Interpretation of course conceptual structure and student self-efficacy: an integrated strategy of knowledge graphs with item response modeling.

BACKGROUND: There is a scarcity of studies that quantitatively assess the difficulty and importance of knowledge points (KPs) depending on students' self-efficacy for learning (SEL). This study aims to validate the practical application of psychological measurement tools in physical therapy education by analyzing student SEL and course conceptual structure. METHODS: From the "Therapeutic Exercise" course curriculum, we extracted 100 KPs and administered a difficulty rating questionnaire to 218 students post-final exam. The pipeline of the non-parametric Item Response Theory (IRT) and parametric IRT modeling was employed to estimate student SEL and describe the hierarchy of KPs in terms of item difficulty. Additionally, Gaussian Graphical Models with Non-Convex Penalties were deployed to create a Knowledge Graph (KG) and identify the main components. A visual analytics approach was then proposed to understand the correlation and difficulty level of KPs. RESULTS: We identified 50 KPs to create the Mokken scale, which exhibited high reliability (Cronbach's alpha = 0.9675) with no gender bias at the overall or at each item level (p > 0.05). The three-parameter logistic model (3PLM) demonstrated good fitness with questionnaire data, whose Root Mean Square Error Approximation was < 0.05. Also, item-model fitness unveiled good fitness, as indicated by each item with non-significant p-values for chi-square tests. The Wright map revealed item difficulty relative to SEL levels. SEL estimated by the 3PLM correlated significantly with the high-ability range of average Grade-Point Average (p < 0.05). The KG backbone structure consisted of 58 KPs, with 29 KPs overlapping with the Mokken scale. Visual analysis of the KG backbone structure revealed that the difficulty level of KPs in the IRT could not replace their position parameters in the KG. CONCLUSION: The IRT and KG methods utilized in this study offer distinct perspectives for visualizing hierarchical relationships and correlations among the KPs. Based on real-world teaching empirical data, this study helps to provide a research foundation for updating course contents and customizing learning objectives. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Not applicable.

La evaluación docente en las residencias médicas: ¿motivación o molestia para los profesores? / Teaching evaluation in medical residencies: motivation or annoyance for teachers?

Introducción: Pocas veces se indaga sobre el significado que tiene para los profesores recibir informes sobre sus competencias docentes en opinión de los médicos residentes. El objetivo de este estudio es comprender la manera en que losprofesores valoran y usan los datos de la evaluación docente (ED) para transformar sus prácticas educativas. Sujetos y métodos: Es un estudio cuantitativo descriptivo por medio de encuesta aplicada en línea durante septiembre y octubre de 2023. La población fue de 896 profesores titulares y adjuntos con nombramiento de 79 especialidades evaluados al menos por los residentes en una ocasión. Respondieron 491 profesores (54,8%). La estructura del instrumento tenía tres secciones: datos sociodemográficos y académicos, preguntas cerradas con escalas de tipo Likert categorizadas en cuatro temas y preguntas abiertas para comentarios escritos.Resultados: Para más del 85%, la ED es un referente que influye en su desempeño docente. El 93,3% está de acuerdo en que la ED ayuda a identificar fortalezas y debilidades. El 75% o más cree que las preguntas del cuestionario que responden los residentes se relacionan con sus prácticas educativas. Conclusiones: La ED es aceptada y valorada positivamente por los docentes, sus respuestas comparten el imaginario colectivo característico de los contextos de educación superior que consideran esta evaluación una estrategia para realimentar y mejorar su desempeño docente, así como para detectar fortalezas y áreas de oportunidad. Se requieren discusiones guiadas sobre las competencias docentes que vayan más allá de los informes individuales con el fin de visibilizar lasdinámicas académicas en la sede.(AU)

Introduction: The meaning of the data given by professors who receive teaching competencies reports in the opinion of resident physicians is rarely investigated. The aim of this study is to understand how teachers value and use teaching evaluation (TE) data to transform their educational practices.Subjects and methods: Quantitative descriptive study by means of an online survey applied during September and October 2023. The population consisted of 896 tenured and associated professors appointed in 79 specialties evaluated by residents at least once. A total of 491 teachers (54.8%) responded. The structure of the instrument had three sections: sociodemographic and academic data, closed-ended questions with Likert-type scales categorized into 4 themes, and open-ended questions for written comments. Results: More than 85% considered TE as a referent that influences their teaching performance. 93.3% agree that TE helps identify strengths and weaknesses. More than 75% believe that the questionnaire items answered by residents relate to their educational practices. Conclusions: TE is accepted and positively valued by teachers, their responses share the collective imaginary characteristic of higher educational contexts that consider this evaluation as a strategy to provide feedback and improve their teaching performance, and to detect strengths and areas of opportunity. Guided discussions on teaching competencies that go beyond individual reports are required to make visible the academic dynamics in each institution.(AU)

The optimization of college tennis training and teaching under deep learning.

To enhance the integration of deep learning into tennis education and instigate reforms in sports programs, this paper employs deep learning techniques to analyze tennis tactics. The experiments initially introduce the concepts of sports science and backpropagation neural networks. Subsequently, these theories are applied to formulate a comprehensive system of tennis tactical diagnostic indicators, encompassing construction principles, basic requirements, diagnostic indicator content, and evaluation indicator design. Simultaneously, a Back Propagation Neural Network (BPNN) is utilized to construct a tennis tactical diagnostic model. The paper concludes with a series of experiments conducted to validate the effectiveness of the constructed indicator system and diagnostic model. The results indicate the excellent performance of the neural network model when trained on tennis match data, with a mean squared error of 0.00037146 on the validation set and 0.0104 on the training set. This demonstrates the outstanding predictive capability of the model. Additionally, the system proves capable of providing detailed tactical application analysis when employing the tennis tactical diagnostic indicator system for real-time athlete diagnosis. This functionality offers robust support for effective training and coaching during matches. In summary, this paper aims to evaluate athletes' performance by constructing a diagnostic system, providing a solid reference for optimizing tennis training and education. The insights offered by this paper have the potential to drive reforms in sports programs, particularly in the realm of tennis education.

Community-supported teaching on the topic of transgender identity in undergraduate medical education - a pilot project.

Introduction and objectives: Future physicians are insufficiently prepared for the topic of transgender identity during their studies. Relevant courses during undergraduate medical education are heterogeneous and not widely established within the curricula. At our university, we investigated if students' knowledge of transgender identity could be increased through medical specialist teaching and teaching delivered by representatives of the trans* community (community-supported teaching). Methods: During summer semester 2021 (SS21), the knowledge level on transgender identity of 134 medical students in their fifth clinical semester was evaluated (phase 1). In addition, knowledge gain on gender incongruence through the module "psychiatry" was retrospectively surveyed across two dimensions: 1. diagnostic criteria, 2. treatment/care. During winter semester 2021/22 (WS 21/22), a 90-minute seminar on transgender identity was held either community-supported or by medical specialists (phase 2). Following the psychiatry exam, a re-evaluation was carried out by 115 students (phase 3). Results: The students in SS21 did not feel sufficiently educated in the topic of transgender identity through their studies, but rated the relevance of the topic for their later profession as high. Learning gain improved after the introduction of the seminar in WS21/22 compared to the previous semester (both dimensions p<.001). Community-supported and specialist teaching achieved equivalent results. Conclusion: One 90-minutes seminar led to a significant learning gain regarding the topic of transgender identity. Community-supported teaching is a promising way to impart knowledge in a qualified manner: Medical faculties should use this form of teaching to convey established knowledge to students in future curricula.

Student Learning Behavior Recognition Incorporating Data Augmentation with Learning Feature Representation in Smart Classrooms.

A robust and scientifically grounded teaching evaluation system holds significant importance in modern education, serving as a crucial metric that reflects the quality of classroom instruction. However, current methodologies within smart classroom environments have distinct limitations. These include accommodating a substantial student population, grappling with object detection challenges due to obstructions, and encountering accuracy issues in recognition stemming from varying observation angles. To address these limitations, this paper proposes an innovative data augmentation approach designed to detect distinct student behaviors by leveraging focused behavioral attributes. The primary objective is to alleviate the pedagogical workload. The process begins with assembling a concise dataset tailored for discerning student learning behaviors, followed by the application of data augmentation techniques to significantly expand its size. Additionally, the architectural prowess of the Extended-efficient Layer Aggregation Networks (E-ELAN) is harnessed to effectively extract a diverse array of learning behavior features. Of particular note is the integration of the Channel-wise Attention Module (CBAM) focal mechanism into the feature detection network. This integration plays a pivotal role, enhancing the network's ability to detect key cues relevant to student learning behaviors and thereby heightening feature identification precision. The culmination of this methodological journey involves the classification of the extracted features through a dual-pronged conduit: the Feature Pyramid Network (FPN) and the Path Aggregation Network (PAN). Empirical evidence vividly demonstrates the potency of the proposed methodology, yielding a mean average precision (mAP) of 96.7%. This achievement surpasses comparable methodologies by a substantial margin of at least 11.9%, conclusively highlighting the method's superior recognition capabilities. This research has an important impact on the field of teaching evaluation system, which helps to reduce the burden of educators on the one hand, and makes teaching evaluation more objective and accurate on the other hand.

Interaction and psychological characteristics of art teaching based on Openpose and Long Short-Term Memory network.

As living standards improve, people's demand for appreciation and learning of art is growing gradually. Unlike the traditional learning model, art teaching requires a specific understanding of learners' psychology and controlling what they have learned so that they can create new ideas. This article combines the current deep learning technology with heart rate to complete the action recognition of art dance teaching. The video data processing and recognition are conducted through the Openpose network and graph convolution network. The heart rate data recognition is completed through the Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) network. The optimal recognition model is established through the data fusion of the two decision levels through the adaptive weight analysis method. The experimental results show that the accuracy of the classification fusion model is better than that of the single-mode recognition method, which is improved from 85.0% to 97.5%. The proposed method can evaluate the heart rate while ensuring high accuracy recognition. The proposed research can help analyze dance teaching and provide a new idea for future combined research on teaching interaction.

The effect of research on the perceived quality of teaching: a cross-sectional study among university students in Lebanon.

INTRODUCTION: The complementarity between research and teaching is still debated, although several higher education institutions require instructors to do research. In the absence of a consensus on this matter and given the lack of related studies in Lebanon, this study aimed to describe students' perception of research integration into teaching, and to link research and professional skills to quality teaching, using validated scales related to these concepts. METHODS: A standardized questionnaire was diffused to university students; it included validated scales: the Student Perception of Research Integration Questionnaire (SPRIQ), the Adapted-Teachers' quality assessment questionnaire (A-TQAQ), the Student Evaluation of Teaching short form (SET37-QS), and Knowledge and Attitudes Towards Health Research Questionnaire. RESULTS: Research integration was well perceived, and teaching was well evaluated by 445 participants from various disciplines, particularly those of a higher socioeconomic level, majoring in health, and females, as indicated by their mean scores. Research-active instructors had a significantly better-perceived teaching quality (17%; p < 0.001) than their non-active counterparts. This finding was particularly true among postgraduate and higher GPA students. The multivariable analysis showed that the knowledge and attitude towards research were related to students' better perception of research integration and higher evaluation of teaching. CONCLUSION: This study showed an overall good perception of research and teaching evaluation among participants from various disciplines, with research-active instructors having a better-perceived teaching quality. These findings could guide decisions on research integration into curricula using multidisciplinary methodologies to strengthen research integration and involve students in research activities.

[Digital teaching 2020: Online teaching receives a better assessment than face-to-face teaching]. / Digitale Lehre 2020: Online-Unterricht erhält bessere Bewertung als Präsenzunterricht.

BACKGROUND: Due to the corona pandemic, face-to-face teaching was no longer permitted in the summer semester 2020 and online alternatives were quickly found. OBJECTIVE: In our article, we illustrate the switch from face-to-face to online teaching in ophthalmology at the University of Lübeck and compare online teaching with face-to-face teaching. METHODS: The central teaching evaluation takes place every semester with a standardized questionnaire. Based on the evaluation of these questions, a direct comparison of the attendance semester of the winter semester 2019/2020 with the online semester of the summer semester 2020 was carried out. RESULTS: The structure (p = 0.003), the organization (p = 0.001), the resources made available (p = 0.034), the attendance of the lectures (p < 0.001) and further dates (p = 0.041), the increase in interest (p = 0.039) and learning (p = 0.001) were rated better in the online semester than in the face-to-face semester. Overall, the digital summer semester 2020 (p < 0.01) received a significantly better overall grade than the face-to-face semester in winter 2019/2020. CONCLUSION: The structure of our courses has also been proven online. The theoretical content could be excellently mediated; however, practical exercises are not possible online. For the learning of practical skills, face-to-face instruction is still necessary.

Analysis and evaluation of Hematology online open course based on SPOC platform / 中华医学教育探索杂志

Objective:To explore the teaching evaluation of online open course of hematology based on small private online course (SPOC) platform by means of quantitative method.Methods:The fourth-year undergraduates of clinical medicine major were selected to receive online course learning of hematology, including video viewing, rich text browsing, in-class quizzes, and seminars. The teaching contents covered the basis of hematological diseases, anemic diseases, hematological tumors, bleeding and coagulation disorders. Teaching evaluation was conducted through teaching behavior assessment, unit test, course examination and SPOC scoring. Linear regression analysis was used to analyze the correlation between the duration of the teaching video and student learning behavior. The correlation between video learning quantity and viewing time and course test scores and SPOC scores was analyzed. Kruskal-Wallis test was used to compare the differences in curriculum learning behavior (participation rate). T-test was used to compare the differences between the two results of two unit tests and to calculate the alternative-form reliability. Chi-square test was used to compare the differences in scores of different sub-specialty questions in hematology, and the differences of participation rate of different examination points of hematological tumors. Results:The teaching video viewing rate was significantly higher than the participation rate of rich text browsing and in-class quizzes ( P < 0.001; P < 0.001). There was no obvious correlation between video duration and video viewing, rich text browsing, in-class quizzes ( R = 0.168, F = 0.81, P = 0.376; R = 0.057, F = 0.07, P=0.802; R=0.124, F=0.37, P=0.546). There was a significant positive correlation between the participation rate of video viewing and rich text browsing and in-class quizzes ( R =0.890, F=76.41, P<0.001; R=0.934, F=163.67, P < 0.001). The participation rate of anemic disease unit test was significantly higher than that of hematological tumors ( χ2 = 49.08, P<0.001), bleeding and coagulation disorders ( χ2= 25.97, P< 0.001), and the second results were significantly improved ( t=-2.09, P=0.040), and the alternative-form reliability was 0.750. There was no significant difference in the participation rate of different sub-specialty courses ( χ2=5.20, P=0.074); the number of video watching was significantly positively correlated with SPOC scores ( R=0.523, F=196.22, P<0.001); the participation rate of molecular genetics and molecular biology tests of blood tumor was significantly lower than that of general clinical information questions ( P < 0.05). Conclusion:Teaching videos are the foundation of online courses. Increasing the number of video viewing and improving video viewing rate can effectively mobilize the enthusiasm of extensive learning, such as rich text browsing and in-class quizzes, and improve learning participation. It is conducive to the improvement of students' academic performance. Simple behavior factors such as video viewing time are not recommended as performance evaluation indicators. Unit test takes two times to get the highest score, which is conducive to improving professional learning level through learning behavior, without affecting the reliability of the performance evaluation. The online open course based on the SPOC platform is conducive to the balanced development of the course teaching of Hematology.

Exploration and practice of process assessment in Human Parasitology teaching for international medical students / 中国血吸虫病防治杂志

Teaching evaluation is an important measure to test the teaching quality. In order to better achieve the training objectives among international medical students based on the specific conditions of foreign students and the characteristics of Human Parasitology, a process-based assessment and evaluation system has been established for international medical students. The process assessment highlights the characteristics of assessment process, diversified forms and inquires of test questions. Following implementation of process assessment, the proportion of excellence (examination scores of 90 and higher) improved from 3.25% (10/308) to 13.09% (50/382) (t = 5.995, P < 0.001) and the proportion of good marks (examination scores of 80 to 89) increased from 18.83% (58/308) to 36.13% (138/382) (t = 7.505, P < 0.001) during the semester assessment among international medical students at five grades, while the proportion of failure in examination pass (examination scores of below 60) reduced from 12.34% (38/308) to 3.24% (10/382) (t = 7.303, P < 0.000 1), indicating that the process-based assessment and evaluation system improves the examination score of Human Parasitology among international medical students and the teaching quality of Human Parasitology.

A pedagogical study on promoting students' deep learning through design-based learning.

This paper illustrates the design-based learning (DBL) approach to promoting the deep learning of students and improving the quality of teaching in engineering design education. We performed three aspects of research with students in a typical educational activity. The first study investigated students' deep learning before and after the DBL approach, both in terms of deep learning status and deep learning ability. The second study examined the effectiveness of the DBL approach by comparative research of a control class (traditional teaching method) and an experimental class (DBL method). The third study examined students' evaluations of the DBL approach. It is approved that the DBL approach has distinctively stimulated the students' motivation to learn, making them more actively engaged in study. The students' higher-order thinking and higher-order capabilities are enhanced, such as critical thinking ability and problem-solving ability. At the same time, they are satisfied with the DBL approach. These findings suggest that the DBL approach is effective in promoting students' deep learning and improving the quality of teaching and learning.

How to make students satisfied with digital teaching? Investigative results from teaching evaluations in Gynecology and Obstetrics.

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to investigate whether students' attitude towards online learning in Gynecology and Obstetrics changed during the COVID-19 pandemic. We further examined which variables impacted students' satisfaction with digital learning. METHODS: A specifically developed questionnaire was used from June 2020-July 2021 for N = 234 medical students participating in the course "Gynecology and Obstetrics" at University of Heidelberg. Thirty-five items were repeatedly applied in different cohorts to assess structure- and content-related quality of teaching. In addition, their influence on overall satisfaction with digital teaching was analyzed by applying investigative analyses like multiple regression and extreme group comparisons. RESULTS: Especially items associated with content-related quality of teaching (ß = 0.24), organization of teaching (ß = 0.25) and subjective learning success (ß = 0.27) seemed to be relevant predictors for overall satisfaction with courses. Fears and changes due to the pandemic situation also played a role for a subgroup of students. Aspects linked to technical quality of teaching, interactions with teachers and students or advantages of web-based learning appeared to play a subordinate role for overall satisfaction with digital teaching. Comparisons of ratings over time revealed that teaching evaluations almost remained the same. CONCLUSION: Our results give several hints regarding how digital teaching should be designed and how it can be improved. Further studies are needed to validate our results and to develop methods to improve digital teaching in medicine.

Teaching program evaluation: How blending theory and practice enhance student-evaluator competencies in an education policy graduate program.

Researchers examined student learning outcomes in two program evaluation courses, taught by the same instructors: a first-year PhD-level course taught using theory and a second-year master's-level course taught blending theory and application by executing an evaluation. Embedding this work in Ghere, King, Stevahn, and Minnema (2006) Essential Competencies for Program Evaluators Self-Assessment (ECPE), researchers investigated student perceptions of their evaluator competencies, scored end-of-course proposals, and interviewed program leaders to understand differences between the two teaching methods, as well as the extent to which the applied evaluation component of the master's-level course may have impacted differential, practice-based outcomes. Researchers analyzed program leader interviews and student data derived via survey, and a six-person team analyzed students' end-of-course proposals. Findings showed master's-level students independently rated all applied components of their course significantly higher than their and their PhD counterparts' rating of the theoretical components, which partially aligned with results of students' final, end-of-course proposals. Program leaders agreed that the applied course yielded strong evaluative findings, given what they perceived as a successful integration of theory and practice.

[Exploration and practice of process assessment in Human Parasitology teaching for international medical students].

Teaching evaluation is an important measure to test the teaching quality. In order to better achieve the training objectives among international medical students based on the specific conditions of foreign students and the characteristics of Human Parasitology, a process-based assessment and evaluation system has been established for international medical students. The process assessment highlights the characteristics of assessment process, diversified forms and inquires of test questions. Following implementation of process assessment, the proportion of excellence (examination scores of 90 and higher) improved from 3.25% (10/308) to 13.09% (50/382) (t = 5.995, P < 0.001) and the proportion of good marks (examination scores of 80 to 89) increased from 18.83% (58/308) to 36.13% (138/382) (t = 7.505, P < 0.001) during the semester assessment among international medical students at five grades, while the proportion of failure in examination pass (examination scores of below 60) reduced from 12.34% (38/308) to 3.24% (10/382) (t = 7.303, P < 0.000 1), indicating that the process-based assessment and evaluation system improves the examination score of Human Parasitology among international medical students and the teaching quality of Human Parasitology.

[Online examination course instead of classroom teaching: adaptation of medical student teaching during the COVID-19 pandemic]. / Online-Untersuchungskurs statt Präsenzveranstaltung: Anpassung der studentischen Lehre im Medizinstudium während der COVID-19-Pandemie.

BACKGROUND: The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic restricted face-to-face interactions of medical students and teachers. OBJECTIVE: To develop and evaluate an online course for ophthalmology examination techniques for medical students and to determine the impact of the course on the practical objective structured clinical examination (OSCE). MATERIAL AND METHODS: The online examination course was developed as a video-based tutorial according to the SMART (specific, measurable, activating, reasonable, time-bound) principle covering all topics of the National Competency-based Catalogue of Learning Objectives for Medical Education and made available to medical students in the ophthalmology course. At the end of the semester the students graded the online examination course on an ordinal scale from 1 (strongly agree) to 6 (strongly disagree) anonymously and were asked for comments. The grades of the OSCE (range 1-5) were compared with the OSCE results of the previous semester. RESULTS: Of the 164 students 67 participated in the online evaluation (41%). The students reported to be well-prepared for the OSCE (mean grade 2.0; SD 1.0). In the future, 70% of the students would prefer combined online and on-site teaching (47 out of 67 students). Among all 164 students, the mean OSCE results were excellent (mean grade 1.1; SD 0.2) and comparable to the previous semester (mean grade among 166 students, 1.1; SD 0.2; two-sided t-test, p = 0.86). CONCLUSION: The online course on ophthalmology examination techniques allowed medical students to prepare for the OSCE. Beyond the COVID-19 pandemic, online teaching options can support on-site teaching.

[ToSkORL: self- and objective assessment of examination skills in the head and neck region]. / ToSkORL: Selbst- und Fremdeinschätzung bei der Untersuchung des Kopf-Hals-Bereichs.

BACKGROUND: A central goal of medical school is acquisition of theoretical and practical competences. However, evidence on how capacity acquisition can be measured for special examination techniques is scarce. ToSkORL (Teaching of Skills in Otorhinolaryngology) is a project aimed at scientifically and didactically investigating students' self-evaluation skills in otorhinolaryngologic and head and neck examination techniques. METHODS: During the examination techniques course, a standardized oral and practical exam for nine different techniques was conducted. Using Likert scales, self-evaluation was based on questionnaires before the clinical skills exam and objective evaluation was performed by the examiners during the examination using a checklist. Self- and objective evaluation were correlated. Nine different examination skills were assessed 42 times each by a total of 91 students. RESULTS: Self-evaluation of competence in the different examination skills varied widely. Nevertheless, self- and objective evaluation correlated well overall, independent of age and gender. Students highly interested in otorhinolaryngology rated their own skills higher but tended toward overestimation. For examination items with intermediate difficulty, the highest divergences between self- and objective evaluation were found. CONCLUSION: Student self-evaluations are an appropriate instrument for measuring competences in otorhinolaryngologic examinations. Instructors should focus on items with allegedly intermediate difficulty, which are most often over- and underestimated.

Gender-biased evaluation or actual differences? Fairness in the evaluation of faculty teaching.

How do we know if a faculty teaching evaluation is biased? Biasing factors studies are an influential source of evidence for arguing about biased teaching evaluations. These studies examine existing evaluation data and compare the results by gender, race, or ethnicity, interpreting a significant difference between subgroups as evidence of bias. However, only a difference explained by irrelevant aspects embedded in the evaluation would compromise its fairness. The study aims to amend how practitioners and researchers address gender bias concerns in faculty teaching evaluations by defining fairness, disparate impact, and statistical bias from an educational measurement standpoint. The study illustrates the use of differential item functioning (DIF) analysis, a strategy to examine whether the meaning of an item changes depending on the gender of the instructor. The study examines instructor's gender bias using responses to a course evaluation questionnaire from education graduate students from two academic departments within the same institution. In one of the departments, the analysis suggested a fair evaluation and no gender gap. In the other department, four of the eight items in the rating scale were easier for women than men with similar teaching ability, and women achieved better evaluations than men. The discussion addresses the conceptual and methodological advantages of adopting an educational measurement perspective on fairness in faculty teaching evaluation. Findings encourage practitioners and administrators to use the best available tools to strengthen the credibility of faculty teaching evaluations and prevent unfair personnel decisions affecting underrepresented subgroups in academia by gender, race, or ethnicity.

A comprehensive indicator system and empirical study for evaluating the teaching effect of laparoscopic simulation training / 中华医学教育探索杂志

We reviewed and developed an indicator system framework for assessing teaching effect of laparoscopic simulation training through literature research, expert consultation, analytic hierarchy process and factor analysis. We also made an empirical study on the constructed index system. The system included 3 domains (A1: evaluation of laparoscopic simulator; A2: operation evaluation of experimental animals; A3: evaluation of clinical practice), 10 second-level indicators and 23 third-level indicators for assessing teaching effect of laparoscopic simulation training. The indicator system framework has good internal consistency (Cronbach α= 0.968) and external consistency (>0.72). The empirical study found that: in the results of A1-A3 in the first level indicator, the score of the experienced group was significantly higher than that of the inexperienced group ( P<0.05). In the evaluation results of the 10 secondary indicators in the secondary indicators B1-B10, the score of the experienced group was significantly higher than that of the inexperienced group ( P<0.01). For the first time, we have established and evaluated a comprehensive evaluation indicator system which is reliable and effective and can be used for further evaluation of teaching effect of laparoscopic simulation training. The following empirical studies have verified the effectiveness and practicability of the evaluation system.

Applying Fuzzy Fault Tree Method to Evaluate the Reliability of College Classroom Teaching.

The evaluation of classroom teaching quality is closely related to the development of higher education as a scientific and effective evaluation system that can provide a solid foundation for formulating educational policies. Therefore, an evaluation model of classroom teaching quality in colleges and universities is established based on the fuzzy fault tree theory with "classroom teaching failure" as the top event to effectively evaluate the reliability of college classroom teaching and optimize the teaching strategies. In consideration of the lack of availability and dynamics of classroom teaching data, fuzzy numbers are used to describe the probability of underlying events. In addition, the top event probability of the fuzzy fault tree is calculated by the double-layer Monte Carlo method (MCM), which analyzes the classroom teaching effect based on the fuzzy fault tree reasonable. In summary, the quantitative evaluation system of classroom teaching quality based on fuzzy fault trees can evaluate classroom teaching more comprehensively and dynamically and help to improve the teaching quality of higher education.

ALUMINI EVALUATION ON THE TECHNICAL COURSE IN NURSING OF A STATE PROFESSIONAL TRAINING CENTER / EVALUACIÓN DE EGRESADOS EN FORMACIÓN DEL CURSO TÉCNICO EN ENFERMERÍA DE UN CENTRO ESTATAL DE FORMACIÓN PROFESIONAL / AVALIAÇÃO DE EGRESSOS SOBRE A FORMAÇÃO NO CURSO TÉCNICO EM ENFERMAGEM DE UM CENTRO ESTADUAL DE EDUCAÇÃO PROFISSIONAL

It is necessary to evaluate the training of nursing technicians to understand how this training is related to professional performance. The objective was to track the alumni profile of a technical school; identify how they evaluate the teaching-learning process experienced in the course; evaluate, from the alumni perspective, the training experienced in relation to their professional performance. This is a descriptive exploratory study, with quantitative data distributed according to absolute and relative frequency and qualitative subjected to content analysis. In total, 128 alumni participated, 92.97% women; 34.37% married; 77.34% under the age of 40; 64.07% got a job within six months after completing the course; 40.63% are employed in the private service; Most of the subjects were considered sufficient for professional practice, with percentages higher than 80%. The topics were systematized: technical training is a passport to enter the world of work; from technical training to comprehensive human training; the role of teachers in training and the things that could be different in the technical nursing course. The training, from alumni perspectives, was sufficient and decisive in their lives for insertion and permanence in work, showing the importance of public spaces for technical training in nursing.

La evaluación de la formación de los trabajadores del Técnico de Enfermería es necesaria para comprender cómo esta formación se relaciona con el desempeño profesional. El objetivo fue rastrear el perfil de los egresados ​​de una escuela técnica; identificar cómo evalúan el proceso de enseñanza-aprendizaje experimentado en el curso; evaluar, desde la perspectiva de los egresados, la formación experimentada en relación a su desempeño profesional. Estudio exploratorio descriptivo, con datos cuantitativos distribuidos según frecuencia absoluta y relativa y cualitativos sometidos a análisis de contenido. Participaron 128 egresados, 92,97% mujeres; 34,37% casado; 77,34% menores de 40 años; El 64,07% consiguió un trabajo dentro de los seis meses posteriores a la finalización del curso; El 40,63% está empleado en el servicio privado; la mayoría de materias se consideraron suficientes para el ejercicio profesional, con porcentajes superiores al 80%. Se sistematizaron los temas: la formación técnica es un pasaporte para el ingreso al mundo laboral; de la formación técnica a la formación humana integral; el rol del docente en la formación y las cosas que podrían ser diferentes en el Curso Técnico de Enfermería. La formación, desde la perspectiva de los egresados, fue suficiente y decisiva en la vida de los egresados ​​para la inserción y permanencia en el trabajo, mostrando la importancia de los espacios públicos para la formación técnica en enfermería.

Avaliar a formação dos trabalhadores Técnicos em Enfermagem é necessidade para entender como esta formação se relaciona com a atuação profissional. Objetivou-se traçar o perfil dos egressos de uma escola técnica; identificar como avaliam o processo ensino-aprendizagem vivenciado no curso; avaliar, na perspectiva dos egressos, a formação vivenciada em relação com sua atuação profissional. Estudo exploratório descritivo, com dados quantitativos distribuídos conforme frequência absoluta e relativa e qualitativos submetidos à análise de conteúdo. Participarem 128 egressos, 92,97% mulheres; 34,37 % casadas; 77,34% com menos de 40 anos; 64,07% conseguiram trabalho em até seis meses após o fim do curso; 40,63% estão empregados no serviço privado; a maioria das disciplinas foram consideradas suficientes para atuação profissional, com percentuais acima de 80%. Sistematizaram-se as temáticas a formação técnica é passaporte para a inserção no mundo do trabalho; da formação técnica à formação humana integral; do papel dos professores na formação e das coisas que poderiam ser diferentes no Curso Técnico em Enfermagem. A formação, na perspectiva dos egressos foi suficiente e determinante na vida dos egressos para inserção e permanência no trabalho mostrando a importância de espaços públicos de formação técnica em enfermagem.