Free subchondral screws in tibial plateau fractures: do they hinder a total knee arthroplasty? Strategies to prevent complications.

Open reduction and internal fixation of extended lateral column tibial plateau fractures through a tibial condyle osteotomy and limited arthrotomy with the use of free subchondral locking screws is a straightforward and safe technique. However, these free subchondral screws are enclosed in the subchondral bone and therefore virtually impossible to remove after bone healing. The question arises whether these free subchondral screws might hinder a future total knee arthroplasty. In order to refute this, we retrospectively reviewed all surgically managed tibial plateau fractures in our tertiary center during one year and assessed the number, position and configuration of these in situ subchondral screws and K-wires. In addition, we performed a cadaver study, wherein we prepared 7 tibial plateaus for a total knee arthroplasty tibial component placement with free subchondral screws in situ. In this experiment, we demonstrated that free subchondral screws do not interfere with total knee arthroplasty, but they can increase operative time in some cases. We also provide recommendations to avoid difficulties and potential complications.

Valgus alignment of the femoral component is associated with higher revision rates 10 years after TKA.

PURPOSE: Appropriate positioning and alignment of tibial and femoral component in primary total knee arthroplasty (TKA) are factors of major importance directly related to patient satisfaction and implant survival. Most literature works elaborate on overall post-operative alignment and its correlation to implant survival. However, less is known about the impact of individual component alignment. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of undercorrection of overall alignment as well as the effect of individual tibial and femoral component alignment on the post-operative failure rate after total knee arthroplasty. METHODS: Clinical and radiographic data of primary TKA cases from 2002 to 2004, with a minimum of 10-year follow-up, were retrospectively reviewed. The pre- and post-operative hip-knee-ankle angle (HKA), mechanical lateral distal femoral angle (mLDFA) and mechanical medial proximal tibial angle (mMPTA) were measured on weight-bearing, full-length antero-posterior lower limb radiographs. Statistical analysis was performed to establish the correlation between both overall and implant alignment and revision rate. RESULTS: In total, 379 primary TKA cases were evaluated. The mean time of follow-up was 12.9 years (range 10.3-15.9 years, SD = 1.8). Nine out of 379 cases were revised due to aseptic loosening; the mean time to revision was 5.5 years (range 1.0-15.5 years, SD = 4.6). Varus undercorrection of overall alignment was not associated with a higher rate of revision (p = 0.316). Post-operative valgus femoral alignment (mLDFA < 87°) contributed to a significant decreased prosthesis survival in contrast to neutral femoral alignment (revision rate valgus group: 10.7% and neutral group: 1.7%; p = 0.003). Post-operative tibial mechanical alignment was not identified as a significant predictor for implant survival (revision rate varus group: 2.9% and neutral group: 2.4%; p = 0.855). CONCLUSIONS: Primary TKA showed significantly higher revision rates when the femoral component was placed in > 3° of valgus (mLDFA < 87°). In contrast, postoperative overall residual varus alignment (HKA) and varus alignment of the tibial component were not related to higher revision rates at a minimum 10-year follow-up after TKA. These findings should be considered when choosing component position in individualised TKA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.

Reduced bone activity in the native compartments after medial mobile-bearing unicompartmental knee arthroplasty. A prospective SPECT/CT study.

AIMS: Altered alignment and biomechanics are thought to contribute to the progression of osteoarthritis (OA) in the native compartments after medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA). The aim of this study was to evaluate the bone activity and remodelling in the lateral tibiofemoral and patellofemoral compartment after medial mobile-bearing UKA. PATIENTS AND METHODS: In total, 24 patients (nine female, 15 male) with 25 medial Oxford UKAs (13 left, 12 right) were prospectively followed with sequential 99mTc-hydroxymethane diphosphonate single photon emission CT (SPECT)/CT preoperatively and at one and two years postoperatively, along with standard radiographs and clinical outcome scores. The mean patient age was 62 years (40 to 78) and the mean body mass index (BMI) was 29.7 kg/m2 (23.6 to 42.2). Mean osteoblastic activity was evaluated using a tracer localization scheme with volumes of interest (VOIs). Normalized mean tracer values were calculated as the ratio between the mean tracer activity in a VOI and background activity in the femoral diaphysis. RESULTS: Significant reduction of normalized tracer activity was observed one year postoperatively in tibial and femoral VOIs adjacent to the joint line in the lateral compartment. Patellar VOIs and remaining femoral VOIs demonstrated a significant, diminished normalized tracer activity at final follow-up. CONCLUSION: The osteoblastic bone activity in the native compartments decreased significantly after treatment of medial end-stage OA with a UKA, implying reduced stress to the subchondral bone in the retained compartments after a UKA. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2019;101-B:915-921.

Hinged versus CCK revision arthroplasty for the stiff total knee.

BACKGROUND: Total knee arthroplasty (TKA) remains the gold standard for end-stage knee osteoarthritis. The prevalence of stiffness after this procedure described in literature varies from 1.3% to 5.3%. The causes of arthrofibrosis after total knee arthroplasty are multifactorial. Revision TKA is a successful procedure when performed for loosening, instability, mechanical implant failure, or infection. The results of revision TKA for idiopathic arthrofibrosis and stiffening are however less favorable. PURPOSE: It has been the authors' impression that the poor results in arthrofibrosis could be in part related to the use of traditional PS or CCK-type revision implants. Our hypothesis is that better results can be achieved in case a rotating hinge design (RHK) is used. The reason could be that RHK designs allow for much more aggressive capsuloligament debridement and therefore more adequate fibrosis removal, while securing optimal implant stability, tibiofemoral rotational freedom, and flexion-extension space stability. The purpose of our study was to investigate in our database whether this hypothesis is correct. METHODS: Retrospectively, 40 patients with the defined range of knee motion were identified. Patients with underlying mechanical malalignment, component malposition, soft-tissue imbalance or infections were excluded. Twenty-two patients received a hinged-type prosthetic device (18 Zimmer RHK, four Stryker RHK) and 18 patients received a less constrained condylar type prosthetic device (17 Legion CCK, one Vanguard CCK). RESULTS: Preoperative data were similar for RHK as CCK-type implants except for knee pain score, which was significantly worse for the RHK group (36 vs 44, p = 0.049). At two years of follow-up, compared to CCK, the RHK group demonstrated significantly better postoperative results for knee function scores (68.9 vs 54.2, p = 0.0015), knee function improvement (22.8 vs 4.8, p = 0.0015), knee pain improvement (26.4 vs 9.4, p = 0.0050), greater maximal flexion (99.9° vs 81.4°, p = 0.0005), better maximal extension (-1.9° vs -6.2°, p = 0.0447), greater flexion gain (35.8° vs 14.2°, p = 0.0002), and greater extension gain (8.6° vs 2.0°, p = 0.0083). CONCLUSION: Our data show that revision arthroplasty of the stiff knee using a rotating hinged device can provide excellent results in selected cases. To date, this is the first study to describe the difference in outcome between revision total knee arthroplasty for idiopathic arthrofibrosis using a hinged or a constrained condylar knee device.

The shape and orientation of the trochlea run more parallel to the posterior condylar line than generally believed.

PURPOSE: This study was set up to identify the native trochlear geometry and define its relationship with the rotational landmarks of the distal femur. METHODS: The rotational landmarks of the distal femur were analysed on CT-scans of 281 patients with end-stage knee osteoarthritis. RESULTS: The anterior trochlear line (ATL) was on average 4.3° (SD 3.3°) internally rotated relative to the surgical transepicondylar axis (sTEA). The ATL was on average 2.1° (SD 3.0°) internally rotated relative to the posterior condylar line (PCL). The relationship between the ATL and the sTEA was statistically different in the different coronal alignment groups (p = 0.004): 3.9° (SD 3.0°) in varus knees, 4.0° (SD 2.9°) in neutral knees and 5.4° (SD 3.8°) in valgus knees. The lateralisation of the trochlea, represented by the distance between the perpendicular to PCL and the perpendicular to the posterior parallel line to the sTEA, was on average 2.2 mm (SD 1.8 mm). CONCLUSION: The ATL was on average 4.3° (SD 3.3°) internally rotated relative to the sTEA and 2.1° (SD 3.0°) internally rotated relative to the PCL. The ATL is more externally orientated in varus knees and more internally rotated in valgus knees. The trochlear groove is lateralised by only 2.2 mm when the femoral component is externally rotated. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.

Proximalisation of the tibial tubercle gives a good outcome in patients undergoing revision total knee arthroplasty who have pseudo patella baja.

AIMS: The aim of this study was to compare the outcome of revision total knee arthroplasty (TKA) with and without proximalisation of the tibial tubercle in patients with a failed primary TKA who have pseudo patella baja. PATIENTS AND METHODS: All revision TKAs, performed between January 2008 and November 2013 at a tertiary referral University Orthopaedic Department were retrospectively reviewed. Pseudo patella baja was defined using the modified Insall-Salvati and the Blackburne-Peel ratios. A proximalisation of the tibial tubercle was performed in 13 patients with pseudo patella baja who were matched with a control group of 13 patients for gender, age, height, weight, body mass index, length of surgery and Blackburne-Peel ratio. Outcome was assessed two years post-operatively using the Knee Society Score (KSS). RESULTS: The increase in KSS was significantly higher in the osteotomy group compared with the control group. The outcome was statistically better in patients in whom proximalisation of > 1 cm had been achieved compared with those in whom the proximalisation was < 1 cm. CONCLUSION: In this retrospective case-control study, a proximal transfer of the tibial tubercle at revision TKA in patients with pseudo patella baja gives good outcomes without major complications. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2017;99-B:912-16.

Predictors of outcome after manipulation under anaesthesia in patients with a stiff total knee arthroplasty.

PURPOSE: Flexion in a stiff total knee arthroplasty (TKA) can be improved by manipulation under anaesthesia (MUA). Although this intervention usually results in an improvement in range of motion, the expected result is not always achieved. The purpose of this study is to determine which factors affect range of motion after manipulation in patients with a stiff total knee. METHODS: After exclusion (n = 22), the data of 158 patients (138 knees) with a stiff knee after TKA who received a manipulation under anaesthesia between 2004 and 2014 were retrospectively analysed. Pre-, peri- and post-operative variables were identified and examined for their influence on flexion after the manipulation using Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney U tests and Spearman correlations. RESULTS: After MUA, a mean improvement in flexion of 30.3° was observed at the final follow-up. Preoperative TKA flexion, design of TKA and interval between TKA procedure and MUA were positive associated with an increase in flexion after MUA. MUA performed 12 weeks or more after TKA procedure deteriorated the outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Three factors, pre-TKA flexion type of prosthesis and interval between TKA procedure and manipulation under anaesthesia, were found to have impact on flexion after TKA and MUA were identified. Results are expected to be inferior in patients with low flexion before TKA procedure or with a long interval (>12 weeks) between the TKA procedure and the manipulation under anaesthesia. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: IV.

The adductor ratio: a new tool for joint line reconstruction in revision TKA.

PURPOSE: In this study, the value of the adductor tubercle as landmark for joint line reconstruction in revision total knee arthroplasty (TKA) was investigated. METHODS: On 100 calibrated full-leg standing radiographs obtained from healthy volunteers, distances from the medial epicondyle, the lateral epicondyle, the adductor tubercle, the fibular head and the centre of the knee to the joint line were determined. RESULTS: The average distance to the joint line from the medial epicondyle, the lateral epicondyle, the adductor tubercle and the fibular head was found to be 27.7 mm (SD 3.0), 27.1 mm (SD 2.7), 44.6 mm (SD 4.3) and 15.1 mm (SD 3.7), respectively. The distance from the adductor tubercle (R = 0.82) and the centre of the knee (R = 0.86) to the joint line showed a strong and linear correlation with the femoral width. The medial epicondyle, the lateral epicondyle and the fibular head showed less strong correlations. There was no significant correlation with the limb alignment. The adductor ratio was defined as the distance from adductor tubercle to the joint line divided by the femoral width and was found to be 0.52 (SD 0.027) with only small inter-individual variation. The adductor ratio was the most accurate ratio and reconstructed the joint line within 4 mm of its original level in 92% of the cases. CONCLUSION: The adductor ratio is a reliable and accurate tool for joint line reconstruction in revision TKA. It was found to be more accurate then the use of absolute distances and the epicondylar ratios. This study supports the use of the adductor tubercle for joint line reconstruction in revision TKA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: II.

Can anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction be performed routinely in day clinic?

Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction is performed as an outpatient procedure in selected cases. Whether it can be safely performed on a routine basis in day clinic remains unclear. Our hypothesis was that routinely performing outpatient anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction would be equally safe as compared to inpatient procedures. A cohort of 355 patients who underwent outpatient primary reconstruction was analysed at an average follow-up of 3.8 years. Four patients (1.1%) could not be discharged or were readmitted within 24 hours. The 1-month readmission rate was 1.4%. The overall complication rate was 12.1% (43 cases) of which 4.2% (15 patients) occurred within the first 30 days. Performing anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions routinely in day clinic is associated with almost negligible readmission rates and has similar complication rates as for standard in-hospital anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions. Outpatient anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions can therefore be safely performed without specific preoperative patient selection protocols.

The influence of leg length difference on clinical outcome after revision TKA.

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this paper was to document the incidence of leg length changes after revision total knee arthroplasty (TKA) and its effect on clinical outcome. METHODS: Leg length difference (LLD) was prospectively measured in 85 patients using digital standing full leg radiography before and after revision TKA. Additionally the patient's subjective perception of LLD was assessed postoperatively. Linear regression models were used to study the correlation between each of these parameters and the clinical outcome after 1 year. Clinical outcome was evaluated by means of the Knee Society Score (KSS). RESULTS: Revision TKA resulted on average in an increased leg length of 5.3 mm. Sixty-five legs (76%) were lengthened with the procedure, 17 (20%) were shortened and three (4%) remained of identical length. Increased leg length after revision was positively correlated with clinical outcome at 3 months (Spearman r=0.22, p=0.044) and 1 year (Spearman r=0.26, p=0.027). The evidence for this correlation remained after correction for age, gender and diagnosis (p=0.012). The most important contributors to improved clinical outcome scores were improved pain score (Spearman r=0.19, p=0.09) and increased stability (Spearman r=0.13, p=0.24), rather than range of motion (Spearman r=-0.02, p=0.85). CONCLUSIONS: The results from our work indicate that revision TKA tends to lengthen the leg by approximately 5mm. Contrary to what might be expected, leg lengthening after revision TKA is correlated with improved clinical outcome. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level 2b.

Opening wedge distal femoral varus osteotomy using the Puddu plate and calcium phosphate bone cement.

PURPOSE: The goal of this study was to document the outcome at midterm follow-up of 19 patients treated for lateral osteoarthritis of the knee between 1999 and 2007. It was our hypothesis that the results and complication rate would be comparable to or better than those reported in the literature for closing wedge or alternative open wedge techniques. METHODS: All patients underwent an open wedge distal femoral varisation osteotomy using the Puddu plate system combined with calcium phosphate injection into the defect. Knee Society Knee Score and Kellgren-Lawrence osteoarthritis score were assessed preoperatively and at final follow-up. RESULTS: The average knee score improved significantly from 43 ± 8 preoperatively to 78 ± 23 at final follow-up. The Kellgren-Lawrence osteoarthritis score remained unchanged. Kaplan-Meier analysis using revision surgery or conversion to TKA as an endpoint demonstrated an 82% successful survivorship at 7 years of follow-up. CONCLUSION: Based upon these results, we believe that a distal femoral varisation osteotomy using the Puddu plate and injectable bone cement is an equivalent treatment option compared to closing wedge techniques and leading to good results at midterm follow-up in patients with lateral gonarthrosis and valgus alignment. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: IV.

Is adapted measured resection superior to gap-balancing in determining femoral component rotation in total knee replacement?

Obtaining a balanced flexion gap with correct femoral component rotation is one of the prerequisites for a successful outcome after total knee replacement (TKR). Different techniques for achieving this have been described. In this study we prospectively compared gap-balancing versus measured resection in terms of reliability and accuracy for femoral component rotation in 96 primary TKRs performed in 96 patients using the Journey system. In 48 patients (18 men and 30 women) with a mean age of 65 years (45 to 85) a tensor device was used to determine rotation. In the second group of 48 patients (14 men and 34 women) with a mean age of 64 years (41 to 86), an 'adapted' measured resection technique was used, taking into account the native rotational geometry of the femur as measured on a pre-operative CT scan. Both groups systematically reproduced a similar external rotation of the femoral component relative to the surgical transepicondylar axis: 2.4° (SD 2.5) in the gap-balancing group and 1.7° (SD 2.1) in the measured resection group (p = 0.134). Both gap-balancing and adapted measured resection techniques proved equally reliable and accurate in determining femoral component rotation after TKR. There was a tendency towards more external rotation in the gap-balancing group, but this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.134). The number of outliers for our 'adapted' measured resection technique was much lower than reported in the literature.

The influence of malrotation and femoral component material on patellofemoral wear during gait.

Complications involving the patellofemoral joint, caused by malrotation of the femoral component during total knee replacement, are an important cause of persistent pain and failure leading to revision surgery. The aim of this study was to determine and quantify the influence of femoral component malrotation on patellofemoral wear, and to determine whether or not there is a difference in the rate of wear of the patellar component when articulated against oxidised zirconium (OxZr) and cobalt-chrome (CoCr) components. An in vitro method was used to simulate patellar maltracking for both materials. Both rates of wear and changes in height on the patellar articular surface were measured. The mean rates of wear measured were very small compared to standard tibiofemoral wear rates. When data for each femoral component material were pooled, the mean rate of wear was 0.19 mm3/Mcycle (sd 0.21) for OxZr and 0.34 mm3/Mcycle (sd 0.335) for CoCr. The largest change in height on each patella varied from -0.05 mm to -0.33 mm over the different configurations. The results suggest that patellar maltracking due to an internally rotated femoral component leads to an increased mean patellar wear. Although not statistically significant, the mean wear production may be lower for OxZr than for CoCr components.

Anteroposterior positioning of the tibial component and its effect on the mechanics of patellofemoral contact.

The biomechanics of the patellofemoral joint can become disturbed during total knee replacement by alterations induced by the position and shape of the different prosthetic components. The role of the patella and femoral trochlea has been well studied. We have examined the effect of anterior or posterior positioning of the tibial component on the mechanisms of patellofemoral contact in total knee replacement. The hypothesis was that placing the tibial component more posteriorly would reduce patellofemoral contact stress while providing a more efficient lever arm during extension of the knee. We studied five different positions of the tibial component using a six degrees of freedom dynamic knee simulator system based on the Oxford rig, while simulating an active knee squat under physiological loading conditions. The patellofemoral contact force decreased at a mean of 2.2% for every millimetre of posterior translation of the tibial component. Anterior positions of the tibial component were associated with elevation of the patellofemoral joint pressure, which was particularly marked in flexion > 90°. From our results we believe that more posterior positioning of the tibial component in total knee replacement would be beneficial to the patellofemoral joint.

The influence of malrotation of the femoral component in total knee replacement on the mechanics of patellofemoral contact during gait: an in vitro biomechanical study.

Malrotation of the femoral component is a cause of patellofemoral maltracking after total knee arthroplasty. Its precise effect on the patellofemoral mechanics has not been well quantified. We have developed an in vitro method to measure the influence of patellar maltracking on contact. Maltracking was induced by progressively rotating the femoral component either internally or externally. The contact mechanics were analysed using Tekscan. The results showed that excessive malrotation of the femoral component, both internally and externally, had a significant influence on the mechanics of contact. The contact area decreased with progressive maltracking, with a concomitant increase in contact pressure. The amount of contact area that carries more than the yield stress of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene significantly increases with progressive maltracking. It is likely that the elevated pressures noted in malrotation could cause accelerated and excessive wear of the patellar button.

The influence of coronal plane deformity on mediolateral ligament status: an observational study in varus knees.

Most surgeons believe that varus deformity leads to progressive tightness of the medial soft tissue envelope and laxity on the lateral side. It is, however, unclear at what stage of the deformity such ligament alterations occur, and whether these are the consequence of intrinsic alterations in the ligaments themselves, or rather due to extrinsic factors such as osteophytes, adhesions to the underlying bone, or other factors which may cause a tightening effect. Thirty-five varus knees that were scheduled for TKA were investigated. Ligament status was evaluated after temporary correction of alignment and removal of osteophytes, using varus/valgus testing with computer navigation technology. Knees with <10 degrees varus deformity were easily correctable to neutral after correction of the extrinsic factors that could cause medial tightness, and these knees maintained normal mediolateral laxity during varus/valgus stress testing. When coronal plane deformity exceeded 10 degrees, progressive shortening of the medial collateral ligament was noted, as well as progressive stretching of the lateral structures (P < 0.001). This study, therefore, demonstrates that the medial collateral structures become intrinsically shortened when preoperative varus deformity exceeds 10 degrees. Likewise, the lateral soft tissues become stretched. None of these occur when the preoperative deformity is <10 degrees.

Is there a biomechanical explanation for anterior knee pain in patients with patella alta?: influence of patellar height on patellofemoral contact force, contact area and contact pressure.

The purpose of this study was to test the hypothesis that patella alta leads to a less favourable situation in terms of patellofemoral contact force, contact area and contact pressure than the normal patellar position, and thereby gives rise to anterior knee pain. A dynamic knee simulator system based on the Oxford rig and allowing six degrees of freedom was adapted in order to simulate and record the dynamic loads during a knee squat from 30 degrees to 120 degrees flexion under physiological conditions. Five different configurations were studied, with variable predetermined patellar heights. The patellofemoral contact force increased with increasing knee flexion until contact occurred between the quadriceps tendon and the femoral trochlea, inducing load sharing. Patella alta caused a delay of this contact until deeper flexion. As a consequence, the maximal patellofemoral contact force and contact pressure increased significantly with increasing patellar height (p < 0.01). Patella alta was associated with the highest maximal patellofemoral contact force and contact pressure. When averaged across all flexion angles, a normal patellar position was associated with the lowest contact pressures. Our results indicate that there is a biomechanical reason for anterior knee pain in patients with patella alta.

The influence of tibial slope on maximal flexion after total knee arthroplasty.

Many surgeons believe that increasing the tibial slope in total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is beneficial with regard to maximal postoperative flexion. Review of the clinical literature, however, does not confirm this hypothesis, neither does it give an answer to the question of how much flexion gain can be expected per degree extra tibial slope. The purpose of this study was, therefore, to evaluate and quantify the influence of tibial slope on maximal postoperative flexion in contemporary posterior cruciate ligament (PCL)-retaining TKA. Twenty-one cadaver simulations of a standard PCL-retaining TKA were studied while reproducing identical deep flexion femorotibial kinematics as documented by three-dimensional computer-aided videofluoroscopy from patients with well-functioning TKAs of the same design. In each knee the tibial component was consecutively implanted with 0 degrees posterior slope, 4 degrees posterior slope, and 7 degrees posterior slope. Maximal flexion was recorded for each configuration. Average maximal flexion at 0 degrees tibial slope was 104 degrees, and increased significantly to 112 degrees when the same knees were implanted with 4 degrees tibial slope. Increasing the slope further to 7 degrees again significantly improved average maximal flexion to 120 degrees. When postoperative radiographic tibial slope was compared to maximal flexion, an average gain of 1.7 degrees flexion for every degree extra tibial slope was noted. Increasing the tibial slope in PCL-retaining TKA does indeed improve maximal flexion before tibial insert impingement occurs against the femoral bone. The surgeon can expect an average gain of 1.7 degrees flexion for every degree extra tibial slope.

Fluoroscopic analysis of the kinematics of deep flexion in total knee arthroplasty. Influence of posterior condylar offset.

Our purpose was to determine the mechanism which allows the maximum knee flexion in vivo after a posterior-cruciate-ligament (PCL)-retaining total knee arthroplasty. Using three-dimensional computer-aided design videofluoroscopy of deep squatting in 29 patients, we determined that in 72% of knees, direct impingement of the tibial insert posteriorly against the back of the femur was the factor responsible for blocking further flexion. In view of this finding we defined a new parameter termed the 'posterior condylar offset'. In 150 consecutive arthroplasties of the knee, the magnitude of posterior condylar offset was found to correlate with the final range of flexion.

Fixation strength of meniscal repair devices.

The aim of this study was to measure and compare the ultimate failure strengths and cyclic fatigue strengths of currently available meniscal suturing devices. No statistically significant difference in failure load was found between a vertical loop suture (mean 46.3 N), a horizontal mattress suture (52.5 N), the T-fix Device (47.5 N), and the 16-mm (39.2 N) and 13-mm (32.8 N) Bionix Arrow. Statistically inferior results were seen with the 10-mm Bionix Arrow (18.8 N), the S.D. Sorb Stapler (4.3 N), and the 12-mm Arthrex Meniscal Dart (10.5 N) (P<0.01). The Mitek Meniscal Repair System (28.1 N) performed intermediate, with significantly better results than the S.D. Sorb Stapler and the 12-mm Arthrex Dart, but significantly worse than the vertical and horizontal sutures, the T-fix and Bionix 16-mm Device (P<0.01). Cyclic fatigue strength was significantly less for the 10-mm Bionix Arrow, the S.D. Sorb Stapler, and the 12-mm Arthrex Meniscal Dart (P<0.01) compared to all other devices. We conclude that the 13- and 16-mm Bionix Arrow and the T-fix Device have comparable ultimate failure strengths and cyclic fatigue strengths to conventional meniscal suturing techniques. The 10-mm Bionix Arrow, S.D. Sorb Stapler, and the 12-mm Arthrex Meniscal Dart, however, have far inferior failure and cyclic fatigue strengths and their clinical application should be questioned.