Inflammatory and Neuropathic Pain From Bench to Bedside: What Went Wrong?

In recent years, the disappointing history of translation in pain research has undergone significant scrutiny. The escalation of knowledge and understanding related to presumed pain in neuropathic and inflammatory animal models contrasted with the unsatisfactory record of "bench-to-bedside" translation has raised many questions about the validity and clinical relevance of preclinical models and methods of behavioral assessment. Although many opinions have been expressed one of the overriding concerns and greatest barriers to the widening gap between preclinical research and the development of new interventions has been the underappreciated distinction between pain and nociception. As a result of these shortcomings, the distance between mechanism-based research and patient-centered product development has been referred to as the "valley of death." The reasons for the disappointing record of translation are many and easy to point out, but the changes needed and the strategies necessary to accomplish translational goals are much more difficult to identify. One of the challenges of translational pain research that has garnered a lot of attention relates to strategies of behavioral assessment which, with few exceptions, has remained basically unchanged for more than 3 decades. Other issues important to the discussion include but are not limited to the predictive validity of preclinical models, and the neglect of gender, age, and comorbidities in the design of preclinical studies. On the clinical side, the lack of sanitization of phenotypes in clinical trials has also contributed to the insufficient success of efforts to translate basic research to the clinic. The current review will discuss these and other issues believed to have contributed to the existing obstacles and challenges facing pain research along with making recommendations for the future. PERSPECTIVE: In this review the challenges of preclinical pain research and the reasons for the disappointing record of translation are examined. Important to this discussion is recognizing the scope of clinical characteristics associated with chronic pain conditions and the need for more clinically relevant models and methods of pain assessment.

Comparison of operant escape and reflex tests of nociceptive sensitivity.

Testing of reflexes such as flexion/withdrawal or licking/guarding is well established as the standard for evaluating nociceptive sensitivity and its modulation in preclinical investigations of laboratory animals. Concerns about this approach have been dismissed for practical reasons - reflex testing requires no training of the animals; it is simple to instrument; and responses are characterized by observers as latencies or thresholds for evocation. In order to evaluate this method, the present review summarizes a series of experiments in which reflex and operant escape responding are compared in normal animals and following surgical models of neuropathic pain or pharmacological intervention for pain. Particular attention is paid to relationships between reflex and escape responding and information on the pain sensitivity of normal human subjects or patients with pain. Numerous disparities between results for reflex and operant escape measures are described, but the results of operant testing are consistent with evidence from humans. Objective reasons are given for experimenters to choose between these and other methods of evaluating the nociceptive sensitivity of laboratory animals.

Effects of gabapentin on thermal sensitivity following spinal nerve ligation or spinal cord compression.

Neuropathic pain challenges healthcare professionals and researchers to develop new strategies of treatment and experimental models to better understand the pathophysiology of this condition. In the present study, the efficacy of gabapentin on thermal sensitivity following spinal nerve ligation and spinal cord compression was evaluated. The method of behavioral assessment was a well-validated cortically dependent operant escape task. Spinal nerve ligation produced peripheral neuropathic pain whereas spinal cord compression, achieved with an expanding polymer placed extradurally, produced a condition of central neuropathic pain. Changes in thermal sensitivity were also observed in animals undergoing nerve ligation surgery without nerve injury. Gabapentin (50 and 100 mg/kg) significantly reduced thermal sensitivity to 10 and 44.5 °C in surgically naive animals as well as those undergoing spinal nerve ligation and spinal cord compression. In conclusion, an operant method of behavioral assessment was used to show that spinal nerve ligation and spinal cord compression produced increases in sensitivity to noxious cold and heat stimuli. A decrease in thermal sensitivity was observed following administration of gabapentin. The results achieved with these methods are consistent with the clinical profile of gabapentin in treating conditions of neuropathic pain.

Excitotoxic injury to thoracolumbar gray matter alters sympathetic activation and thermal pain sensitivity.

Studies of humans, monkeys and rodents have implicated combined gray and white matter damage as important for development of chronic pain following spinal cord injury (SCI). Below-level chronic pain and hyperalgesia following injury to the spinal white matter, including the spinothalamic tract (STT), can be enhanced by excitotoxic influences within the gray matter at the site of SCI. Also, excitotoxic injury of thoracic gray matter without interruption of the STT results in below-level heat hyperalgesia. The present study evaluates the possibility that thoracolumbar gray matter injury increases sensitivity to nociceptive heat stimulation by altering spinal sympathetic outflow. Thermal preferences of rats for heat (45 °C) versus cold (15 °C) were evaluated before and after thoracolumbar injections of quisqualic acid (QUIS). A pre-injury preference for heat changed to a post-injury preference for cold. Systemic activation of the sympathetic nervous system by restraint stress decreased the heat preference pre-injury and increased the cold preference post-injury. The heat aversive effect of stress was magnified and prolonged post-injury, compared to pre-injury. Also, peripheral sympathetic activation by nociceptive stimulation was evaluated pre- and post-injury by measuring thermal transfer through a hindpaw during stimulation with 44.5 °C. Skin temperature recordings revealed enhanced sympathetic activation by nociceptive heat stimulation following spinal QUIS injury. However, increased sympathetic activation with peripheral vasoconstriction should enhance cold aversion, in contrast to the observed increase in heat aversion. Thus, peripheral sympathetic vasoconstriction can be ruled out as a mechanism for heat hyperalgesia following excitotoxic gray matter injury.

Overpressure blast-wave induced brain injury elevates oxidative stress in the hypothalamus and catecholamine biosynthesis in the rat adrenal medulla.

Explosive overpressure brain injury (OBI) impacts the lives of both military and civilian population. We hypothesize that a single exposure to OBI results in increased hypothalamic expression of oxidative stress and activation of the sympatho-adrenal medullary axis. Since a key component of blast-induced organ injury is the primary overpressure wave, we assessed selective biochemical markers of autonomic function and oxidative stress in male Sprague Dawley rats subjected to head-directed overpressure insult. Rats were subjected to single head-directed OBI with a 358kPa peak overpressure at the target. Control rats were exposed to just noise signal being placed at ~2m distance from the shock tube nozzle. Sympathetic nervous system activation of the adrenal medullae (AM) was evaluated at 6h following blast injury by assessing the expression of catecholamine biosynthesizing enzymes, tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), dopamine-ß hydroxylase (DßH), neuropeptide Y (NPY) along with plasma norepinephrine (NE). TH, DßH and NPY expression increased 20%, 25%, and 91% respectively, following OBI (P<0.05). Plasma NE was also significantly elevated by 23% (P<0.05) following OBI. OBI significantly elevated TH (49%, P<0.05) in the nucleus tractus solitarius (NTS) of the brain stem while AT1 receptor expression and NADPH oxidase activity, a marker of oxidative stress, was elevated in the hypothalamus following OBI. Collectively, the increased levels of TH, DßH and NPY expression in the rat AM, elevated TH in NTS along with increased plasma NE suggest that single OBI exposure results in increased sympathoexcitation. The mechanism may involve the elevated AT1 receptor expression and NADPH oxidase levels in the hypothalamus. Taken together, such effects may be important factors contributing to pathology of brain injury and autonomic dysfunction associated with the clinical profile of patients following OBI.

The effects of age on pain sensitivity: preclinical studies.

OBJECTIVE: Preclinical studies of pain and aging represent an area of research where considerations of age, strain, gender, and method of behavioral assessment are but some of the challenges that must be addressed. The results of studies related to the impact of age on pain sensitivity have ranged from increased to decreased sensitivity to no change. Examining the design of these studies one discovers that cross-sectional designs using animals of different ages have been used to evaluate age-related effects in normal animals as well as animals with inflammatory and neuropathic pain conditions. In the present review a summary of these studies is presented along with a discussion of potential mechanisms responsible for changes that have been described. OUTCOME MEASURES: The dominant method of behavioral assessment in the majority of studies involving rodents has been reflex-based strategies that unfortunately do not reveal the same effects of experimental manipulations known to affect pain sensitivity in humans. A comparison of results obtained with reflex-based methods versus those obtained with cortically dependent operant methods reveals significant differences. CONCLUSIONS: Increases in pain sensitivity under different experimental conditions have been suggested to result from age-related anatomical, physiological, and biochemical changes as well as compensatory changes in homeostatic mechanisms and intrinsic plasticity of somatosensory pathways involved in the processing and perception of pain. Other factors that may contribute to the impact of age on pain sensitivity include dysregulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and changes in autonomic function that occur with advancing age. In the future translational research in the field of pain and aging will need to focus on establishing clinically relevant animal models and assessment strategies to evaluate the causal relationships between the biological changes associated with advancing age and the varied behavioral changes in pain sensitivity.

Sex differences in effects of excitotoxic spinal injury on below-level pain sensitivity.

Effects of excitotoxic injury to the thoracic gray matter on sensitivity to below-level nociceptive stimulation were evaluated for female and male Long-Evans rats. Operant escape and lick/guard (L/G) reflex responses to thermal stimulation were evaluated before and for 13-15 weeks after: 1) injections of quisqualic acid (QUIS) into the thoracic gray matter (T8-9), 2) laminectomy and spinal exposure and penetration without injection (sham) or 3) no surgical procedure (control). L/G responding to heat stimulation (44 °C) was unaffected for females and males following thoracic QUIS injections. Similarly, male escape performance was not significantly altered for 44 °C or 10 °C stimulation after QUIS injections or sham surgery. However, escape testing following QUIS and sham injections revealed increased heat sensitivity (44 °C) and decreased cold sensitivity (10 °C) for females. This selective effect is indicative of altered sympathetic activation by the thoracic injections. The effect of sham surgery suggests that female rats are vulnerable to ischemic injury during exposure and manipulation of the spinal cord. Escape from nociceptive heat and cold sensitivity of control males and females was unchanged over 13-15 weeks of testing.

Effects of analgesics on orthodontic pain.

INTRODUCTION: Our objective was too assess the effectiveness of 3 analgesics (ibuprofen, naproxen sodium, and acetaminophen) and a placebo administered before and after the placement of separators in reducing the severity of postseparator placement pain. We also examined the impact of treatment on chewing efficiency at 24 hours after separator placement. METHODS: Twenty-four subjects participated in the study. Each subject received 3 of 4 treatments: ibuprofen, naproxen sodium, acetaminophen, or placebo in random order at monthly intervals. The dosing times were 1 hour before separator placement and 3 and 7 hours after separator placement. Before placement, the subjects completed a masticatory efficiency test and a visual analog scale (VAS) for expected pain and pain experienced. A VAS pain diary was kept for 24 hours. Subjects returned to the clinic after 1 week for separator removal. RESULTS: VAS pain summary scores after separator placement were significantly affected by the administration of ibuprofen (P = 0.0298) and the time after separator placement (P <0.0001). Administering ibuprofen before and after separator placement significantly reduced pain compared with the placebo. The analgesic effects diminished by day 2, resulting in peak pain levels and decreased chewing efficiency. The expected pain after separator placement also played a role in experienced pain; subjects expecting more pain experienced more pain. CONCLUSIONS: Ibuprofen was superior to the placebo in relieving postseparator pain as measured by the VAS pain summary scores, whereas acetaminophen and naproxen sodium did not significantly differ from the placebo.

Interview: Pathways to discovery: reflections on an ongoing journey.

Dr Robert Yezierski received his PhD in Physiology from West Virginia University (WV, USA). He completed postdoctoral training at the Marine Biomedical Institute in Galveston (TX, USA). Dr Yezierski joined the faculty in the Department of Anatomy at the University of Mississippi Medical Center in Jackson (MS, USA) in 1981 where he carried out studies related to the anatomy, physiology and pharmacology of spinal neurons projecting to different targets of the mesencephalon (spinomesencephalic tract). In 1987, he assumed the position of Associate Professor in the Department of Neurological Surgery and The Miami Project to Cure Paralysis at the University of Miami (FL, USA) where he initiated studies related to the condition of pain and abnormal sensation associated with spinal cord injury. Dr Yezierski created a program in pain research at The Miami Project and was co-chair of an international task force related to the condition of spinal cord injury pain along with organizing numerous symposia and workshops related to this topic. In 2001 Dr Yezierski was appointed Professor and Director of the Comprehensive Center for Pain Research at the University of Florida (FL, USA). Dr Yezierski's current research is dedicated to understanding the mechanisms underlying the onset and progression of abnormal sensation including pain with advancing age. His research program is multidisciplinary, combining a variety of anatomical, molecular, pharmacological, physiological and behavioral techniques.

Involvement of ERK2 in traumatic spinal cord injury.

Activation of extracellular signal-regulated protein kinase 1/2 (ERK1/2) are implicated in the pathophysiology of spinal cord injury (SCI). However, the specific functions of individual ERK isoforms in neurodegeneration are largely unknown. We investigated the hypothesis that ERK2 activation may contribute to pathological and functional deficits following SCI and that ERK2 knockdown using RNA interference may provide a novel therapeutic strategy for SCI. Lentiviral ERK2 shRNA and siRNA were utilized to knockdown ERK2 expression in the spinal cord following SCI. Pre-injury intrathecal administration of ERK2 siRNA significantly reduced excitotoxic injury-induced activation of ERK2 (p < 0.001) and caspase 3 (p < 0.01) in spinal cord. Intraspinal administration of lentiviral ERK2 shRNA significantly reduced ERK2 expression in the spinal cord (p < 0.05), but did not alter ERK1 expression. Administration of the lentiviral ERK2 shRNA vector 1 week prior to severe spinal cord contusion injury resulted in a significant improvement in locomotor function (p < 0.05), total tissue sparing (p < 0.05), white matter sparing (p < 0.05), and gray matter sparing (p < 0.05) 6 weeks following severe contusive SCI. Our results suggest that ERK2 signaling is a novel target associated with the deleterious consequences of spinal injury.

Pain as a stressor: effects of prior nociceptive stimulation on escape responding of rats to thermal stimulation.

In our previous studies, psychological stress was shown to enhance operant escape responding of male and female rats. The stressors that produced hyperalgesia were physical restraint and social defeat. Nociceptive input also elicits stress reactions, generating the prediction that pain would facilitate pain under certain circumstances. For example, the usual method of evaluating stress in laboratory animals is to test for effects after termination of the stressor. Accordingly, operant escape performance of male and female rats was evaluated during two successive trials involving nociceptive thermal stimulation. The intent was to determine whether nociceptive sensitivity differed on first trials and during pain-induced stress on second trials. Compared to a first trial of 44.5 degrees C stimulation, escape responding increased during a second trial of 44.5 degrees C stimulation (preceded by an escape trial of 10 degrees C). Similarly, escape from cold (10 degrees C) was enhanced when preceded by escapable 44.5 degrees C stimulation. Thus, prior nociceptive stimulation enhanced escape from aversive thermal stimulation. Facilitation of pain by a preceding pain experience is consistent with stress-induced hyperalgesia and contrasts with other models of pain inhibition by concurrent nociceptive stimulation.

Effects of preoperative ibuprofen on pain after separator placement.

INTRODUCTION: Many patients experience pain with orthodontics, but there is no widely accepted standard of care for controlling orthodontic pain. Previous studies were inconclusive as to the most effective way to manage orthodontic pain. The purpose of this study was to assess the effectiveness in reducing pain of preemptive ibuprofen added to an ibuprofen regimen administered after separator placement. We also examined the contributions of psychological factors and sex to the experience of pain. METHODS: The subjects were randomly assigned to group A, 400 mg of ibuprofen 1 hour before separator placement (D1), 3 hours after placement (D2), and 7 hours after placement (D3); group B, placebo at D1, 400 mg of ibuprofen at D2 and D3; or group C, placebo at D1, D2, and D3. Before separator placement, the subjects completed 2 psychological surveys, a masticatory efficiency test, and a visual analog scale for expected pain and experienced pain during the masticatory efficiency test. After placement, the subjects recorded their actual pain, kept a pain diary for 24 hours after separator placement, and performed a 24-hour follow-up masticatory efficiency test. RESULTS: Group A, receiving ibuprofen before and after separator placement, experienced significantly less pain (P <0.05) at 6 hours, at bedtime, and at awakening on the second day. No contributions to pain were found for psychological factors or sex. CONCLUSIONS: Preemptive administration of analgesics should be recommended to orthodontic patients before separator placement.

Spinal cord injury pain: spinal and supraspinal mechanisms.

Altered sensations, including pain, are well-documented consequences associated with spinal cord injury (SCI). Although loss of sensory and motor functions at and below the level of injury is commonly thought to affect individuals with SCI most significantly, secondary consequences that include spasticity, bladder and bowel dysfunctions, infertility, and pain rank among the most difficult conditions to deal with following injury. Understanding the mechanisms responsible for the condition of pain requires one to appreciate the pathological, physiological, neurochemical, and molecular events associated with injury of the spinal cord parenchyma. Over the past 15 years, a systematic examination related to the pathophysiology, clinical characteristics, and treatment of pain associated with SCI has provided insights into the spinal and supraspinal mechanisms associated with the development of at- and below-level pain. In this review, experimental studies focusing on the spinal and supraspinal mechanisms associated with pain at and below level will be discussed.

Dose-dependent effects of icilin on thermal preference in the hindpaw and face of rats.

UNLABELLED: Icilin induces wet dog shakes (WDS) in rodents when injected systemically and activates the cold receptor TRPM8 and putative cold receptor TRPA1. It is assumed that WDS reflect an enhanced cold sensitivity; however, none have examined the relationship between WDS and cutaneous cold sensitivity following systemic icilin. In this study, we sought to characterize the effect of systemic and central icilin administration on WDS and thermal preference with either hindpaw or facial stimulation. It was found that a low dose of icilin (.025 mg), which transiently elevated WDS, decreased preference for cold with hindpaw stimulation (15 and 45 degrees C) when administered ip or it. Intracisternal administration of this dose produced similar results for facial stimulation (10 and 48 degrees C), but had no effect when administered ip. In contrast a high dose of icilin (.25 mg), which persistently elevated WDS, strongly increased preference for cold with hindpaw stimulation and had no effect on thermal preference with facial stimulation. These findings indicate that at the low concentration, systemic and central icilin enhances cold sensitivity, likely via TRPM8 and TRPA1 activation. In contrast, systemic icilin at the high concentration produces peripheral and/or central effects that diminish cold sensitivity, while WDS is maintained at a persistent rate. PERSPECTIVE: Icilin is a unique compound that produces dissociable effects on an innate behavior (WDS) and on operant behaviors related to thermal perception. This compound could help clarify the relationship between peripheral cold transduction and the central induction of thermogenesis and nocifensive behaviors, as well as alterations that produce pathological pain.

Social defeat stress potentiates thermal sensitivity in operant models of pain processing.

Higher-order processing of nociceptive input is distributed in corticolimbic regions of the brain, including the anterior cingulate, parieto-insular and prefrontal cortices, as well as subcortical structures such as the bed nucleus of stria terminalis and amygdala. In addition to their role in pain processing, these regions encode or modulate emotional, motivational and sensory responses to stress. Thus, pain and stress pathways in the brain intersect at cortical and subcortical forebrain structures. Accordingly, previous work has shown that acute restraint stress in female rats induces heat hyperalgesia in a forebrain-dependent operant test of thermal escape. In the present study, we investigated the effects of social defeat stress in male rats on the operant escape task, as well as in a test of nociceptive thermal preference. After establishing baseline behaviors in these tests, separate groups of rats were socially defeated by dominant "resident" male rats. They were tested for thermal preference after 5 successive social defeat sessions. Escape from cold, heat and a neutral warm temperature also was evaluated after social defeat. Defeated rats exhibited a significant increase in cold preference after social defeat compared to the baseline. In the escape task, the rats exhibited increased escape from warm and nociceptive cold and heat temperatures. Thus, chronic social stress produces hyperalgesia for both hot and cold stimuli in male rats, suggesting a mutually facilitatory cross-regulation between central pathways regulating stress and pain.

Evaluation of prescription opioids using operant-based pain measures in rats.

Opioids are the most effective compounds available for the relief of pain, yet there are a number of side effects that are of great concern to clinicians. For example, opioids are powerful reinforcers, and the treatment of pain using opioids could lead to the development of addiction. In addition, there is an increasing body of literature demonstrating that the repeated administration of opioids could lead to a phenomenon called opioid-induced hyperalgesia (i.e., increased sensitivity to painful stimulation). Studies examining these potential adverse effects are necessary in the development of novel analgesics. Furthermore, most studies of pain sensitivity and pain relief use reflex-based procedures to identify analgesics; however, it is argued here that operant-based procedures provide measures that are more analogous to the human condition (i.e., the mechanisms of pain are similar to those in humans) and should be useful in the assessment of novel analgesics. A series of studies examining the effects of opioids and the influence of variables such as age are discussed to demonstrate the utility of this approach.