Incidental Bilateral Thighs Muscular Uptake of Technetium-99m MDP on Bone Scan in a Patient with Left Condylar Hyperplasia.

We present a case of a 22-year-old male patient who underwent a bone scan for evaluation of left condylar hyperplasia. Incidentally, the bone scan revealed bilateral thighs muscular uptake of technetium-99m methylene diphosphonate, which initially raised concerns for an underlying pathological process. However, further investigation revealed that the abnormal uptake was due to postexercise effects. This case report highlights the importance of considering benign causes of abnormal radiotracer uptake and the need for careful correlation with clinical history to avoid unnecessary diagnostic interventions.

Post-condylectomy orthodontic treatment for a severe asymmetrical open bite in a condylar hyperplasia patient.

A satisfactory treatment of an 18-year-old lady was reported with right combination-type condylar hyperplasia (CH) in active phase. The chin severely deviated to the left, with the right gonial angle locating at a lower level. Intraorally, the lower centre line shifted to the left, the scale of which reached the width of one lower incisor. The right molar relation was mesial. Right maxillary second molar over-erupted without contact to lower teeth. There had been 2.5-mm anterior open bite (AOB) before surgery (T1) due to the tongue-spitting habit. After judging the benefits and disadvantages of all treatment alternatives, the decision was made to perform a right condylectomy and post-surgery orthodontics. Before orthodontics (T2) when the chin was positioned centred, an asymmetrical open bite occurred, caused by pre-contact between the right maxillary and mandibular second molars. Meanwhile, the AOB at T2 became 11.5mm. Orthodontic-related treatment included four premolars extraction and intrusion of bilateral maxillary molars using four miniscrews. Finally, this treatment achieved a clinically centred chin with two gonial angles at the same level. Post-condylectomy, the large AOB was resolved, together with a bilateral neutral molar relationship and alignment of the incisor midlines. Besides, the resected right condyle was covered by a continuous cortex bone and returned to the glenoid fossa. In sum, a high-challenging combined-type CH case was accomplished with impressive improvement in facial and occlusal symmetry, thanks to condylectomy and post-surgery miniscrew-assisted orthodontics.

Late Outcomes of Undiagnosed Unilateral Condylar Hyperplasia and Reoccurrence of Mandibular Asymmetry.

Unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) is a rare cause of asymmetrical mandibular overgrowth because of the presence of an atypical growth in the affected condyle. SPECT (single-photon emission computed tomography) can easily establish the presence of an atypical, prolonged growth exceeding far beyond normal condylar growth and activity. A CT, CBCT, or LDCT (computed tomography, cone-beam computed tomography, or low-dose computed tomography) can confirm the diagnosis by evaluating the scope of bone overgrowth, mandibular basis/ramus asymmetry, tendency to condylar head enlargement, changes in bone density, and occurrence of differences in condylar head shapes, size, and bone structure. In most cases, a condylectomy is the procedure of choice in growing cases of UCH to remove the pathological condyle and reduce asymmetry levels. Sometimes, the growth is very slow and progressive over time, causing slowly growing asymmetry with similar symptoms to any other mandibular asymmetry, and this causes some troublesome procedures in UCH diagnostics, resulting in patients being underdiagnosed; it can even lead to some relapses in mandibular asymmetry and skeletal malocclusion after previously performed orthodontic and surgical treatment of such discrepancies. When the source of asymmetry is not identified in time, possible inadequate treatment protocols can be used. If any relapse of facial and mandibular asymmetry re-occur, SPECT and CT evaluation are necessary to evaluate if condylar hyperplasia is present and to establish what kind of surgical intervention should be used in each case.

A proposed protocol for correlation between bone density in hemimandibular hyperplasia radiography and histopathological findings - A retrospective study.

The role of low-dose computed tomography (LDCT) in surgical planning can be assessed based on the correlation among bone density (BD/HU), radiographic values, and the histopathological appearance of hyperplastic overgrowth in mandibular condyles (hemimandibular hyperplasia/osteochondroma). The aim of this study was to evaluate the correlation between LDCT indices of bone-density measurements in surgical planning and histopathological specimens. The patients incuded in this study underwent detailed radiological evaluation as preparation for further clinical procedures. Excised condyles were evaluated in terms of bone density index using LDCT, and then histopathologically to investigate the accuracy of surgical procedures and set the basis for future surgical planning. An index value between both condyles' bone densities represented the relative difference between the healthy condyle and the side with hemimandibular hyperplasia (HH). Patients with unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) showed a statistical correlation between condyle heads with increased bone density (BD) and scintigraphic (SCI) values (p < 0.001). On the other hand, correlation between BD and histopathological studies alone was significant (p < 0.001). With the increase in BD measured in HU in UCH condyles, the overall value of fibrous cartilage layer thickness decreased (p < 0.001). Furthermore, histopathological evaluation indicated that increased bone density on the UCH side resulted in increased total thickness (p > 0.001). The proposed index measurements in the mandibular condyles based on LDCT/BD can be used to estimate the degree of required surgical resection. Results from LDCT radiographic studies correlate with histopathological specimens more than scintigraphy.

Assessment of unilateral condylar hyperplasia with quantitative SPECT/CT.

Purpose: The current study aimedto assess condylar activityin patients with unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) with quantitative SPECT/CT. Patients and methods: This retrospective study included patients with UCH who underwent quantitative SPECT/CT. SPECT analysis and quantification of SPECT/CT were performed, and the maximum count per pixel and SUVmax of either side of the condyles were calculated. Results: 39 patients were included in the analysisand classified into three subgroups according to the percentile differential right-left ratio: inactive group, left active (LA) group, and right active (RA) group. Totally, the SUVmax of the affected side is significantly higher than the unaffected side (active:5.93 ± 2.43 vs inactive:3.62 ± 1.76, P < 0.001), SUVmax-based ratios correlated well with the ratios based on maximum count (R = 0.944, P < 0.001). ROC analysis showed poorSUVmaxperformance in differentiation between theactive condyles and the inactive condyles due to the lower area under the curve (AUC) (0.588). In subgroup analysis, the affected side is significantly higher than the unaffected side in active groups with SUVmax, no significant difference was found between the active sides or the inactive sides of active groups. Interestingly, the SUVmax of the left side was statistically higher than that of the right sidein the inactive group (P = 0.01),while the left side of the right active group has significantlylower activitythan that in the inactive group, meanwhile,the right side showed no significant difference. Furthermore, each side showed no significant difference between the left active group and the inactive group. Conclusions: SUVmax is not an optimal measurement effectively used to evaluate active condyles. However, SUV ratios correlated well with the count ratios, and the left side of condyles showed a peculiar feature in condyle growth status reflected in radioactivity quantified with SPECT/CT, which needs further study to determine the role in the development of the UCH.

Condylar Hyperplasia: Case Report and Literature Review.

Condylar hyperplasia is a rare pathology characterised by excessive bone growth that presents virtually unilaterally, resulting in facial asymmetry. The aetiology of this disorder is not well understood. This pathology has been reported to be a rare entity with very few cases being reported in the literature, mostly seen between 11 and 30 years of age, with males and females being equally affected and having no predominance to the left or right side. It has also been reported to be a self-limiting condition, that is, the active growth can cease at any point in time. We report two cases of unilateral condylar hyperplasia in 24- and 19-year-old male and female patients, where the first was treated by condylectomy and BSSO, and the latter was treated by high condylectomy and recontouring of the mandible.

Computed Tomographic Analysis of Position of Mandibular Canal and Mandibular Foramen in Patients with Mandibular Asymmetry.

Introduction: Mandibular osteotomies in facial asymmetry are complicated by the abnormal position and course of inferior alveolar nerve. This manuscript aims to evaluate the possible variations in the preoperative positions of mandibular canal and mandibular foramen in patients with mandibular asymmetry due to condylar hyperplasia or condylar hypoplasia. Materials & Methods: This study included 15 patients with mandibular asymmetry due to condylar hyperplasia or condylar hypoplasia for which bilateral sagittal split osteotomy (BSSO) was performed as a corrective procedure. The presence/absence and extent of postoperative neurosensory deficiency was recorded subjectively and objectively. The measurements were done using multiplanar reconstruction (MPR) of three-dimensional radiographic imaging and were compared to normal subjects. Discussion: The results revealed that the mandibular canal was closer to the buccal cortex on the affected side and the inferior border on both sides in the region of second molar in condylar hyperplasia. In condylar hypoplasia, the canal was nearer to the inferior border and the alveolar crest in relation to second and third molars respectively on the affected and contralateral sides.The mandibular foramen was also more superior to the occlusal plane on both sides in both condylar hyperplasia and hypoplasia. Conclusion: Based on the study outcomes, the authors propose that assessment of the positions of mandibular canal and mandibular foramen is crucial to avoid postoperative neurosensory deficiencies.

Single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) diagnostic accuracy in active unilateral condylar hyperplasia: Retrospective study.

The aim of this study was to assess the diagnostic accuracy of single photon emission tomography (SPECT) in unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH). To this end, 3D morphometric changes of the mandibles in one year were assessed (T0 vs. T1) and compared over SPECT results in T1, in a sample of 40 patients. A contingency table was constructed based on these results for SPECT diagnostic accuracy evaluation, classifying patients as SPECT true-positive, true-negatives, false positives and false-negatives. Additionally, the morphometric analysis was used to describe the presentation of mandibular changes using principal component analysis (PCA) and non-parametric statistics. We obtained diagnostic accuracy results of sensitivity 81%, specificity 63%, positive predictor value (PPV) 59%, negative predictor value (NPV) 83% and accuracy 70%, showing that SPECT yields poor results regarding accuracy diagnostic performance. The morphometric analysis showed that individuals without progress of asymmetry and those with more progress differ particularly in a group of landmarks representing the mental region and the right mandibular body. Based on these landmarks, difference among the four SPECT-accuracy groups was statistically significant (p < 0.001), where the landmark showing the largest change within a year had a mean increase of 1.13 + 0.66 mm. Within the limitations of the study, it seems that SPECT alone is not suitable for making surgical decisions regarding condylectomy in active UCH. Follow up with morphological assessment methods are recommended for confirming an active UCH in combination with SPECT.

Treatment of dentofacial deformities secondary to condylar hyperplasia.

Dentofacial deformities secondary to condylar hyperplasiais a kind of disease presenting facial asymmetry, malocclusion, temporomandibular joint dysfunction, and other symptoms caused by non-neoplastic hyperplasia of the condyle. The etiology is still unknown, and currently, pre- and post-operative orthodontics accompanied by orthognathic surgery, temporomandibular joint surgery and jawbone contouring surgery are the main treatment methods. A personalized treatment plan was developed, considering the active degree of condyle hyperplasia, the severity of the jaw deformity, and the patient's will, to correct deformity, obtain ideal occlusal relationship, and regain good temporomandibular joint function. Combined with the author's clinical experience, the etiology, clinical and imageological features, treatment aims, and surgical methods of condylar hyperplasia and secondary dentofacial deformities were discussed in this paper.

Early Treatment of Unilateral Condylar Hyperplasia in Adolescents: Preliminary Results.

Facial asymmetry associated with unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) is a rare disease. The aim of this study was to evaluate the clinical conditions of progressive facial asymmetry in young subjects treated with high condylectomy. A retrospective study was performed including nine subjects diagnosed with UCH type 1B and progressive facial asymmetry around 12 years old with an upper canine progressing towards dental occlusion. After an analysis and a decision of treatment, orthodontics began one to two weeks prior to the condylectomy (with a mean vertical reduction of 4.83 ± 0.44 mm). Facial and dental asymmetry, dental occlusion, TMJ status and an open/closing mouth were analyzed before surgery and in the final stage of treatment, almost 3 years after surgery. Statistical analyses were performed using the Shapiro-Wilk test and a Student's t-test considering a p value of <0.05. Comparing T1 (before surgery) and T2 (once orthodontic treatment was finalized), the operated condyle showed a similar height to that observed in stage 1 with a 0.12 mm difference in height (p = 0.8), whereas the non-operated condyle showed greater height increase with an average of 3.88 mm of vertical growth (p = 0.0001). This indicated that the non-operated condyle remained steady and that the operative condyle did not register significant growth. In terms of facial asymmetry in the preoperative stage, a chin deviation of 7.55 mm (±2.57 mm) was observed; in the final stage, there was a significant reduction in the chin deviation with an average of 1.55 mm (±1.26 mm) (p = 0.0001). Given the small number of patients in the sample, we can conclude that high condylectomy (approx. 5 mm), if performed early, especially in the mixed-dentition stage before full canine eruption, is beneficial for the early resolution of asymmetry and thus the avoidance of future orthognathic surgery. However, further follow-up until the end of facial growth is required.

Evaluation of optimal single-photon emission computed tomography reference value and three-dimensional mandibular growth pattern in 54 Chinese unilateral condylar hyperplasia patients.

BACKGROUND: The research aimed to evaluate the optimal Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT) cut-off value in differentiating condylar growth activeness, to observe 3-dimensional (3D) mandibular growth pattern, and to explore the potential correlation between 3D measurement parameters and SPECT uptake ratios in Chinese unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) patients. METHODS:  Data of fifty-four Chinese UCH patients were analyzed retrospectively. All patients underwent SPECT within 1 month before or after the first CT examination (CT1); and received a second CT examination at least 12 months later (CT2). Data from CT scans were analyzed by comparing bilateral differences between CT1 and CT2. The sensitivity and specificity of SPECT were calculated by the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve. Pearson's correlation analysis was performed to investigate whether the mandibular growth was correlated with SPECT value. RESULTS: SPECT had a sensitivity of 68.00% and a specificity of 72.41%, with an area under the ROC curve being 0.709. The optimal SPECT cut-off value for evaluating condylar activity has been determined to be 13%. In patients with an active growing condyle, there was a significant increase in Co-Gn and Co-Go, but not in Go-Gn, Go-MF, or MF-Gn. Pearson's correlation analysis revealed no correlation between 3D measurement parameters and differences in relative condylar uptake ratios. CONCLUSION: SPECT showed good diagnostic performance in UCH with the cut-off value of 13%. For those with an active growing condyle, the mandible grows diagonally and vertically, while the relative condylar uptake ratio was not directly related to mandibular growth.

'Study of the maxillary yaw on cone beam computed tomography: A preliminary report and comparison between two different dento-skeletal malocclusions'.

OBJECTIVES: To assess the skeletal and dental maxillary transverse compensation (yaw) on the cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) three-dimensional reconstructed image of the skull in two groups of patients, both clinically affected by a class III malocclusion with deviation of the lower midline. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An observational retrospective study was designed to analyse differences in two groups of patients, the first one was composed by patients affected by horizontal condylar hyperplasia, the second one by patients affected by dento-skeletal asymmetric class III malocclusion. Each group was composed by 15 patients. Transverse analysis was performed by measuring five landmarks (three bilateral and two uneven) with respect to a mid-sagittal plane; sagittal analysis was performed by measuring the sagittal distance on the mid-sagittal plane between bilateral points. Means were compared through inferential analysis. RESULTS: In the condylar hyperplasia group, all differences between the two sides were not statistically significant, nor for canines' difference (P = .0817), for molars (P = .1105) or for jugular points (.05871). In the class III group, the differences between the two sides were statistically significant for molars (P = .0019) and jugular points (P = .0031) but not for canines (P = .1158). Comparing the two groups, significant differences were found only for incisors' midline deviation (P = .0343) and canine (P = .0177). CONCLUSION: The study of the yaw on CBCT should be integrated into three-dimensional cephalometry and could help in differentiating the various malocclusion patterns.

Diagnosis and Treatment in Unilateral Condylar Hyperplasia.

Unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) is an uncommon disease involving progressive facial asymmetry. The aim of this research was to perform an analysis of the diagnosis and treatment of patients with UCH in a clinical series. An observational retrospective study was performed on subjects with progressive facial asymmetry in the lower third of the face; all the subjects were under treatment with condylectomy and orthodontics to improve occlusion and face balance. Variables such as age, sex, clinical type, SPECT (single photon emission computed tomography) intensity and a requirement for secondary surgery were included; the Shapiro Wilk test was performed to analyze the normality of the data and nonparametric analysis and the Kruskal-Wallis or Mann-Whitney tests were used to assess the association between the SPECT difference and the variables, where 2-tailed p values < 0.05 were considered to be statistically significant. Forty-nine patients between 10 and 45 y.o. (average age: 19.1 ± 7.4 y.o.) were included in the study. There were 41 female (83.6%) and 8 male (16.4%) subjects. The SPECT analysis comparing the right and left condyles with more than 10% in caption of the isotope was present in 46 subjects; the results obtained using SPECT were not statistically related to the age or sex of the sample (p = 0.277). The patients were classified into clinical types I, II and III, and no correlations could be confirmed between the clinical type and other variables. High condylectomy was conducted on all patients, among which 14 patients underwent a secondary surgery for orthognathic or cosmetic treatment, and was not related to the initial variables used in diagnosis (p = 0.98); interestingly, the second surgical treatment was more present in the clinical type I and in subjects under 16 years old with no statistical differences. Clinical analysis, medical records, 3D imaging and SPECT should be used as a complementary analysis in assessing the diagnosis of UCH and progressive facial asymmetry.

Factors affecting duration of post-surgical orthodontics in the Surgery First/Early Approach: A retrospective study.

BACKGROUND: Surgery First Approach (SFA) and Surgery Early (SE) are considered promising alternatives, compared to the conventional three-stages orthodontic-surgical approach, for treatment of dento-maxillofacial deformities. However, many features need further study, like the role of the orthodontist. Aim of the study was to analyse the clinical characteristics of patients who underwent SFA and SE, and if differences in duration of orthodontics could be influenced by clinical features. METHODS: A retrospective research was performed on patients who met the inclusion criteria for SFA (31) and SE (12), of the total of patients affected by dento-facial deformities in our Unit (191) in the period 2012-2017. After collection of clinical data, duration of orthodontics, age, pre-treatment PAR Index, ANB angle, amount of the curve of Spee were compared. A regression analysis evaluated if these clinical parameters, together with type of bracket and type of intervention, could influence the duration of post-surgical orthodontics. RESULTS: All patients who performed the SFA/SE were affected by class III, II and active Unilateral Condylar Hyperplasia (22% of total population). Pre-treatment mean differences of age (p = 0.0518), PAR Index (p = 0.0916), curve of Spee (p = 0.1006) between groups were not statistically significant. A statically significant difference was found for the overall duration of therapy, for the significant shorter duration of pre-surgical orthodontics, while the difference of post-surgical orthodontics duration was not significant (p = 0.4753). Type of bracket (rho=-0.19039, p = 0.266) and intervention performed (rho=-0.11522, p = 0.5034) were not correlated with duration of post-surgical orthodontics, as well as pre-treatment PAR Index, ANB angle and depth of the curve of Spee. CONCLUSIONS: Surgery First/Early Approach is a therapeutic choice that could be performed only in patients affected by specific malocclusions and who exactly meet indications. Protocol and post-surgical occlusal stability are factors that should influence the duration of therapy more than clinical characteristics.

Bone characteristics in condylar hyperplasia of the temporomandibular joint: a microcomputed tomography, histology, and Raman microspectrometry study.

Unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) of the temporomandibular joint is a progressive deformation of the mandibular condyle of unknown origin. UCH is characterized by excessive growth of the condylar head and neck, leading to an increase in size and volume. The aim of this study was to investigate the characteristics of the bone in patients with UCH using microcomputed tomography (micro-CT), histology, and Raman microspectroscopy. The mandibular condyles of six patients with UCH were analysed using micro-CT, histology, and Raman microspectrometry and imaging, and the results were compared with those obtained for a normal control subject. Three-dimensional micro-CT models revealed focal abnormalities of the bone microarchitecture, with foci of osteosclerosis. Histological sections showed that these foci included islands of calcified cartilage matrix with live chondrocytes. Raman analysis revealed that the cartilage matrix was more heavily calcified than the bone matrix and that the cartilage could be identified by the phenylalanine (PHE) band of its matrix, as well as by its glycosaminoglycan (GAG) content. The persistence of foci of live and active chondrocytes within the bone matrix is intriguing and appears to be pathognomonic of UCH. These new findings on UCH could help to determine its pathophysiology and thus prevent this disease, which can lead to major facial deformity.

Treatment of dentofacial deformities secondary to condylar hyperplasia / 华西口腔医学杂志

Dentofacial deformities secondary to condylar hyperplasiais a kind of disease presenting facial asymmetry, malocclusion, temporomandibular joint dysfunction, and other symptoms caused by non-neoplastic hyperplasia of the condyle. The etiology is still unknown, and currently, pre- and post-operative orthodontics accompanied by orthognathic surgery, temporomandibular joint surgery and jawbone contouring surgery are the main treatment methods. A personalized treatment plan was developed, considering the active degree of condyle hyperplasia, the severity of the jaw deformity, and the patient's will, to correct deformity, obtain ideal occlusal relationship, and regain good temporomandibular joint function. Combined with the author's clinical experience, the etiology, clinical and imageological features, treatment aims, and surgical methods of condylar hyperplasia and secondary dentofacial deformities were discussed in this paper.

Unilateral condylar hyperplasia treated with simultaneous 2-jaw orthognathic surgery and posterior segmental osteotomy.

A 25-year-old woman presented with left condylar hyperplasia, canting-type facial asymmetry, mandibular prognathism, and arch width discrepancy. Bone scintigraphy confirmed the inactive status of the condyle, and the temporomandibular joint functioned within the normal range; thus, orthognathic surgery without condylectomy was performed. To correct facial asymmetry successfully through orthognathic surgery, sufficient dentoalveolar decompensation must be achieved in the presurgical orthodontic phase. In cases of canting-type facial asymmetry, teeth on the nondeviated side are extruded as dentoalveolar compensation. Therefore, vertical decompensation is required for intrusion of the extruded teeth. A miniscrew and resin build-ups were used for the intrusion of teeth, and posterior segmental osteotomy was simultaneously performed with orthognathic surgery for further intrusion. The canting-type facial asymmetry was notably corrected through successful vertical decompensation and close cooperation between orthodontists and maxillofacial surgeons. After 2 years of retention, the treatment results remained stable.

Can electrocautery of the mandibular condyle effectively treat condylar hyperplasia?

This study aims to introduce and evaluate a novel technique to treat unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) by electrocauterization of the mandibular condyle via an intraoral approach. Patients suffering from unilateral condylar hyperplasia (UCH) were included in this study. All patients underwent electrocauterization of the affected condyle. An intraoral incision on the anterior border of the mandibular ramus was made to expose the external surface of the ramus and access the anterior border of the condylar head. A hole was then drilled into the condyle and cauterization was performed; six patients also received orthognathic surgery during the procedure. Patients underwent careful clinical assessment and radiological evaluation including panoramic view, lateral and posteroanterior cephalometry, cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) and scintigraphy to assess condylar growth for a period of 12-24 months. Ten patients (5 male and 5 female) with active UCH type 1B or 2A were included in this study with a mean age of 20.7 years (range, 18-21.7 years). At the 12-month postoperative assessment, clinical evaluation showed stable dental occlusion with no midline shift; scintigraphy showed persistently reduced cellular activity, and computed tomography scans revealed no degeneration in either of the condyles with complete healing of the drilled holes. Within the limitations of this study it seems that the proposed treatment approach might be an alternative to previously established protocols.

Methods of Definitive Correction of Mandibular Deformity in Hemimandibular Hyperplasia Based on Radiological, Anatomical, and Topographical Measurements-Proposition of Author's Own Protocol.

In order to fully evaluate and establish the degree of bone overgrowth, various radiological studies are essential in the careful planning of the amount of surgical excision. In the presented paper, the authors use self-designed anatomo-topographical reference points for planning the surgeries. Routine panoramic radiographs and low-dose computed tomography based on anatomical landmarks help in measuring the proportions of mandibular bone overgrowth with the following preoperative anatomical landmarks: (Go-Go), (Go(Right)-Gn), (Go(Left)-Gn), and (Me−Gn). Measurements taken at selected points and landmarks (gonion-gnathion/gnathion-menton) are easy to conduct. In the authors' proposal, the main key factor is total chin correction, which is necessary in cases of severe overgrowth; when F0 > C and Go-Gn>, there is >7 mm of vertical bone overgrowth, and the mandibular canal is positioned <5 mm from the inferior mandibular border­MIB. Larger overgrowths (>7 mm) have a greater outcome on the final symmetry than smaller overgrowths. As no guidelines are known, the authors present their own proposal.