An evidence-based approach to red blood cell transfusions in asymptomatically anaemic patients.

INTRODUCTION: Surgeons and physicians encounter blood transfusions on a daily basis but a robust evidence-based strategy on indications and timing of transfusion in asymptomatic anaemic patients is yet to be determined. For judicious use of blood products, the risks inherent to packed red blood cells, the patient's co-morbidities and haemoglobin (Hb)/haematocrit levels should be considered. This review critiques and summarises the latest available evidence on the indications for transfusions in healthy and cardiac disease patients as well as the timing of transfusions relative to surgery. METHODS: An electronic literature search of the MEDLINE(®), Google Scholar™ and Trip databases was conducted for articles published in English between January 2006 and January 2015. Studies discussing timing and indications of transfusion in medical and surgical patients were retrieved. Bibliographies of studies were checked for other pertinent articles that were missed by the initial search. FINDINGS: Six level 1 studies (randomised controlled trials or systematic reviews) and six professional society guidelines were included in this review. In healthy patients without cardiac disease, a restrictive transfusion trigger of Hb 70-80g/l is safe and appropriate whereas in cardiac patients, the trigger is Hb 80-100g/l. The literature on timing of transfusions relative to surgery is limited. For the studies available, preoperative transfusions were associated with a decreased incidence of subsequent transfusions and timing of transfusions did not affect the rates of colorectal cancer recurrence.

The anatomy of a weight recidivism and revision bariatric surgical clinic.

Abstract. Weight recidivism in bariatric surgery failure is multifactorial. It ranges from inappropriate patient selection for primary surgery to technical/anatomic issues related to the original surgery. Most bariatric surgeons and centers focus on primary bariatric surgery while weight recidivism and its complications are very much secondary concerns. Methods. We report on our initial experience having established a dedicated weight recidivism and revisional bariatric surgery clinic. A single surgeon, dedicated nursing, dieticians, and psychologist developed care maps, goals of care, nonsurgical candidate rules, and discharge planning strategies. Results. A single year audit (2012) of clinical activity revealed 137 patients, with a mean age 49 ± 10.1 years (6 years older on average than in our primary clinic), 75% of whom were women with BMI 47 ± 11.5. Over three quarters had undergone a vertical band gastroplasty while 15% had had a laparoscopic adjustable gastric band. Only 27% of those attending clinic required further surgery. As for primary surgery, the role of the obesity expert clinical psychologist was a key component to achieving successful revision outcomes. Conclusion. With an exponential rise in obesity and a concomitant major increase in bariatric surgery, an inevitable increase in revisional surgery is becoming a reality. Anticipating this increase in activity, Alberta Health Services, Alberta, Canada, has established a unique and dedicated clinic whose early results are promising.

Referral rate to oncologists and its variation by hospital for colorectal cancer patients.

BACKGROUND: Recent population-based studies in Alberta, Canada, found that approximately 50% of patients with stage III colon or stages II/III rectal adenocarcinoma did not receive guideline-recommended treatment (surgery plus chemotherapy or chemoradiation); a primary reason was not having an oncologist consult. We assessed the relationship between the hospital where the surgery was performed and the probability of a patient not having an oncologist consult. METHODS: All patients diagnosed with stage III colon or stage II/III rectal adenocarcinoma between 2002 and 2005 in Alberta who had surgery were identified from the Alberta Cancer Registry and included in the study. Multivariable logistic regression modeling with hospitals as random effects was used to estimate cancer-type-specific odds ratios of not having an oncologist consult for each hospital, adjusted for age, sex, and comorbidities, relative to the overall nonconsultation rate. RESULTS: Overall, 21% of stage III colon, 25% of stage II rectal, and 13% of stage III rectal adenocarcinoma patients did not have an oncologist consult. Rates varied appreciably across hospitals and between cancer types within hospitals, even after the case-mix adjustment (adjusted odds ratios of nonconsultation ranged from 0.4 to 8.1). Small hospitals that performed 12 or fewer surgeries had nearly 100% consultation rates. CONCLUSIONS: The variation in oncologist-consult rates, particularly for stage II rectal cancer patients, is concerning. We are presenting the findings to the surgical community and discussing interventions to improve oncologist-consult rates.

Survival in rectal cancer is predicted by T cell infiltration of tumour-associated lymphoid nodules.

Lymphoid nodules are a normal component of the mucosa of the rectum, but little is known about their function and whether they contribute to the host immune response in malignancy. In rectal cancer specimens from patients with local (n=18), regional (n=12) and distant (n=10) disease, we quantified T cell (CD3, CD25) and dendritic cell (CD1a, CD83) levels at the tumour margin as well as within tumour-associated lymphoid nodules. In normal tissue CD3+, but not CD25+, T cells are concentrated at high levels within lymphoid nodules, with significantly fewer cells found in surrounding normal mucosa (P=0.001). Mature (CD83), but not immature (CD1a), dendritic cells in normal tissue are also found clustered almost exclusively within lymphoid nodules (P=<0.0001). In rectal tumours, both CD3+ T cells (P=0.004) and CD83+ dendritic cells (P=0.0001) are also localized preferentially within tumour-associated lymphoid nodules. However, when comparing tumour specimens to normal rectal tissue, the average density of CD3+ T cells (P=0.0005) and CD83+ dendritic cells (P=0.0006) in tumour-associated lymphoid nodules was significantly less than that seen in lymphoid nodules in normal mucosa. Interestingly, regardless of where quantified, T cell and dendritic cell levels did not depend upon the stage of disease. Increased CD3+ T cell infiltration of tumour-associated lymphoid nodules predicted improved survival, independent of stage (P=0.05). Other T cell (CD25) markers and different levels of CD1a+ or CD83+ dendritic cells did not predict survival. Tumour-associated lymphoid nodules, enriched in dendritic cells and T cells, may be an important site for antigen presentation and increased T cell infiltration may be a marker for improved survival.

Procedural skills: what's taught in medical school, what ought to be?

BACKGROUND: Medical schools' instruction of skills is often found to be inadequate. In 1999, the American Association of Medical Colleges (AAMC) published a list of eight procedural skills that medical students are recommended to learn. This study aims to evaluate compliance with these guidelines and to examine the instruction of other skills to determine if the most important skills receive adequate instruction. METHODS: In 2004, surveys were sent to 138 educational representatives at North American (AAMC) medical schools and 1208 Canadian family physicians. The survey addressed the importance of selected skills. Findings were analyzed by chi2 testing. RESULTS: Of the eight skills recommended by the AAMC, only four were taught by all schools. All eight, except for suturing, and most of the other skills, were taught at a higher rate than they were practiced. Only digital block anesthesia was practiced more commonly than it was taught. CONCLUSION: Although guidelines exist for skills instruction in medical school, they are not followed completely. Furthermore, the guidelines may reflect an emphasis on skills that are more suited to specialist rather than general practice. This may come at the expense of the instruction of other more practical skills.

What procedures are students doing during undergraduate surgical clerkship?

BACKGROUND: Many North American medical schools have removed didactic surgical teaching from the nonclinical years, and there has been a trend toward shortening surgical clerkships. Of concern is that this policy has led to a decrease in surgical exposure and a diminished interest in students pursuing a surgical career. We aimed to determine the effect of curricular change on practical experiences during surgical clerkship and to evaluate overall practical clinical exposure of students during surgical clerkship. METHODS: We collected validated experience logbooks completed before (1999-2001) and after (2001-2003) the curriculum change at the University of Alberta and converted them into electronic format. The study analyzed 10 procedures and 5 patient management situations. We assessed numbers of procedures performed and student performance on the Objective Structured Clinical Exam (OSCE) and Multiple-Choice Question (MCQ) examinations before and after the curriculum change. In addition, we completed an overall survey of all 4 classes (2000, 2001, 2002, 2003), measuring clinical exposure. We reviewed a total of 428 logbooks. RESULTS: There were significant gaps in clinical exposure, which was demonstrated by more than 70% of students in each class failing to complete 8 of 15 procedures or managements at least once. No significant change in practical surgical exposure resulted from the curriculum change. The curriculum change did result in a decrease in end-of-rotation MCQ score performance, which was demonstrated by a 5% decrease in the class average after the curriculum change. Students' performance on ward evaluations and their OSCE scores were unaffected. CONCLUSION: We were encouraged that a major change in how surgical education is delivered did not have a detrimental effect on subjective and objective evaluations of student performance. However, we are concerned that a considerable number of students appeared to have not performed several inpatient procedures. Further study is warranted to determine whether this is a common problem in other schools. There is a clear need at our school, and no doubt at others, to establish skills centres and other strategies to ensure that this component of medical education is appropriately and effectively taught.

Gastric cancer: establishing predictors of biologic behavior with use of population-based data.

BACKGROUND: Tumor thickness and nodal status are important predictors of survival following curative resection for gastric cancer. Lymphovascular invasion (LVI) is a potential predictor of biological behavior. The relationship between LVI and tumor thickness (T status) has not been established in population-based studies. METHODS: Clinicopathological and survival data of 577 patients at nine centers, from between 1991 and 1997, was collected from patient records and a Provincial Cancer Registry. The primary endpoint of the study was death. A secondary analysis of a node-negative subgroup examined the significance of LVI with respect to T status. RESULTS: The population disease-specific survival was 28%. In a multivariate analysis, T, N, M, esophageal margin, tumor morphology, and residual tumor category were independent predictors of survival. LVI was documented in 58% of resected tumors. LVI correlated with advancing T and N status but was not significant in a multivariate population model. Subgroup analysis of node-negative gastric cancer found T status and LVI to be independent predictors of survival. LVI was associated with a 5-year survival of 8%, versus 43% among patients in whom it was absent (P <.001). CONCLUSIONS: T status and N status were the most important independent predictors of survival in a population-based study of gastric cancer. LVI correlated with advancing N and T status. Multivariate analysis of node-negative patients showed LVI and T status are independent predictors of survival.

Prophylaxis in elective colorectal surgery: the cost of ignoring the evidence.

INTRODUCTION: Three strategies are used to prevent complications in colorectal surgery: heparin and antibiotics given perioperatively and abdominal drains placed intraoperatively. To investigate the appropriate and inappropriate use of these prophylactic techniques and to assess the costs associated with their inappropriate use, we studied patients who underwent elective colorectal procedures. METHODS: We reviewed the charts of 103 patients operated on between April and December 1999 at a 519-bed tertiary care, teaching hospital in Edmonton, Alta. The procedures carried out were elective sigmoid resection, low anterior resection, left hemicolectomy, right hemicolectomy and total or subtotal colectomy for benign or malignant conditions. The data collected included patient age and sex, diagnosis, the operating surgeon, and the housestaff or surgeon writing the pre- and postoperative orders. Patients who required emergency colorectal surgery were excluded from the study. Antibiotic, heparin and drain prophylaxis was assessed and considered appropriate if prescribed according to the evidence or inappropriate if prescribed when not recommended. RESULTS: Thirty-six of 98 patients had inappropriate heparin prophylaxis (5 of the 103 were excluded because they were already receiving heparin). Only 5 of 96 patients were treated appropriately with antibiotics preoperatively without postoperative doses (7 of the 103 were excluded due to intraoperative spillage with fecal contamination or an intra-abdominal abscess found intraoperatively); 95% of patients were inappropriately treated with antibiotics postoperatively. Half of all the patients had a drain inserted inappropriately for prophylaxis. On average, drains inserted inappropriately cost 30.40 dollars per patient, inappropriate antibiotic use cost 62.42 dollars per patient and inappropriate heparin use cost 89.30 dollars per patient. Preoperative orders were usually written by the staff surgeon, whereas postoperative orders were usually written by the resident or intern. CONCLUSIONS: We observed considerable inappropriate use of heparin, antibiotic and drain prophylaxis. Considering the number of elective colorectal procedures performed annually, these inappropriately used strategies represent a substantial cost to the health care system. Improved education of surgeons and residents is needed to change to evidence-based practice habits.

Perceptions of intimidation in the psychiatric educational environment in Edmonton, Alberta.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the perceptions of intimidation in the psychiatric educational environment in Edmonton, Alberta. METHODS: We distributed a 7-point modified Likert scale questionnaire that included questions with respect to intimidation perceptions and experience in psychiatry during a 1-week period to all student interns on psychiatry rotations, residents, and teaching faculty in the 5 teaching hospitals in Edmonton. RESULTS: A total of 92 individuals responded, with response rates of 81% for faculty, 82% for residents, and 84% for students. Response rates did not differ among sites. While there were differences between site and group with respect to comparing the perceived intimidation in psychiatry with other specialties, respondents did not view psychiatry as worse than other specialties. Although, overall, women perceived intimidation as more prevalent at their sites than did men, the overall means reflect sites that are relatively free from intimidation. Faculty and student interns within sites, except for the university hospital, tended to disagree on management's approach to perceived intimidation. All groups, however, reported little personal experience and felt their sites had little tolerance for intimidators. CONCLUSIONS: Reported perceptions and personal experiences of intimidation within the psychiatric learning environment in Edmonton are low.

A rare association between acromegaly and pheochromocytoma.

The occurrence of multiple endocrine tumors is rare; however, they may be found with hereditary diseases such as multiple endocrine neoplasia (MEN). The endocrine tumors involved with these diseases are well documented. We present a case of a patient with a pheochromocytoma and a growth hormone (GH) secreting pituitary adenoma. This association is not described with any of the known MEN syndromes. The association may be a cross-over MEN syndrome or a secondarily induced GH-secreting pituitary adenoma from a pheochromocytoma producing growth hormone releasing hormone (GHRH) instead of catecholamines.

Amputation and the prevention of phantom pain.

Although it has been proposed that preoperative analgesia with epidural administration of analgesics may prevent long-term phantom pain, published results to date have been contradictory and controversial. In this case report, we describe a 41-year-old man with local recurrence of squamous cell carcinoma of the anus who underwent a hemipelvectomy. Preoperatively he had a significant neuropathic pain syndrome requiring oxycodone 60 mg every 4 hours. An epidural infusion of morphine and bupivacaine was started 24 hours preoperatively and discontinued on the third postoperative day. Over the next 10 days the oxycodone was gradually decreased and eventually discontinued prior to discharge. A review of the literature reveals conflicting reports on the benefit of preoperative epidural pain management in the prevention of postoperative pain syndromes. Conflicting research and conclusions of commentators leaves unanswered questions for clinicians. Nevertheless, we do know that we need to provide the best pain relief for patients both before and after amputation. This may require a combination of the oral, subcutaneous or intravenous, and epidural routes.

Speed of healing and symptom relief in grade II to IV gastroesophageal reflux disease: a meta-analysis.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Esophagitis healing proportions are often incorrectly called the healing rate. The aim of this study was to compare different drug classes by expressing the speed of healing and symptom relief through a new approach. METHODS: A fully recursive literature search to July 1996 identified 43 articles on gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) (7635 patients) meeting strict inclusion criteria: single- or double-blind randomized studies in adults with endoscopically proven erosive or ulcerative esophagitis. For each drug class, linear regression analysis estimated the average percentage of patients who were healed and heartburn free per week. RESULTS: Mean overall healing proportion irrespective of drug dose or treatment duration (< or =12 weeks) was highest with proton pump inhibitors (PPIs; 83.6% +/- 11.4%) vs. H2-receptor antagonists (H2RAs; 51.9% +/- 17.1%), sucralfate (39.2% +/- 22.4%), or placebo (28.2% +/- 15.6%). Correcting for patients without baseline heartburn, the mean heartburn-free proportion was highest with PPIs (77.4% +/- 10.4%) vs. H2RAs (47.6% +/- 15.5%). PPIs showed a significantly faster healing rate (11.7%/wk) vs. H2RAs (5.9%/wk) and placebo (2.9%/wk). PPIs provided faster, more complete heartburn relief (11.5%/wk) vs. H2RAs (6.4%/wk). CONCLUSIONS: More complete esophagitis healing and heartburn relief is observed with PPIs vs. H2RAs and occurs nearly twice as fast. This semiquantitative expression of speed of healing and symptom relief permits comparisons for future economic evaluation and quality-of-life assessments.

Effect of surgical experience on results of esophagectomy for esophageal carcinoma.

BACKGROUND: Esophagectomy for esophageal cancer is associated with substantial operative morbidity and mortality. The effect of surgical experience on results of esophagectomy has received little attention in the medical literature. METHODS: A retrospective review of esophagectomies for cancer was done. RESULTS: Seventy-four patients underwent esophagectomy by 20 different surgeons. Three surgeons performed 6 or more esophagectomies per year ("frequent" surgeons), whereas the other 17 surgeons performed 5 or fewer esophagectomies per year ("occasional" surgeons). Forty-two patients were operated on by frequent surgeons. There were 3 (7%) anastomotic leaks and no deaths. In 32 patients operated on by occasional surgeons, there were 7 (22%) anastomotic leaks and 7 (22%) operative deaths. The anastomotic leak rates were not significantly different (P < .07), but frequent surgeons had a significantly lower operative mortality (P < .0014). CONCLUSIONS: Esophagectomy for esophageal cancer should be performed by experienced esophageal surgeons with sufficient yearly volume of procedures to maintain competence.

Artificial nutrition support in hospitals in the United Kingdom--1994: Third national survey.

OBJECTIVE: To determine how artificial nutrition support is used in hospitals in the United Kingdom and to determine whether there have been any alterations in practice when compared to similar studies in 1988 (1) and 1991 (2). DESIGN: A 94-question survey about artificial nutrition support (ANS) was sent to all district dietitians registered with the British Dietetic Association on 1 January 1994. Information was collected additionally from pharmacists, nutrition nurses and clinicians. RESULTS: 66.6% of questionnaires distributed were returned with analysable information. Of the respondents, 37.3% had access to nutrition support teams, compared with 27% in 1988. The documentation of usage of nutrition support was poor, only 33% of respondents being able to accurately quantify administration of enteral nutrition (EN), and 53% parenteral nutrition (PN). CONCLUSIONS: Despite increasing awareness about the role of artificial nutrition support, and the value of nutrition support teams there has only been a modest increase in the provision and monitoring of NSTs in the last 3 years. This has important implications when considering audit of such practices.

Open cholecystectomy: muscle splitting versus muscle dividing incision: a randomized study.

While laparoscopic cholecystectomy has become the standard procedure for symptomatic gallstones, it is likely that 10% of patients will require an open cholecystectomy whether owing to contraindications to the laparoscopic approach or because conversion to the open technique became necessary following laparoscopy. Although the trend towards smaller open cholecystectomy incisions has led to a reduced hospital stay, much of the postoperative morbidity can be ascribed to wound pain. Muscle splitting incisions tend to be less painful than muscle dividing incisions. This randomized consecutive study of elective and emergent open cholecystectomies compared a muscle splitting incision with the traditional muscle dividing technique. The muscle splitting technique was significantly (P < 0.001) less painful than the muscle dividing method as evaluated by the short form of the McGill pain questionnaire. Similarly, a significantly greater proportion of patients were fully mobile on the first and second postoperative day in the muscle splitting group compared with the muscle dividing group. Analgesia requirements, however, were not statistically significant between the two groups. We recommend that when open cholecystectomy is necessary the muscle splitting technique should be employed.

Improving visualization of distal and terminal ileum during the small bowel meal: an evaluation of fluoroscopic manoeuvres.

This study evaluated a variety of fluoroscopic manoeuvres used during small bowel meals for assessment of the terminal ileum and pelvic loops of small bowel. The purpose was to identify those manoeuvres which provide maximum diagnostic yield. Fifty-six consecutive patients undergoing small bowel meal and pneumocolon entered the study. The individual manoeuvres were graded and their contribution to diagnostic quality determined. An analysis of variance was used to determine the diagnostic value of the manoeuvres. There was a significant difference in the diagnostic quality provided by the different manoeuvres. Compression of the terminal ileum with the 'F spoon' and of the pelvic bowel loops with the compression paddle in the supine position provided the best diagnostic information in single contrast. The double contrast images obtained with the pneumocolon contributed most to the diagnostic quality of the examination. The results enable us to recommend a sequence of manoeuvres which are most likely to provide diagnostic views of the terminal ileum and pelvic ileal loops yielding maximum information and optimizing use of fluoroscopic time.

The value of endorectal ultrasonography in the follow-up of intracavitary radiation treated early rectal cancer.

In selected patients with early rectal cancer, intracavitary radiation is a successful treatment. Endorectal ultrasound has proved an accurate method for staging and selecting such cancers for treatment. The value of endorectal ultrasound in the follow-up of patients with intracavitary radiation has not been previously assessed. Between 1989 and 1991, 30 patients treated at the Hamilton Regional Cancer Centre with intracavitary radiation were assessed by endorectal ultrasound. The mean age was 65 +/- 12 years with a range of 37-78 years. There were 17 males and 13 females. All patients were treated with curative intent. The dose of radiation administered was 8963 +/- 1506 cGy over 3.5 +/- 0.7 fractions. No patient received supplemental iridium implantation. Thirty-seven endorectal ultrasounds were carried out in 30 of the intracavitary radiation treated patients. Clinical findings (digital, sigmoidoscopic, and histology) were compared with the radiologist's interpretation of the endorectal ultrasounds. Using a 2 x 2 table accepting the clinical findings as the 'Gold Standard', the sensitivity of endorectal ultrasound was 71%, the specificity 61%, the positive predictive value 53%, the negative predictive value 78% with an overall accuracy of 75%. We conclude that endorectal ultrasound in the routine follow-up of patients treated with intracavitary radiotherapy for carcinoma of the rectum is questionable.

The influence of age on the management of anal cancer.

The standard treatment for anal cancer is combination chemo-radiotherapy. Management decisions such as radical chemotherapy, resective surgery for poor response or relapse are frequently modified by age-associated comorbid factors. Between 1980 and 1990, our regional cancer center serving a population of 1.8 million saw 78 patients with squamous carcinoma of the anus. We have compared patients who were younger than 65 years (n = 38) with those older than 65 years (n = 38). The mean +/- standard deviation age for the whole cohort was 65 +/- 12 years, with a ratio of 2 females to each male presenting. Fewer of the elderly age group had major surgery (26% vs. 42%) (p = 0.03), and fewer suffered no toxicity (42% vs. 26%) (p = 0.03). However, 61% of the under-65-year age group are alive disease-free vs. 26% of the elderly group (p = 0.03). Similarly, only 18% of the under-65-year group died with disease compared with 37% of the elderly group (b = 0.03). For the series as a whole, the crude mortality was 42%, with 27% dying of their disease. The stage distribution, and the amount of radiotherapy or chemotherapy administered was not age-specific, but younger patients had more surgery and suffered more toxicity, with a greater proportion remaining alive and disease-free, and fewer dying of their disease. These data suggest that a more aggressive multi-modality approach in the elderly may improve disease response and survival.

Hepatic interstitial laser photocoagulation. An investigation of the relationship between acute thermal lesions and their sonographic images.

OBJECTIVES: The relationship between hepatic interstitial laser photocoagulation (ILP) lesions and their acute ultrasound images was evaluated. In addition, the natural history of ILP lesions in normal pig liver was documented. METHODS: Eighteen pigs underwent laparotomy and ultrasound-monitored ILP. In part 1 of the study, 12 pigs each had four separate exposures (1.50 W for 60, 100, 300, and 500 seconds) and were divided into four groups according to when they were killed (0, 3, 7, and 21 days). In part 2 of the study, six pigs each had two sequential exposures (1.60 W for 1,000 and then 500 seconds) at separate hepatic sites. Survival time was 3 days. Necropsy and histologic examination were performed in all animals. In 0- and 3-day survivors, actual thermal lesions were compared with "early" (immediately after ILP) and "late" (1 hour after ILP) ultrasound images. RESULTS: In the 300-, 500-, and 1,000-second exposures of parts 1 and 2, thermal lesions were overestimated or approximated by early ultrasound and were underestimated or approximated by late ultrasound. Analysis of variance showed statistically significant differences between thermal lesions and their early and late ultrasound images (F = 18.6, P < .001, no interactions). Time-growth characteristics of ILP lesions were reasonably consistent on ultrasound; exceptions were identifiable 200 seconds into the exposure. In part 2, ultrasound changes were minimal in five of six 500-second (second sequential) technically satisfactory exposures. Thermal lesions were seen at necropsy. All lesions healed by formation of granulation tissue and collagen. CONCLUSIONS: During ILP, early ultrasound images frequently overestimate actual thermal lesions. Ultrasound-monitored ILP of tumors may be most effective if, on early ultrasound, echogenic changes extend beyond the tumor margins. Late ultrasound images underestimate or approximate thermal lesions. Their value in clinical ILP should be investigated. It is unclear why ultrasound images of proven thermal lesions were not seen during 5 of 6 otherwise satisfactory 500-second ILP exposures performed immediately after 1,000-second exposures.