of estrogen and neurotrophin signaling pathways.

We have shown that estrogen elicits a selective enhancement of the growth and differentiation of axons and dendrites (neurites) in the developing CNS. We subsequently demonstrated widespread colocalization of estrogen and neurotrophin receptors (trk) within developing forebrain neurons and reciprocal transcriptional regulation of these receptors by their ligands. Using organotypic explants of the cerebral cortex, we tested the hypothesis that estrogen/neurotrophin receptor coexpression also may result in convergence or cross-coupling of their signaling pathways. Estradiol elicited rapid (within 5-15 min) tyrosine phosphorylation/activation of the mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinases, ERK1 and ERK2, that persisted for at least 2 hr. This extracellular signal-regulated protein kinase (ERK) activation was inhibited successfully by the MEK1 inhibitor PD98059, but not by the estrogen receptor (ER) antagonist ICI 182,780, and did not appear to result from estradiol-induced activation of trk. Furthermore, we also found that estradiol elicited an increase in B-Raf kinase activity. The latter and subsequent downstream events leading to ERK activation may be a consequence of our documentation of a multimeric complex consisting of, at least, the ER, hsp90, and B-Raf. These novel findings provide an alternative mechanism for some of the estrogen actions in the developing CNS and could explain not only some of the very rapid effects of estrogen but also the ability of estrogen and neurotrophins to regulate the same broad array of cytoskeletal and growth-associated genes involved in neurite growth and differentiation.

The estrogen/neurotrophin connection during neural development: is co-localization of estrogen receptors with the neurotrophins and their receptors biologically relevant?

Estrogen enhances neurite growth within the developing rodent forebrain. Estrogen receptor mRNA is co-expressed with the mRNA for the neurotrophins and their receptors. Estrogen may act independently by altering growth-related genes directly, but may interact additionally with growth factors (neurotrophins) and their receptors (trks). Estrogen may also act permissively to facilitate neurotrophin actions by genomic cross-talk with neurotrophin regulatory pathways whose nuclear end points may be the same estrogen-responsive genes. Differential and reciprocal regulation of estrogen and nerve growth factor (NGF) receptor gene expression by their ligands suggests that estrogen and the neurotrophins may influence each other's actions by regulating receptor/ligand availability or by reciprocal regulation at the level of gene transcription or signal transduction. Steroid/neurotrophin interactions may stimulate the synthesis of proteins required for neuronal differentiation, survival and maintenance of function.

Mechanisms of estrogen action during neural development: mediation by interactions with the neurotrophins and their receptors?

Estrogen enhances the growth and differentiation of neurites within the developing forebrain. A critical issue is whether these developmental actions of estrogen are mediated directly or indirectly by means of autocrine responses or local paracrine mechanisms, through interactions with growth factors, such as the neurotrophins, and their receptors. Support for the latter hypothesis comes from our recent observations of co-expression of estrogen receptor mRNA with the mRNAs for the neurotrophins and their receptors; differential and reciprocal up-regulation of estrogen and NGF receptor mRNA and protein expression by estrogen in adult female rat sensory neurons, PC12 cells; and cerebral cortical cultures; and putative estrogen response elements in the NGF, BDNF, trkA and p75 genes. Estrogen and the neurotrophins may influence each other's actions by regulating receptor and ligand availability or by reciprocal regulation at the level of signal transduction or gene transcription. The neurotrophins may serve as regulatory "switches" for the apparent developmentally-regulated, differential pattern of estrogen receptor regulation by its ligand, whereby their ability to increase estrogen receptor levels significantly may be sufficient to override the intrinsic suppressive action of estrogen on its receptor. Estrogen and the neurotrophins, acting in concert and reciprocally, may stimulate the synthesis of proteins required for neuronal differentiation, survival and maintenance of function.

Identification of a putative estrogen response element in the gene encoding brain-derived neurotrophic factor.

We have been studying the role and mechanism of estrogen action in the survival and differentiation of neurons in the basal forebrain and its targets in the cerebral cortex, hippocampus, and olfactory bulb. Previous work has shown that estrogen-target neurons in these regions widely coexpress the mRNAs for the neurotrophin ligands and their receptors, suggesting a potential substrate for estrogen-neurotrophin interactions. Subsequent work indicated that estrogen regulates the expression of two neurotrophin receptor mRNAs in prototypic peripheral neural targets of nerve growth factor. We report herein that the gene encoding the neurotophin brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) contains a sequence similar to the canonical estrogen response element found in estrogen-target genes. Gel shift and DNA footprinting assays indicate that estrogen receptor-ligand complexes bind to this sequence in the BDNF gene. In vivo, BDNF mRNA was rapidly up-regulated in the cerebral cortex and the olfactory bulb of ovariectomized animals exposed to estrogen. These data suggest that estrogen may regulate BDNF transcription, supporting our hypothesis that estrogen may be in a position to influence neurotrophin-mediated cell functioning, by increasing the availability of specific neurotrophins in forebrain neurons.

Aromatase in the cerebral cortex, hippocampus, and mid-brain: ontogeny and developmental implications.

Aromatase activity was measured in explant cultures from the newborn mouse and rat brain and in homogenates of regions of the rat brain sampled between birth and 51 days of age. Conversion of 19-[3H]hydroxy-androstenedione to estradiol and estrone was detected in explant cultures from the mouse preoptic/septal region, anterior cingulate cortex, and midbrain, as well as from the rat preoptic area, septum, hippocampus, anterior cingulate cortex, and midbrain central grey. No detectable estrogen biosynthesis was observed in explants from the cerebellum and spinal cord of either species. Measurements of aromatase in tissue homogenates using 1 beta[3H]androstenedione as substrate revealed detectable enzyme activity in the hypothalamus + preoptic area, amygdala, hippocampus, anterior cingulate cortex, and midbrain, from birth onward. Aromatase activity per milligram of tissue protein was highest in the hypothalamus-preoptic area and amygdala, followed by the hippocampus, midbrain, and cingulate cortex. In all brain regions, aromatase activity was markedly higher at Postnatal Days 1 and 7 than later in life. In both the cingulate cortex and the hippocampus, aromatase was barely detectable above the assay blank in adult (51 day) animals. These results demonstrate that regions of the developing rodent neo- and archicortex have the capacity to convert androgen to estrogen, consistent with a role for local estrogen biosynthesis in the sexual differentiation of higher brain functions.

Reciprocal regulation of estrogen and NGF receptors by their ligands in PC12 cells.

Recent work has shown that estrogen receptor mRNA and protein co-localize with neurotrophin receptor systems in the developing basal forebrain. In the present study we examined the potential for reciprocal regulation of estrogen and neurotrophin receptor systems by their ligands in a prototypical neurotrophin target, the PC12 cell. Using in situ hybridization histochemistry, RT-PCR and a modified nuclear exchange assay, we found both estrogen receptor mRNA and estrogen binding in PC12 cells. Moreover, while estrogen binding was relatively low in naive PC12 cells, long-term exposure to NGF enhanced estrogen binding in these cells by sixfold. Furthermore, concurrent exposure to estrogen and NGF differentially regulated the expression of the two NGF receptor mRNAs. The expression of trkA mRNA was up-regulated, while p75NGFR mRNA was down-regulated transiently. The present data indicate that NGF may increase neuronal sensitivity to estrogen, and that estrogen, by differentially regulating p75NGFR and trkA mRNA, may alter the ratio of the two NGF receptors, and, consequently, neurotrophin responsivity. In view of the widespread co-localization of estrogen and neurotrophin receptor systems in the developing CNS, the reciprocal regulation of these receptor systems by NGF and estrogen may have important implications for processes governing neural maturation and the maintainance of neural function.

Estrogen regulates metabolism of Alzheimer amyloid beta precursor protein.

We have investigated the possible effect of estrogen on the metabolism of the Alzheimer amyloid precursor protein (APP). Using a cell line that contains high levels of estrogen receptors, we have found that treatment with physiological concentrations of 17 beta-estradiol is associated with accumulation in the conditioned medium of an amino-terminal cleavage product of APP (soluble APP or protease nexin-2), indicative of non-amyloidogenic processing. There were no obvious changes in the levels of intracellular immature or mature APP holoproteins, suggesting that estrogen may increase the secretory metabolism of APP.

Estrogen differentially regulates estrogen and nerve growth factor receptor mRNAs in adult sensory neurons.

We have previously shown that neurons in the basal forebrain colocalize the neurotrophin receptor p75NGFR and estrogen receptors. The present study was designed to examine (1) if neural neurotrophin targets respond to estrogen as a general phenotypic feature and (2) if NGF receptor mRNAs are regulated by estrogen, using a prototypical target of NGF, the dorsal root ganglion (DRG) (sensory) neuron. We demonstrate, for the first time, the presence of estrogen receptor mRNA and protein (binding sites) in adult female rat DRG. Moreover, estrogen receptor mRNA expression, while present in DRG neurons from both the ovariectomized (OVX; estrogen deficient) and intact female rat, was downregulated, as in the adult CNS, during proestrus (high estrogen levels) and in OVX animals replaced with proestrus levels of estrogen, as compared to OVX controls. In contrast, although the mRNAs for the NGF receptors p75NGFR and trkA were also expressed in DRG neurons from OVX and intact animals, expression of both NGF receptor mRNAs was upregulated in sensory neurons during proestrus, as compared to the OVX condition. Estrogen replacement, on the other hand, resulted in a transient downregulation of p75NGFR mRNA and a time-dependent upregulation of trkA mRNA. Estrogen regulation of NGF receptor mRNA in adult peripheral neural targets of the neurotrophins supports the hypothesis that estrogen may regulate neuronal sensitivity to neurotrophins such as NGF and may be an important mediator of neurotrophin actions in normal neural function and following neural trauma.

Neuronal colocalization of mRNAs for neurotrophins and their receptors in the developing central nervous system suggests a potential for autocrine interactions.

Development and survival of neurons in the central nervous system are dependent on the activity of a variety of endogenous neurotrophic agents. Using combined isotopic and nonisotopic in situ hybridization histochemistry, we have found that subsets of neurons within the developing forebrain coexpress the mRNAs for both neurotrophins (nerve growth factor, brain-derived neurotrophic factor, and neurotrophin 3) and their receptors (p75NGFR, TrkA, and TrkB). The colocalization of mRNA for neurotrophin receptors and their ligands in presumptive neurotrophin target neurons suggests the potential for autocrine and paracrine mechanisms of action during development. Such mechanisms may ensure the onset of differentiation and survival of specific subsets of neurons prior to and following target innervation.

Presumptive Estrogen Target Neurons Express mRNAs for both the Neurotrophins and Neurotrophin Receptors: A Basis for Potential Developmental Interactions of Estrogen with the Neurotrophins.

Estrogen and the neurotrophins regulate development, survival, and plasticity of the nervous system. We have shown previously that neurons of the developing basal forebrain and their cortical and hippocampal targets express estrogen receptor mRNA and protein. Furthermore, subsets of neurons within these regions colocalize mRNAs for neurotrophin receptors (p75(NGFR), (trk) A, and (trk)B) and their cognate ligands (NGF, BDNF, and NT-3). Using combined isotopic/nonisotopic in situ hybridization histochemistry, we now demonstrate that mRNAs for the neurotrophins as well as their receptors colocalize to individual estrogen receptor mRNA-containing neurons in these regions of the developing rodent forebrain. The patterns of colocalization were both region and mRNA specific. These results suggest a potential for interactions between estrogen and the neurotrophins, including possible estrogen-stimulated, neurotrophin-mediated autocrine mechanisms that may regulate neuronal differentiation and survival during development.

Estrogen receptors colocalize with low-affinity nerve growth factor receptors in cholinergic neurons of the basal forebrain.

The rodent and primate basal forebrain is a target of a family of endogenous peptide signaling molecules, the neurotrophins--nerve growth factor, brain-derived neurotrophic factor, and neurotrophin 3--and of the gonadal steroid hormone estrogen, both of which have been implicated in cholinergic function. To investigate whether or not these ligands may act on the same neurons in the developing and adult rodent basal forebrain, we combined autoradiography with 125I-labeled estrogen and either nonisotopic in situ hybridization histochemistry or immunohistochemistry. We now report colocalization of intranuclear estrogen binding sites with the mRNA and immunoreactive protein for the low-affinity nerve growth factor receptor, which binds all three neurotrophins, and for the cholinergic marker enzyme choline acetyltransferase (acetyl-CoA:choline O-acetyltransferase, EC 2.3.1.6). Colocalization of estrogen and low-affinity nerve growth factor receptors implies that their ligands may act on the same neuron, perhaps synergistically, to regulate the expression of specific genes or gene networks that may influence neuronal survival, differentiation, regeneration, and plasticity. That cholinergic neurons in brain regions subserving cognitive functions may be regulated not only by the neurotrophins but also by estrogen may have considerable relevance for the development and maintenance of neural substrates of cognition. If estrogen-neurotrophin interactions are important for survival of target neurons, then clinical conditions associated with estrogen deficiency could contribute to the atrophy or death of these neurons. These findings have implications for the subsequent decline in those differentiated neural functions associated with aging and Alzheimer disease.

Cellular variations in estrogen receptor mRNA translation in the developing brain: evidence from combined [125I]estrogen autoradiography and non-isotopic in situ hybridization histochemistry.

The spatial distribution of cells in the adult rodent forebrain which express estrogen receptor mRNA, as shown by in situ hybridization histochemistry with isotopically-labeled probes, has been reported to overlap with regions that are known targets of estrogen and which bind estrogen. The extent to which detection of estrogen receptor mRNA within developing forebrain neurons of the postnatal day 10-12 female rat is accompanied by translation into estrogen binding sites was investigated by combining [125I]estrogen autoradiography with non-isotopic (digoxigenin) in situ hybridization, using a 48-base oligodeoxyribonucleotide probe encoding a sequence of the estrogen-binding domain of rat uterine estrogen receptor cDNA. Estrogen receptor mRNA and estrogen binding sites appeared to be restricted to neurons. No mRNA or binding was seen in ependymal cells. Cells expressing estrogen receptor mRNA were widely distributed in the developing rat forebrain and were found in brain regions generally corresponding to those previously shown in the adult, with the addition of some regions not previously described, such as the medial habenula and dorsal endopiriform nucleus. Although there was widespread overlapping of estrogen receptor mRNA expression with known estrogen binding sites, there were regional and cellular variations in the extent of receptor mRNA translation. This pattern was true for developing forebrain regions previously defined as estrogen receptor-containing (hypothalamus, preoptic area, medial and lateral septum, vertical and horizontal nuclei of the diagonal band, cerebral cortex, hippocampus and amygdala) as well as for regions heretofore not considered estrogen targets (the thalamus, dorsal endopiriform nucleus, claustrum, ventral pallidum/substantia innominata and the basal nucleus of Meynert) or characterized as estrogen-responsive in the adult without previously documented estrogen binding [caudate-putamen (striatum)]. While estrogen binding and receptor mRNA expression always co-localized, neurons expressing estrogen receptor mRNA did not always exhibit ligand binding and there was no clear-cut relationship between the intensity of the hybridization signal and estrogen binding. Little, however, is known about translational control of estrogen receptor expression in the brain. Localization of estrogen binding sites to regions not generally considered targets of estrogen would appear to reflect the greater sensitivity of the iodinated ligand than the tritiated estrogens more commonly used for autoradiography. Non-isotopic in situ hybridization histochemistry combined with [125I]estrogen autoradiography represents a very powerful tool with which to study regulation of estrogen receptor gene expression at the single cell level with an exceptional degree of cellular and anatomical resolution.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Developmental expression of estrogen receptor mRNA in the rat cerebral cortex: a nonisotopic in situ hybridization histochemistry study.

The distribution of estrogen receptor mRNA expression was studied in the developing rat cerebral cortex by in situ hybridization histochemistry. We used a specific, nonisotopically (digoxigenin) labeled, synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotide complementary to a 48 base sequence in the region of the estrogen-binding domain of rat uterine estrogen receptor cDNA. During development, estrogen receptor mRNA was observed in all forebrain regions previously reported to bind estrogen, as determined by steroid autoradiography or nuclear binding assay. In the developing cerebral cortex, estrogen receptor mRNA was extensively expressed in the ventricular zone, primitive plexiform layer, and immature cortical plate at least as early as embryonic day 16. During the first 3 postnatal weeks, cortical mRNA expression was increasingly restricted to the upper third of the cerebral cortex and to the neurons of the cortical subplate (layer VIb/VII) and decreased to low levels by postnatal day 28. In the cerebral cortex, the spatial distribution of estrogen receptor mRNA expression overlapped that reported for the encoded protein. The extensive distribution of estrogen receptor mRNA throughout the late prenatal and early postnatal cerebral cortex points to an important role for estrogen in the differentiation and maturation of the cerebral cortex.