Designing and implementing a new icon-based difficult airway cart: a two-phase prospective qualitative improvement project.

PURPOSE: The difficult airway cart is essential for difficult airway management. Recognition of the importance of human factors in critical scenarios promoted the evolution of the difficult airway cart. Limitation to essential equipment, a structured layout, and proper labelling should be observed. We sought to redesign the difficult airway cart accordingly and analyze how perioperative professionals reacted to it. METHODS: We conducted a two-phase prospective qualitative improvement project involving a multidisciplinary team. In phase 1, we reconfigured our difficult airway cart, including developing icons for labelling the drawers and discussing the equipment content. In phase 2, we delivered a multidisciplinary educational program and pre- and postsession questionnaires were administered to the professionals involved and compared. RESULTS: Phase 1 of the project encompassed 21 participants. We presented the final layout and content of the difficult airway cart. In phase 2, 44 participants responded the presession questionnaires, and 30 participants answered the postsession questionnaires. The results showed that the new design and the implementation program increased the comfort level of professionals involved in a potential airway crisis (presession mean [standard deviation (SD)]: anesthesiologists, 8.0 [1.9]; anesthesia assistants/respiratory therapists [AAs/RTs], 9.3 [0.8]; operating room registered nurses [OR RNs], 6.3 [2.7]; P = 0.001; postsession: anesthesiologists, 8.5 [2.0]; AAs/RTs, 9.6 [0.5]; OR RN, 7.9 [2.0]; P = 0.10). Nevertheless, the improvement was only statistically significant among the OR RNs (presession mean [SD]: 6.3 [2.7]; postsession: 7.9 [2.0]; P = 0.01). Additionally, the program facilitated the recognition of the location of airway equipment in the airway cart (positive responses ranging from 97% to 100%). CONCLUSION: Our quality improvement project successfully designed and implemented a new visual-based difficult airway cart at our institution. We believe this report enables other institutions to reproduce our project.

RéSUMé: OBJECTIF: Le chariot d'intubation difficile est essentiel pour la prise en charge des voies aériennes difficiles. La reconnaissance de l'importance des facteurs humains dans les situations critiques a favorisé l'évolution du chariot d'intubation difficile. Il est crucial de se limiter à l'équipement essentiel tout en organisant les éléments de manière structurée et en les étiquetant adéquatement. Nous avons cherché à repenser le chariot d'intubation difficile en gardant ces éléments à l'esprit et à analyser la réaction des professionnel·les oeuvrant en périopératoire. MéTHODE: Nous avons réalisé un projet d'amélioration qualitative prospective en deux phases impliquant une équipe multidisciplinaire. Au cours de la phase 1, nous avons reconfiguré notre chariot d'intubation difficile, en développant notamment des icônes pour étiqueter les tiroirs et en discutant du contenu matériel. Au cours de la phase 2, nous avons mis en place un programme éducatif multidisciplinaire et des questionnaires ont été administrés aux professionnel·les concerné·es avant et après la session. RéSULTATS: La phase 1 du projet a réuni 21 participant·es. Nous avons présenté la disposition finale et le contenu du chariot d'intubation difficile. Au cours de la phase 2, 44 participant·es ont répondu aux questionnaires d'avant-session et 30 participant·es ont répondu aux questionnaires d'après-session. Les résultats ont montré que la nouvelle disposition avec icônes et le programme de mise en œuvre ont augmenté le niveau de confort des professionnel·les impliqué·es dans une situation critique potentielle impliquant les voies aériennes (moyenne avant la séance [écart type (ET)] : anesthésiologistes, 8,0 [1,9]; assistant·es en anesthésie/inhalothérapeutes, 9,3 [0,8]; personnel infirmier autorisé en salle d'opération (SOP), 6,3 [2,7]; P = 0,001; après la session : anesthésiologistes, 8,5 [2,0]; assistant·es en anesthésie/inhalothérapeutes, 9,6 [0,5]; personnel infirmier de SOP, 7,9 [2,0]; P = 0,10). Néanmoins, l'amélioration n'était statistiquement significative que chez le personnel infirmier autorisé de SOP (moyenne avant la session [ET] : 6,3 [2,7]; après la session : 7,9 [2,0]; P = 0,01). De plus, le programme a facilité la reconnaissance de l'emplacement de l'équipement pour les voies aériennes dans le chariot d'intubation (réponses positives allant de 97 % à 100 %). CONCLUSION: Dans le cadre de notre projet d'amélioration de la qualité, nous avons réussi à concevoir et mettre en œuvre un nouveau chariot d'intubation difficile avec icônes dans notre établissement. Nous pensons que ce compte rendu permettra à d'autres institutions de reproduire notre projet.

Achieving Competency in Fiber-Optic Intubation Among Resident Physicians After Higher- Versus Lower-Fidelity Task Training: A Randomized Controlled Study.

BACKGROUND: The high-fidelity ORSIM (Airway Simulation Ltd) and the low-fidelity wooden-block fiber-optic task trainers allow users to familiarize themselves with the psychomotor skills required to manipulate the fiber-optic scope. METHODS: This single-center study aimed to compare residents' performance of fiber-optic intubation after 2 different types of task training. Twenty-four residents with experience of <8 fiber-optic intubations were randomized to either the ORSIM or a wooden-block task trainer. In a single teaching session, the resident performed 20 fiber-optic intubations on their assigned task trainer. This implied simulator competence. In the 4 months after this training, all subjects then attempted to perform a fiber-optic intubation on an American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) I or II anesthetized patient whose airway was preoperatively assessed as normal. The primary outcome was the cumulative sum (CUSUM) learning curves obtained as the residents trained on their respective task trainers. Secondary outcomes included: the mean time (in seconds) to perform each of the 20 fiber-optic intubations on their assigned task trainer, the total simulator training time, global rating scale score, checklist score, and time to carina when performing fiber-optic intubation on the patient. RESULTS: The CUSUM analysis showed that the ORSIM group achieved simulator competence faster. The mean time to perform fiber-optic intubation was shorter in the ORSIM group. A 2-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) test suggests that the combined effect of group (wooden-block or ORSIM) and time is statistically significant ( P < .05).Total training time (mean, 899 s ± 440 s vs 1358 s ± 405 s; 95% confidence interval [CI], 100.46-818.54; P = .01) was also significantly better in the ORSIM group.No significant difference was found between the 2 groups ( P > 0) in terms of global rating scale, checklist score, and time to reach the carina ( P >.05) when performing the fiber-optic intubation on the patient. CONCLUSIONS: ORSIM showed superiority in terms of the CUSUM learning curve in reaching competence faster in fewer attempts. There was no statistically significant difference in residents' performance when translated to clinical practice on a patient. This information should assist course directors when choosing task trainers for fiber-optic intubation training programs.

Role of ultrasonography in an impalpable tissue larynx model during a simulated front-of-neck access scenario: a randomized simulation study.

PURPOSE: A large vertical incision is recommended when performing front-of-neck access in patients with impalpable neck landmarks during a cannot intubate-cannot oxygenate (CICO) scenario. We investigated the impact of ultrasonography on vertical incision size of a front-of-neck access on an ultrasound-compatible impalpable porcine larynx model. METHODS: Emergency medicine and anesthesia trainees were randomized to the Ultrasound (US, n = 21) and Non-Ultrasound (NUS, n = 21) groups. Within 1 week after a teaching session on airway ultrasound and Scalpel-Bougie-Tube (SBT) technique, participants were instructed to perform cricothyroidotomy on the model during a simulated cannot intubate-cannot oxygenate scenario. The primary outcome was a vertical size incision. Secondary outcomes were procedural completion time, horizontal size incision, tissue injury severity, and correct tube placement. RESULTS: The ultrasound group performed a significantly smaller vertical incision [median (IQR), 35.0 (15, 40) vs 65.0 (52, 100) mm (95% CI) - 30.0 (- 55.1, - 4.9), p = 0.02] and took longer total time to complete the procedure [median (IQR), 200.5 (126, 267) vs 93.5 (71.0, 167.5) secs (95% CI) 91.0 (3.73, 178.3), p = 0.04]. Tissue injury severity and correct tube placement were similar between groups. CONCLUSIONS: Ultrasound-guided identification of the cricothyroid membrane significantly reduced the recommended vertical incision size with similar success rates. However, there was an increased time when performing a Scalpel-Bougie-Tube cricothyroidotomy on an impalpable porcine larynx model by physicians in training. Ultrasonography should not be used in an emergency scenario of airway rescue. Its potential use to pre-mark the cricothyroid membrane should be considered in difficult airway management of impalpable neck.

RéSUMé: OBJECTIF: Il est recommandé de pratiquer une grande incision verticale lors de l'accès à l'avant du cou chez les patients dont les repères du cou sont impalpables, dans le cadre d'un scénario d'intubation impossible à oxygéner (CICO). Nous avons étudié l'impact de l'échographie sur la taille de l'incision verticale d'un accès à la face avant du cou sur un modèle de larynx porcin impalpable compatible avec l'échographie. MéTHODES: Des stagiaires en médecine d'urgence et en anesthésie ont été répartis de manière aléatoire entre les groupes "échographie" (US, n = 21) et "non-échographie" (NUS, n = 21). Une semaine après une session d'enseignement sur l'échographie des voies aériennes et la technique Scalpel-Bougie-Tube (SBT), les participants ont reçu l'instruction de réaliser une cricothyroïdotomie sur le modèle lors d'un scénario simulé d'impossibilité d'intubation et d'oxygénation. Le résultat primaire était une incision de taille verticale. Les résultats secondaires étaient le temps de réalisation de la procédure, la taille horizontale de l'incision, la gravité de la lésion tissulaire et le placement correct du tube. RéSULTATS: Le groupe échographie a réalisé une incision verticale significativement plus petite [médiane (IQR), 35,0 (15,40) vs 65,0 (52,100) mm (IC à 95 %) -30,0 (-55,1, -4,9), p = 0,02] et a pris un temps total plus long pour terminer la procédure [médiane (IQR), 200,5 (126, 267) vs 93,5 (71,0, 167,5) secondes (IC à 95 %) 91,0 (3,73, 178,3), p = 0,04]. La gravité des lésions tissulaires et le placement correct du tube étaient similaires entre les groupes. CONCLUSIONS: L'identification échoguidée de la membrane cricothyroïdienne a réduit de manière significative la taille de l'incision verticale recommandée avec des taux de réussite similaires. Cependant, il y avait une augmentation du temps lors de la réalisation d'une cricothyroïdotomie Scalpel-Bougie-Tube sur un modèle de larynx porcin impalpable par des médecins en formation. L'échographie ne doit pas être utilisée dans un scénario d'urgence de sauvetage des voies respiratoires. Son utilisation potentielle pour pré-marquer la membrane cricothyroïdienne devrait être envisagée dans la gestion des voies aériennes difficiles du cou impalpable.

Effects of prior exposure to a visual airway cognitive aid on decision-making in a simulated airway emergency: A randomised controlled study.

BACKGROUND: Decision-making deficits in airway emergencies have led to adverse patient outcomes. A cognitive aid would assist clinicians through critical decision-making steps, preventing key action omission. OBJECTIVE: We aimed to investigate the effects of a visual airway cognitive aid on decision-making in a simulated airway emergency scenario. DESIGN: Randomised controlled study. SETTING: Single-institution, tertiary-level hospital in Toronto, Canada from September 2017 to March 2019. PARTICIPANTS: Teams consisting of a participant anaesthesia resident, nurse and respiratory therapist were randomised to intervention (N = 20 teams) and control groups (N = 20 teams). INTERVENTION: Participants in both groups received a 15-min didactic session on crisis resource management which included teamwork communication and the concepts of cognitive aids for the management of nonairway and airway critical events. Only participants in the intervention group were familiarised, oriented and instructed on a visual airway cognitive aid that was developed for this study. Within 1 to 4 weeks after the teaching session, teams were video-recorded managing a simulated 'cannot intubate-cannot oxygenate' scenario with the aid displayed in the simulation centre. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Decision-making time to perform a front-of-neck access (FONA), airway checklist actions, teamwork performances and a postscenario questionnaire. RESULTS: Both groups performed similar key airway actions; however, the intervention group took a shorter decision-making time than the control group to perform a FONA after a last action [mean ± SD, 80.9 ±â€Š54.5 vs. 122.2 ±â€Š55.7 s; difference (95% CI) -41.2 (-76.5 to -6.0) s, P = 0.023]. Furthermore, the intervention group used the aid more than the control group (63.0 vs. 28.1%, P < 0.001). Total time of scenario completion, action checklist and teamwork performances scores were similar between groups. CONCLUSIONS: Prior exposure and teaching of a visual airway cognitive aid improved decision-making time to perform a FONA during a simulated airway emergency.

Complications of cricothyroidotomy versus tracheostomy in emergency surgical airway management: a systematic review.

BACKGROUND: Airway guidelines recommend an emergency surgical airway as a potential life-saving treatment in a "Can't Intubate, Can't Oxygenate" (CICO) situation. Surgical airways can be achieved either through a cricothyroidotomy or tracheostomy. The current literature has limited data regarding complications of cricothyroidotomy and tracheostomy in an emergency situation. The objective of this systematic review is to analyze complications following cricothyroidotomy and tracheostomy in airway emergencies. METHODS: This synthesis of literature was exempt from ethics approval. Eight databases were searched from inception to October 2018, using a comprehensive search strategy. Studies were included if they were randomized controlled trials or observational studies reporting complications following emergency surgical airway. Complications were classified as minor (evolving to spontaneous remission or not requiring intervention or not persisting chronically), major (requiring intervention or persisting chronically), early (from the start of the procedure up to 7 days) and late (beyond 7 days of the procedure). RESULTS: We retrieved 2659 references from our search criteria. Following the removal of duplicates, title and abstract review, 33 articles were selected for full-text reading. Twenty-one articles were finally included in the systematic review. We found no differences in minor, major or early complications between the two techniques. However, late complications were significantly more frequent in the tracheostomy group [OR (95% CI) 0.21 (0.20-0.22), p < 0.0001]. CONCLUSIONS: Our results demonstrate that cricothyroidotomies performed in emergent situations resulted in fewer late complications than tracheostomies. This finding supports the recommendations from the latest Difficult Airway Society (DAS) guidelines regarding using cricothyroidotomy as the technique of choice for emergency surgical airway. However, emergency cricothyroidotomies should be converted to tracheostomies in a timely fashion as there is insufficient evidence to suggest that emergency cricothyrotomies are long term airways.

Ultrasound Is Superior to Palpation in Identifying the Cricothyroid Membrane in Subjects with Poorly Defined Neck Landmarks: A Randomized Clinical Trial.

WHAT WE ALREADY KNOW ABOUT THIS TOPIC: WHAT THIS ARTICLE TELLS US THAT IS NEW: BACKGROUND:: Success of a cricothyrotomy is dependent on accurate identification of the cricothyroid membrane. The objective of this study was to compare the accuracy of ultrasonography versus external palpation in localizing the cricothyroid membrane. METHODS: In total, 223 subjects with abnormal neck anatomy who were scheduled for neck computed-tomography scan at University Health Network hospitals in Toronto, Canada, were randomized into two groups: external palpation and ultrasound. The localization points of the cricothyroid membrane determined by ultrasonography or external palpation were compared to the reference midpoint (computed-tomography point) of the cricothyroid membrane by a radiologist who was blinded to group allocation. Primary outcome was the accuracy in identification of the cricothyroid membrane, which was measured by digital ruler in millimeters from the computed-tomography point to the ultrasound point or external-palpation point. Success was defined as the proportion of accurate attempts within a 5-mm distance from the computed-tomography point to the ultrasound point or external-palpation point. RESULTS: The percentage of accurate attempts was 10-fold greater in the ultrasound than external-palpation group (81% vs. 8%; 95% CI, 63.6 to 81.3%; P < 0.0001). The mean (SD) distance measured from the external-palpation to computed-tomography point was five-fold greater than the ultrasound to the computed-tomography point (16.6 ± 7.5 vs. 3.4 ± 3.3 mm; 95% CI, 11.67 to 14.70; P < 0.0001). Analysis demonstrated that the risk ratio of inaccurate localization of the cricothyroid membrane was 9.14-fold greater with the external palpation than with the ultrasound (P < 0.0001). There were no adverse events observed. CONCLUSIONS: In subjects with poorly defined neck landmarks, ultrasonography is more accurate than external palpation in localizing the cricothyroid membrane.

Practice of Ultrasound-Guided Palpation of Neck Landmarks Improves Accuracy of External Palpation of the Cricothyroid Membrane.

BACKGROUND: Ultrasonography can accurately identify the cricothyroid membrane; however, its impact on the subsequent accuracy of external palpation is not known. In this study, we tested the ability of anesthesia participants to identify the midpoint of the cricothyroid membrane using external palpation with and without ultrasound (US)-guided practice. METHODS: Following institutional ethics approval and informed consent, anesthesia participants consisting of anesthesia residents, fellows, and practicing anesthesia assistants underwent didactic teaching on neck landmarks. The participants were then randomized to practice palpation of neck landmarks with US guidance (US group) or without ultrasonography (non-US [NUS] group). After the practice session, each participant identified the cricothyroid membrane using external palpation on the neck of 10 volunteers and marked the anticipated entry point for device insertion (palpation point [PT]). The midpoint of the cricothyroid membrane of each volunteer had been premarked with invisible ink using ultrasonography (US point) by a separate member of the research team. The primary outcome was the accuracy rate defined as the percentage of the attempts with the distance ≤5 mm measured from the PT to US point for the participant. The primary outcome was compared between NUS and US groups using Wilcoxon rank sum test. A mixed-effect logistic regression or mixed-effect linear model was also conducted for outcomes accounting for the clustering and adjusting for potential confounders. RESULTS: Fifteen anesthesia participants were randomized to US (n = 8) and NUS (n = 7) groups. A total of 80 and 61 attempts were performed by the US and NUS groups, respectively. The median accuracy rate in the US group was higher than the NUS group (65% vs 30%; P = .025), and the median PT-US distance in the US group was shorter than in the NUS group (4.0 vs 8.0 mm; P = .04). The adjusted mean PT-US distance in the US group was shorter compared to the NUS group (adjusted mean [95% CI], 3.6 [2.9-4.6] vs 6.8 [5.2-8.9] mm; P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Anesthesia participants exposed to practice with US-guided palpation of the cricothyroid membrane location were better able to identify the cricothyroid membrane using only blind palpation than participants without US-guided practice. Practice with US-guided palpation of neck landmarks improves subsequent blind localization of the cricothyroid membrane using palpation alone.

Point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) of the upper airway.

Airway management is a critical skill in the practice of several medical specialities including anesthesia, emergency medicine, and critical care. Over the years mounting evidence has showed an increasing role of ultrasound (US) in airway management. The objective of this narrative review is to provide an overview of the indications for point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) of the upper airway. The use of US to guide and assist clinical airway management has potential benefits for both provider and patient. Ultrasound can be utilized to determine airway size and predict the appropriate diameter of single-lumen endotracheal tubes (ETTs), double-lumen ETTs, and tracheostomy tubes. Ultrasonography can differentiate tracheal, esophageal, and endobronchial intubation. Ultrasonography of the neck can accurately localize the cricothyroid membrane for emergency airway access and similarly identify tracheal rings for US-guided tracheostomy. In addition, US can identify vocal cord dysfunction and pathology before induction of anesthesia. A rapidly growing body of evidence showing ultrasonography used in conjunction with hands-on management of the airway may benefit patient care. Increasing awareness and use of POCUS for many indications have resulted in technologic advancements and increased accessibility and portability. Upper airway POCUS has the potential to become the first-line non-invasive adjunct assessment tool in airway management.

Ultrasound Improves Cricothyrotomy Success in Cadavers with Poorly Defined Neck Anatomy: A Randomized Control Trial.

BACKGROUND: Misidentification of the cricothyroid membrane in a "cannot intubate-cannot oxygenate" situation can lead to failures and serious complications. The authors hypothesized that preprocedure ultrasound-guided identification of the cricothyroid membrane would reduce complications associated with cricothyrotomy. METHODS: A group of 47 trainees were randomized to digital palpation (n = 23) and ultrasound (n = 24) groups. Cricothyrotomy was performed on human cadavers by using the Portex device (Smiths Medical, USA). Anatomical landmarks of cadavers were graded as follows: grade 1-easy = visual landmarks; 2-moderate = requires light palpation of landmarks; 3-difficult = requires deep palpation of landmarks; and 4-impossible = landmarks not palpable. Primary outcome was the complication rate as measured by the severity of injuries. Secondary outcomes were correct device placement, failure to cannulate, and insertion time. RESULTS: Ultrasound guidance significantly decreased the incidence of injuries to the larynx and trachea (digital palpation: 17 of 23 = 74% vs. ultrasound: 6 of 24 = 25%; relative risk, 2.88; 95% CI, 1.39 to 5.94; P = 0.001) and increased the probability of correct insertion by 5.6 times (P = 0.043) in cadavers with difficult and impossible landmark palpation (digital palpation 8.3% vs. ultrasound 46.7%). Injuries were found in 100% of the grades 3 to 4 (difficult-impossible landmark palpation) cadavers by digital palpation compared with only 33% by ultrasound (P < 0.001). The mean (SD) insertion time was significantly longer with ultrasound than with digital palpation (196.1 s [60.6 s] vs. 110.5 s [46.9 s]; P < 0.001). CONCLUSION: Preprocedure ultrasound guidance in cadavers with poorly defined neck anatomy significantly reduces complications and improves correct insertion of the airway device in the cricothyroid membrane.

Cricothyrotomy training increases adherence to the ASA difficult airway algorithm in a simulated crisis: a randomized controlled trial.

PURPOSE: Non-adherence to airway guidelines in a 'cannot intubate-cannot oxygenate' (CICO) crisis situation is associated with adverse patient outcomes. This study investigated the effects of hands-on training in cricothyrotomy on adherence to the American Society of Anesthesiologists difficult airway algorithm (ASA-DAA) during a simulated CICO scenario. METHODS: A total of 21 postgraduate second-year anesthesia residents completed a pre-test teaching session during which they reviewed the ASA-DAA, became familiarized with the Melker cricothyrotomy kit, and watched a video on cricothyrotomy. Participants were randomized to either the intervention 'Trained' group (n = 10) (taught and practiced cricothyrotomy) or the control 'Non-Trained' group (n = 11) (no extra training). After two to three weeks, performances of the groups were assessed in a simulated CICO scenario. The primary outcome measure was major deviation from the ASA-DAA. Secondary outcome measures were (1) performance of the four categories of non-technical behaviours using the validated Anaesthetists' Non-Technical Skills scale (ANTS) and (2) time to perform specific tasks. RESULTS: Significantly more non-trained than trained participants (6/11 vs 0/10, P = 0.012) committed at least one major ASA-DAA deviation, including failure to insert an oral airway, failure to call for help, bypassing the laryngeal mask airway, and attempting fibreoptic intubation. ANTS scores for all four categories of behaviours, however, were similar between the groups. Trained participants called for help faster [26 (2) vs 63 (48) sec, P = 0.012] but delayed opening of the cricothyrotomy kit [130 (50) vs 74 (36) sec, P = 0.014]. CONCLUSION: Hands-on training in cricothyrotomy resulted in fewer major ASA-DAA deviations in a simulated CICO scenario. Training in cricothyrotomy may play an important role in complying with the ASA-DAA in a CICO situation but does not appear to affect non-technical behaviours such as decision-making.