New Insights on Molecular Autopsy in Sudden Death: A Systematic Review.

Sudden unexpected deaths often remain unresolved despite forensic examination, posing challenges for pathologists. Molecular autopsy, through genetic testing, can reveal hidden causes undetectable by standard methods. This review assesses the role of molecular autopsy in clarifying SUD cases, examining its methodology, utility, and effectiveness in autopsy practice. This systematic review followed PRISMA guidelines and was registered with PROSPERO (registration number: CRD42024499832). Searches on PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science identified English studies (2018-2023) on molecular autopsy in sudden death cases. Data from selected studies were recorded and filtered based on inclusion/exclusion criteria. Descriptive statistics analyzed the study scope, tissue usage, publication countries, and journals. A total of 1759 publications from the past 5 years were found, with 30 duplicates excluded. After detailed consideration, 1645 publications were also excluded, leaving 84 full-text articles for selection. Out of these, 37 full-text articles were chosen for analysis. Different study types were analyzed. Mutations were identified in 17 studies, totaling 47 mutations. Molecular investigations are essential when standard exams fall short in determining sudden death causes. Expertise in molecular biology is crucial due to diverse genetic conditions. Discrepancies in post-mortem protocols affect the validity of results, making standardization necessary. Multidisciplinary approaches and the analysis of different tissue types are vital.

Coenzyme Q deficiency may predispose to sudden unexplained death via an increased risk of cardiac arrhythmia.

Cardiac arrhythmia is currently considered to be the direct cause of death in a majority of sudden unexplained death (SUD) cases, yet the genetic predisposition and corresponding endophenotypes contributing to SUD remain incompletely understood. In this study, we aimed to investigate the involvement of Coenzyme Q (CoQ) deficiency in SUD. First, we re-analyzed the exome sequencing data of 45 SUD and 151 sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) cases from our previous studies, focusing on previously overlooked genetic variants in 44 human CoQ deficiency-related genes. A considerable proportion of the SUD (38%) and SIDS (37%) cases were found to harbor rare variants with likely functional effects. Subsequent burden testing, including all rare exonic and untranslated region variants identified in our case cohorts, further confirmed the existence of significant genetic burden. Based on the genetic findings, the influence of CoQ deficiency on electrophysiological and morphological properties was further examined in a mouse model. A significantly prolonged PR interval and an increased occurrence of atrioventricular block were observed in the 4-nitrobenzoate induced CoQ deficiency mouse group, suggesting that CoQ deficiency may predispose individuals to sudden death through an increased risk of cardiac arrhythmia. Overall, our findings suggest that CoQ deficiency-related genes should also be considered in the molecular autopsy of SUD.

Molecular autopsy by proxy: relevance for genetic counseling in rare genetic disorders.

Background: Rare genetic disorders may result in death before a definitive clinical diagnosis is established. Aim: This study aims to outline the processes and challenges in managing, from a genetic perspective, couples who lost children affected by rare genetic disorders. Results: Six couples who experienced child loss due to rare genetic disorders, seen by the primary author at genetic evaluation and counseling sessions, were retrospectively analyzed. Four out of 6 couples reported consanguinity. Exome and genome sequencing were performed for the parents. Carrier status of two rare lethal metabolic disorders was confirmed in one consanguineous couple. Three couples were carriers of 3 other rare diseases. Variants of LYST, MPV17, HEXB, ITGB4, CD3E, ASPM, TK2, COL11A2, and LAMB3 genes were identified. Six out of 10 were pathogenic variants, out of which 4 correlated with the demised children's phenotypes. One couple was negative for pathogenic variants. The last couple did not undergo genetic testing since they were beyond the fertile window. Conclusion: Appropriate parental genetic evaluation and counseling are mandatory for selecting the right genetic test to certify the diagnosis postmortem, by virtue of molecular autopsy by proxy. Clarifying a rare disorder diagnosis can help couples to avoid recurrence and plan early for their next pregnancies.

Dried Blood Spot Postmortem Metabolic Autopsy With Genotype Validation for Sudden Unexpected Deaths in Infancy and Childhood in Hong Kong.

Background Inborn errors of metabolism (IEM) are collectively rare but potentially preventable causes of sudden unexpected death (SUD) in infancy or childhood, and metabolic autopsy serves as the final tool for establishing the diagnosis. We conducted a retrospective review of the metabolic and molecular autopsy on SUD and characterized the biochemical and genetic findings. Methodology A retrospective review of postmortem metabolic investigations (dried blood spot acylcarnitines and amino acid analysis, urine metabolic profiling where available, and next-generation sequencing on a panel of 75 IEM genes) performed for infants and children who presented with SUD between October 2016 and December 2021 with inconclusive autopsy findings or autopsy features suspicious of underlying IEM in our locality was conducted. Clinical and autopsy findings were reviewed for each case. Results A total of 43 infants and children aged between zero days to 10 years at the time of death were referred to the authors' laboratories throughout the study period. One positive case of multiple acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency was diagnosed. Postmortem reference intervals for dried blood spot amino acids and acylcarnitines profile were established based on the results from the remaining patients. Conclusions Our study confirmed the importance of metabolic autopsy and the advantages of incorporating biochemical and genetic testing in this setting.

Cardiac genetic test yields and genotype-phenotype correlations from large cohort investigated by medical examiner's office.

BACKGROUND: Few reports describe the yield of postmortem genetic testing from medical examiners' offices or correlate genetic test results with autopsy-confirmed phenotypes from a large cohort. OBJECTIVES: To report results from cardiomyopathy- and cardiac arrhythmia-associated genetic testing in conjunction with autopsy findings of cases investigated at the United States' largest medical examiner office. METHODS: Postmortem cases tested from 2015 to 2022 with a cardiomyopathy- and cardiac arrhythmia-associated gene panel were reviewed. American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics/Association for Molecular Pathology guidelines were used to classify variant pathogenicity. Correlations of pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants (P/LPVs) with cardiac pathology were evaluated. RESULTS: The cohort included 1107 decedents of diverse ages and ethnicities. P/LPVs were detected in 87 (7.9%) cases, with 73 and 14 variants in cardiomyopathy and cardiac arrhythmia genes, respectively. Variants of uncertain significance were detected in 437 (39.5%) cases. The diagnostic yield (percentage of P/LPV) in decedents with cardiomyopathy (26.1%) was significantly higher than those without (P<.0001). The diagnostic yield was significantly lower in infants (0.7%) than older age groups (ranging from 1 to 74 years old, 5.7%-25.9%), which had no statistical difference between their yields. The diagnostic yields by cardiac autopsy findings were 54.0% for hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, 47.1% for arrhythmogenic cardiomyopathy, 20.0% for myocardial fibrosis, 19.0% for dilated cardiomyopathy, and 11.3% for myocarditis. Most P/LPVs were in MYBPC3, TTN, PKP2, SCN5A, MYH7, and FLNC. Ten P/LPVs were novel. CONCLUSIONS: Our results support the importance of performing postmortem genetic testing on decedents of all ages with cardiomyopathy, cardiac lesions insufficient to diagnosis a specific cardiomyopathy (e.g., myocardial fibrosis), and myocarditis. Combined postmortem cardiac examination and genetic analysis are advantageous in accurately determining the underlying cause of death and informing effective clinical care of family members.

Sudden Cardiac Death, Post-Mortem Investigation: A Proposing Panel of First Line and Second Line Genetic Tests.

Investigating the causes of Sudden cardiac death (SCD) is always difficult; in fact, genetic cardiac conditions associated with SCD could be "silent" even during autopsy investigation. In these cases, it is important to exclude other aetiology and assist to ask for genetic investigations. Herein, the purpose of this review is to collect the most-implicated genes in SCD and generate a panel with indications for first line and second line investigations. A systematic review of genetic disorders that may cause SCD in the general population was carried out according to the Preferred Reporting Item for Systematic Review (PRISMA) standards. We subsequently listed the genes that may be tested in the case of sudden cardiac death when the autopsy results are negative or with no evidence of acquired cardiac conditions. To make genetic tests more specific and efficient, it is useful and demanded to corroborate autopsy findings with the molecular investigation as evident in the panel proposed. The genes for first line investigations are HCM, MYBPC3, MYH7, TNNT2, TNNI3, while in case of DCM, the most implicated genes are LMNA and TTN, and in second line for these CDM, ACTN2, TPM1, C1QPB could be investigated. In cases of ACM/ARVC, the molecular investigation includes DSP, DSG2, DSC2, RYR2, PKP2. The channelopathies are associated with the following genes: SCN5A, KCNQ1, KCNH2, KCNE1, RYR2. Our work underlines the importance of genetic tests in forensic medicine and clinical pathology; moreover, it could be helpful not only to assist the pathologists to reach a diagnosis, but also to prevent other cases of SCD in the family of the descendant and to standardise the type of analysis performed in similar cases worldwide.

Sudden Cardiac Death in the Young: State-of-the-Art Review in Molecular Autopsy.

Sudden cardiac death (SCD) is defined as unexpected death due to a cardiac cause that occurs rapidly. Despite the identification of prevention strategies, SCD remains a serious public health problem worldwide, accounting for 15-20% of all deaths, and is therefore a challenge for modern medicine, especially when it affects young people. Sudden cardiac death in young people affects the population aged ≤ 35 years, including athletes and non-athletes, and it is due to various hereditary and non-hereditary causes. After an autopsy, if the cause remains unknown, it is called sudden unexplained death, often attributable to genetic causes. In these cases, molecular autopsy-post-mortem genetic testing-is essential to facilitate diagnostic and therapeutic pathways and/or the monitoring of family members of the cases. This review aims to elaborate on cardiac disorders marked by genetic mutations, necessitating the post-mortem genetic investigation of the deceased for an accurate diagnosis in order to facilitate informed genetic counseling and to implement preventive strategies for family members of the cases.

Diagnostic yield from cardiac gene testing for inherited cardiac conditions and re-evaluation of pre-ACMG variants of uncertain significance.

BACKGROUND: Inherited cardiomyopathies (HCM, DCM, ACM) and cardiac ion channelopathies (long QT/Brugada syndromes, CPVT) are associated with significant morbidity and mortality; however, diagnosis of a familial pathogenic variant in a proband allows for subsequent cascade screening of their at-risk relatives. AIMS: We investigated the diagnostic yield from cardiac gene panel testing and reviewed variants of uncertain significance from patients attending three specialist cardiogenetics services in Ireland in the years 2002 to 2020. RESULTS: Reviewing molecular genetic diagnostic reports of 834 patients from 820 families, the initial diagnostic yield of pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants was 237/834 patients (28.4%), increasing to 276/834 patients (33.1%) following re-evaluation of cases with variant(s) of uncertain significance. Altogether, 42/85 patients with VUS reviewed (49.4%) had a re-classification that could change their clinical management. Females were more likely to carry pathogenic/likely pathogenic variants than males (139/374, 37.2% vs 137/460, 29.8%, respectively, p = 0.03), and the diagnostic yields were highest in the 0 to < 2 years age group (6/12, 50.0%) and amongst those tested for cardiomyopathy gene panels (13/35, 37.1%). Variants in the MYBPC3/MYH7 (87/109, 79.8%) and KCNQ1/KCNH2 (91/100, 91.0%) genes were the predominant genetic causes for hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and long QT syndrome, respectively. CONCLUSION: Our study highlights the importance of collation and review of pre-ACMG genetic variants to increase diagnostic utility of genetic testing for inherited heart disease. Almost half of patients with pre-ACMG VUS reviewed had their variant re-classified to likely pathogenic/likely benign which resulted in a positive clinical impact for patients and their families.

The grading diagnostic strategy of molecular autopsy combined with pathological autopsy in the forensic diagnosis of cardiomyopathy.

The diagnosis of cardiomyopathy often relies on the subjective judgment of pathologists due to the variety of morphologic changes in the condition and its low specificity. This uncertainty can contribute to unexplained sudden cardiac deaths (USCD). To enhance the accuracy of hereditary cardiomyopathy diagnosis in forensic medicine, we proposed a combination of molecular autopsy and pathologic autopsy. By analyzing 16 deceased patients suspected of cardiomyopathy, using whole exome sequencing (WES) in molecular autopsy, and applying a combined diagnostic strategy, the study found pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants in 6 cases. Out of the 16 cases, cardiomyopathy was confirmed in 3, while 3 exhibited conditions consistent with it. Data for 4 cases was inconclusive, and cardiomyopathy was ruled out in 6. Notably, a novel variant of the TTN gene was identified. This research suggests that a grading diagnostic strategy, combining molecular and pathological evidence, can improve the accuracy of forensic cardiomyopathy diagnosis. This approach provides a practical model and strategy for precise forensic cause-of-death determination, addressing the limitations of relying solely on morphologic assessments in cardiomyopathy cases, and integrating genetic information for a more comprehensive diagnosis.

Molecular autopsy for sudden death in Japan.

Japan has various death investigation systems; however, external examinations, postmortem computed tomography, macroscopic examinations, and microscopic examinations are performed regardless of the system used. These examinations can reveal morphological abnormalities, whereas the cause of death in cases with non-morphological abnormalities can be detected through additional examinations. Molecular autopsy and postmortem genetic analyses are important additional examinations. They are capable of detecting inherited arrhythmias or inherited metabolic diseases, which are representative non-morphological disorders that cause sudden death, especially in infants and young people. In this review, we introduce molecular autopsy reports from Japan and describe our experience with representative cases. The relationships between drug-related deaths and genetic variants are also reviewed. Based on the presented information, molecular autopsy is expected to be used as routine examinations in death investigations because they can provide information to save new lives.

Yield of molecular autopsy in sudden cardiac death in athletes: data from a large registry in the UK.

AIMS: Sudden cardiac death (SCD) may occur in apparently healthy individuals, including athletes. The aim was to investigate the diagnostic role of post-mortem genetic testing, molecular autopsy (MA), in elucidating the cause of SCD in athletes. METHODS AND RESULTS: We reviewed a database of 6860 consecutive cases of SCD referred to our specialist cardiac pathology centre. All cases underwent detailed cardiac autopsy, and 748 were deemed to be athletes. Of these, 42 (6%) were investigated with MA (28 using a targeted sequencing, 14 exome sequencing). Variants were classified as pathogenic, likely pathogenic, or variant of unknown significance using international guidelines. Clinical information was obtained from referring coroners who completed a detailed health questionnaire. Out of the 42 decedents (average age 35 years old, 98% males) who were investigated with MA, the autopsy was in keeping with a structurally normal heart [sudden arrhythmic death syndrome (SADS)] in n = 33 (78%) cases, followed by arrhythmogenic cardiomyopathy (ACM) in eight (19%) individuals and idiopathic left ventricular fibrosis in one (2%). Death occurred during exercise and at rest in 26 (62%) and 16 (38%) individuals, respectively. Variants that were adjudicated clinically actionable were present in seven cases (17%). There was concordance between the genetic and phenotypic findings in two cases of ACM (in FLNC and TMEM43 genes). None of the variants identified in SADS cases were previously linked to channelopathies. Clinically actionable variants in cardiomyopathy-associated genes were found in five cases of SADS. CONCLUSION: The yield of MA in athletes who died suddenly is 17%. In SADS cases, clinically actionable variants were found in cardiomyopathy-associated genes and not in channelopathy-associated genes. Arrhythmogenic cardiomyopathy is a common cause of SCD in athletes, and one in four decedents with this condition had a clinically actionable variant in FLNC and TMEM43 genes.

Postmortem Identification of Genetic Variations Associated with Sudden Unexpected Death in Young People.

Sudden unexpected death in the young (SUDY) is a traumatic occurrence for their family; however, information on the genetic variations associated with the condition is currently lacking. It is important to carry out postmortem genetic analyses in cases of sudden death to provide information for relatives and to allow appropriate genetic counselling and clinical follow-up. This study aimed to investigate the genetic variations associated with the occurrence of SUDY in Japan, using next-generation sequencing (NGS). The study included 18 cases of SUDY (16 males, 2 females; age 15-47 years) who underwent autopsy, including NGS DNA sequencing for molecular analysis. A total of 168 genes were selected from the sequencing panel and filtered, resulting in the identification of 60 variants in cardiac disease-related genes. Many of the cases had several of these genetic variants and some cases had a cardiac phenotype. The identification of genetic variants using NGS provides important information regarding the pathogenicity of sudden death.

[Postmortem genetic analysis following sudden cardiac death : Background, approach, and future]. / Postmortale Genetik nach einem plötzlichen Herztod : Hintergründe, Vorgehen und Zukunft.

BACKGROUND: Sudden cardiac death (SCD) is defined as an unexpected, nontraumatic death with a possible cardiac or unknown cause. The lowest incidence is observed in infancy and childhood (1 per 100,000), and the incidence is approximately 50 per 100,000 in the middle-aged population, reaching a plateau around the age of 80 (200 per 100,000). While most SCD cases occur in older people with coronary artery disease, there is a predominance of monogenetic and polygenetic diseases in the young. METHODS: Postmortem genetic analysis (molecular autopsy) using next-generation sequencing reveals a definite pathogenic genetic alteration, which can explain SCD of young patients in near 20% of the cases. Hence, postmortem genetic analysis has become an important tool to unravel the inheritable cause of death. Furthermore, early identification of a pathogenic genetic sequence variant in the deceased is crucial to reduce risk in relatives due to preventive personalized measures. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: Postmortem genetic analysis forms together with the clinical assessment the basis for early identification of at-risk relatives. A new guideline for the management of ventricular arrhythmias and prevention of sudden death was recently published by the European Society of Cardiology. The new recommendations give genetic testing, also in deceased patients a much higher priority reflecting increasing relevance of genetic testing for diagnostic evaluation, risk stratification and prevention.

Clinical exome sequencing elucidates underlying cause of death in sudden unexpected death of infants: two case reports.

Sudden unexpected death in infants (SUDI) is a traumatic event for families, and unfortunately its occurrence remains high in many parts of the world. Whilst cause of death is resolved for most cases, others remain undetermined following postmortem investigations. There has been a recognition of the role of genetic testing in unexplained cases, where previous studies have demonstrated the resolution of cases through DNA analyses. Here we present two case reports of SUDI cases admitted to Salt River Mortuary, South Africa, and show that underlying causes of death were determined for both infants using clinical exome sequencing. The first infant was heterozygous for a variant (rs148175795) in COL6A3, which suggested a bronchopulmonary dysplasia phenotype. This hypothesis led to finding of a second candidate variant in DMP1 (rs142880465), which may contribute towards a digenic/polygenic mechanism of a more severe phenotype. Histological analysis of retained tissue sections showed an asphyxial mechanism of death, where bronchiolar muscle weakness from an underlying bronchopulmonary dysplasia may have contributed to the asphyxia by affecting respiration. In the second infant, a homozygous variant (rs201340753) was identified in MASP1, which was heterozygous in each parent, highlighting the value of including parental DNA in genetic studies. Whilst mannose-binding lectin deficiency could not be assessed, it is plausible that this variant may have acted in combination with other risk factors within the triple-risk model to result in sudden death. These results may have genetic implications for family members, and represent possible new candidate variants for molecular autopsies.

The Role of miRNA Expression Profile in Sudden Cardiac Death Cases.

Sudden cardiac death (SCD) is one of the leading causes of death in the world and for this reason it has attracted the attention of numerous researchers in the field of legal medicine. It is not easy to determine the cause in a SCD case and the available methods used for diagnosis cannot always give an exhaustive answer. In addition, the molecular analysis of genes does not lead to a clear conclusion, but it could be interesting to focus attention on the expression level of miRNAs, a class of non-coding RNA of about 22 nucleotides. The role of miRNAs is to regulate the gene expression through complementary binding to 3'-untraslated regions of miRNAs, leading to the inhibition of translation or to mRNA degradation. In recent years, several studies were performed with the aim of exploring the use of these molecules as biomarkers for SCD cases, and to also distinguish the causes that lead to cardiac death. In this review, we summarize experiments, evidence, and results of different studies on the implication of miRNAs in SCD cases. We discuss the different biological starting materials with their respective advantages and disadvantages, studying miRNA expression on tissue (fresh-frozen tissue and FFPE tissue), circulating cell-free miRNAs in blood of patients affected by cardiac disease at high risk of SCD, and exosomal miRNAs analyzed from serum of people who died from SCD.

Cardiac Genetic Investigation of Sudden Infant and Early Childhood Death: A Study From Victims to Families.

Background Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) is the leading cause of death up to age 1. Sudden unexplained death in childhood (SUDC) is similar but affects mostly toddlers aged 1 to 4. SUDC is rarer than SIDS, and although cardiogenetic testing (molecular autopsy) identifies an underlying cause in a fraction of SIDS, less is known about SUDC. Methods and Results Seventy-seven SIDS and 16 SUDC cases underwent molecular autopsy with 25 definitive-evidence arrhythmia-associated genes. In 18 cases, another 76 genes with varying degrees of evidence were analyzed. Parents were offered cascade screening. Double-blind review of clinical-genetic data established genotype-phenotype correlations. The yield of likely pathogenic variants in the 25 genes was higher in SUDC than in SIDS (18.8% [3/16] versus 2.6% [2/77], respectively; P=0.03), whereas novel/ultra-rare variants of uncertain significance were comparably represented. Rare variants of uncertain significance and likely benign variants were found only in SIDS. In cases with expanded analyses, likely pathogenic/likely benign variants stemmed only from definitive-evidence genes, whereas all other genes contributed only variants of uncertain significance. Among 24 parents screened, variant status and phenotype largely agreed, and 3 cases positively correlated for cardiac channelopathies. Genotype-phenotype correlations significantly aided variant adjudication. Conclusions Genetic yield is higher in SUDC than in SIDS although, in both, it is contributed only by definitive-evidence genes. SIDS/SUDC cascade family screening facilitates establishment or dismissal of a diagnosis through definitive variant adjudication indicating that anonymity is no longer justifiable. Channelopathies may underlie a relevant fraction of SUDC. Binary classifications of genetic causality (pathogenic versus benign) could not always be adequate.

Genetics and SUDEP: Challenges and Future Directions.

Sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP) is the leading cause of epilepsy-related deaths in children and adults with epilepsy. The incidence of SUDEP in children and adults is equal, approximately 1.2 per 1000-person years. Although inroads have been made in our understanding of SUDEP, its pathophysiology remains unknown. The most important risk factor for SUDEP is the presence of tonic-clonic seizures. Recently there has been growing interest in the contribution of genetic risk factors to SUDEP deaths. Pathogenic variants in epilepsy-related and cardiac genes have been found in some cases of SUDEP post-mortem. Pleiotropy may occur in which a single gene when altered may cause multiple phenotypes (i.e., epilepsy and cardiac arrhythmia). Recently it has been shown that some developmental and epileptic encephalopathies (DEEs) may also be at heightened risk of SUDEP. In addition, polygenic risk has been postulated to effect SUDEP risk with current models evaluating the additive effect of variants in multiple genes. However, the mechanisms underpinning polygenic risk in SUDEP are likely more complex than this. Some preliminary studies also highlight the feasibility of detecting genetic variants in brain tissue post-mortem. Despite the advances in the field of SUDEP genetics, the use of molecular autopsy remains underutilized in SUDEP cases. Several challenges exist concerning genetic testing post-mortem in SUDEP cases, such as interpretation, cost of testing, and availability. In this focused review, we highlight the current landscape of genetic testing in SUDEP cases, its challenges, and future directions.

The fundamental need for unifying phenotypes in sudden unexpected pediatric deaths.

A definitive, authoritative approach to evaluate the causes of unexpected, and ultimately unexplained, pediatric deaths remains elusive, relegating final conclusions to diagnoses of exclusion in the vast majority of cases. Research into unexplained pediatric deaths has focused primarily on sudden infant deaths (under 1 year of age) and led to the identification of several potential, albeit incompletely understood, contributory factors: nonspecific pathology findings, associations with sleep position and environment that may not be uniformly relevant, and the elucidation of a role for serotonin that is practically difficult to estimate in any individual case. Any assessment of progress in this field must also acknowledge the failure of current approaches to substantially decrease mortality rates in decades. Furthermore, potential commonalities with pediatric deaths across a broader age spectrum have not been widely considered. Recent epilepsy-related observations and genetic findings, identified post-mortem in both infants and children who died suddenly and unexpectedly, suggest a role for more intense and specific phenotyping efforts as well as an expanded role for genetic and genomic evaluation. We therefore present a new approach to reframe the phenotype in sudden unexplained deaths in the pediatric age range, collapsing many distinctions based on arbitrary factors (such as age) that have previously guided research in this area, and discuss its implications for the future of postmortem investigation.