A mechanical study of six digital pulley reconstruction techniques: Part I. Mechanical effectiveness.

A laboratory study on fresh-frozen human cadaver limbs compared six types of flexor tendon pulley reconstruction in the fingers. The reconstructions used were those described by (1) Bunnell, (2) Karev, (3) Weilby, and (4) Lister, and two types developed by us that have not been previously described. The pulleys were studied in specific configurations to determine their effectiveness in transforming tendon excursion into finger flexion. In each finger, comparison was made between the amount of tendon excursion required for full flexion with an intact pulley system versus the various types of reconstructed pulleys. The ratio of these two values was defined as the mechanical effectiveness of the pulley reconstruction. The Karve reconstruction was most effective at 108.2%, which was significantly different from the other five reconstructions (p less than 0.01). The remaining reconstructions ranged in effectiveness from 80.0% to 88.5%.

A mechanical study of six digital pulley reconstruction techniques: Part II. Strength of individual reconstructions.

A laboratory study was done on fresh-frozen human cadaver limbs, using six types of pulley reconstructions about the flexor tendons of the fingers. The reconstructions used were those described by (1) Bunnell, (2) Karev, (3) Weilby, and (4) Lister, and two types developed by us that have not been previously described. The pulleys were tested at constant strain rate to failure with the peak force recorded as the breaking strength. A total of 385 reconstructed pulleys were tested and the results were analyzed statistically. A new "loop and one half" pulley reconstruction was significantly stronger than the other five reconstructions (p less than 0.01) with an average load to failure of 22.5 kilograms-force. The other pulley reconstructions varied in average breaking strength from 2.8 kilograms-force to 18.4 kilograms-force.