RESUMO
Data were collected prospectively on all 67 women who underwent an attempt at external cephalic version (ECV) over 1 year in the four Glasgow maternity hospitals. Ultrasonography was used in all women. However, tocolytics were used in only two (6%) nulliparous women despite published evidence of their efficacy. Only 25 (37%) women undergoing ECV had a free presenting part which is known to be associated with success. Seventeen (25%) women were less than 37 weeks pregnant despite spontaneous version being common at this stage. ECV was successful in only 26 (39%) women and only 18 (27%) had a vaginal cephalic delivery. These results compare unfavourably with published results of around two-thirds for both end-points. Although publication bias is likely, patient selection, under-usage of tocolytics and lack of experience may also be factors. Consideration should be given to a reduced number of operators who can maximise their throughput and expertise.
RESUMO
Breech presentation occurs in 3-5% of deliveries and can be managed by either a trial of vaginal breech delivery (TOVBD), external cephalic version (ECV) or Caesarean section. A postal questionnaire was completed by 82% of Scottish consultant obstetricians and revealed wide variations in practice. Eighteen percent never offered ECV. Among those who did consensus was lacking on some contraindications. One-quarter sometimes performed ECV before 37 weeks gestations despite the possibility of spontaneous version. Only 70% restricted ECV to one or more designated operators thereby maintaining levels of expertise. Variations were demonstrated in the use of tocolytics, and pre and post procedure investigations. Following failed ECV 28% considered a repeat attempt and 56% a TOVBD. TOVBD was not offered as first line management by one-fifth of respondents. Those who did varied in the pre-procedure investigations performed. Guidelines are required to ensure safe, consistent practice and avoid unnecessary Caesarean sections.
