Statistical support for uncertainty in radiological diagnosis.

Radiological interpretation and diagnosis involves the comparison and classification of complex medical images and is typical of the categorisation tasks that have been the subject of observational studies in Cognitive Science. This paper considers the affinity between statistical modelling and theories of categorisation for naturally occurring categories. Statistical based measures of similarity and typicality with a probabilistic interpretation are derived. The utilisation of these measures in the support of diagnosis under uncertainty via interactive overview plots is described. The application of the methodology to magnetic resonance imaging of the head is considered. The methods detailed have application to other fields involving archiving and retrieving of image data.

Structured computer-based training in the interpretation of neuroradiological images.

Computer-based systems may be able to address a recognised need throughout the medical profession for a more structured approach to training. We describe a combined training system for neuroradiology, the MR Tutor that differs from previous approaches to computer-assisted training in radiology in that it provides case-based tuition whereby the system and user communicate in terms of a well-founded Image Description Language. The system implements a novel method of visualisation and interaction with a library of fully described cases utilising statistical models of similarity, typicality and disease categorisation of cases. We describe the rationale, knowledge representation and design of the system, and provide a formative evaluation of its usability and effectiveness.

The story of the internal carotid artery of mammals: from Galen to sudden infant death syndrome.

Some anatomical aspects of the blood supply of the brains of mammals have been examined to illuminate their functions. A fundamental explanation of sudden infant death syndrome (cot death) is suggested following experimental observations. Speculative contributions have been made to comparative physiological ideas concerning mammals of pronograde and erect habitus, their vascular pressure adaptations and temperature management. Neuro- and interventional radiologists may make some significant future applications of these ideas. Of immediate practical interest is the possibility of influencing the well-being of human embryos' neural tube development in utero by a comprehensive study of their temperature environment.

Patterns of disease activity in multiple sclerosis patients: a study with quantitative gadolinium-enhanced brain MRI and cytokine measurement in different clinical subgroups.

In this study we assessed the subclinical disease activity in 45 patients with primary progressive, secondary progressive or relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (MS). The patients had gadolinium-enhanced brain MRI scans, which were analysed using a semiquantitative method both for lesion load and for degree of enhancement. At the same time cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and serum samples were collected and, from these, cytokine levels were measured in most cases by enzyme-linked immunoassay using commercially available kits. Enhancing lesions on MRI were found in 73% of the patients. The sensitivity of this test was greatly increased by our method of analysis as far as the primary progressive patients are concerned (70% vs 40% for conventional evaluation). CSF interleukin-1 beta (IL-1 beta) levels were above the normal range in 22% and IL-6 levels in 13% of patients, while tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) was undetectable or below the upper normal limits in all the samples tested. Serum IL-1 beta was above the normal limits in 40%, IL-6 in 42% and TNF-alpha in 7% of patients. No significant differences in cytokine profiles were found between the clinical subgroups. This study confirms the high sensitivity of gadolinium-enhanced MRI in detecting MS activity, which was further increased by our method of analysis. Longitudinal studies performed with more sensitive immunological techniques are needed to define better the relationship between cytokine, clinical and MRI data in MS patients.

Age determination of common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus) by radiographic examination of skeletal development.

Seventy-four animals were examined radiographically to determine the skeletal development of the common marmoset (Callithrix jacchus) from 6 months of age. Twenty-one epiphyses were examined and five stages of ossification were described for each. The animals were divided into nine groups, according to age, and a table of the stage of ossification and age was produced, which may be used for determining the age of animals of unknown history.

The measurement of blood flow waveforms from X-ray angiography. Part 1: Principles of the method and preliminary validation.

The principles and implementation of a method for measurement of blood flow waveforms from X-ray angiography are described. Contrast medium mass values are obtained at multitudinous positions along individual vessels and from numerous images in a time sequence. These values are represented as a matrix of grey levels in a parametric image. This image is normalized to represent contrast medium concentration, and the movement over time of isoconcentration portions of the contrast bolus is recovered to determine blood flow. Preliminary validation has been undertaken using parametric images generated in two ways: synthesis from a computer model of vascular pulsatile flow and analysis of cine-angiograms of physical models (plastic and perspex tubes) carrying known pulsatile flows. Two distinct methods for interrogation of parametric images by digital image processing were employed; both provided accurate flow measurements.

The measurement of blood flow waveforms from X-ray angiography. Part 2: Application to video recordings of digital subtraction angiography.

A method of measuring blood flow from X-ray angiograms recorded on cine film, by obtaining contrast mass values at numerous positions along individual vessels and at multiple instants of time, has been previously reported. In the present work it was hypothesized that the signal-to-noise limitations of recordings on video tape could be overcome by recording already-subtracted angiograms from a digital subtraction angiographic (DSA) system and that the spatial resolution of video was adequate to use a similar measurement method. Validation experiments were recorded, in which flows measured using a calibrated electromagnetic flowmeter passed through tubes of 4-7 mm diameter, during injections of 2-5 ml contrast medium. The video sequences were computer analysed and produced angiographic flow measurements agreeing with the electromagnetic flows to within 5 per cent. A case study of a clinical carotid artery DSA in a patient with secondary carcinoma metastases in the brain is described. It is concluded that accurate flow measurements can be made from DSA video recordings.

Volume measurement of multiple sclerosis lesions with magnetic resonance images. A preliminary study.

The ability to visualise multiple sclerosis lesions in vivo with magnetic resonance imaging suggests an important role in monitoring the course of the disease. In order to help the long-term assessment of prospective treatments, a semi-automated technique for measuring lesion volume has been developed to provide a quantitative index of disease progression. Results are presented from a preliminary study with a single patient and compared to measurements taken from lesion outlines traced by a neuroradiologist, two neurologists and a technician. The semi-automated technique achieved a precision of 6% compared to a range of 12-33% for the manual tracing method. It also reduced the human interaction time from at least 60 min to 15 min.

Frequent involvement of the optic radiation in patients with acute isolated optic neuritis.

Magnetic resonance imaging revealed asymptomatic lesions in white matter regions corresponding with the optic radiations in 20 of 28 patients (71%) with clinically isolated optic neuritis. In contrast to the findings with symptomatic lesions, there was no relationship between the latency of the visual evoked potential and the presence of these asymptomatic posterior visual pathway lesions.

Correlation of SEP abnormalities with brain and cervical cord MRI in multiple sclerosis.

In 31 patients with definite or suspected multiple sclerosis (MS) presenting with a cervical cord syndrome, somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) were recorded to median and posterior tibial nerve stimulation, using cephalic and noncephalic reference electrodes. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain and cervical spinal cord was performed, the latter in sagittal and axial views. SEPs were abnormal in 67.7% of patients, whereas MRI showed cervical cord lesions in 74.2% and intracranial lesions possibly involving the somatosensory pathways in 64.5% of cases. A significant correlation was found between abnormalities of cervical (N13) and cortical (N20) potentials following median nerve stimulation with Fz reference and MRI abnormalities involving the ipsilateral or posterior half of the cervical cord, but not the contralateral or anterior half. The N13 potential, recorded from the low cervical region to a supraglottal reference, was most frequently abnormal in patients with MRI lesions at C6 or C7, whereas P14, recorded from the scalp to a clavicle reference, was most often affected by lesions at Cl or the cervicomedullary junction. Abnormalities of the cortical P40 to tibial nerve stimulation were less significantly correlated with cervical MRI lesions. The latency of N20 measured from N9 at the clavicle and the absolute latency of P40 were significantly correlated with the length of MRI abnormalities in the ipsilateral cervical cord. No significant correlation was observed between SEP abnormalities and brain MRI lesions, which it was considered might possibly involve the intracranial somatosensory pathways. It was concluded that (1) the morphological lesions seen in MRI of the cervical cord usually give rise to appropriate electrophysiological deficits, but the occasional finding of a widespread MRI lesion with normal SEP suggests that myelin damage is not the only or the major factor responsible for abnormal MRI signal; and (2) 'clinically silent' lesions apparently involving the radiations and other sensory structures of the brain appear not to give rise to detectable SEP abnormalities, using the methods of the present study.

Comparing the cost of spinal MR with conventional myelography and radiculography.

All spinal magnetic resonance imaging examinations carried out during a three month period were analysed retrospectively in order to determine the clinical reasons for the scan requests. Technical details of the examinations they received and the clinical profiles formed a data set which revealed 10 separate "Clinical groups" for management purposes. Hardware, salary and expendables were costed as though the imaging unit had been sited within a National Health Service radiology department. A spread sheet was designed capable of calculating costs per patient for a variety of types of working week and of different staffing structures, sensitive to the mixture of clinical groups referred for examination. The spreadsheet also accomodated straight line depreciation for hardware value and interest rates for borrowed capital. A second, prospectively observed, sample of spinal MR examinations was used to improve the accuracy of the timing of the length of patient examinations. Costs were compared with those for patients submitted for myelography and radiculography at the adjacent hospital during the same period. The comparison indicated that spinal MR was less costly than myelography and radiculography. The most important element of the extra cost of myelography related to the need to admit patients to hospital for at least one night for this examination because of the likelihood of headache and other common (though usually minor) complications following lumbar puncture and/or the injection of contrast medium. From the limited information that it was possible to obtain in the period of follow up, it appeared that MR had either been superior or equivalent to myelography or radiculography in all the clinical groups of patients where both could be tested. There were a number of groups in which no myelograms had been requested, presumably because clinical suspicions had pointed toward conditions like tumours, developmental abnormalities and demyelinating diseases in which neurologists and neurosurgeons have already made up their minds about the superiority of MR.

Evaluation of computer advisor in the interpretation of CT images of the head.

This paper describes the evaluation of a computer advisor system (BRAINS), which was constructed to aid in the interpretation of CT images of the head. It was developed at the National Hospital for Nervous Diseases, Queen Square, London. The system was transferred, without difficulty, to an 'external', that is previously unassociated, site (the Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University of Manchester) for an external evaluation. Response of external users to the system was mixed. Many were unfamiliar with the concept of formal description of images and the evaluation demonstrated the need for a person to person training programme. Users who accessed the HELP facilities most frequently were the most successful in obtaining accurate descriptions and hence satisfactory diagnostic advice. An objective appraisal of user's success in describing images to obtain the correct diagnosis as first choice indicated that, in general, the system performed well.

Towards an advisor for MRI.

This paper discusses the role of a computer advisor in MR image acquisition, interpretation and the diagnosis of cerebral disease. The development of an image and statistical database for use in providing advice is described.

Magnetic resonance imaging in isolated noncompressive spinal cord syndromes.

The frequency with which patients presenting with acute or chronic noncompressive cord syndromes subsequently develop multiple sclerosis is uncertain. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed on 121 patients with such syndromes to determine the frequency of asymptomatic brain lesions and to assess the sensitivity of MRI in detecting the local cord lesion. MRI findings were compared with those from visual, brainstem, and somatosensory evoked potentials (VEPs, BAEPs, SEPs), and cerebrospinal fluid electrophoresis. Lesions were seen in the appropriate cord region in 47 of 73 patients (64%) with a cervical syndrome, and in 7 of 25 patients (28%) with a thoracic or lumbar syndrome. MRI demonstrated more cervical lesions than did SEPs, but fewer thoracic or lumbar lesions. Cord swelling was seen in 6 patients and atrophy in 10. Of those with acute syndromes, abnormalities were seen with brain MRI in 18 of 32 patients (56%), with VEPs in 2 of 30 patients (7%), and with BAEPs in 2 of 24 patients (8%). In patients with chronic syndromes, abnormalities were seen with brain MRI in 73 of 89 patients (82%), with VEPs in 22 of 80 patients (28%), and with BAEPs in 12 of 62 patients (19%). Brain MRI was thus more sensitive than evoked potentials were in establishing multiplicity of lesions. However, in acute syndromes, it was not possible to diagnose multiple sclerosis from a single abnormal brain scan in chronic syndromes, a diagnosis of clinically probable multiple sclerosis could be made from one scan, provided there was no better explanation for the abnormalities: the added presence of oligoclonal bands allows a diagnosis of laboratory-supported, definite multiple sclerosis as was the case in 28 patients in this series.

Brains--a computer advisor system to aid in CT scan interpretation and cerebral disease diagnosis.

This paper describes a prototype system to aid in the radiological interpretation of CT scan images of patients with cerebral disease. The system is able to provide guidance, both on diagnosis and the need for enhancement.

Computer-assisted myelography in cervical spondylotic myelopathy and radiculopathy. Clinical correlations and pathogenetic mechanisms.

A total of 53 patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy and/or radiculopathy were studied with computer-assisted myelography following metrizamide myelography. Cervical cord deformities resulting from spondylotic protrusions were classified into four groups. The A shape (anterior central concavity) is the commonest and is often associated clinically with bilateral anterolateral and posterior column deficits. In the B shape (lateral deformity on one side), unilateral anterolateral column and root signs, usually mild, predominate. The symptomatology of the C shape (lateral deformity on both sides) and the D shape (flattened anterior surface) is bilateral, although not often symmetrical, and includes anterolateral and posterior column disturbances and root signs. Radiculopathy may, however, occur in the absence of cord deformity if the spondylotic lesion is close to or inside the intervertebral foramen. As there is some relationship between cord shapes and symptomatology, the decision as to whether a particular deformity is responsible for the clinical presentation may be made with more confidence. Moreover, the degree of cord deformity correlates well with the severity of symptomatology. Those with mild deformity had relatively few or mild cord signs, whereas in those with severe deformity cord signs were numerous and severe. Certain observations on cord deformity in vivo support the view that compression is an important pathogenetic mechanism in cervical spondylotic myelopathy. Most patients had anterior cord compression and the anterolateral signs were more frequent and marked. Severity of cord signs is associated with the degree of compression. Removal of the compression is followed by re-expansion of the cord and clinical improvement. In a small number of cases where cord compression by osteophytic protrusion was mild, and where clinical improvement followed the removal of the protrusion, the theory of cord traction and friction appears to apply. The contribution of other mechanical factors and of ischaemia to cord damage is also discussed.

Disseminated lesions at presentation in patients with optic neuritis.

Thirty five adults and two children with clinically isolated optic neuritis were examined by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to determine the presence of disseminated lesions within the brain at presentation and to compare these findings with the results of evoked potential studies. Of the adult patients, 61% showed lesions on the scans whereas the evoked potentials suggested the presence of lesions outside the visual system in 30%. MRI is a sensitive method for the demonstration of clinically unsuspected lesions in patients with uncomplicated optic neuritis.

Cerebral arterial constriction due to contrast media.

Angiography, either with Iohexol or Hexabrix, was carried out on a series of baboons, each of which had both contrast media, but on separate occasions. A double blind trial showed that in the carotid and middle cerebral arteries: Hexabrix generally caused vasoconstriction by 1.5 min, but in spite of a subsequent injection at 6 min constriction had largely disappeared by 20 minutes. Iohexol was generally followed by less severe constriction, but it may persist for longer and even show an increase at 20 min.

Volume flow measurement of pulsatile flow by digitised cine angiography.

The validation, by phantom experiments, of a method of measuring volumetric, pulsatile blood flow in vessels of about 4 mm calibre is described. 'Instantaneous' as well as integrated flow is obtained from cine angiograms by digitisation of the images and densitometric analysis in an advanced computer vision analysis system. From 48 frames per second cine, pulsatile flow at any moment between 0 and about 400 ml/min was calculated within about 10 per cent of the electromagnetic flow meter reading. Further improvement is expected. It is proposed to advance to 3D and have the methodology available for clinical use in due course.

Computed tomography in cervical spondylotic myelopathy and radiculopathy: visualisation of structures, myelographic comparison, cord measurements and clinical utility.

Sixty-nine patients with cervical spondylotic myelopathy (CSM), radiculopathy (CSR), or both (CSMR) were studied with computed tomography (CT). Computer-assisted myelography (CAM) accurately determines the site and nature of spondylotic protrusions and provides good visualisation of the subarachnoid space and cord deformities even in areas with dilute metrizamide. However, excessive vertebral movement and bulging ligamenta flava with their effects on cord deformity, so easily visualised in myelograms, are completely or partially missed. In the assessment of CSM, metrizamide myelography (MM) followed by CAM should be performed, particularly when the myelographic images are unsatisfactory due to contrast dilution or blockage, when cord compression cannot be ascertained with MM and when cord atrophy is suspected. In CSR, the diagnostic information from MM and CAM is comparable. The diagnostic criteria in CAM are, however, less direct and since MM is adequate in uncomplicated cases, CAM is generally not necessary. The APD, APD/TD ratio, area and circularity are sensitive indices of cord deformity and the first two should be used more often to assist visual assessment of cord deformity. The relation between cord parameters and treatment response is better reflected in CSM cases managed conservatively and the results suggest that the degree of cord deformity is helpful in determining the outcome and hence the choice between surgical and conservative treatment. In plain CT, the osteophytes and calcified discs are adequately visualised and canal dimensions measured with accuracy, but the cervical cord and roots cannot be properly assessed and the diagnosis of CSM or CSR cannot be ascertained. At present, its role in cervical spondylosis is therefore limited.