Common and specific roles of the related CDK inhibitors p27 and p57 revealed by a knock-in mouse model.

Although p27 and p57 are structurally related cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors (CKIs), and are thought to perform similar functions, p27 knockout (p27(KO)) and p57(KO) mice show distinct phenotypes. To elucidate the in vivo functions of these CKIs, we have now generated a knock-in mouse model (p57(p27KI)), in which the p57 gene has been replaced with the p27 gene. The p57(p27KI) mice are viable and appear healthy, with most of the developmental defects characteristic of p57(KO) mice having been corrected by p27 knock-in. Such developmental defects of p57(KO) mice were also ameliorated in mice deficient in both p57 and the transcription factor E2F1, suggesting that loss of p57 promotes E2F1-dependent apoptosis. The developmental defects apparent in a few tissues of p57(KO) mice were unaffected or only partially corrected by knock-in expression of p27. Thus, these observations indicate that p57 and p27 share many characteristics in vivo, but that p57 also performs specific functions not amenable to substitution with p27.

Modeling cell cycle control and cancer with pRB tumor suppressor.

Cancer is a complex syndrome of diseases characterized by the increased abundance of cells that disrupts the normal tissue architecture within an organism. Defining one universal mechanism underlying cancer with the hope of designing a magic bullet against cancer is impossible, largely because there is so much variation between various types of cancer and different individuals. However, we have learned much in past decades about different journeys that a normal cell takes to become cancerous, and that the delicate balance between oncogenes and tumor suppressor is upset, favoring growth and survival of the tumor cell. One of the most important cellular barriers to cancer development is the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (pRB) pathway, which is inactivated in a wide range of human tumors and controls cell cycle progression via repression of the E2F/DP transcription factor family. Much of the clarity with which we view tumor suppression via pRB is due to our belief in the universality of the cell cycle and our attempts to model tumor pathways in vivo, nowhere so evident as in the multitude of data emerging from mutant mouse models that have been engineered to understand how cell cycle regulators limit growth in vivo and how deregulation of these regulators facilitates cancer development. In spite of this clarity, we have witnessed with incredulity several stunning results in the last 2 years that have challenged the very foundations of the cell cycle paradigm and made us question seriously how important these cell cycle regulators actually are.

Visualizing dynamic E2F-mediated repression in vivo.

Although many E2F target genes have been identified recently, very little is known about how any single E2F site controls the expression of an E2F target gene in vivo. To test the requirement for a single E2F site in vivo and to learn how E2F-mediated repression is regulated during development and tumorigenesis, we have constructed a novel series of wild-type and mutant Rb promoter-LacZ transgenic reporter lines that allow us to visualize the activity of a crucial E2F target in vivo, the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor gene (Rb). Two mutant Rb promoter-LacZ constructs were used to evaluate the importance of a single E2F site or a nearby activator (Sp1/Ets) site that is found mutated in low-penetrance retinoblastomas. The activity of the wild-type Rb promoter is dynamic, varying spatially and temporally within the developing nervous system. While loss of the activator site silences the Rb promoter, loss of the E2F site stimulates its activity in the neocortex, retina, and trigeminal ganglion. Surprisingly, E2F-mediated repression of Rb does not act globally or in a static manner but, instead, is a highly dynamic process in vivo. Using neocortical extracts, we detected GA-binding protein alpha (GABPalpha, an Ets family member) bound to the activator site and both E2F1 and E2F4 bound to the repressor site of the Rb promoter in vitro. Additionally, we detected binding of both E2F1 and E2F4 to the Rb promoter in vivo using chromatin immunoprecipitation analysis on embryonic day 13.5 brain. Unexpectedly, we detect no evidence for Rb promoter autoregulation in neuroendocrine tumors from Rb+/-; RbP-LacZ mice that undergo loss of heterozygosity at the Rb locus, in contrast to the situation in human retinoblastomas where high RB mRNA levels are found. In summary, this study provides the first demonstration that loss of an E2F site is critical for target gene repression in vivo and underscores the complexity of the Rb and E2F family network in vivo.

Cell cycle, proteolysis and cancer.

Research in the past 15 years has shown that the mammalian cell cycle is controlled by the action of cyclin-dependent kinases (CDKs). A crucial substrate of the CDKs in G1-phase is the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (pRB), which restrains proliferation largely by repressing the activity of the E2F transcription factors. More recent work has shown that the cell cycle is also a tale of two classes of ubiquitin ligases, referred to as SCF and APC/C ligases. CDKs, E2F and ubiquitin ligases reciprocally regulate each other, resulting in complex feedback loops. Perturbation of this network of molecular machines is associated with proliferative diseases, including cancer.

Role of F-box protein betaTrcp1 in mammary gland development and tumorigenesis.

The F-box protein betaTrcp1 controls the stability of several crucial regulators of proliferation and apoptosis, including certain inhibitors of the NF-kappaB family of transcription factors. Here we show that mammary glands of betaTrcp1(-/-) female mice display a hypoplastic phenotype, whereas no effects on cell proliferation are observed in other somatic cells. To investigate further the role of betaTrcp1 in mammary gland development, we generated transgenic mice expressing human betaTrcp1 targeted to epithelial cells under the control of the mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) long terminal repeat promoter. Compared to controls, MMTV betaTrcp1 mammary glands display an increase in lateral ductal branching and extensive arrays of alveolus-like protuberances. The mammary epithelia of MMTV betaTrcp1 mice proliferate more and show increased NF-kappaB DNA binding activity and higher levels of nuclear NF-kappaB p65/RelA. In addition, 38% of transgenic mice develop tumors, including mammary, ovarian, and uterine carcinomas. The targeting of betaTrcp1 to lymphoid organs produces no effects on these tissues. In summary, our results support the notion that betaTrcp1 positively controls the proliferation of breast epithelium and indicate that alteration of betaTrcp1 function and expression may contribute to malignant behavior of breast tumors, at least in part through NF-kappaB transactivation.

Dp1 is largely dispensable for embryonic development.

E2F/DP complexes activate or repress the transcription of E2F target genes, depending on the association of a pRB family member, thereby regulating cell cycle progression. Whereas the E2F family consists of seven members, the DP family contains only two (Dp1 and Dp2), Dp1 being the more highly expressed member. In contrast to the inactivation of individual E2F family members, we have recently demonstrated that loss of Dp1 results in embryonic lethality by embryonic day 12.5 (E12.5) due to the failure of extraembryonic lineages to develop and replicate DNA properly. To bypass this placental requirement and search for roles of Dp1 in the embryo proper, we generated Dp1-deficient embryonic stem (ES) cells that carry the ROSA26-LacZ marker and injected them into wild-type blastocysts to construct Dp1-deficient chimeras. Surprisingly, we recovered mid- to late gestational embryos (E12.5 to E17.5), in which the Dp1-deficient ES cells contributed strongly to most chimeric tissues as judged by X-Gal (5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-beta-D-galactopyranoside) staining and Western blotting. Importantly, the abundance of DP2 protein does not increase and the expression of an array of cell cycle genes is virtually unchanged in Dp1-deficient ES cells or chimeric E15.5 tissues with the absence of Dp1. Thus, Dp1 is largely dispensable for embryonic development, despite the absolute extraembryonic requirement for Dp1, which is highly reminiscent of the restricted roles for Rb and cyclins E1/E2 in vivo.

A dynamic switch in Rb+/- mediated neuroendocrine tumorigenesis.

Rb+/- mice develop a complex spectrum of neuroendocrine tumors on a mixed genetic (129Sv x C57BL/6) background. To understand how the 129Sv and C57BL/6 contributions affect Rb+/- tumorigenesis, we serially backcrossed Rb+/- animals to the 129Sv or C57BL/6 strain, and analysed their pathological profiles. Strikingly, the length of survival and the penetrance, severity and multiplicity of neuroendocrine tumors switch dramatically between Rb+/- animals from the two genetic backgrounds. In fact, the 129Sv background significantly enhances both the initiation and progression of tumorigenesis in the intermediate lobe of the pituitary (ILP) in Rb+/- animals. This is due to the surprising fact that ILPs from wild-type 129Sv animals are inherently abnormal, and thus greatly predisposed to neoplasia. This is likely to explain the high incidence of ILP tumors, an otherwise rare tumor type in wild-type mice, in numerous knockout studies performed on the 129Sv strain, and raises the intriguing possibility that the classic Rb+/- neuroendocrine tumors may fade away in another as of yet unidentified inbred strain. Finally, we have increased the utility of the Rb+/- tumor model, since Rb+/- animals on the C57BL/6 background develop high-penetrance tumors of the anterior lobe of the pituitary, a class of tumors estimated to occur in 20-25% of humans.

Control of meiotic and mitotic progression by the F box protein beta-Trcp1 in vivo.

SCF ubiquitin ligases, composed of three major subunits, Skp1, Cul1, and one of many F box proteins (Fbps), control the proteolysis of important cellular regulators. We have inactivated the gene encoding the Fbp beta-Trcp1 in mice. beta-Trcp1(-/-) males show reduced fertility correlating with an accumulation of methaphase I spermatocytes. beta-Trcp1(-/-) MEFs display a lengthened mitosis, centrosome overduplication, multipolar metaphase spindles, and misaligned chromosomes. Furthermore, cyclin A, cyclin B, and Emi1, an inhibitor of the anaphase promoting complex, are stabilized in mitotic beta-Trcp1(-/-) MEFs. Indeed, we demonstrate that Emi1 is a bona fide substrate of beta-Trcp1. In contrast, stabilization of beta-catenin and IkappaBalpha, two previously reported beta-Trcp1 substrates, does not occur in the absence of beta-Trcp1 and instead requires the additional silencing of beta-Trcp2 by siRNA. Thus, beta-Trcp1 regulates the timely order of meiotic and mitotic events.

Role of the RB tumor suppressor in cancer.

Apart from their coordinated inactivation by DNA tumor viral oncoproteins, the pRB and p53 tumor suppressor pathways were not known to be connected ten years ago. Within the last decade, our appreciation of how these pathways are interconnected has grown substantially. The checks and balances that exist between pRB and p53 involve the regulation of the G1/S transition and its checkpoints, and much of this is under the control of the E2F transcription factor family. Following DNA damage, the p53-dependent induction of p21CIP1 regulates cyclin E/Cdk2 and cyclin A/Cdk2 complexes both of which phosphorylate pRB, leading to E2F-mediated activation. Similarly, E2F1-dependent induction of p19ARF antagonizes the ability of mdm2 to degrade p53, leading to p53 stabilization and potentially p53-mediated apoptosis or cell cycle arrest. From the existing mouse models discussed above, we also know that proliferation, cell death and differentiation of distinct tissues are also intimately linked through entrance and exit from the cell cycle, and thus through pRB and p53 pathways. Virtually all human tumors deregulate either the pRB or p53 pathway, and often times both pathways simultaneously, which is critical for crippling cellular defense against neoplasia. The next decade of cancer research will likely see these two tumor suppressor pathways only merge even more.

Dp1 is required for extra-embryonic development.

Release of E2F1/DP1 heterodimers from repression mediated by the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor (pRB) triggers cell cycle entry into S phase, suggesting that E2F1 and DP1 proteins must act in unison, either to facilitate or to suppress cell-cycle progression. In stark contrast to the milder phenotypes that result from inactivation of E2Fs, we report that loss of Dp1 leads to death in utero because of the failure of extra-embryonic development. Loss of Dp1 compromises the trophectoderm-derived tissues - specifically, the expansion of the ectoplacental cone and chorion, and endoreduplication in trophoblast giant cells. Inactivation of p53 is unable to rescue the Dp1-deficient embryonic lethality. Thus, DP1 is absolutely required for extra-embryonic development and consequently embryonic survival, consistent with E2F/DP1 normally acting to promote growth in vivo.