Vinyl-pyrazole as a biomimetic acetaldehyde surrogate.

Inspired by the enzyme acetylene hydratase, we investigated the reactivity of acetylene with tungsten(II) pyrazole complexes. Our research revealed that the complex [WBr2(pz-NHCCH3)(CO)3] (pz = 3,5-dimethyl-pyrazolate) facilitates the stochiometric reaction between pzH and acetylene to give N-vinyl-pz. This vinyl compound readily hydrolyzes to acetaldehyde, mirroring the product of acetylene hydration in the enzymatic process. The formation of the vinyl compound likely involves a reactive intermediate complex where acetylene acts as a two-electron donor, in contrast to isolable acetylene complexes that are inert to nucleophilic attack by water. Results suggest an alternative mechanism for the enzyme, including vinylation of a neighboring amino acid by acetylene in the active site prior to hydration.

The Effect of Selenium-Based Ligands on Tungsten Acetylene Complexes.

Bioinspired tungsten acetylene complexes containing pyridine-2-selenolato (PySe) or 6-methyl-pyridine-2-selenolato (6-MePySe) ligands were synthesized. 77Se NMR spectroscopy allowed for an assessment of the resonance structures in the pyridine-2-selenolato ligands and the rationalization of chemoselectivity observed in regard to 1,2 migratory insertion of HC≡CH. [W(CO)(C2H2)(CHCH-PySe)(PySe)] is formed exclusively via insertion of HC≡CH into the W-N bond, while the use of bulkier 6-MePySe allows for the isolation of [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2], which only partially reacts with excess HC≡CH to give [W(CO)(C2H2)(CHCH-6-MePySe)(6-MePySe)]. Oxidation of [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2] with pyridine-N-oxide gave the tungsten(IV) complex [WO(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2]. Complexes [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2] and [WO(C2H2)(6-MePySe)2] react with trimethyl phosphine to carbyne complex [W(CO)(CCH2PMe3)(PMe3)2(6-MePySe)]Cl and alkylidene complex [WO(CHCHPMe3)(PMe3)2(6-MePySe)]Cl, respectively. The addition of substituted alkynes to [W(CO)3(PySe)2] via thermal decarbonylation gave complexes [W(CO)(MeC≡CMe)(PySe)2] and [W(CO)(HC≡Ct-Bu)(PySe)2], respectively. The here presented complexes are relevant for the modeling of the active site of acetylene hydratase from Pelobacter acetylenicus, in which a tungsten atom is enclosed in a sulfur-rich coordination sphere. A recently published theoretical study concluded that the exchange of sulfur for selenium would increase the activity of the enzyme. Our findings contrast this claim as comparative analysis concludes negligible structural and electronic differences between the selenium-based and previously published sulfur-based complexes.

Nucleophiles Target the Tungsten Center Over Acetylene in Biomimetic Models.

Inspired by the first shell mechanism proposed for the tungstoenzyme acetylene hydratase, the electrophilic reactivity of tungsten-acetylene complexes [W(CO)(C2H2)(6-MePyS)2] (1) and [WO(C2H2)(6-MePyS)2] (2) was investigated. The biological nucleophile water/hydroxide and tert-butyl isocyanide were employed. Our findings consistently show that, regardless of the nucleophile used, both tungsten centers W(II) and W(IV), respectively, are the preferred targets over the coordinated acetylene. Treatment of 2 with aqueous NaOH led to protonation of coordinated acetylene to ethylene, pointing toward the Brønsted basic character of the coordinated alkyne instead of the anticipated electrophilic behavior. In cases involving isocyanides as nucleophiles, the attack on the W(II) center of 1 took place first, whereas the W(IV) complex 2 remained unchanged. These experiments indicate that the direct nucleophilic attack of W-coordinated acetylene by water, as some computational studies of acetylene hydratase propose, is unlikely to occur.

Synthesis of Soluble High Molar Mass Poly(Phenylene Methylene)-Based Polymers.

Poly(phenylene methylene) (PPM) is a multifunctional polymer that is also active as an anticorrosion fluorescent coating material. Although this polymer was synthesized already more than 100 years ago, a versatile synthetic route to obtain soluble high molar mass polymers based on PPM has yet to be achieved. In this article, the influence of bifunctional bis-chloromethyl durene (BCMD) as a branching agent in the synthesis of PPM is reported. The progress of the reaction was followed by gel permeation chromatography (GPC) and NMR analysis. PPM-based copolymers with the highest molar mass reported so far for this class of materials (up to Mn of 205,300 g mol-1) were isolated. The versatile approach of using BCMD was confirmed by employing different catalysts. Interestingly, thermal and optical characterization established that the branching process does not affect the thermoplastic behavior and the fluorescence of the material, thus opening up PPM-based compounds with high molar mass for applications.

A new family with a case of severe early-onset muscle fatigue and a peculiar maternally inherited painful swelling in chewing muscles associated with homoplasmic m.15992A>T mutation in mitochondrial tRNAPro.

A 16-year-old boy was evaluated for a history of exercise-induced fatigability associated with nausea even after minimal effort, lower limbs muscle hypotrophy, and swelling of the masseter muscles after chewing. Laboratory tests were remarkable for hyperlactatemia and metabolic acidosis after short physical activity. The muscle biopsy showed non-specific mitochondrial alterations and an increase in intrafibral lipids. Biochemical analysis showed reduced activity of the respiratory chain complexes. Mitochondrial DNA sequencing revealed the presence of a homoplasmic variant m.15992A>T in the MT-TP gene, coding for the mt-tRNAPro in the patient, in his mother and in his brother. Pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in MT-TP gene are rare. They are responsible for different clinical presentation, almost ever involving the muscle tissue. We report the first family with exercise-induced muscle weakness and swelling of the chewing muscles due to m.15992A>T variant in absence of J1c10 haplogroup, confirming its pathogenicity.

NGS-Based Genetic Analysis in a Cohort of Italian Patients with Suspected Inherited Myopathies and/or HyperCKemia.

Introduction/Aims HyperCKemia is considered a hallmark of neuromuscular diseases. It can be either isolated or associated with cramps, myalgia, weakness, myoglobinuria, or rhabdomyolysis, suggesting a metabolic myopathy. The aim of this work was to investigate possible genetic causes in order to help diagnose patients with recurrent hyperCKemia or clinical suspicion of inherited metabolic myopathy. Methods A cohort of 139 patients (90 adults and 49 children) was analyzed using a custom panel containing 54 genes associated with hyperCKemia. Results A definite genetic diagnosis was obtained in 15.1% of cases, while candidate variants or variants of uncertain significance were found in a further 39.5%. Similar percentages were obtained in patients with infantile or adult onset, with some different causative genes. RYR1 was the gene most frequently identified, either with single or compound heterozygous variants, while ETFDH variants were the most common cause for recessive cases. In one patient, mRNA analysis allowed identifying a large LPIN1 deletion missed by DNA sequencing, leading to a certain diagnosis. Conclusion These data confirm the high genetic heterogeneity of hyperCKemia and metabolic myopathies. The reduced diagnostic yield suggests the existence of additional genes associated with this condition but also allows speculation that a significant number of cases presenting with hyperCKemia or muscle symptoms are due to extrinsic, not genetic, factors.

Nanopore long-read next-generation sequencing for detection of mitochondrial DNA large-scale deletions.

Primary mitochondrial diseases are progressive genetic disorders affecting multiple organs and characterized by mitochondrial dysfunction. These disorders can be caused by mutations in nuclear genes coding proteins with mitochondrial localization or by genetic defects in the mitochondrial genome (mtDNA). The latter include point pathogenic variants and large-scale deletions/rearrangements. MtDNA molecules with the wild type or a variant sequence can exist together in a single cell, a condition known as mtDNA heteroplasmy. MtDNA single point mutations are typically detected by means of Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) based on short reads which, however, are limited for the identification of structural mtDNA alterations. Recently, new NGS technologies based on long reads have been released, allowing to obtain sequences of several kilobases in length; this approach is suitable for detection of structural alterations affecting the mitochondrial genome. In the present work we illustrate the optimization of two sequencing protocols based on long-read Oxford Nanopore Technology to detect mtDNA structural alterations. This approach presents strong advantages in the analysis of mtDNA compared to both short-read NGS and traditional techniques, potentially becoming the method of choice for genetic studies on mtDNA.

Dioxygen Activation by a Bioinspired Tungsten(IV) Complex.

An increasing number of discovered tungstoenzymes raises interest in the biomimetic chemistry of tungsten complexes in oxidation states +IV, +V, and +VI. Bioinspired (sulfur-rich) tungsten(VI) dioxido complexes are relatively prevalent in literature. Still, their energetically demanding reduction directly correlates with a small number of known tungsten(IV) oxido complexes, whose chemistry is not well explored. In this paper, a reduction of the [WO2(6-MePyS)2] (6-MePyS = 6-methylpyridine-2-thiolate) complex with PMe3 to a phosphine-stabilized tungsten(IV) oxido complex [WO(6-MePyS)2(PMe3)2] is described. This tungsten(IV) complex partially releases one PMe3 ligand in solution, creating a vacant coordination site capable of activating dioxygen to form [WO2(6-MePyS)2] and OPMe3. Therefore, [WO2(6-MePyS)2] can be used as a catalyst for the aerobic oxidation of PMe3, rendering this complex a rare example of a tungsten system utilizing dioxygen in homogeneous catalysis. Additionally, the investigation of the reactivity of the tungsten(IV) oxido complex with acetylene, substrate of a tungstoenzyme acetylene hydratase (AH), revealed the formation of the tungsten(IV) acetylene adduct. Although this adduct was previously reported as an oxidation product of the tungsten(II) acetylene carbonyl complex, here it is obtained via substitution at the sulfur-rich tungsten(IV) center, mimicking the initial step of the first shell mechanism for AH as suggested by computational studies.

New strategies towards advanced CT contrast agents. Development of neutral and monoanionic sulfur-bridged W(V) dimeric complexes.

Multinuclear tungsten complexes are intriguing candidates for new contrast media that can provide substantial improvements in CT imaging diagnostics. Herein, we present a ligand strategy, based on amino acids, and mono- and disubstituted EDTA derivatives, that enables the development of stable complexes with high tungsten content and reasonably low osmolality. Accordingly, a series of neutral and monoanionic di-µ-sulfido W(V) dimers have been synthesized via a convenient procedure utilizing microwave heating in combination with ion-pair HPLC reaction monitoring. The compounds were characterized in detail by various techniques, including ESI-HRMS, NMR spectroscopy, HPLC, elemental analysis, and X-ray crystallography. The aqueous stability of the complexes under physiologically relevant conditions, and during heat sterilization was also examined as an initial assessment of their potential applicability as radiocontrast agents. Monoanionic complexes featuring monosubstituted EDTA derivatives have demonstrated high stability, while producing a lower number of ions in solution (resulting in lower osmolality) in comparison to their bis-anionic EDTA counterparts. Nevertheless, they exhibited insufficient water solubility for application as intravascular contrast agents. However, our study showed that aqueous solubility of this type of complexes can be tuned by small modifications in the ligand structure.

Molybdenum(VI) Bis(imido) Complexes: From Frustrated Lewis Pairs to Weakly Coordinating Cations.

Molybdenum(VI) bis(imido) complexes [Mo(NtBu)2 (LR )2 ] (R=H 1 a; R=CF3 1 b) combined with B(C6 F5 )3 (1 a/B(C6 F5 )3 , 1 b/B(C6 F5 )3 ) exhibit a frustrated Lewis pair (FLP) character that can heterolytically split H-H, Si-H and O-H bonds. Cleavage of H2 and Et3 SiH affords ion pairs [Mo(NtBu)(NHtBu)(LR )2 ][HB(C6 F5 )3 ] (R=H 2 a; R=CF3 2 b) composed of a Mo(VI) amido imido cation and a hydridoborate anion, while reaction with H2 O leads to [Mo(NtBu)(NHtBu)(LR )2 ][(HO)B(C6 F5 )3 ] (R=H 3 a; R=CF3 3 b). Ion pairs 2 a and 2 b are catalysts for the hydrosilylation of aldehydes with triethylsilane, with 2 b being more active than 2 a. Mechanistic elucidation revealed insertion of the aldehyde into the B-H bond of [HB(C6 F5 )3 ]- . We were able to isolate and fully characterize, including by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis, the inserted products Mo(NtBu)(NHtBu)(LR )2 ][{PhCH2 O}B(C6 F5 )3 ] (R=H 4 a; R=CF3 4 b). Catalysis occurs at [HB(C6 F5 )3 ]- while [Mo(NtBu)(NHtBu)(LR )2 ]+ (R=H or CF3 ) act as the cationic counterions. However, the striking difference in reactivity gives ample evidence that molybdenum cations behave as weakly coordinating cations (WCC).

Replacement of Molybdenum by Tungsten in a Biomimetic Complex Leads to an Increase in Oxygen Atom Transfer Catalytic Activity.

Upon replacement of molybdenum by tungsten in DMSO reductase isolated from the Rhodobacteraceae family, the derived enzyme catalyzes DMSO reduction faster. To better understand this behavior, we synthesized two tungsten(VI) dioxido complexes [WVIO2L2] with pyridine- (PyS) and pyrimidine-2-thiolate (PymS) ligands, isostructural to analogous molybdenum complexes we reported recently. Higher oxygen atom transfer (OAT) catalytic activity was observed with [WO2(PyS)2] compared to the Mo species, independent of whether PMe3 or PPh3 was used as the oxygen acceptor. [WVIO2L2] complexes undergo reduction with an excess of PMe3, yielding the tungsten(IV) oxido species [WOL2(PMe3)2], while with PPh3, no reactions are observed. Although OAT reactions from DMSO to phosphines are known for tungsten complexes, [WOL2(PMe3)2] are the first fully characterized phosphine-stabilized intermediates. By following the reaction of these reduced species with excess DMSO via UV-vis spectroscopy, we observed that tungsten compounds directly react to WVIO2 complexes while the Mo analogues first form µ-oxo Mo(V) dimers [Mo2O3L4]. Density functional theory calculations confirm that the oxygen atom abstraction from WVIO2 is an endergonic process contrasting the respective reaction with molybdenum. Here, we suggest that depending on the sacrificial oxygen acceptor, the tungsten complex may participate in catalysis either via a redox reaction or as an electrophile.

Synthesis and structure of two isomers of a molybdenum(II) 2-butyne complex stabilized by bioinspired S,N-bidentate ligands.

The synthesis and structural determination of two isomers of the molybdenum(II) complex (η2-but-2-yne)carbonylbis[2-(4,4-dimethyl-4,5-dihydro-1,3-oxazol-2-yl)benzenethiolato-κ2N,S]molybdenum(II), [Mo(C11H12NOS)2(C4H6)(CO)] or Mo(CO)(C2Me2)(S-Phoz)2, are presented. The N,N-cis-S,S-trans isomer 1 shows quite different bond lengths to the metal atom [Mo-N = 2.4715 (10) versus 2.3404 (11) Å; Mo-S = 2.4673 (3) versus 2.3665 (3) Å]. In the N,N-trans-S,S-cis isomer 2, which is isotypic with the corresponding W complex, the Mo-N bond lengths [2.236 (2) and 2.203 (2) Å], as well as the Mo-S bond lengths [2.5254 (8) and 2.5297 (8) Å], are almost the same.

Biallelic Variants in ENDOG Associated with Mitochondrial Myopathy and Multiple mtDNA Deletions.

Endonuclease G (ENDOG) is a nuclear-encoded mitochondrial-localized nuclease. Although its precise biological function remains unclear, its proximity to mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) makes it an excellent candidate to participate in mtDNA replication, metabolism and maintenance. Indeed, several roles for ENDOG have been hypothesized, including maturation of RNA primers during mtDNA replication, splicing of polycistronic transcripts and mtDNA repair. To date, ENDOG has been deemed as a determinant of cardiac hypertrophy, but no pathogenic variants or genetically defined patients linked to this gene have been described. Here, we report biallelic ENDOG variants identified by NGS in a patient with progressive external ophthalmoplegia, mitochondrial myopathy and multiple mtDNA deletions in muscle. The absence of the ENDOG protein in the patient's muscle and fibroblasts indicates that the identified variants are pathogenic. The presence of multiple mtDNA deletions supports the role of ENDOG in mtDNA maintenance; moreover, the patient's clinical presentation is very similar to mitochondrial diseases caused by mutations in other genes involved in mtDNA homeostasis. Although the patient's fibroblasts did not present multiple mtDNA deletions or delay in the replication process, interestingly, we detected an accumulation of low-level heteroplasmy mtDNA point mutations compared with age-matched controls. This may indicate a possible role of ENDOG in mtDNA replication or repair. Our report provides evidence of the association of ENDOG variants with mitochondrial myopathy.

The Effect of Pyridine-2-thiolate Ligands on the Reactivity of Tungsten Complexes toward Oxidation and Acetylene Insertion.

Intending to deepen our understanding of tungsten acetylene (C2H2) chemistry, with regard to the tungstoenzyme acetylene hydratase, here we explore the structure and reactivity of a series of tungsten acetylene complexes, stabilized with pyridine-2-thiolate ligands featuring tungsten in both +II and +IV oxidation states. By varying the substitution of the pyridine-2-thiolate moiety with respect to steric and electronic properties, we examined the details and limits of the previously reported intramolecular nucleophilic attack on acetylene followed by the formation of acetylene inserted complexes. Here, we demonstrate that only the combination of high steric demand and electron-withdrawing features prevents acetylene insertion. Nevertheless, although variable synthetic approaches are necessary for their synthesis, tungsten acetylene complexes can be stabilized predictably with a variety of pyridine-2-thiolate ligands.

Synthesis and Reactivity of a Bioinspired Molybdenum(IV) Acetylene Complex.

The isolation of a molybdenum(IV) acetylene (C2H2) complex containing two bioinspired 6-methylpyridine-2-thiolate ligands is reported. The synthesis can be performed either by oxidation of a molybdenum(II) C2H2 complex or by substitution of a coordinated PMe3 by C2H2 on a molybdenum(IV) center. Both C2H2 complexes were characterized by spectroscopic means as well as by single-crystal X-ray diffraction. Furthermore, the reactivity of the coordinated C2H2 was investigated with regard to acetylene hydratase, one of two enzymes that accept C2H2 as a substrate. While the reaction with water resulted in the vinylation of the pyridine-2-thiolate ligands, an intermolecular nucleophilic attack on the coordinated C2H2 with the soft nucleophile PMe3 was observed to give a cationic ethenyl complex. A comparison with the tungsten analogues revealed less tightly bound C2H2 in the molybdenum variant, which, however, shows a higher reactivity toward nucleophiles.

Bioinspired Nucleophilic Attack on a Tungsten-Bound Acetylene: Formation of Cationic Carbyne and Alkenyl Complexes.

Inspired by the proposed inner-sphere mechanism of the tungstoenzyme acetylene hydratase, we have designed tungsten acetylene complexes and investigated their reactivity. Here, we report the first intermolecular nucleophilic attack on a tungsten-bound acetylene (C2H2) in bioinspired complexes employing 6-methylpyridine-2-thiolate ligands. By using PMe3 as a nucleophile, we isolated cationic carbyne and alkenyl complexes.

Vapochromism and Magnetochemical Switching of a Nickel(II) Paddlewheel Complex by Reversible NH3 Uptake and Release.

Reaction of [NiCl2 (PnH)4 ] (1) (PnH=6-tert-butyl-pyridazine-3-thione) with NiCl2 affords the binuclear paddlewheel (PW) complex [Ni2 (Pn)4 ] (2). Diamagnetic complex 2 is the first example of a PW complex capable of reversibly binding and releasing NH3 . The NH3 ligand in [Ni2 (Pn)4 (NH3 )] (2⋅NH3 ) enforces major spectroscopic and magnetic susceptibility changes, thus displaying vapochromic properties (λmax (2)=532 nm, λmax (2⋅NH3 )=518 nm) and magnetochemical switching (2: S=0; 2⋅NH3 : S=1). Upon repeated adsorption/desorption cycles of NH3 the PW core remains intact. Compound 2 can be embedded into thin polyurethane films (2P ) under retention of its sensing abilities. Therefore, 2 qualifies as reversible optical probe for ammonia. The magnetochemical switching of 2 and 2⋅NH3 was studied in detail by SQUID measurements showing that in 2⋅NH3 , solely the Ni atom coordinated the NH3 molecule is responsible for the paramagnetic behavior.

Current and New Next-Generation Sequencing Approaches to Study Mitochondrial DNA.

Mitochondria harbor multiple copies of a maternally inherited nonnuclear genome. Point mutations, deletions, or depletion of the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) are associated with various human diseases. mtDNA defects are currently studied using Sanger sequencing, Southern blot, and long and quantitative PCR. However, these technologies are expensive and are limited in speed, throughput, and sensitivity. Recently, next-generation sequencing (NGS) has been used to study mtDNA defects; however, its potential applications still need to be fully validated. We analyzed mtDNA from 16 control samples and 33 affected samples, which were previously investigated by traditional techniques. Different NGS approaches were tested, using classic library preparation based on PCR amplifications and an innovative PCR-free protocol, defining their suitability and utility for: i) generating full accurate mtDNA sequence, ii) assessing heteroplasmy for single point mutations with high accuracy, and iii) detecting break positions and heteroplasmy of single large deletions. This study confirmed that PCR-based library preparations are appropriate for the first two points and showed that a new PCR-free method gave the best results for the third aim. This study tested different approaches and describes an innovative PCR-free protocol, suitable for detection and heteroplasmy quantification of mtDNA single large deletions. NGS may become the method of choice for genetic analysis on mtDNA.

Hydroalkylation of Aryl Alkenes with Organohalides Catalyzed by Molybdenum Oxido Based Lewis Pairs.

Three molybdenum(VI) dioxido complexes [MoO2(L)2] bearing Schiff base ligands were reacted with B(C6F5)3 to afford the corresponding adducts [MoO{OB(C6F5)3}(L)2], which were fully characterized. They exhibit Frustrated Lewis-Pairs reactivity when reacting with silanes. Especially, the [MoO{OB(C6F5)3}(L)2] complex with L=2,4-dimethyl-6-((phenylimino)methyl)phenol proved to be active as catalyst for the hydroalkylation of aryl alkenes with organohalides and for the Atom-Transfer Radical Addition (ATRA) of organohalides to aliphatic alkenes. A series of gem-dichloride and gem-dibromide compounds with potential for further derivatization were synthesized from simple alkenes and organohalides, like chloroform or bromoform, using low catalyst loading.

Oxygen Atom Transfer Reactivity of Molybdenum(VI) Complexes Employing Pyrimidine- and Pyridine-2-thiolate Ligands.

Four dioxidomolybdenum(VI) complexes of the general structure [MoO2L2] employing the S,N-bidentate ligands pyrimidine-2-thiolate (PymS, 1), pyridine-2-thiolate (PyS, 2), 4-methylpyridine-2-thiolate (4-MePyS, 3) and 6-methylpyridine-2-thiolate (6-MePyS, 4) were synthesized and characterized by spectroscopic means and single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis (2-4). Complexes 1-4 were reacted with PPh3 and PMe3, respectively, to investigate their oxygen atom transfer (OAT) reactivity and catalytic applicability. Reduction with PPh3 leads to symmetric molybdenum(V) dimers of the general structure [Mo2O3L4] (6-9). Kinetic studies showed that the OAT from [MoO2L2] to PPh3 is 5 times faster for the PymS system than for the PyS and 4-MePyS systems. The reaction of complexes 1-3 with PMe3 gives stable molybdenum(IV) complexes of the structure [MoOL2(PMe3)2] (10-12), while reduction of [MoO2(6-MePyS)2] (4) yields [MoO(6-MePyS)2(PMe3)] (13) with only one PMe3 coordinated to the metal center. The activity of complexes 1-4 in catalytic OAT reactions involving Me2SO and Ph2SO as oxygen donors and PPh3 as an oxygen acceptor has been investigated to assess the influence of the varied ligand frameworks on the OAT reaction rates. It was found that [MoO2(PymS)2] (1) and [MoO2(6-MePyS)2] (4) are similarly efficient catalysts, while complexes 2 and 3 are only moderately active. In the catalytic oxidation of PMe3 with Me2SO, complex 4 is the only efficient catalyst. Complexes 1-4 were also found to catalytically reduce NO3- with PPh3, although their reactivity is inhibited by further reduced species such as NO, as exemplified by the formation of the nitrosyl complex [Mo(NO)(PymS)3] (14), which was identified by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis. Computed ΔG⧧ values for the very first step of the OAT were found to be lower for complexes 1 and 4 than for 2 and 3, explaining the difference in catalytic reactivity between the two pairs and revealing the requirement for an electron-deficient ligand system.