Multicentric characterization of organ-based tube current modulation in head computed tomography: A dosimetric and image quality study.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the efficiency of organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) in head Computed Tomography (CT) for different radiology departments and manufacturers. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Five CT scanners from four radiology departments were evaluated in this study. All scans were performed using a standard and a routine head protocol. A scintillating fiber optic detector was placed directly on the gantry to measure the tube exit kerma. Image quality was quantified on a 16-cm HEAD phantom by measuring the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and the standard deviation of the Hounsfield units (HU) of circular regions of interest placed in the phantom. The Noise Power Spectrum (NPS) was also studied. Measured values were compared on images with and without OBTCM. RESULTS: The reduction rates in tube exit kerma, on the anterior part, vary between 11 % and 74 % depending on the CT scanner and the protocol used. The tube exit kerma on the posterior part remains unchanged in GE and Canon CT scanners. On the contrary, the tube exit kerma to the posterior part increases by up to 39 % in Siemens CT scanner. Image noise and SNR increase by up to 10 % in the five CT scanners. Nonetheless, the differences in noise and SNR are statistically significant (p-value < 0.05).The analysis of the NPS indicates that the noise texture remains unchanged. CONCLUSION: OBTCM reduces the tube exit kerma to the anterior part of the gantry without reducing substantially image quality for head protocols.

Noise reduction performance of a deep learning-based reconstruction in brain computed tomography images acquired with organ-based tube current modulation.

We aimed to evaluate the image quality of brain computed tomography (CT) images reconstructed using deep learning-based reconstruction (DLR) in organ-based tube current modulation (OB-TCM) acquisition. An anthropomorphic head phantom and a cylindrical low-contrast phantom were scanned at the standard dose level for adult brain CT in axial volume acquisition without OB-TCM. Moreover, image acquisition with OB-TCM was performed. The radiation dose on the eye lens was measured using a scintillation fibre-optic dosimeter placed on the anthropomorphic phantom's eye surface. The task transfer function (TTF), contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), and low-contrast object specific CNR obtained from low-contrast phantom images reconstructed with filtered back projection (FBP), hybrid iterative reconstruction (HIR), and two types of DLR (DLRCTA and DLRLCD) were compared. In result, OB-TCM achieved a 32.5% dose reduction in the eye lens. Although HIR, DLRCTA, and DLRLCD showed lower TTF than FBP, the difference in TTF at the highest contributing spatial frequency corresponding to the contrast rod diameter was < 10%. Despite the OB-TCM acquisition, DLRCTA and DLRLCD achieved significantly lower noise and a higher CNR than FBP without OB-TCM (p < 0.05). However, low-contrast object specific CNR was equivalent among all reconstruction methods for the objective diameter of 5 mm and slightly improved in DLRLCD for the objective diameter of 7 mm. DLR with OB-TCM acquisition enabled dose reduction for the eye lens and high CNR image appearance, whereas the low contrast detectability evaluated by low-contrast object specific CNR did not always improve.

Comparison of selected photon shield and organ-based tube current modulation for radiation dose reduction in head computed tomography: A phantom study.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to investigate the radiation dose and image quality of head CT using SPS and OBTCM techniques. METHODS: Three anthropomorphic head phantoms (1-yr-old, 5-yr-old, and adult) were used. Images were acquired using four modes (Default protocol, OBTCM, SPS, and SPS+OBTCM). Absorbed dose to the lens, anterior brain (brain_A), and posterior brain (brain_P) was measured and compared. Image noise and CNR were assessed in the selected regions of interest (ROIs). RESULTS: Compared with that in the Default protocol, the absorbed dose to the lens reduced by up to 28.33%,71.38%, and 71.12% in OBTCM, SPS, and SPS+OBTCM, respectively. The noise level in OBTCM slightly (≤1.45HU) increased than that in Default protocol, and the SPS or SPS+OBTCM mode resulted in a quantitatively small increase (≤2.58HU) in three phantoms. There was no significant difference in CNR of different phantoms under varies scanning modes (p > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: During head CT examinations, the SPS mode can reduce the radiation dose while maintaining image quality. SPS+OBTCM couldn't further effectively reduce the absorbed dose to the lens for 1-yr and 5-yr-old phantoms. Thus, SPS mode in pediatric and SPS+OBTCM mode in adult are better than other modes, and should be used in clinical practice.

A study of the effect of scanning center on the performance of organ dose modulation in head CT / 中华放射医学与防护杂志

Objective:To investigate the effect of different scanning centers on eye lens dose, image quality, and the dose reduction rate when using the organ dose modulation (ODM) technique in head CT.Methods:The porus acusticus externus of the head phantom was considered the scanning isocenter. The ODM was initiated and the spiral scans were performed at the scanning centers with the height of porus acusticus externus and its upper and lower 2, 4, and 6 cm, respectively. The scanning range was from the top of the head to the base of the head. Three thermoluminescent dosimeters (TLD) were placed on the surface of two eyes at each scan and the average measurement value was regarded as the radiation dose to the eye lens. The volume CT dose index (CTDI vol) and dose length product (DLP) were recorded. The scans were repeated with no ODM and the dose reduction rates at each scanning center were calculated. The regions of interest (ROI) in each group of images with ODM were drawn and the noise (SD), signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) were evaluated. Results:Compared with the isocenter, the maximum change rates of CTDI vol and DLP in each scanning center were 2.46% and 2.43%, respectively. The eye lens dose increased as the scanning centre moving upwars (i.e. the bed dropping) by 39.02% at the position of 6 cm above the isocenter and decreased by 35.91% at the position of 6 cm below the isocenter. With the seven groups of scanning centers, the reduction rates of CTDI vol and DLP caused by ODM were 7.95%-8.61%, 7.91%-8.61% respectively, and the difference in the reduction rate of each dose value was not statistically significant( P>0.05). The reduction rate for eye lens dose ranged from 18.09% to 26.14%, with the highest reduction rate at the position of 4 cm above the isocentre and the second rate at the isocentre (24.73%). The difference in the rate of reduction at each scanning center was statistically significant( t=0.13, P<0.05). As the scanning center moved up, the SD of the eye region decreased and the SNR increased, and the highest CNR at the isocentre was 239.79. The SD and SNR of the brain parenchyma region were 6.85-7.96 and 3.08-4.19 respectively, and the highest CNR at the isocentre was 244.79. Conclusions:When ODM technique is used in head CT, the scan centre has a significant effect on the eye lens dose and image quality. Meanwhile, the reduction rate of the eye lens dose caused by ODM is also affected. Therefore, porus acusticus externus is recommended as the scanning center in head CT.

The impact of vertical off-centering on image noise and breast dose in chest CT with organ-based tube current modulation: A phantom study.

PURPOSE: To determine the effects of patient vertical off-centering when using organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) in chest computed tomography (CT) with focus on breast dose. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An anthropomorphic adult female phantom with two different breast attachment sizes was scanned on GE Revolution EVO and Siemens Definition Edge CT systems using clinical chest CT protocols and anterior-to-posterior scouts. Scans with and without OBTCM were performed at different table heights (GE: centered, ±6 cm, and ± 3 cm; Siemens: centered, -6 cm, and ± 3 cm). The dose effects were studied with metal-oxidesemiconductor field-effect transistor dosimeters with complementary Monte Carlo simulations to determine full dose maps. Changes in image noise were studied using standard deviations of subtraction images from repeated acquisitions without dosimeters. RESULTS: Patient off-centering affected both the behavior of the normal tube current modulation as well as the extent of the OBTCM. Generally, both OBTCM techniques provided a substantial decrease in the breast doses (up to 30% local decrease). Lateral breast regions may, however, in some cases receive higher doses when OBTCM is enabled. This effect becomes more prominent when the patient is centered too low in the CT gantry. Changes in noise roughly followed the expected inverse of the change in dose. CONCLUSIONS: Patient off-centering was shown to affect the outcome of OBTCM in chest CT examination, and on some occasions, resulting in higher exposure. The use of modern dose optimization tools such as OBTCM emphasizes the importance of proper centering when preparing patients to CT scans.

Head CT dose reduction with organ-based tube current modulation.

BACKGROUND: A helical head CT examination uses a pitch factor (PF) of <1.0, resulting in a part of the slice being directly irradiated twice. This raises the possibility of double irradiation, which may increase the amount of radiation to the lens. Organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) is an effective method for reducing lens exposure because it reduces the dose to the anterior aspect of the patient. However, it is challenging to visualize the complex dose distribution when factoring in double irradiation. PURPOSE: To visualize twice-irradiated areas in helical head CT in three dimensions and to clarify the exposure reduction effect of OBTCM. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A leuco crystal violet (LCV) dosimeter was placed into an empty polyethylene terephthalate bottle 16.5 cm in diameter. Helical scans were performed without and with OBTCM using the following parameters: tube voltage 120 kV, tube current 600 mA, pitch factor 0.637, rotation time 0.5 s, 80 (detector rows) × 0.5 mm (detector collimation), and ten scans. Exposed areas were visualized using an optical computed tomography (OCT) system designed by our group. The dose reduction rate of OBTCM was defined as the ratio of the average values of the histogram with the dose value on the x-axis and the frequency on the y-axis without and with OBTCM at 90° to the anterior midline. RESULTS: The LCV dosimeter visualized the spiral-shaped twice-irradiated areas. Double irradiation resulted in a dose of 2.19/1.90 and 1.38/1.19 Gy (15.0% and 15.9% increase) without and with OBTCM, respectively. The dose reduction using OBTCM was 29.6% at 90° anterolateral. CONCLUSION: The LCV dosimeter visualized the complex three-dimensional irradiated areas and enabled dose measurement in twice-irradiated areas. Increased exposure from double irradiation was attenuated by OBTCM.

Evaluation of selected photon shield and organ-based tube current modulation for organ dose reduction and image quality in head CT for infants: a phantom study / 中华放射医学与防护杂志

Objective:To compare the dose and image quality of selected photon shield (SPS) technique, organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) technique and the combination of these two techniques for reducing the organ dose in head CT examination for infants.Methods:Two anthropomorphic head phantoms (CIRS 1-yr-old and 5-yr-old) were scanned by using Reference mode, Reference + OBTCM mode, SPS mode and SPS + OBTCM mode, respectively. Radiation doses to the lens of the eye, the anterior of the brain, the posterior of the brain, noise level and CNR of orbit and brain in different phantoms were measured and compared by using different scanning modes.Results:Compared with Reference mode, the doses to the lens of the eye in 1-yr-old and 5-yr-old phantom decreased by (21.89 ± 0.01)% and (28.33 ± 0.34)%, respectively. In SPS mode, the reduction in doses to the lens of the eye in 1-yr-old and 5-yr-old phantom were (71.38 ± 1.30)% and (53.72 ± 2.42)%, respectively. In SPS + OBTCM mode, the reduction was (71.12 ± 2.54)% and (55.73 ± 1.90)%, respectively. There was significant difference in the noise level of orbit and brain in different phantoms under various scanning modes ( F=5.67-85.47, P< 0.05). The noise level in OBTCM mode compared with reference mode increased slightly (<1.45 HU) in various phantoms. SPS and SPS + OBTCM mode resulted in a small noise increase (<2.58 HU). There was no significant difference in CNR of different phantoms under various scanning modes ( P>0.05). Conclusions:SPS and SPS + OBTCM mode can significantly reduce the radiation dose of lens and the whole image plane in the head CT scan for infants, with maintaining the image quality.

Radiation dose reduction to the eye lens in head CT using tungsten functional paper and organ-based tube current modulation.

PURPOSE: We investigated whether a tungsten functional paper (TFP) shield and/or organ-based tube current modulation (TCM) can reduce the dose to the eye lens. MATERIALS AND METHODS: All scans were performed using our routine head examination protocol (spiral acquisition, 120 kVp, noise Index 3.5) with an anthropomorphic head phantom. The dose reduction rate was measured by the following methods with a scintillation fiber optic dosimeter: (a) without any dose reduction techniques (Original scan), (b) TFP shield, (c) TCM, and (d) TFP shield plus TCM. Image noise and CT number were obtained and compared between the three groups. In addition, image noise in method (d) was measured with varying distances between the TFP shield and eye lens. RESULTS: The reduction rates using TFP shield, TCM, and TFP shield plus TCM compared with those for the Original scan were 17.8 %, 13.6 %, and 27.7 %, respectively. Image noise (mean ± standard deviation) in the anterior region for the Original scan, TFP shield, TCM, and TFP shield plus TCM were 4.1 ± 0.2, 4.6 ± 0.2, 4.4 ± 0.3, and 5.0 ± 0.2, while the CT numbers were 19.3 ± 0.8, 23.8 ± 0.8, 19.6 ± 0.8, and 24.1 ± 0.8, respectively. Increasing the distance between the TFP and the eye significantly decreased the CT number when using TFP shield plus TCM (p < .05). CONCLUSION: TFP shield plus TCM reduced the dose to the eye lens in head CT while maintaining image quality with an air gap between the TFP and skin surface.

Breast exposure reduction using organ-effective modulation on chest CT in Asian women.

PURPOSE: Organ-effective modulation (OEM) is a mechanism to reduce radiation dose to selected organs on computed tomography (CT). The purpose of this study was to measure radiation dose to the breast in Asian patients undergoing chest CT and to clarify the degree of exposure reduction. METHOD: We randomly selected 60 female patients undergoing non-contrast chest CT after breast cancer surgery. To measure radiation dose, an optically stimulated luminescence dosimeter had been attached directly to the gown over the nonoperated breast in 30 patients. Radiologists evaluated the image quality with and without OEM. In order to clarify the characteristics of OEM, the effects of angle and object size were measured using a phantom and an ionization chamber dosimeter. RESULTS: The OEM group received 9.1 ±â€¯1.9 mGy and the non-OEM group received 10.7 ±â€¯2.4 mGy. OEM reduced the exposure by 12.2% (P <  0.01). OEM caused no reduction in diagnostic quality. In the phantom study, the results of the angle effect were 3.2%, 11.2%, 28.7%, 31.3, 25.9%, 14.9% and 6.0% dose reductions at -90, -60, -30, 0, 30, 60 and 90°, respectively. The effect of the subject thickness was 3.7%, 17.5%, 30.2%, 31.7%, and 34.1% at 16, 20, 24, 28 and 32 cm diameters, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: OEM is a useful mechanism for reducing radiation exposure to the breast without affecting diagnostic imaging quality. The reduction rate correlated negatively with body habitus.

New organ-based tube current modulation method to reduce the radiation dose during computed tomography of the head: evaluation of image quality and radiation dose to the eyes in the phantom study.

A new organ-based tube current modulation (NOB-TCM) method was designed with the intent to decrease tube current by 30% over a prescribed 90° radial arc across the anterior aspect of the radiosensitive organ, without increasing tube current in the remaining radial arc. We compared a reference scan and five other dose-reducing methods with regard to effects on dose, practicality, and image quality to determine the most effective method for the reduction of the radiation dose to the eyes during CT examinations of the head. We compared the radiation doses to the eyes and physical image quality in different regions of interest for TCM and shielding scans. Three types of TCM scans were performed: longitudinal TCM, angular TCM, and NOB-TCM. A bismuth sheet and lead goggles were each applied for the shielding scan. Relative to the reference scan, the dose to the eye was reduced to 25.88% with NOB-TCM, 44.53% with lead goggles, and 36.91% with a bismuth shield. Relative to the reference scan, the mean signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) was decreased to 8.02% with NOB-TCM, 28.36% with lead goggles, and 32.95% with the bismuth shield. The SNR of the anterior region of interest was decreased to 11.89% with NOB-TCM and 87.89% with the bismuth shield. The average figure of merit was increased by 11.7% with longitudinal TCM and 13.39% with NOB-TCM, compared with the reference scan. NOB-TCM is a superior solution for head CT, including the orbital area, due to the reduction in radiation exposure without significant loss in image quality.

CT breast dose reduction with the use of breast positioning and organ-based tube current modulation.

PURPOSE: This study aimed to investigate the breast dose reduction potential of a breast-positioning (BP) technique for thoracic CT examinations with organ-based tube current modulation (OTCM). METHODS: This study included 13 female anthropomorphic computational phantoms (XCAT, age range: 27-65 y.o., weight range: 52-105.8 kg). Each phantom was modified to simulate three breast sizes in standard supine geometry. The modeled breasts were then morphed to emulate BP that constrained the majority of the breast tissue inside the 120° anterior tube current (mA) reduction zone. The OTCM mA value was modeled using a ray-tracing program, which reduced the mA to 20% in the anterior region with a corresponding increase to the posterior region. The organ doses were estimated by a validated Monte Carlo program for a typical clinical CT system (SOMATOM Definition Flash, Siemens Healthcare). The simulated organ doses and organ doses normalized by CTDIvol were used to compare three CT protocols: attenuation-based tube current modulation (ATCM), OTCM, and OTCM with BP (OTCMBP ). RESULTS: On average, compared to ATCM, OTCM reduced breast dose by 19.3 ± 4.5%, whereas OTCMBP reduced breast dose by 38.6 ± 8.1% (an additional 23.8 ± 9.4%). The dose saving of OTCMBP was more significant for larger breasts (on average 33, 38, and 44% reduction for 0.5, 1, and 2 kg breasts, respectively). Compared to ATCM, OTCMBP also reduced thymus and heart dose by 15.1 ± 7.4% and 15.9 ± 6.2% respectively. CONCLUSIONS: In thoracic CT examinations, OTCM with a breast-positioning technique can markedly reduce unnecessary exposure to radiosensitive organs in anterior chest wall, specifically breast tissue. The breast dose reduction is more notable for women with larger breasts.

Evaluation of a Net Dose-Reducing Organ-Based Tube Current Modulation Technique: Comparison With Standard Dose and Bismuth-Shielded Acquisitions.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to compare the dose and image noise associated with two methods of radiation dose reduction to the superficial anterior organs: bismuth shielding and a net dose-reducing organ-based tube current modulation TCM technique. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Three scanning modes-the reference dose, bismuth-shielded, and organ dose-modulated modes-were evaluated. With the use of an anthropomorphic phantom, surface doses to the eye, thyroid, and female breast were measured using optically stimulated luminescence detectors. A CT dose index (CTDI) phantom was used to compare doses with the overall phantom volume in the different modes. RESULTS: The dose to the anterior surface was reduced by 35%, 42%, and 37% in the head, neck, and chest regions, respectively, when the bismuth-shielded scanning mode was used, whereas surface dose reductions of 20%, 34%, and 38%, respectively, were noted for the organ-based TCM scanning mode. The CTDI-type dose was reduced by 13%, 14%, and 17% in the head, neck, and chest regions, respectively, when the bismuth-shielded mode was used, whereas dose reductions of 9%, 18%, and 20%, respectively, were observed for the organ-based TCM mode. Anterior image noise increased by 0.1, 9.5, and 0.7 HU in the head, neck, and chest regions, respectively, when the bismuth-shielded mode was used. These findings compared with increases in image noise of 0.1, 0.5, and 0.6 HU, respectively, for the organ-based TCM mode. CONCLUSION: The implementation of organ-based TCM reduces the net tube current per rotation, so no body region receives increased radiation exposure. The use of this method allows the dose to the anterior surface to be reduced to an extent similar to that observed with the use of the bismuth shield, yet it does not produce the image quality degradation associated with bismuth shielding.