The radioiodine turnover rate as a determinant of radioiodine treatment outcome in Graves' disease.

For individual iodine-131 ((131)I) treatment dosage calculations, most physicians use the 'standard dosage formula', which requires measurements of thyroid volume and thyroidal (131)I uptake. The effective half-life of (131)I (T(eff)) is then unjustifiably ignored. Evidence is presented that the 5/24h (131)I uptake ratio can be used as a surrogate parameter for T(eff), and that it is a determinant of the (131)I therapy outcome for patients with Graves' disease. A correction factor based on the thyroidal (131)I metabolism in individual patients could provide a means to increase the success rate of radioiodine treatment.

No survival difference after successful (131)I ablation between patients with initially low-risk and high-risk differentiated thyroid cancer.

PURPOSE: To compare disease-specific survival and recurrence-free survival (RFS) after successful (131)I ablation in patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) between those defined before ablation as low-risk and those defined as high-risk according to the European Thyroid Association 2006 consensus statement. METHODS: Retrospective data from three university hospitals were pooled. Of 2009 consecutive patients receiving ablation, 509 were identified as successfully ablated based on both undetectable stimulated serum thyroglobulin in the absence of antithyroglobulin antibodies and a negative diagnostic whole-body scan in a follow-up examination conducted 8.1+/-4.6 months after ablation. Of these 509 patients, 169 were defined as high-risk. RESULTS: After a mean follow-up of 81+/-64 months (range 4-306 months), only three patients had died of DTC, rendering assessment of disease-specific survival differences impossible. Of the 509 patients, 12 (2.4%) developed a recurrence a mean 35 months (range 12-59 months) after ablation. RFS for the duration of follow-up was 96.6% according to the Kaplan-Meier method. RFS did not differ between high-risk and low-risk patients (p=0.68). RFS differed slightly but significantly between those with papillary and those with follicular thyroid carcinoma (p=0.03) and between those aged 45 years at diagnosis (p=0.018). CONCLUSION: After (near) total thyroidectomy and successful (131)I ablation, RFS does not differ between patients classified as high-risk and those classified as low-risk based on TNM stage at diagnosis. Consequently, the follow-up protocol should be determined on the basis of the result of initial treatment rather than on the initial tumour classification.

The success rate of I-131 ablation in differentiated thyroid cancer: comparison of uptake-related and fixed-dose strategies.

INTRODUCTION: The aim of the study was to compare the success rate of an uptake-related ablation protocol in which the dose depends on an I-131 24-h neck uptake measurement and a fixed-dose ablation protocol in which the dose depends on tumour stage. METHODS: All differentiated thyroid carcinoma patients with M0 disease who had undergone (near-) total thyroidectomy followed by I-131 ablation were included. In the uptake-related ablation protocol, 1100 (uptake >10%), 1850 (uptake 5-10%) and 2800 MBq (uptake <5%) were used. In the fixed-dosage ablation strategy, 3700 (T1-3, N0 stage) and 5550 MBq (N1 and/or T4 stage) were applied. We used I-131 uptake on whole-body scintigraphy and thyroglobulin-off values to evaluate the ablation 6-12 months after treatment. RESULTS: In the uptake-related ablation protocol, 60 out of 139 (43%) patients were successfully treated versus 111 out of 199 for the fixed-dose ablation protocol (56%) (P=0.022). The differences were not statistically significant for patients with T4 (P=0.581) and/or N1 (P=0.08) disease or for patients with T4N1 tumour stage (P=0.937). CONCLUSION: The fixed-dose I-131 ablation protocol is more effective in ablation of the thyroid remnant in differentiated thyroid carcinoma patients than an uptake-related ablation protocol. This difference is not observed in patients with a N1 and/or T4 tumour stage.

I-131 accumulation in a benign cystic mesothelioma in a patient with follicular thyroid cancer.

Focal I-131 accumulation is generally a reliable indicator of functioning normal thyroid tissue or a differentiated thyroid cancer metastasis. However, physiologic accumulation of activity may also be observed in organs such as the intestinal tract, liver, and salivary glands. Extrathyroidal I-131 accumulation has been reported in various sites, such as ectopic gastric mucosa, gastrointestinal and urinary tract abnormalities, cysts (mammary, liver, kidney, and ovaries), and inflammation and infection foci. We report a case of focal I-131 accumulation in a benign cystic mesothelioma in a patient with follicular thyroid cancer.

Persistent disease in patients with papillary thyroid carcinoma and lymph node metastases after surgery and iodine-131 ablation.

AIM: The aim of this study was to assess the efficacy of treatment of patients with papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) and lymph node metastases at the time of diagnosis and its influence on the course of the disease. METHODS: It is a retrospective review of all 51 patients with PTC and histologically proven lymph node metastases treated with I-131 ablation in our center between January 1990 and January 2003. Patients were considered disease-free if during follow-up thyroglobulin levels were undetectable and scintigraphy with 370 MBq (131)I was negative during thyroid-stimulating hormone stimulation. Staging of patients was in accordance with the 5th edition of the TNM system. RESULTS: After a median follow-up of 84 months, 33 (65%) patients were never free of detectable disease; and 3 of these patients had died of the PTC. In total, 22 patients still showed persistent activity in the neck outside the thyroid bed, which was suspect to be cervical lymph node metastasis on postablation scintigraphy; it was not related to the initial clinical presentation (lymph node metastasis or a thyroid nodule without suspicion of metastatic disease) or to the extent of surgery. Altogether, 34 patients required additional treatment. Patients presenting with clinically overt lymph node metastasis showed a significantly (p = 0.022) lower rate of becoming disease-free than those in whom microscopic lymph node involvement was unexpectedly found upon pathologic examination. There was no significant association of the eventual outcome with the extent of surgical treatment, TNM staging, or age. CONCLUSIONS: Patients with lymph node metastasis are considerably less likely to become disease-free. If the initial treatment does not result in a disease-free status, chances are low that additional treatment will succeed in achieving it.

Use of radiopharmaceuticals for diagnosis, treatment, and follow-up of differentiated thyroid carcinoma.

In 1942, Dr. Seidlin of the Memorial Hospital in New York was faced with a 51-year- old patient who had undergone a thyroidectomy in 1923 [1]. At the time, the histologic diagnosis was a 'malignant adenoma' of the thyroid. In 1938 the patient returned with overt signs of thyroid hyperfunction (hyperthyroidism) and lower back pain. A metastasis was found in the lower spine, and surgically removed. Over the next years the patient remained hyperthyroid and developed more bone metastases. At the time of presentation to Dr. Seidlin, the patient was in an extremely poor condition: he was in severe pain, severely hyperthyroid, and severely underweight. At this time radioiodine therapy had just reached the clinical arena. In 1937 Hertz, Roberts and Evans investigated the rabbit's thyroid function using I-128 [2]. Later they pursued therapeutic goals for e.g. Graves' disease using I-130. They used dosages that we now know would have been merely diagnostic if it were not for a probable 10% I-131 contaminant [3]. Livingood and Seaborg identified I-131 as a separate isotope. In 1942 two groups independently reported on the successful treatment of hyperthyroidism with I-131 sodium iodide [4,5]. Radioiodine was so rare that it was recovered from the urine, purified and re-administered to the patient. The patient responded favourably to the radioiodine treatment, and he received several more courses of I-131. Geiger-counter examination of the patient revealed two previously unknown metastases, thereby indicating the diagnostic capabilities of radioiodine. The patient did very well on these courses: the hyperthyroidism subsided, the body-weight kg increased from 38 to 53 kilograms, and the pains diminished. This report of a potential cure for terminally ill patients fuelled the public imagination to a degree that it hit the political agenda. Effective on August 1, 1946, the Atomic Energy Act (AEA) made radioisotopes available for medical use in the USA. This date marks the beginning of 'atomic medicine', later named nuclear medicine.

Suspected thyroid stunning after radioiodine-131 scanning in a patient with a diffuse goiter.

A case of suspected thyroid stunning is presented in a previously hyperthyroid patient with a diffuse goiter, who had undergone a 185 MBq (131)I-NaI thyroid scan shortly before a (99m)Tc-pertechnetate scan. A less likely alternative hypothesis is the development of early hypothyroidism, 3.5 weeks after a modest (131)I dose.

Comparison of methods for thyroid volume estimation in patients with Graves' disease.

Individualised dosage models are frequently applied for radioiodine therapy in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism, especially in Europe. In these dosage schemes the thyroid volume is an important parameter. Thyroid volume determinations are usually made with ultrasonography or with thyroid scintigraphy, although the accuracy of planar scintigraphy for this purpose is not well established. The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy of three modalities for the determination of the thyroid volume in patients with Graves' disease: planar scintigraphy (PS), single-photon emission tomography (SPET) and ultrasonography (US). These three modalities were compared with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) as the gold standard. Thyroid volume estimations were performed in 25 patients with Graves' disease. The PS images were subjected to filtering and thresholding, and a standard surface formula was used to calculate the thyroid volume. With SPET the iteratively reconstructed thyroid images were filtered, and after applying a threshold method an automatic segmentation algorithm was used for the volume determinations. Thyroid volumes were estimated from the US images using the ellipsoid volume model for multiple two-dimensional measurements. For MRI, thyroid segmentation was performed manually in gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted images and a summation-of-areas technique was used for the volume measurements. The thyroid volumes calculated with MRI were 25.0+/-13.8 ml (mean+/-SD, range 7.0-56.3 ml). PS correlated poorly with MRI ( R(2)=0.61) and suffered from a considerable bias (-4.0+/-17.6 ml). The differences between PS and MRI volume estimations had a very large spread (33+/-58%). For SPET both the correlation with MRI ( R(2)=0.84) and the bias (1.8+/-11.9 ml) were better than for PS. US had by far the best correlation with MRI ( R(2)=0.97) and the best precision, but the bias (6.8+/-7.5 ml) was not negligible. In conclusion, SPET is preferred over PS for accurate measurements of thyroid volume. US is the most accurate of the three modalities, if a correction is made for bias.