Antiepileptic drug-related cognitive complaints in seizure-free children with epilepsy before and after drug discontinuation.

The cognitive complaints reported by children and their parents, as subjectively associated with antiepileptic drug (AED) treatment, were evaluated in seizure-free children before and after drug discontinuation. The aim of the design was to isolate the cognitive side effects of AEDs from other factors, such as the effect of seizures. Our inventory explored the following areas: "alertness," "concentration," "activation/ tiredness," "memory," "drowsiness," "depression," "aggressiveness," and "hyperactivity," using a 5-point Likert scaling procedure. One hundred two eligible patients were selected, each matched with a healthy control and assessed when still on antiepileptic medication. All children were seizure free for at least 1 year. The medication was then discontinued gradually over a 3-month period. Four months after the children were completely medication free, a second assessment was carried out, but only in the 83 children who remained seizure free and in their matched controls. The results of the reports made by the children themselves did not show differences with the matched controls, and only showed improvement after drug discontinuation for complaints about "tiredness." Parents of the children with epilepsy reported significant improvement in all areas related to "alertness and activation" after discontinuation of the drugs. The finding that only a limited number of children have cognitive complaints, both when still on AEDs and after discontinuation, may be in line with the reports that the major factor contributing to quality of life is whether patients are seizure free or still have seizures. All patients in this study were seizure free for a period >1 year, which may have caused the favorable pattern of response in our patient group.

Withdrawal of antiepileptic medication in children. Correlation of cognitive function and plasma concentration--the multicentre 'Holmfrid' study.

Eighty-three patients with epilepsy and 83 matched controls completed 12 computerized cognitive tests while on antiepileptic drugs and six months later when they had been medication-free for three to four months. All patients had been seizure-free for more than one year and were on monotherapy with carbamazepine (CBZ, n = 56), valproate (VPA, n = 17), or phenytoin (PHT, n = 10). The tests and plasma concentration collection were done at noon. The mean peak plasma concentrations in the CBZ patients were as follows: 31% below 30 mumol/l, 48% between 30 and 42 mumol/l and 21% above 42 mumol/l. No difference in performance could be detected between the groups. One significant correlation between plasma concentration and test results was found. The mean VPA concentration was 625 mumol/l (S.D. 189). A tendency towards a weak negative correlation between test results and plasma concentration was present. The PHT patients' therapeutic range had a mean concentration of 32.0 mumol/l (S.D. 18.5). One significant correlation between a memory test and plasma concentration could be detected. Overall, the patients in the different antiepileptic groups performed less good than the control group and in a few cases the differences were statistically significant when compared either before or after withdrawal. A comparison of the changes after withdrawal showed improvement in the majority of tests, but these changes were also present in the matched control group.

Withdrawal of antiepileptic medication in children--effects on cognitive function: The Multicenter Holmfrid Study.

We present 100 children diagnosed with epilepsy who were seizure-free for more than 1 year and still on monotherapy of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs). We matched each child with a healthy classmate and performed neuropsychological testing and EEG before and after complete withdrawal of the AEDs. The withdrawal phase lasted 3 months, but the dose decrease was individualized for each patient. Three to 4 months after complete withdrawal of the drug all patients were reassessed. Patients with seizure relapse are excluded from the study. Seventeen patients are regarded as dropout, 11 because of seizure relapse and six because of protocol violation. The remaining 83 patients were treated with carbamazepine (n = 56), valproic acid (n = 17), or phenytoin (n = 10). Serum concentrations of the AEDs were measured using peak plasma levels that were taken immediately before or after psychological testing. We used neuropsychological tests to assess psychomotor function and "central" cognitive processing such as information processing or memory function. We found significant improvement attributable to drug withdrawal on only one of the cognitive tests, namely, psychomotor speed, suggesting that the impact of AED treatment on higher-order cognitive function is rather limited. In addition, we found group differences between the epilepsy group and the control group at baseline that persisted after drug withdrawal. Subsequent analysis showed some factors that may have contributed to these group differences. First, patients with a former diagnosis of absence seizures show lower scores both at baseline and after drug withdrawal. We may assume that the seizure propensity has not disappeared completely in these patients. Some evidence is found that phenytoin may have a different cognitive profile than carbamazepine, with more impairment on tests that measure motor and mental speed. Again, this impairment persists after drug withdrawal.