RESUMO
INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES: There is limited evidence to identify the most accurate method for measuring the mitral valve area (MVA) after percutaneous edge-to-edge mitral repair. Our objective was to evaluate the optimal method in this context and its correlation with the mean transmitral gradient. METHODS: A registry of patients undergoing percutaneous mitral repair was conducted, analyzing different methods of measuring MVA and their correlation with the mean gradient. RESULTS: We analyzed data from 167 patients. The mean age was 76±10.3 years, 54% were men, and 46% were women. Etiology was degenerative in 45%, functional in 39%, and mixed in 16%. Postclip MVA measurements were 1.89±0.60 cm2 using pressure half-time (PHT), 2.87±0.83 cm2 using 3D planimetry, and the mean gradient was 3±1.19mmHg. MVA using 3D planimetry showed a stronger correlation with the mean gradient (r=0.46, P<.001) than MVA obtained by PHT (r=0.19, P=.048). Interobserver agreement was also higher with 3D planimetry than with PHT (intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.90 vs 0.81 and variation coefficient of 9.6 vs 19.7%, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Our study demonstrates that the PHT method significantly underestimates MVA after clip implantation compared with direct measurement using transesophageal 3D planimetry. The latter method also correlates better with postimplantation gradients and has less interobserver variability. These results suggest that 3D planimetry is a more appropriate method for assessing postclip mitral stenosis.
RESUMO
Abstract Background: percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy has become an ideal treatment option for mitral stenosis due to its less adverse events and more favorable outcomes. Patients improve symptomatically after percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy but we have minimal available data about the quality of life after percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy. Objective: to assess the quality of life after percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy through WHOQol scoring covering different aspects of life, to determine its correlation with a net gain in mitral valve area (MVA) and to ascertain its association with gender. Methods: it was a prospective cohort study carried out for a period of 15 months. A total of 100 patients with mitral stenosis who had successful percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy done were enrolled in the study. Among the total included, 4 patients were lost to follow up and data were collected from 96 patients. Quality of life was assessed before the procedure, at 1 month and 3 months follow up after percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy using WHOQol scoring questionnaire. Results: among 96 patients, 64 (67%) were females and 32 (33%) were males. WHOQol scoring improved significantly after percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy from 32.8±8.9 to 54.6±11.2 and 62.8± 9.7, after one month and 3 months respectively. There was a significant association between net gain of MVA and WHOQol scoring with an R value of 0.46 and p value of 0.03. There was no difference in group comparison of all the six domains between male and female patients. Conclusion: successful percutaneous transmitral commissurotomy improves the quality of life in mitral stenosis patients regardless of their gender and has a positive correlation with a net gain in mitral valve area.
Resumen Antecedentes: La comisurotomía mitral percutánea se ha convertido en una opción terapéutica ideal para la estenosis mitral, debido a efectos menos adversos y a resultados más favorables. Los pacientes mejoran sintomáticamente tras la realización de esta técnica, aunque se dispone de escasos datos acerca de la calidad de vida tras su puesta en práctica. Objetivo: Evaluar la calidad de vida tras la comisurotomía mitral percutánea mediante la puntuación WHOQol, que cubre diferentes aspectos de la vida, para determinar su correlación con la ganancia neta del área valvular mitral (AVM), y determinar su asociación con el sexo. Métodos: Estudio prospectivo de cohorte durante un periodo de 15 meses, en el que se incluyeron 100 pacientes con estenosis mitral a quienes se les practicó con éxito comisurotomía mitral percutánea. De entre el total incluido, se perdieron 4 pacientes durante el estudio, por lo que se recolectaron datos de los 96 pacientes restantes. La calidad de vida se evaluó antes del procedimiento, y transcurridos un mes y tres meses de seguimiento, utilizando el cuestionario de puntuación WHOQol. Resultados: De los 96 pacientes, 64 (67%) eran mujeres y 32 (33%) varones. La puntuación WHOQol mejoró considerablemente tras la realización de la comisurotomía mitral percutánea, con valores de 32,8±8,9 a 54,6±11,2 y 62,8± 9,7, transcurridos uno y 3 meses, respectivamente. Se produjo una asociación significativa entre la ganancia neta de AVM y la puntuación WHOQol, con un valor R de 0,46 y un valor p de 0,03. No se produjo diferencia alguna en cuanto a la comparación grupal de los seis dominios entre varones y mujeres. Conclusión: La comisurotomía mitral percutánea exitosa mejora la calidad de vida de los pacientes de estenosis mitral, independientemente del sexo, y tiene una correlación positiva con la ganancia neta del área valvular mitral.
