Effect of dentine conditioners on the bonding efficacy of one-bottle adhesives.

The bonding efficacy of four one-bottle adhesives (OptiBond Solo Plus, Gluma Comfort Bond, One Step and Prime & Bond NT) and a multi-step adhesive (Clearfil Photo Bond) as a control was evaluated. The dentine cavity wall was conditioned with phosphoric acid or ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) and the marginal integrity was estimated by measuring the wall-to-wall contraction gap width between the composite and the dentine cavity surface. In the positive control group, the adhesive was applied following glyceryl methacrylate (GM) priming. The analyses were performed by Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney U-tests. One-bottle adhesives were clearly inferior to the multi-step bonding system in marginal integrity when dentine was conditioned with EDTA. The present findings also suggested that the marginal sealing ability of ethanol-based one-bottle systems was better than acetone-based one-bottle systems when dentine surfaces were conditioned with EDTA. Nevertheless, further investigations are needed on the function of fillers in one-bottle adhesives for the prevention of contraction gaps.

Depth of cure and marginal adaptation to dentin of xenon lamp polymerized resin composites.

Marginal adaptation of four resin composites (Clearfil APX, Estelite, Silux Plus and Z-100) cured with two xenon lamp units (Plasma Arc Curing System or Apollo 95E) or a halogen lamp unit (Witelite) were evaluated by measuring the wall-to-wall contraction gap width. A cylindrical dentin cavity (ø3 mm x 1.5 mm) prepared in an extracted human molar was treated with the Megabond system or an experimental bonding system consisting of 0.5 M EDTA, 35% GM and Clearfil Photo Bond prior to composite filling and was irradiated for three seconds (xenon lamp) or 40 seconds (halogen lamp). The contraction gap was measured with a light microscope. In addition, the curing capability of these three light sources was evaluated by measuring the curing depth of the composites filled in a split Teflon mold (ø4 mm x 8 mm). There was no marginal gap formation for Clearfil APX, Estelite and Silux Plus treated with the experimental bonding system regardless of the type of light sources. The curing depth of the xenon lamp was significantly higher than the halogen lamp, while marginal adaptation did not suffer any significant deterioration.

Effects of soft-start irradiation on the depth of cure and marginal adaptation to dentin.

Marginal adaptation of four resin composites, Clearfil APX, Estelite, Silux Plus and Z-100 cured with two irradiation methods (soft-start or high-power start) of a commercial soft-start halogen lamp unit (Elipar Highlight) were evaluated by measurement of the wall-to-wall contraction gap width. One-hundred and sixty cylindrical cavities, 3 mm in diameter and 1.5 mm in depth, were prepared in extracted human molars. The 80 cavity walls were treated with the Megabond system and each 20 cavities were filled with one of four resin composites. Then, each 10 fillings were irradiated by the soft-start method (soft-power light for 10 seconds followed by high-power light for 30 seconds) or high-power light for 40 seconds. The other 80 cavity walls were treated with an experimental bonding system consisting of 0.5M EDTA as a conditioner, 35% glyceryl mono-methacrylate as a primer and Clearfil Photo Bond as a bonding agent. The cavities were restored wtih the four resin composites and two irradiation methods, the same as the Megabond group. The contraction gap was measured with a light microscope and expressed in % of the cavity diameter. In addition, the curing capability of these two light sources was evaluated by measurement of the curing depth of the four resin composites using a split Teflon mold 4 mm in inner-diameter and 8 mm in height. Marginal gap formation of Clearfil APX, Estelite and Silux Plus with the experimental bonding system was completely prevented regardless of the kind of irradiation methods used. The deterioration of marginal adaptation caused by the Megabond system could not be improved by use of the soft-start method programmed in Elipar Highlight.

Adverse effect of dentine bonding agent on the oral mucosa of guinea pigs.

The purpose of present study was to determine the possibility of nebulous discoloration of the oral mucosa of guinea pigs as a result of the application of dentine bonding agents. The materials used were the Clearfil Photo Bond (CPB) system's mixture agent, universal agent and catalyst agent. Four types of experimental catalysts were used. In male albino guinea pigs weighing 300-500 g, oral mucosa irritation tests were performed in accordance with the guidelines of the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Fragrance Association (CTFA). Macroscopical findings on the oral mucosa showed that there was strong nebulous discoloration immediately after application of CPB mix and CPB catalyst and throughout the experimental periods. However, CPB without 10-methacryloxdecyl dihydrogen phosphate (MDP) did not produce noticeable nebulous discoloration and inflammation. The CPB mix caused pathological changes, such as paraketosis and hyperkeratosis on the endepidermis of the mucosa, immediately after its application.

Efficacy of dentin bonding to cervical defects.

The bonding efficacy of sclerotic dentin was determined by measuring the polymerization contraction gap width of a commercial light-activated resin composite in a cervical defect and by measuring the micro-Vicker's hardness at the dentin adhesive surface; morphological characteristics were observed using a scanning electron microscope in extracted human incisors and premolars. Contraction gap formation was completely prevented when the cavity wall was primed with 35 vol% glyceryl mono-methacrylate solution after 0.5 mol/L EDTA conditioning. The contraction gap width was significantly decreased when the resin composite was filled into the sclerotic dentin cavity even when priming was omitted. These results suggest that the sclerotic dentin, which is frequently observed in cervical defects, should be preserved as a substrate because it exhibits an effect of dentin priming and is suitable for bonding.

Effect of mechanical properties of resin composites on the efficacy of the dentin bonding system.

This study determined the relationship between marginal adaptation to dentin cavity preparations, tensile bond strength of the restorations, and mechanical properties of the composites. Contraction gaps, tensile bond strengths, flexural strengths, and Young's modulus of eight commercial resin composites were determined. Eight resin composites (Clearfil AP-X, Estelite, Estio LC, Litefil II-A, Prodigy, Progress, Silux Plus, and Z-100) were applied to dentin cavities or flat dentin surfaces mediated with an experimental dentin bonding system consisting of 0.5 M EDTA dentin conditioner, priming with 35% glyceryl mono-methacrylate solution, and a commercial dentin bonding agent application (Clearfil Photo Bond). The contraction gap of the resin composite in a cylindrical dentin cavity was prevented completely for three of the resin composites tested (Clearfil AP-X, Estelite, and Silux Plus). The measured tensile bond strength correlated significantly not only with the tensile strength (r2 = 0.506; 0.01 < P < 0.05), but also with the flexural strength (r2 = 0.871; P < 0.001) and Young's modulus (r2 = 0.712; 0.001 < P < 0.01) of the composites, whereas the contraction gap did not correlate significantly with the measured tensile bond strength, the tensile strength, the flexural strength, or Young's modulus (P > 0.05). However, the results did indicate that the higher tensile bond strengths measured in the traditional test may be related to the higher mechanical properties of the resin composites because of the number of specimens that exhibited cohesive failure.

Effect of cavosurface angle on dentin cavity adaptation of resin composites.

The effect of the cavosurface angle of dentin cavities prepared in extracted human molars on the cavity adaptation of a resin composite was evaluated by measuring the gap width between the resin composite and the dentin cavity wall. Cavities with cavosurface angles of 90 degrees, 120 degrees, 135 degrees, or 150 degrees were pretreated with one of two commercial dentin bonding systems or an experimental dentin bonding system. The contraction gap width was measured at both the cavity margin and the section cavity using a light microscope. Complete cavity adaptation was obtained with pretreatment of the experimental groups regardless of the cavosurface angle. The contraction gap observed at the cavity margin was prevented with the two commercial dentin bonding systems when the cavosurface angle was increased to 150 degrees. A high correlation was observed between the contraction gap width and the proportion of the free surface to the adhesive surface of the resin composite restoration.

Effect of functional monomer in commercial dentin bonding agents use of an experimental dentin bonding system.

The objective of the present study was to understand the role of the functional monomers in dentin bonding agents of an experimental dentin bonding system by measuring the wall-to-wall contraction gap and tensile bond strength measurement. The efficacy of three commercial dentin bonding agents after using EDTA for conditioning and GM for priming was evaluated by measuring the contraction gap of the resin composite in a cylindrical dentin cavity, and by measuring the tensile bond strength of the composite to a flat dentin surface. The effect of the functional monomers was demonstrated by the contraction gap measurement alone. The value of the contraction gap was significantly different between the commercial dentin bonding agents and these agents without functional monomers (p < 0.05). It was concluded that the functional monomers were essential to obtaining the marginal integrity of the resin composite in the dentin cavities.

Effectiveness of simplified dentin bonding systems.

The effectiveness of newly developed commercial dentin bonding systems (SB, MB II and KB) was evaluated by measuring the contraction gap width of a resin composite restored into a cylindrical dentin cavity prepared in an extracted human molar and by measuring the tensile bond strength to the flat dentin surface. In addition, calcium loss during dentin conditioning was analyzed using electron microanalyses. An experimental dentin bonding system composed of EDTA conditioning, GM solution priming and a bonding agent containing 10-MDP was employed as a control in which it was presumed that contraction gap formation was prevented completely. However, gap formation was observed using the three commercial simplified dentin bonding systems. SEM observation showed that the gap was formed between the resin composite and the top surface of the dentin cavity wall indicating that the fracture occurred at the adhesive interface, but never inside the dentin nor inside the resin composite.

Effect of 10% phosphoric acid conditioning on the efficacy of a dentin bonding system.

The efficacy of a commercial total-etch wet-bonding dentin bonding system and the effect of conditioning using 10% phosphoric acid both on the Ca-content in the substrate dentin and on the efficacy of the experimental contraction gap-free dentin bonding system were evaluated by measuring the wall-to-wall polymerization contraction gap width of a commercial light-activated resin composite filled into a cylindrical cavity prepared in extracted human dentin. The Ca-content in the dentin was measured with an EDS. Complete marginal adaptation was obtained only in the experimental contraction gap-free dentin bonding system group. The Ca-content in the dentin was rapidly reduced by the 10% phosphoric acid conditioning. It was concluded that the dentist should not decalcify the dentin cavity wall possibly by using a dentin conditioner such as 10% phosphoric acid because the resin composite paste is apt to separate easily from the decalcified dentin cavity wall during polymerization.

2-HEMA-free dentin bonding system to prevent contraction gap.

The effects of 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (2-HEMA) both in the primer and in the commercial dentin bonding agent on the efficacy of the dentin bonding system was evaluated by measuring the polymerization contraction gap width of a commercial resin composite restored in a cylindrical dentin cavity prepared in an extracted human molar. Contraction gap formation was prevented in the group of the EDTA-conditioning followed by glyceryl mono-methacrylate, ethylene glycol and 1,6-hexanediol priming regardless of the 2-HEMA content in the dentin bonding agent containing 10-methacryloxydecyl dihydrogen phosphate. However, gap formation could not be prevented completely by the 2-HEMA priming. Therefore, it was possible to conclude that 2-HEMA was neither essential in the primer nor in the dentin bonding agent because of its low bonding efficacy and the resulting side effects on skin tissue as a delayed allergic reaction.

The adverse effect of commercial dentine-bonding systems on the skin of guinea pigs.

It was widely known that 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (2-HEMA) can cause contact dermatitis. Commercially available dentine primers and dentine bonding agents that contain 2-HEMA are widely used. The purpose of this study was to investigate the cumulative irritation and delayed hypersensitivity caused by commercial dentine bonding systems when applied to the skin of guinea pigs. We have concluded that almost no dentine bonding systems cause cumulative irritation, but some commercially available dentine bonding systems may produce delayed hypersensitivity.

Bonding efficacy and interfacial microstructure between resin and dentine primed with glyceryl methacrylate.

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the effect of two experimental primers based on glyceryl methacrylate (GM, 2,3-dihydroxypropyl methacrylate) and 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (2-HEMA) on the marginal adaptation of light-cured composite placed into cylindrical dentine cavities and to study the interfacial microstructure. METHODS: The bonding efficacy of two experimental dentine primers combined with a dentine cleanser composed of either 0.5 mol l-1 EDTA neutralized to pH 7.4 by sodium hydroxide or 10% citric acid containing 3% ferric chloride (10-3 solution), and a commercial dentine bonding agent containing phosphate ester, were examined by measuring the wall-to-wall polymerization contraction gap of a commercial light-activated resin composite placed into cylindrical dentine cavities. The adhesive interface between the dentine and the dentine adhesive was observed using a transmission electron microscope (TEM). RESULTS: The formation of a contraction gap was completely prevented by priming with GM, regardless of the dentine cleanser used. However, in groups primed with 2-HEMA, gap formation was observed in three and four specimens out of 10 in the groups that were cleaned with the EDTA and 10-3 solution, respectively. In samples primed with GM, a high-density layer was observed by TEM at the superficial dentine in the hybrid layer, which may have indicated a high monomer content, whereas no density variations were observed in the hybrid layer in samples primed with 2-HEMA.

Cavity adaptation of resin composite in canine cavity in vivo.

The efficacy of four commercial and two experimental dentin bonding systems was examined by observing the cavity adaptation of commercial light-cured resin composites restored in the dogs scheduled to be sacrificed after a medical experiment. Before being sacrificed, a cylindrical class V cavity was prepared in each canine, and the cavity wall was treated with one of four commercial dentin bonding systems according to the manufacturers instructions followed by resin composite filling. The maximum contraction gap widths at the occlusal, gingival and axial cavity wall were measured on the cavity section 30 min after the polymerization of the resin composite under a light microscope. Contraction gap formation was completely prevented in only one of the experimental groups in which the cavity wall was primed with 35 vol% glyceryl mono-methacrylate (GM). In addition, observation of cavity adaptation in the canine in vivo was useful to estimate consistently the efficacy of the bonding systems.

Marginal adaptation of commercial compomers in dentin cavity.

The dentin cavity adaptation and setting characteristics of four commercial compomers were evaluated by measuring the wall-to-wall contraction gap width in the cylindrical dentin cavity and measuring the compressive strength for a maximum of 14 days after setting. The dentin cavity wall was pretreated by the dentin adhesives according to each manufacturer's instructions or the experimental contraction gap-free dentin bonding system. Complete marginal integrity was obtained in only one compomer and two resin composites which were combined with the experimental dentin bonding system. The compressive strength of two resin composites and two compomers ten minutes after setting was comparable to that after 14 days which indicated that the compomers exhibited setting characteristics as rapidly as the resin composite. It was concluded that a high efficacy dentin bonding system is required for commercial compomers to prevent gap formation during irradiation caused by the rapid setting shrinkage.

Effects of polyvalent alcohol solutions as dentine primers.

OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to examine the bonding effect of polyvalent alcohols as dentine primers without a methacrylate group, which may cause contact dermatitis. METHODS: The efficacy of polyvalent alcohols as dentine primers was estimated by measuring the wall-to-wall polymerization contraction gap width of a light-activated resin composite filled in a cylindrical dentine cavity in an extracted human tooth. A dentine cavity was cleaned with ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) and primed with an aqueous solution of either ethylene glycol, glycerol, erythritol, xylitol or sorbitol at concentrations of between 25 and 75 wt%. A light-cured resin composite was filled after the application of a commercial dual-cured bonding agent. RESULTS: Contraction gap formation was completely prevented only in the group in which the dentine cavity had been primed with an aqueous solution of 62.5% wt% ethylene glycol. Furthermore, in the measurement of a tensile bond strength to a flat dentine surface, high tensile bond strength (17.5 +/- 4.4 MPa) was observed in the group that was primed with 62.5% ethylene glycol solution. CONCLUSION: These results suggest that it is not necessary to dissolve methacrylates in a dentine primer when the primer is dried with a blast of compressed air before application of a polymerizable, suitable bonding agent. It is concluded that a dentine primer composed of polyvalent alcohol solutions without a methacrylate group which may cause contact dermatitis, is effective as a dentine primer, affects the dentine surface, and promotes the efficacy of the dentine bonding system.

Marginal adaptation of dental composites containing prepolymerized filler.

Marginal adaptation to cylindrical dentin preparations of five commercially available dental composites--Charisma, Estelite, Herculite, Pertac, and Silux Plus--and seven experimental dental composites containing prepolymerized filler was evaluated by measurement of the wall-to-wall polymerization contraction gaps. The experimental composites were prepared with varying amounts of spherical inorganic filler particles, irregularly shaped prepolymerized filler particles, and a base resin matrix composed of BIS-GMA and TEGDMA. Cylindrical dentin preparations, approximately 3.0 mm in diameter and 1.5 mm deep, were prepared in the exposed approximal dentin surfaces of extracted human molars. These cavity preparations were pretreated with an experimental dentin bonding system consisting of 0.5 mol/L EDTA, 35% glyceryl methacrylate, and Clearfil Photo Bond, then restored with each composite. Complete marginal adaptation was observed in two composites (Silux Plux and Estelite). Wall-to-wall contraction gaps were significantly related to the amount of ashed inorganic component in the composites (0.01 < P < 0.05) and to the spherical inorganic filler content by volume (P < 0.01).

Evaluation of skin irritation and sensitization of two diol solutions used as experimental dentin primers in humans and guinea pigs.

The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the safety of ethylene glyco (EG) and 1,6-hexanediol (HD) solutions as experimental dentin primers when subjected to the guinea pig maximization test (GPMT), primary irritation test, cumulative skin irritation test and human patch test. No primary and cumulative skin irritation resulting from the use of 62.5% EG or 45% HD solutions was observed. In the case of GPMT, the animals sensitized with 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (2-HEMA) responded to 100% HD. 62.5% EG and 45% HD as dentin primers were safer than 2-HEMA such as a methacrylic primer.

Contact dermatitis caused by 2-HEMA and GM dentin primer solutions applied to guinea pigs and humans.

The purposes of this study were to examine whether 2-HEMA, GM, and methacrylic acid cause contact dermatitis, and to determine the optimum concentrations of these primers for sensitization and challenge in guinea pigs. A sensitizing concentration of 0.2% 2-HEMA resulted in strong rubefaction and several vesiculopapules in response to the challenge, and a sensitizing concentration of 0.5% GM produced strong rubefaction at 24 hours. We also observed the development of contact dermatitis on human brachia in a closed-patch test. Skin that was treated with both 2-HEMA and GM clearly showed the onset of rubefaction and itchiness. 2-HEMA caused sensitized delayed allergic reactions at all the concentrations tested.

Contact angle of dentin bonding agents on the dentin surface.

Physical changes in the surface characteristics of dentin during bonding procedures were evaluated by measuring the contact angles of three standard liquids, to determine the surface free energy, and that of a commercially available dual cured dentin bonding agent dropped on the primed dentin surface. The commercial dentin bonding agent did not form a hemispherical shape on the ground dentin surface, probably because it penetrated into the smear layer due to the microcapillary effect. Not could the contact angle be measured on the dentin surfaces treated with any of four experimental primers, because the bonding agent rapidly spread over the primed dentin surface. It was concluded that the priming of the dentin surface after removing the smear layer served to increase the surface free energy and to improve the wettability of the bonding agent on the dentin.