Transcriptomic analysis of the innate immune response to in vitro transfection of plasmid DNA.

The innate immune response to cytosolic DNA is intended to protect the host from viral infections, but it can also inhibit the delivery and expression of therapeutic transgenes in gene and cell therapies. The goal of this work was to use mRNA sequencing to identify genes that may influence transfection efficiency in four different cell types (PC-3, Jurkat, HEK-293T, and primary T cells). The highest transfection efficiency was observed in HEK-293T cells, which upregulated only 142 genes with no known antiviral functions after transfection with lipofectamine. Lipofection upregulated 1,057 cytokine-stimulated genes (CSGs) in PC-3 cells, which exhibited a significantly lower transfection efficiency. However, when PC-3 cells were transfected in serum-containing media or electroporated, the observed transfection efficiencies were significantly higher while the expression levels of cytokines and CSGs decreased. In contrast, lipofection of Jurkat and primary T cells only upregulated a few genes, but several of the antiviral CSGs that were absent in HEK-293T cells and upregulated in PC-3 cells were observed to be constitutively expressed in T cells, which may explain the relatively low Lipofection efficiencies observed with T cells (8%-21% GFP+). Indeed, overexpression of one CSG (IFI16) significantly decreased transfection efficiency in HEK-293T cells.

Enhancement of transgene expression by the ß-catenin inhibitor iCRT14.

The innate immune response is an essential defense mechanism that allows cells to detect pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) like endotoxin or cytosolic DNA and then induce the expression of defensive genes that restrict the replication of viruses and other pathogens. However, the therapeutic DNA used in some gene therapy treatments can also trigger the innate immune response, which activates host cell genes that may inhibit transgene expression. The goal of this study was to enhance transgene expression by inhibiting key components of the innate immune response with small molecule inhibitors (iCRT14, curcumin, Amlexanox, H-151, SC-514, & VX-702). Most of the inhibitors significantly increased transgene (luciferase) expression at least 2-fold, but the ß-catenin/TCF4 inhibitor iCRT14 showed the highest enhancement (16 to 35-fold) in multiple cell lines (PC-3, MCF7, & MB49) without significantly decreasing cellular proliferation. Alternatively, cloning a ß-catenin/TCF4 binding motif (TCAAAG) into the EF1α promoter also enhanced transgene expression up to 8-fold. To further investigate the role of ß-catenin/TCF4 in transgene expression, mRNA-sequencing experiments were conducted to identify host cell genes that were upregulated following transfection with PEI but down-regulated after the addition of iCRT14. As expected, transfection with plasmid DNA activated the innate immune response and upregulated hundreds (687) of defensive genes, but only 7 of those genes were down-regulated in the presence of iCRT14 (e.g., PTGS2 & PLA1A). Altogether, these results show that transgene expression can be enhanced by inhibiting the innate immune response with SMIs like iCRT14, which inhibits ß-catenin/TCF4 to prevent the expression of specific host cell genes.

Nonviral gene delivery to T cells with Lipofectamine LTX.

Retroviral gene delivery is widely used in T cell therapies for hematological cancers. However, viral vectors are expensive to manufacture, integrate genes in semirandom patterns, and their transduction efficiency varies between patients. In this study, several nonviral gene delivery vehicles, promoters, and additional variables were compared to optimize nonviral transgene delivery and expression in both Jurkat and primary T cells. Transfection of Jurkat cells was maximized to a high efficiency (63.0% ± 10.9% EGFP+  cells) by transfecting cells with Lipofectamine LTX in X-VIVO 15 media. However, the same method yielded a much lower transfection efficiency in primary T cells (8.1% ± 0.8% EGFP+ ). Subsequent confocal microscopy revealed that a majority of the lipoplexes did not enter the primary T cells, which might be due to relatively low expression levels of heparan sulfate proteoglycans detected via messenger RNA-sequencing. Pyrin and HIN (PYHIN) DNA sensors (e.g., AIM2 and IFI16) that can induce apoptosis or repress transcription after binding cytoplasmic DNA were also detected at high levels in primary T cells. Therefore, transfection of primary T cells appears to be limited at the level of cellular uptake or DNA sensing in the cytoplasm. Both of these factors should be considered in the development of future viral and nonviral T cell gene delivery methods.