Photoinduced Electron Transfer in Inclusion Complexes of Carbon Nanohoops.

ConspectusPhotoinduced electron transfer (PET) in carbon materials is a process of great importance in light energy conversion. Carbon materials, such as fullerenes, graphene flakes, carbon nanotubes, and cycloparaphenylenes (CPPs), have unusual electronic properties that make them interesting objects for PET research. These materials can be used as electron-hole transport layers, electrode materials, or passivation additives in photovoltaic devices. Moreover, their appropriate combination opens up new possibilities for constructing photoactive supramolecular systems with efficient charge transfer between the donor and acceptor parts. CPPs build a class of molecules consisting of para-linked phenylene rings. CPPs and their numerous derivatives are appealing building blocks in supramolecular chemistry, acting as suitable concave receptors with strong host-guest interactions for the convex surfaces of fullerenes. Efficient PET in donor-acceptor systems can be observed when charge separation occurs faster than charge recombination. This Account focuses on selected inclusion complexes of carbon nanohoops studied by our group. We modeled charge separation and charge recombination in both previously synthesized and computationally designed complexes to identify how various modifications of host and guest molecules affect the PET efficiency in these systems. A consistent computational protocol we used includes a time-dependent density-functional theory (TD-DFT) formalism with the Tamm-Dancoff approximation (TDA) and CAM-B3LYP functional to carry out excited state calculations and the nonadiabatic electron transfer theory to estimate electron-transfer rates. We show how the photophysical properties of carbon nanohoops can be modified by incorporating additional π-conjugated fragments and antiaromatic units, multiple fluorine substitutions, and extending the overall π-electron system. Incorporating π-conjugated groups or linkers is accompanied by the appearance of new charge transfer states. Perfluorination of the nanohoops radically changes their role in charge separation from an electron donor to an electron acceptor. Vacancy defects in π-extended nanohoops are shown to hinder PET between host and guest molecules, while large fully conjugated π-systems improve the electron-donor properties of nanohoops. We also highlight the role of antiaromatic structural units in tuning the electronic properties of nanohoops. Depending on the aromaticity degree of monomeric units in nanohoops, the direction of electron transfer in their complexes with C60 fullerene can be altered. Nanohoops with aromatic units usually act as electron donors, while those with antiaromatic monomers serve as electron acceptors. Finally, we discuss why charged fullerenes are better electron acceptors than neutral C60 and how the charge location allows for the design of more efficient donor-acceptor systems with an unusual hypsochromic shift of the charge transfer band in polar solvents.

Effect of external electric fields in the charge transfer rates of donor-acceptor dyads: A straightforward computational evaluation.

We present a straightforward and low-cost computational protocol to estimate the variation of the charge transfer rate constant, kCT, in a molecular donor-acceptor caused by an external electric field. The proposed protocol also allows for determining the strength and direction of the field that maximize the kCT. The application of this external electric field results in up to a >4000-fold increase in the kCT for one of the systems studied. Our method allows the identification of field-induced charge-transfer processes that would not occur without the perturbation caused by an external electric field. In addition, the proposed protocol can be used to predict the effect on the kCT due to the presence of charged functional groups, which may allow for the rational design of more efficient donor-acceptor dyads.

Excited State Processes in Supramolecular Complexes of Cyclic Dibenzopyrrolopyrrole Isomers with C60 Fullerene.

An approach to modulating the properties of carbon nanorings by incorporating pyrrolo[3,2-b]pyrrole units is of particular interest due to the combined effect of heteroatom and antiaromatic character on electronic properties. The inclusion of units other than phenylene leads to the formation of stereoisomers. In this work, we computationally study how the spatial orientation of monomeric units in the ring affects the properties of cyclic dibenzopyrrolo[3,2-b]pyrroles and their complexes with C60 fullerene. For [4]PP and [4]DHPP, the most symmetrical AAAA isomer is the most stable and forms stronger interactions with fullerene than the isomers where one or two monomeric units are flipped, mostly due to less Pauli repulsion. π-Electron delocalization in the monomeric unit is crucial for directing the electron transfer (from or to nanoring). The energy of excited states with charge transfer depends on the HOMO-LUMO gap, which varies from one stereoisomer to another only for [4]DHPP⊃C60 with aromatic 1,4-dihydropyrrolo[3,2-b]pyrrole units. The rates of electron transfer and charge recombination reactions are relatively weakly dependent of the spatial isomerism of nanorings.

The Hunter Falls Prey: Photoinduced Oxidation of C60 in Inclusion Complex with Perfluorocycloparaphenylene.

Perfluorocycloparaphenylenes (PFCPPs) are cycloparaphenylenes (CPPs) in which all hydrogen atoms have been replaced by fluorine atoms. Like CPPs, PFCPPs are highly strained, hoop-shaped π-conjugated molecules. In this article, we report a computational modeling of photoinduced electron transfer processes in the inclusion complex of PF[10]CPP with C60 fullerene. Its unique feature is the favorable electron transfer from C60 to the host molecule. The photooxidation of C60 is predicted to occur on a sub-nanosecond timescale. The PF[10]CPP⊃C60 dyad is the first nanoring-fullerene complex in which C60 acts as an electron donor in the photoinduced charge separation.

Initiating Electron Transfer in Doubly Curved Nanographene Upon Supramolecular Complexation of C60.

The formation of supramolecular complexes between C60 and a molecular nanographene endowed with both positive and negative curvatures is described. The presence of a corannulene moiety and the saddle shape of the molecular nanographene allows the formation of complexes with 1:1, 1:2, and 2:1 stoichiometries. The association constants for the three possible supramolecular complexes were determined by 1 H NMR titration. Furthermore, the stability of the three complexes was calculated by theoretical methods that also predict the photoinduced electron transfer from the curved nanographene to the electron acceptor C60 . Time-resolved transient absorption measurements on the ns-time scale showed that the addition of C60 to NG-1 solutions and photo-exciting them at 460 nm leads to the solvent-dependent formation of new species, in particular the formation of the one-electron reduced form of C60 in benzonitrile was observed.

Unexpected Disparity in Photoinduced Reactions of C60 and C70 in Water with the Generation of O2 •- or 1O2.

Well-defined fullerene-PEG conjugates, C60-PEG (1) and two C70-PEG (2 and 3 with the addition sites on ab-[6,6] and cc-[6,6]-junctions), were prepared from their corresponding Prato monoadduct precursors. The resulting highly water-soluble fullerene-PEG conjugates 1-3 were evaluated for their DNA-cleaving activities and reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation under visible light irradiation. Unexpectedly, photoinduced cleavage of DNA by C60-PEG 1 was much higher than that by C70-PEG 2 and 3 with higher absorption intensity, especially in the presence of an electron donor (NADH). The preference of photoinduced ROS generation from fullerene-PEG conjugates 1-3 via the type II (energy transfer) or the type I (electron transfer) photoreaction was found to be dependent on the fullerene core (between C60 and C70) and functionalization pattern of C70 (between 2 and 3). This was clearly supported by the electron transfer rate obtained from cyclic voltammetry data and computationally estimated relative rate of each step of the type II and the type I reactions, with the finding that type II energy transfer reactions occurred in the inverted Marcus regime while type I electron transfer reactions proceeded in the normal Marcus regime. This finding on the disparity in the pathways of photoinduced reactions (type I versus type II) provides insights into the behavior of photosensitizers in water and the design of photodynamic therapy drugs.

Solvation Free Energies for Aqueous and Nonaqueous Solutions Computed Using PM7 Atomic Charges.

We describe a simple and accurate method, ESE-PM7, for calculating solvation free energies ΔGsolv° in aqueous and nonaqueous solutions. The method is based on a noniterative COSMO algorithm. Molecular geometries and atomic charges calculated using the semiempirical method PM7 are used to calculate ΔGsolv°. The method has been tested on 92 different solvents and 988 solutes. The mean absolute errors (MAEs) in ΔGsolv° in aqueous solutions estimated by the ESE-PM7 approach are found to be 1.62 kcal/mol for 389 neutral solutes and 3.06 kcal/mol for 139 ions. The MAEs for neutral molecules in organic solvents are 0.97, 0.74, and 0.51 kcal/mol in polar protic, polar aprotic, and nonpolar solvents, respectively. The developed method can be employed to quickly screen ΔGsolv° values of extended molecular systems including pharmaceutical and biological molecules.

Photophysics of DFHBI bound to RNA aptamer Baby Spinach.

The discovery of the GFP-type dye DFHBI that becomes fluorescent upon binding to an RNA aptamer, termed Spinach, led to the development of a variety of fluorogenic RNA systems that enable genetic encoding of living cells. In view of increasing interest in small RNA aptamers and the scarcity of their photophysical characterisation, this paper is a model study on Baby Spinach, a truncated Spinach aptamer with half its sequence. Fluorescence and fluorescence excitation spectra of DFHBI complexes of Spinach and Baby Spinach are known to be similar. Surprisingly, a significant divergence between absorption and fluorescence excitation spectra of the DFHBI/RNA complex was observed on conditions of saturation at large excess of RNA over DFHBI. Since absorption spectra were not reported for any Spinach-type aptamer, this effect is new. Quantitative modelling of the absorption spectrum based on competing dark and fluorescent binding sites could explain it. However, following reasoning of fluorescence lifetimes of bound DFHBI, femtosecond-fluorescence lifetime profiles would be more supportive of the notion that the abnormal absorption spectrum is largely caused by trans-isomers formed  within the cis-bound DFHBI/RNA complex. Independent of the origin, the unexpected discrepancy between absorption and fluorescence excitation spectra allows for easily accessed screening and insight into the efficiency of a fluorogenic dye/RNA system.

How Do Defects in Carbon Nanostructures Regulate the Photoinduced Electron Transfer Processes? The Case of Phenine Nanotubes.

Photoinduced electron transfer is studied in a series of inclusion complexes of structurally modified phenine nanotubes (pNT) with C70 using the TD-DFT method. Analysis of electronic properties of the complexes shows that the electron transfer is infeasible in pNT_4d⊃C70 built on the tetrameric array of [6]cyclo-meta-phenylene ([6]CMP) units. However, replacing one or more [6]CMP units with a coronene moiety enables electron transfer from pNT to C70 . The generation of the charge separated states from the lowest locally excited states occurs on a sub-nanosecond time scale. Depending on the number of the [6]CMP units, the charge recombination rate varies from 1.8 ⋅ 107 to 3.1 ⋅ 102  s-1 , i. e., five orders of magnitude.

Fast non-iterative calculation of solvation energies for water and non-aqueous solvents.

We propose an efficient and accurate non-iterative method, dubbed uESE, for calculating solvation free energies. Apart from a COSMO-like electrostatic term, the model takes into account non-electrostatic contributions, which depend on atomic surfaces, induced surface charge densities, and the molecular volume. uESE is tested on 35 polar and 57 non-polar solvents. The calculated and experimental solvation free energies are compared for 2892 systems. The method exhibits an excellent performance, which is superior to major solvation methods. The mean absolute error of predicted solvation energies is found below 1 kcal/mol for neutral solutes and below 3 kcal/mol for ions. The calculated data are almost independent of the quantum-chemical method or/and basis sets employed.

Evaluation of charge-transfer rates in fullerene-based donor-acceptor dyads with different density functional approximations.

The shift towards renewable energy is one of the main challenges of this generation. Dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs), based on donor-acceptor architectures, can help in this transition as they present excellent photovoltaic efficiencies yet cheap and simple manufacturing. For molecular heterojunction DSSCs, donor-acceptor pairs are linked in a covalent manner, which facilitates their tailoring and rational design. Nevertheless, reliable computational characterization of charge transfer rate constants (kCT) is needed to speed this development process up. In this context, the performance of time-dependent density functional theory for the calculation of kCT values in donor-acceptor fullerene-based dyads has not been benchmarked yet. Herein, we present a detailed analysis on the performance of seven well-known density functional approximations (DFAs) for this type of system, focusing on several parameters such as the reorganization energies (λ), electronic couplings (VDA), and Gibbs energies (ΔG0CT), as well as the final rate constants. The amount of exact exchange at short range (SR) and long range (LR) electron-electron distances (and the transition from the SR to LR) turned out to be key for the success of the prediction. The tuning of these parameters improves significantly the performance of current DFAs.

[10]CPP-Based Inclusion Complexes of Charged Fulleropyrrolidines. Effect of the Charge Location on the Photoinduced Electron Transfer.

A number of non-covalently bound donor-acceptor dyads, consisting of C60 as the electron acceptor and cycloparaphenylene (CPP) as the electron donor, have been reported. A hypsochromic shift of the charge transfer (CT) band in polar medium has been found in [10]CPP⊃Li+ @C60 . To explore this anomalous effect, we study inclusion complexes [10]CPP⊃Li+ @C60 -MP, [10]CPP⊃C60 -MPH+ , and [10]CPP⊃C60 -PPyMe+ formed by fulleropyrrolidine derivatives and [10]CPP using the DFT/TDDFT approach. We show that the introduction of a positively charged fragment into fullerene stabilizes CT states that become the lowest-lying excited states. These charge-separated states can be generated by the decay of locally excited states on a nanosecond to picosecond time scale. The distance of the charged fragment to the center of the fullerenic cage and its accessibility to the solvent determine the strength of the hypsochromic shift.

Photoinduced electron transfer in nanotube⊃C70 inclusion complexes: phenine vs. nanographene nanotubes.

In this work, we computationally study the photoinduced electron transfer in fullerene inclusion complexes of two phenine nanotubes pre-pNT⊃C70 and pNT⊃C70 and their nanographene analog [4]CHBC⊃C70. Charge separation is shown to efficiently occur in [4]CHBC⊃C70. In contrast, the electron transfer process between the host and guest units in the pre-pNT⊃C70 and pNT⊃C70 complexes is blocked by the structural changes incorporated in the nanographene framework.

Covalent Functionalization of Single-Walled Carbon Nanotubes by the Bingel Reaction for Building Charge-Transfer Complexes.

Functionalization of nanotubes with donor and acceptor partners by the Bingel reaction leads to the formation of charge-transfer dyads, which can operate in organic photovoltaic devices. In this work, we theoretically examine the mechanism of the Bingel reaction for the (6,5)-chiral, (5,5)-armchair, and (9,0)-zigzag single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs), and demonstrate that the reaction is regioselective and takes place at the perpendicular position of (6,5)- and (5,5)-SWCNTs, and the oblique position of (9,0)-SWCNT. Further, we design computationally the donor-acceptor complexes based on (6,5)-SWCNT coupled with partners of different electronic nature. Analysis of their excited states reveals that efficient photoinduced charge transfer can be achieved in the complexes with π-extended analogue of tetrathiafulvalene (exTTF), zinc tetraphenylporphyrin (ZnTPP), and tetracyanoanthraquinodimethane (TCAQ). The solvent can significantly affect the population of the charge-separated states. Our calculations show that electron transfer (ET) occurs in the normal Marcus regime on a sub-nanosecond time scale in the complexes with exTTF and ZnTPP, and in the inverted Marcus regime on a picosecond time scale in the case of the TCAQ derivative. The ET rate is found to be not very sensitive to the degree of functionalization of the nanotube.

Fast and accurate calculation of hydration energies of molecules and ions.

We present an efficient method with adjustable parameters for calculating the hydration free energy of molecules and ions using the gas-phase geometry and atomic charges. In most cases, the method yields accurate results, with a mean absolute error for neutral molecules below 1 kcal mol-1 and for ions about 3 kcal mol-1. Overall, despite its simplicity, the proposed method shows the best performance among major computational approaches applied to estimate hydration free energies. The method requires as input Cartesian cordinates and CM5 atomic charges only, which are easily available from any DFT calculation, and yields the hydration energy in a matter of seconds for a medium-size molecule or ion.

Triquinoline- versus Fullerene-Based Cycloparaphenylene Ionic Complexes: Comparison of Photoinduced Charge-Shift Reactions.

A triquinoline cationic moiety (TQ⋅H+ ) has recently been designed as a novel molecular unit for supramolecular chemistry. In addition to some useful features, TQ⋅H+ has strong electron-acceptor properties, which renders the molecular cation a unique element in nanochemistry. TQ⋅H+ is found to form complexes with coronene (COR) and cycloparaphenylene (CPP). In this work, we report a computational study of photoinduced electron transfer in supramolecular complexes TQ⋅H+ -COR, TQ⋅H+ ⊂[12]CPP and (TQ⋅H+ -COR)⊂[12]CPP. The electron-transfer rates are estimated by using the semi-classical approach. The results are compared with the data previously obtained for a structurally similar inclusion complex Li+ @C60 ⊂[10]CPP. In particular, we found a red solvatochromic shift for charge-shift bands in the TQ⋅H+ -complexes unlike a blueshift showed by Li+ @C60 ⊂[10]CPP. This distinction is explored in terms of electronic and structural features of the systems.

Correction: Cyclo[18]carbon: the smallest all-carbon electron acceptor.

Correction for 'Cyclo[18]carbon: the smallest all-carbon electron acceptor' by Anton J. Stasyuk et al., Chem. Commun., 2020, 56, 352-355.

Cyclo[18]carbon: the smallest all-carbon electron acceptor.

The recently synthesized C18 molecule demonstrates strong electron acceptor properties similar to C60. In this work, we study computationally the ground and excited state properties of C18 and its complexes with several electron-donating molecules. We demonstrate that a high amount of the exact (HF) exchange in the DFT functional leads to a polyynic structure of C18, in agreement with the experiment. We show that in complexes of C18 with electron donors, the lowest excited states are charge separated states formed by electron transfer to C18. This makes C18 the smallest all-carbon electron acceptor reported so far. Because C18 exhibits a larger internal reorganization energy compared to fullerene C60, the electron transfer reactions with relatively high driving force will be shifted from the inverted to the normal Marcus regime when replacing C60 by C18.

Unusual Through-Space Interactions between Oxygen Atoms that Mediate Inverse Morphochromism of an AIE Luminogen.

We have studied the photophysics of tetrafurylethene, an aggregation-induced emission luminogen with exceptionally short intramolecular O-O distances of 2.80 Šand a significant red-shifted morphochromism (27 nm) when going from the aggregate to the crystal. The short O-O distances, which are substantially smaller than the sum of the van der Waals radii (3.04 Å), are due to the fact that the oxygen atoms act as an electronic bridge connecting the furan rings on opposite ends of the central double bond, giving rise to a circular delocalization of the π-electron density across the rings. In the excited state the O-O distance is further reduced to 2.70 Å; the increased O-O interaction causes a narrowing of the HOMO-LUMO gap, resulting in the red morphochromism of the emission. Our results show the structural origin of the red-shifted emission lies in close O-O contacts, paving the way for understanding the clusteroluminescence of oxygen-rich non-conjugated systems that emit visible light.

Hypsochromic solvent shift of the charge separation band in ionic donor-acceptor Li+@C60⊂[10]CPP.

In this work, we study computationally, using the DFT/TDDFT approach, the photoinduced electron transfer (PET) in CPP-based donor-acceptor supramolecules C60⊂[10]CPP and Li+@C60⊂[10]CPP. Based on the analysis of the excited states we find a system, Li+@C60⊂[10]CPP, which shows anomalous solvent effects, i.e., destabilization of charge separated states by polar medium.