Comparison between two prospective studies of cardiovascular disease carried out amongst renal replacement patients in UK and Italy.

The data on 256 non-diabetic patients entering renal replacement therapy (RRT) in Manchester between 1 January 1983 and 31 December 1986 were compared with those on 84 non-diabetic patients entering RRT in Milan between 1 January 1983 and 31 December 1988. In each unit, patients had been studied prospectively and the findings were entered on the same database for this report. At the end of the study, 68% of patients were alive in each centre and in each 16% had died from cardiovascular disease. 11% of Manchester and 18% of the Milan patients developed angina. The data do not support the view that there is a differential risk for cardiovascular disease in the Northern and Southern parts of Europe and it may be advisable to study the matter prospectively in a larger patient cohort.

Comparative mortality from cardiovascular disease in patients with chronic renal failure.

Patients with chronic renal failure show an excess mortality from cardiovascular disease (CVD). Over a 4-year period (1983-1986) we have prospectively studied 305 patients (177 men, 128 women) from a geographically constrained population entering a renal replacement therapy (RRT) programme. The development of new cardiovascular events and patient survival have been documented up to the end of 1990. We have determined the incidence of CVD amongst the patients compared to the general population of the region and assessed the predictive value for future cardiovascular events of risk factors present at the start of RRT. One hundred and fourteen patients experienced a new cardiovascular event. One hundred and fifteen patients died, 89 from CVD. Stratification by age and sex identified diabetes, previous coronary heart disease, and cardiomegaly to be significantly associated with an increased risk of a cardiovascular event, and diabetes, previous coronary heart disease, and accelerated hypertension to be significantly associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular death. Mortality from CVD was 10.1 times that of the corresponding general population, and was increased 44 times for patients with diabetes. Duration of RRT did not influence mortality rates. This excessive early mortality has significant implications for RRT programmes and further research is necessary to identify individuals at risk and the modifiable risk factors that could receive targeted interventional therapy.

Value of thallium myocardial imaging in the prediction of future cardiovascular events in patients with end-stage renal failure.

Chronic renal failure is associated with an increased rate of premature death from cardiovascular disease. Non-invasive identification of asymptomatic cardiac disease should be valuable in the management of such patients, and in selection for transplantation. One hundred and three high-risk patients (66 male, 37 female) with chronic renal failure who were without cardiovascular symptoms were assessed by exercise-graded thallium myocardial perfusion imaging and followed prospectively for 4 years. The development of a cardiovascular event, or death, and the interval to event or death were recorded. Cardiovascular events were documented in 50 patients; in 44 of the 60 patients with a positive thallium test and in only six of the 43 patients with a negative thallium test (test sensitivity 88%, specificity 70%, predictive value of a positive test 73%). Forty patients died, 28 from cardiovascular causes, during the study period. Thallium myocardial perfusion imaging is of value in the prediction of future cardiovascular events in patients with chronic renal failure, and is a useful non-invasive screening technique in patients with end-stage renal failure being considered for transplantation.