Primary care physician supply and colorectal cancer.

OBJECTIVES: Our goal was to determine if increasing primary care physician supply was associated with lower incidence and mortality rates for colorectal cancer. STUDY DESIGN: We performed an ecologic study of Florida's 67 counties, using data from the state tumor registry and the American Medical Association physician masterfile. POPULATION: Florida residents were included. OUTCOMES MEASURED: We measured age-adjusted colorectal cancer incidence and mortality rates for Florida's 67 counties during the period 1993 to 1995. RESULTS: Increasing primary care physician supply was negatively correlated with both colorectal cancer (CC) incidence (CC = -0.46; P < .0001) and mortality rates (CC = -0.29; P =.02). In linear regression that controlled for other county characteristics, each 1% increase in the proportion of county physicians who were in primary care specialties was associated with a corresponding reduction in colorectal cancer incidence of 0.25 cases per 100,000 (P < .0001) and a reduction in colorectal cancer mortality of 0.08 cases per 100,000 (P =.0008). CONCLUSIONS: Incidence and mortality of colorectal cancer decreased in Florida counties that had an increased supply of primary care physicians. This suggests that a balanced work force may achieve better health outcomes.

Comorbid illness and the early detection of cancer.

BACKGROUND: Comorbidity may be associated with later detection of cancer. METHODS: Incident cases of colorectal, breast, and prostate cancer and melanoma were determined from the 1994 Florida state tumor registry (N = 32,074). The relationship between comorbidity and late stage at diagnosis was examined using multiple logistic regression. RESULTS: Patients with comorbid conditions had greater odds of late stage diagnosis for each of the four cancers (colorectal, melanoma, breast, and prostate). Higher mortality rates were observed among patients with comorbid illness, not as a result of later stage at diagnosis, but rather due to their underlying disease. CONCLUSIONS: Comorbidity was associated with later stage diagnosis. Further research is needed to determine mechanisms by which comorbidity might influence stage at diagnosis.

Effects of health insurance and race on colorectal cancer treatments and outcomes.

OBJECTIVES: We hypothesized that health insurance payer and race might influence the care and outcomes of patients with colorectal cancer. METHODS: We examined treatments received for all incident cases of colorectal cancer occurring in Florida in 1994 (n = 9551), using state tumor registry data. We also estimated the adjusted risk of death (through 1997), using proportional hazards regression analysis controlling for other predictors of mortality. RESULTS: Treatments received by patients varied considerably according to their insurance payer. Among non-Medicare patients, those in the following groups had higher adjusted risks of death relative to commercial fee-for-service insurance: commercial HMO (risk ratio [RR] = 1.40; 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.18, 1.67; P = .0001), Medicaid (RR = 1.44; 95% CI = 1.06, 1.97; P = .02), and uninsured (RR = 1.41; 95% CI = 1.12, 1.77; P = .003). Non-Hispanic African Americans had higher mortality rates (RR = 1.18; 95% CI = 1.01, 1.37; P = .04) than non-Hispanic Whites. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with colorectal cancer who were uninsured or insured by Medicaid or commercial HMOs had higher mortality rates than patients with commercial fee-for-service insurance. Mortality was also higher among non-Hispanic African American patients.

Increasing supplies of dermatologists and family physicians are associated with earlier stage of melanoma detection.

BACKGROUND: Physicians are important in the early detection of melanoma. We investigated whether primary care physician supply and the supply of dermatologists were related to stage at diagnosis for malignant melanoma. METHODS: From the state tumor registry in Florida in 1994, we identified incident cases of malignant melanoma for which stage at diagnosis was available (N = 1884). Data on physician supply was obtained from the 1994 American Medical Association Physician Masterfile. Logistic regression determined the effects of physician supply (at the ZIP code level) on the odds of early-stage diagnosis controlling for patients' age, gender, race/ethnicity, marital status, education level, income level, comorbidity, and type of health insurance. RESULTS: Each additional dermatologist per 10,000 population was associated with a 39% increased odds of early diagnosis (odds ratio = 1.39, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.09-1.70, P =.010). For each additional family physician per 10,000 population, the odds of early diagnosis increased 21% (odds ratio = 1.21, 95% CI 1.09-1.33, P <.001). Each additional general internist per 10,000 population was associated with a 10% decrease in the odds of early-stage diagnosis (odds ratio = 0.90, 95% CI 0.83-0.98, P =.009). The supplies of general practitioners, obstetrician/gynecologists, and other nonprimary care specialists were not associated with stage at diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: Increasing supplies of dermatologists and family physicians were associated with earlier detection of melanoma. In contrast, increasing supplies of general internists were associated with reduced odds of early detection. Our findings suggest that the composition of the physician work force may affect important health outcomes and needs further study.

Demographic predictors of melanoma stage at diagnosis.

OBJECTIVE: To examine sociodemographic characteristics as possible predictors of late-stage melanoma diagnosis. We hypothesized that late-stage diagnosis would be associated with the following: older age, male sex, unmarried status, lower educational attainment and income level, rural residence, and cigarette smoking. METHODS: We used data from the state tumor registry to study all incident cases of melanoma occurring in Florida during 1994 whose stage at diagnosis was available (N = 1884). We used multiple logistic regression to determine the effects of sociodemographic characteristics on the odds of late-stage (regional or distant metastases) diagnosis. RESULTS: There were 243 patients (12.9%) diagnosed as having melanoma that had metastasized to either regional lymph nodes or distant sites. Patients who were unmarried (odds ratio, 1.5; P= .01), male (odds ratio, 2.2; P<.001), or smokers (odds ratio, 2.2; P<.001) or who resided in communities with lower median educational attainment (odds ratio, 1.5; P= .048) had greater odds of having a late-stage diagnosis. CONCLUSIONS: To detect these cancers at an earlier stage and improve outcomes, there should be increased educational efforts directed toward physicians who treat these patients. A recognition that there may be additional risk factors for late-stage diagnosis, beyond the established risk factors, such as family history and excess sun exposure, should be included in the initial assessment. Specific public education efforts should also be targeted to these patients to increase their self-surveillance and surveillance of their partners.

The accuracy of community-based automated blood pressure machines.

BACKGROUND: Despite widespread use, the accuracy of community-based automated blood pressure machines has been questioned. We sought to determine if these machines are as accurate and reliable as those obtained by a clinician with a mercury manometer. METHODS: We randomly selected 25 pharmacies and compared blood pressure readings obtained from their automated machines with from a mercury manometer. We used 3 volunteers with arm circumferences at the low, medium, and high ends of the acceptable range of a normal adult cuff size. RESULTS: For the subject with the small arm size, store machines reported systolic pressure readings that were, on average, 10 mm Hg higher than those obtained by the clinician (P <.001) and diastolic pressures 9 mm Hg higher (P <.001). The mean systolic pressure readings for the subject with the medium arm size were not significantly different between the store machine and the mercury manometer, and the readings were only modestly different for diastolic pressure. For the subject with the large arm size, store machines reported diastolic pressure readings that were, on average, 8.3 mm Hg lower than those obtained using the mercury manometer (P <.001), but with no significant difference in the systolic pressure. CONCLUSIONS: We found that automated blood pressure machines from a representative community-based sample of pharmacies did not meet the accepted standards of accuracy and reliability. Accuracy of readings is especially uncertain for patients having arm sizes larger or smaller than average.

Effects of health insurance and race on breast carcinoma treatments and outcomes.

BACKGROUND: The authors hypothesized that insurance payer and race would influence the care and outcomes for patients with breast carcinoma. METHODS: The authors examined treatments and adjusted risk of death (through 1997) for all incident cases of breast carcinoma occurring in Florida in 1994 (n = 11,113) by using state tumor registry data. RESULTS: Patients lacking health insurance were less likely to receive breast-conserving surgery (BCS) compared with patients who had private health insurance. Among patients insured by Medicare, those belonging to a health maintenance organization (HMO) were more likely to receive BCS but less likely to receive radiation therapy after BCS. Non-Hispanic African Americans had higher mortality rates even when stage at diagnosis, insurance payer, and treatment modalities used were adjusted in multivariate models (adjusted risk ratio [RR], 1.35; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.12-1.61; P = 0.001). Patients who had HMO insurance had similar survival rates compared with those with fee-for-service (FFS) insurance. Among non-Medicare patients, mortality rates were higher for patients who had Medicaid insurance (RR, 1.58, 95% CI, 1.18-2.11; P = 0.002) and those who lacked health insurance (RR, 1.31; 95% CI, 1.03-1.68; P = 0.03) compared with patients who had commercial FFS insurance. There were no insurance-related differences in survival rates, however, once stage at diagnosis was controlled. CONCLUSIONS: As a result of later stage at diagnosis, patients with breast carcinoma who were uninsured, or insured by Medicaid, had higher mortality rates. Mortality rates were also higher among non-Hispanic African Americans, a finding that was not fully explained by differences in stage at diagnosis, treatment modalities used, or insurance payer.

The effects of physician supply on the early detection of colorectal cancer.

BACKGROUND: Policymakers question whether there is a relationship between the number and distribution of physicians and the outcomes for important health conditions. We hypothesized that increasing primary care physician supply would be related to earlier detection of colorectal cancer. METHODS: We identified incident cases of colorectal cancer occurring in Florida in 1994 (n = 8,933) from the state cancer registry. We then obtained measures of physician supply from the 1994 American Medical Association Physician Masterfile and examined the effects of physician supply (at the levels of county and ZIP code clusters) on the odds of late-stage diagnosis using multiple logistic regression. RESULTS: For each 10-percentile increase in primary care physician supply at the county level, the odds of late-stage diagnosis decreased by 5% (adjusted odds ratio [OR] = 0.95; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.92 - 0.99; P = .007). For each 10-percentile increase in specialty physician supply, the odds of late-stage diagnosis increased by 5% (adjusted OR = 1.05; 95% CI, 1.02-1.09; P = .006). Within ZIP code clusters, each 10-percentile increase in the supply of general internists was associated with a 3% decrease in the odds of late-stage diagnosis (OR = 0.97; 95% CI, 0.95 - 0.99; P = .006), and among women, each 10-percentile increase in the supply of obstetrician/gynecologists was associated with a 5% increase in the odds of late-stage diagnosis (OR = 1.05; 95% CI, 1.01 - 1.08; P = .005). CONCLUSIONS: If the relationships observed were causal, then as many as 874 of the 5463 (16%) late-stage colorectal cancer diagnoses are attributable to the physician specialty supply found in Florida. These findings suggest that an appropriate balance of primary care and specialty physicians may be important in achieving optimal health outcomes.

Influence of longitudinal primary care training on medical students' specialty choices.

BACKGROUND: At the University of South Florida College of Medicine, a program designed to give students four years of primary care training began in 1983. As of 1992, six classes that included program participants had graduated. The present study examined the effect of the program on the participants' choices of specialty by comparing their choices with those of other graduates. METHOD: Each year program volunteers were solicited from a class size of about 96 freshmen. Of the 201 volunteers from the classes of 1987-1992, 93 were randomly selected to participate in the program. The participants received primary care education one half-day per week in a community-based clinical setting. The specialty choices of the 543 graduates from 1987-1992 were determined from the National Resident Matching Program and were divided into primary care (family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics); surgery, obstetrics-gynecology, and psychiatry; and other (high-technology specialties). Comparisons were made (1) between volunteers and nonvolunteers and (2) between volunteers who were participants and those who were not. The Z-test was used, with alpha set at .01. RESULTS: Significantly more volunteers--with no difference between participants and nonparticipants--matched with primary care specialties, and more volunteers were women. Significantly more nonvolunteers matched with high-technology specialties--again, no difference between participants and nonparticipants. CONCLUSION: The program did not seem to influence the students' specialty choices, because students interested in participating--regardless of whether they actually participated--were more likely to match with primary care specialties and were more likely to be women.

Validity of immunization documentation presented to a student health program.

BACKGROUND: Unavoidable exposure to disease and to patients susceptible and vulnerable to disease warrants that students entering medical school be immunized against many of the illnesses for which vaccines are available. The validity of immunization records presented at the time of registration, however, is largely dependent on the provision of accurate and reliable documentation by the student. METHODS: We evaluated for authenticity the immunization and tuberculin testing records of 85 students entering medical school in 1990. Five levels of valid documentation were defined, and the information on each record was reviewed accordingly. RESULTS: Only 43% of the records were original documents or laboratory reports of antibody titers, and 7.5% were not date-specific. We found that 8% to 20% of the forms were missing physician and/or student signatures, and 12% to 19% of the forms did not have health care provider addresses. CONCLUSIONS: Even though medical student preventive health programs may have strict requirements, there may be substantial deficiencies in the quality of the documentation provided by the students. Such deficiencies undermine the purpose of these programs.

Cancer screening. Knowledge, recommendations, and practices of physicians.

BACKGROUND: Americans visit their primary care physicians several times a year. These visits provide physicians with many opportunities to reduce cancer risk in their patients by recommending periodic cancer screening. There is evidence of noncompliance among primary care physicians and their patients with regard to periodic cancer screening. Barriers to screening may be perceived by physicians and patients. RESULTS: The authors found that when physicians recommended cancer screening tests, the compliance among patients was relatively high. CONCLUSION: Primary care physicians can take the opportunity to recommend cancer screening tests during routine patient visits, and this strategy may well increase cancer screening rates in the population.

Barriers to screening among participants of a media-promoted breast cancer screening project.

Breast cancer detection and awareness projects have been implemented nationwide in an attempt to increase compliance with screening mammography. Previous studies, however, showed that the elderly, minorities, and women of lower socioeconomic status fail to respond in representative numbers. A cross-sectional analysis of 6640 participants of a Breast Cancer Detection and Awareness Project in Tampa, FL, was conducted to determine if barriers and motivations to screening differed among targeted (the elderly, minorities, women of lower socioeconomic status) and nontargeted groups. Targeted demographic groups reported far more barriers to screening and fewer motivating factors in their decision to participate in screening. This was true for the elderly, minorities, and women of lower socioeconomic status. Women in greater need of screening mammography report fewer motivations, and must overcome greater barriers to participate in media-promoted breast screening projects. Changes in the design and promotion of these screening projects must occur to prevent reverse targeting.

Matriculants' compliance with a required preventive health program.

Several organizations have made recommendations about medical students' health. To determine the University of South Florida College of Medicine's concurrence with published guidelines, a prospective analytic study of the 1990 entering class was carried out, using the 1989 class as a control. Enforcement measures not present in 1989 were initiated in 1990. The requirements for the 1990 matriculants were a history and physical examination; tuberculin testing; immunizations to rubella, rubeola, tetanus-diphtheria, and hepatitis B; status of immunity to chickenpox; and proof of health insurance. The results showed that in 1990 expensive requirements had the lowest rates of compliance, and inexpensive ones, the highest rates of compliance. Comparing 1990 with 1989 showed that the enforcement measures significantly improved compliance for expensive requirements, and for requirements that obligated a student to incur a fee because they needed to be updated. The authors conclude that cost is a major deterrent to compliance and that, in order to improve compliance, medical schools must either implement effective enforcement measures or transfer the cost from the student to the institution.

Compliance with screening mammography. Survey of primary care physicians.

A survey of primary care physicians in the greater Tampa Bay metropolitan area was conducted to determine compliance with screening mammography and associated physician characteristics. Information requested included their age, sex, specialty, and board certification status, and the ages and frequencies that they recommend screening mammography for their patients. A total of 565 physicians responded. Even though 88% indicated they follow American Cancer Society recommendations when advising screening mammography, only 62% were actually in full compliance. A significantly greater percentage of obstetricians/gynecologists were compliant (74%) compared to other specialties (family practice, 57%, p = .006; internal medicine, 56%, p = .007; general practice, 53%, p = .003). Women physicians were more likely to be compliant than men (83% versus 58%, p less than .001), and younger physicians more likely than older physicians (72% versus 49%, p less than .001). There was no significant difference in compliance rates between board certified and noncertified physicians.

Influence of uncertainty about a specialty's administrative status on students' specialty choices at a Florida medical school.

At the University of South Florida College of Medicine, there was a statistically significant drop in the number of 1990 graduates entering family practice residencies compared with the numbers entering during the previous decade. A retrospective analysis was carried out to determine what factors could have produced such a change and what specialties benefitted. The only factor identified was an administrative policy change that threatened the departmental status of the family medicine unit. Psychiatry was the only specialty choice that showed significant increases. The findings of this study suggest that medical students' selection of family practice as a specialty choice is detrimentally influenced by uncertainty about the family medicine unit's departmental status, and that family medicine may be competing with psychiatry for students' interest.