Enhancing Stoma Care Education for Junior Doctors: A Comprehensive Teaching Series.

Introduction Colorectal stomas are prevalent in surgical wards and demand careful medical attention, particularly in stoma management. Junior doctors play a vital role in this care, but their limited exposure and training may hinder their ability, impacting patient care. Given the dearth of literature, we aimed to assess junior doctors' stoma care knowledge and the efficacy of a specialized teaching course in boosting their confidence and skills. Methods The research, conducted at the West Suffolk Hospital NHS Trust in the UK, engaged 60 junior doctors, predominantly from Foundation Year 1 and Year 2, from August 2021 to December 2022. To ensure effective management and assessment, participants were divided into four groups, each comprising 15 doctors. A pivotal aspect of the study was implementing a structured stoma teaching series delivered by a panel of seasoned surgical experts. This series, conducted every Friday for three weeks, comprehensively covered all facets of stoma care. Both before and after the teaching series, assessments were administered to measure the impact of this educational intervention on the participants' understanding of stomas. The study meticulously adhered to ethical guidelines, with all participants providing informed consent, and measures were implemented to guarantee anonymity, thus safeguarding the privacy and confidentiality of all individuals involved. The primary objective of this investigation was to evaluate the efficacy of the stoma teaching series in augmenting the knowledge and comprehension of stomas among junior doctors. The findings of this study hold significant potential in guiding healthcare professionals toward developing more efficacious stoma education programs, ultimately leading to improved patient care outcomes. Results The study involved 60 junior doctors categorized into four groups from August 2021 to December 2022. It aimed to assess their understanding of colorectal stomas, focusing on complications and their knowledge about stoma appliances and care nurses. A questionnaire was used to evaluate their knowledge in these areas at the start of their surgical rotation, which showed significant knowledge gaps among participants. Of the 60 participants, 48 (80%) expressed slight or no confidence in basic stoma care, while 54 (90%) admitted unfamiliar with managing stoma complications. Astonishingly, all 60 (100%) participants lacked awareness of fundamental stoma care concepts. Significant improvements were observed following a comprehensive stoma teaching series covering basic stoma knowledge, its complications and management, and practical stoma care. Feedback from the course revealed positive outcomes, with 54 (87%) doctors feeling confident or very confident in basic stoma knowledge and 48 (80%) reporting increased familiarity with managing stoma complications. Remarkably, all 60 (100%) doctors indicated comfort with stoma care concepts after the sessions. Participants emphasized the course's value in medical education and professional development, citing enhanced practical skills such as communication and teamwork. Conclusion Our study revealed junior doctors' limited stoma knowledge, emphasizing the need for a dedicated teaching program that significantly improves their understanding. Focused stoma education is vital for junior doctors to deliver optimal patient care, necessitating hospitals to promote awareness for improved patient outcomes.

Adaptive activation Functions with Deep Kronecker Neural Network optimized with Bear Smell Search Algorithm for preventing MANET Cyber security attacks.

An Adaptive activation Functions with Deep Kronecker Neural Network optimized with Bear Smell Search Algorithm (BSSA) (ADKNN-BSSA-CSMANET) is proposed for preventing MANET Cyber security attacks. The mobile users are enrolled with Trusted Authority Using a Crypto Hash Signature (SHA-256). Every mobile user uploads their finger vein biometric, user ID, latitude and longitude for confirmation. The packet analyser checks if any attack patterns are identified. It is implemented using adaptive density-based spatial clustering (ADSC) that deems information from packet header. Geodesic filtering (GF) is used as a pre-processing method for eradicating the unsolicited content and filtering pertinent data. Group Teaching Algorithm (GTA)-based feature selection is utilized for ideal collection of features and Adaptive Activation Functions along Deep Kronecker Neural Network (ADKNN) is used to categorizing normal and attack packets (DoS, Probe, U2R, and R2L). Then BSSA is utilized for optimizing the weight parameters of ADKNN classifier for optimal classification. The proposed technique is executed in python and its efficiency is evaluated by several performances metrics, such as Accuracy, Attack Detection Rate, Detection Delay, Packet Delivery Ratio, Throughput, and Energy Consumption. The proposed technique provides 36.64%, 33.06%, and 33.98% lower Detection Delay on NSL-KDD dataset compared with the existing methods.

Using varied technological agents-assisted simultaneous prompting for teaching discrete skills to children with developmental disabilities.

This study examines the effectiveness of combining simultaneous prompting method with small group teaching through computer projection, SMART board, tablet computer and humanoid robot to teach discrete skills to children with developmental disabilities (CDD). The study included 14 CDD aged 10-15. It utilizes a multiple probe design across behaviors and probe conditions and replicates them across subjects. Each participant is taught discrete skills within a small group teaching arrangement. The study includes daily probes, full probes, teaching sessions, generalization, and follow-up sessions. It also collects interobserver reliability and application reliability data. Graphical analysis demonstrates the effectiveness of computer-based simultaneous prompting incorporating different technologies in a small group teaching setting. Additionally, we examined differences in children's responses to different technological agents in teaching discrete skills to children with developmental disabilities. The study provided preliminary data on which of these agents is best. The results demonstrate its effectiveness by showing that participants maintained the learned behaviors and applied them to a variety of tools, equipment, and individuals in the first, third, and fourth weeks after the intervention. Additionally, the study highlights the subjects' high accuracy in acquiring behavior through observational learning. Finally, simple humanoid robots, tablets, smart SMART boards, and computer projections have been effective in teaching discrete skills to CDD, respectively.

'A human face and voice': transgender patient-educator and medical student perspectives on gender-diversity teaching.

BACKGROUND: Transgender and gender diverse (TGD) people face many obstacles in accessing health care, including discrimination, institutional bias, and clinician knowledge deficits. We developed a clinical skills and education module on gender-affirming care for pre-clinical medical students, in collaboration with a TGD-led civil society organisation. The module consisted of an educational session followed by preceptor-facilitated small group tutorials, led by TGD patient-educators (n = 22) who used their lived experience to explore medical history-taking and broader issues related to TGD healthcare with students (n = 199). This study aimed to explore the views of students and TGD patient-educators on the structure, delivery and impact of the module. METHODS: Analysis of responses of TGD patient-educators and students to the module (2020 and 2021), in post-intervention surveys using open-ended questions for TGD patient-educators (18 responses from 22 educators) and free text comments as part of a quantitative survey for medical students (89 responses). RESULTS: Responses from students and patient-educators to the session were highly positive. Students and patient-educators emphasised that the teaching session succeeded through elevating the centrality of shared experience and creating a safe space for learning and teaching. Safety was experienced by patient-educators through the recognition of their own expertise in a medical environment, while students reported a non-judgemental teaching space which allowed them to explore and redress recognised limitations in knowledge and skill. Patient-educators described their motivation to teach as being driven by a sense of responsibility to their community. Preceptor attitudes may function as a barrier to the effectiveness of this teaching, and further attention should be paid to supporting the education of clinical facilitators in TGD health. CONCLUSION: The experiences of TGD patient-educators and medical students in this study suggest that this model of teaching could serve as a transferable template for TGD health and the inclusion of other historically marginalised groups in medical education.

Teaching attentive listening to medical students: need and strategies.

Listening is a primary skill essential for learning and is positively correlated with academic achievement. It also enables a healthcare professional to fully explore patients' concerns in healthcare settings. There has been much discussion on how effective listening practices can facilitate students' learning. A clear understanding of listening as a 'process' and planned listening activities can help exploit listening skills in formal and informal learning contexts. This paper explores strategies through which listening can be taught to undergraduate medical students in a small group setting. A planned tutorial is discussed, including methods that can be used to teach listening skills. The simple guidelines provided here can be used in most small group teaching methods. These teaching strategies are likely to allow undergraduate students to evolve into better listeners and, therefore, better lifelong learners and future physicians.

Online interactive medical neuroimaging exercise to identify human brain structures.

A persisting need remains for developing methods for inspiring and teaching undergraduate medical students to quickly learn to identify the hundreds of human brain structures, tracts and spaces that are clinically relevant (viewed as three-dimensional volumes or two-dimensional neuroimages), and to accomplish this with the option of virtual on-line methods. This notably includes teaching the essentials of recommended diagnostic radiology to allow students to be familiar with patient neuroimages routinely acquired using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT). The present article includes a brief example video plus details a clinically oriented interactive neuroimaging exercise for first year medical students (MS1s) in small groups, conducted with instructors either in-person or as an entirely online virtual event. This "find-the-brain-structure" (FBS) event included teaching students to identify brain structures and other regions of interest in the central nervous system (and potentially in head and neck gross anatomy), which are traditionally taught using brain anatomy atlases and anatomical specimens. The interactive, small group exercise can be conducted in person or virtually on-line in as little as 30 min depending on the scope of objectives being covered. The learning exercise involves coordinated interaction between MS1s with one or several non-clinical faculty and may include one or several physicians (clinical faculty and/or qualified residents). It further allows for varying degrees of instructor interaction online and is easy to convey to instructors who do not have expertise in neuroimaging. Anonymous pre-event survey (n = 113, 100% response rate) versus post-event surveys (n = 92, 81% response rate) were attained from a cohort of MS1s in a neurobiology course. Results showed multiple statistically significant group-level shifts in response to several of the questions, showing an increase in MS1 confidence with reading MRI images (12% increase shift in mean, p < 0.001), confidence in their approaching physicians for medical training (9%, p < 0.01), and comfort levels in working online with virtual team-based peers and with team-based faculty (6%, p < 0.05). Qualitative student feedback revealed highly positive comments regarding the experience overall, encouraging this virtual medium as a desirable educational approach.

Assessment of Virtual Peer Learning by Peer Feedback: A Pilot Project.

Introduction Virtual learning has become the preferred modality for health education during and after the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. Peer learning is gaining a lot of significance lately and has been successfully tested in various settings. We combined virtual delivery of health education with peer-assisted learning and evaluated the effectiveness using peer-generated feedback and tested the effectiveness of the model for different cohorts. Methods We performed this study as part of a formal educational course on Health Professions Education. The educators were volunteers from different informal multi-disciplinary groups, working in varied healthcare settings, globally. This involved eight teaching sessions which were delivered virtually and the feedback was recorded as responses to six items (questions), which the learners graded on the Likert scale. The average for each item and the larger domains was then calculated and analyzed.  Results The feedback was provided by all the participants (53/53). In the feedback received item-wise, the best average rating was for legibility of the slides (4.8). The least rating was for adequate checking and assessment of prior knowledge (4.2). In terms of the broader domains, the best feedback was for the teaching material (4.6) and the lowest was for the planning of the sessions (4.4). Overall, the ratings for the domains and the items were above 3 on a scale of 1-5. Conclusions Virtual delivery of healthcare education, facilitated by peer-assisted learning, is an effective model for health education when delivered for a small group, as evidenced by the overall peer feedback. This model can be tested for larger cohorts in the future.

Faculty and Students' Perceptions About Online Teaching Styles of Faculty in Large Group Lectures.

Introduction: An unprecedented disruption in medical education worldwide was caused due to the Covid 19 pandemic. Online teaching has become one of the primary forms of education. In this paper, we aimed to understand the faculty and students' perceptions about the teaching styles adopted by the faculty during online large group teaching from two universities in the United Arab Emirates. Patients and Methods: This is a cross-sectional opinion survey-based study. A pre-validated teaching style inventory in higher education (TSIHE) questionnaire was emailed to the students and faculty involved in large group online learning and teaching activities during the lock-down period of the COVID 19 pandemic from two different medical Universities in the United Arab Emirates. A total of 423 students and 57 faculty participated in the study. Descriptive and Inferential statistics were used to analyze the data. Results: There was a significant difference between the faculty and students on the perception of faculty online teaching styles. The difference was significant in teacher-student interaction and teacher structuring styles. In contrast, faculty and students' perceptions were comparable for decision-making negotiation and behavioral control teaching styles. Conclusion: The study found that there was a significant perception differences between the faculty and students on the faculty teaching style during online large group teaching. Importantly, faculty perceived that they were more emotionally attached and more flexible in teacher-student interaction and teaching structuring during online teaching than the student perceived.

Increasing Collaborative Discussion in Case-Based Learning Improves Student Engagement and Knowledge Acquisition.

Background: In the transition from academic to clinical learning, the development of clinical reasoning skills and teamwork is essential, but not easily achieved by didactic teaching only. Case-based learning (CBL) was designed to stimulate discussions of genuine clinical cases and diagnoses but in our initial format (CBL'10) remained predominantly tutor-driven rather than student-directed. However, interactive teaching methods stimulate deep learning and consolidate taught material, and we therefore introduced a more collaborative CBL (cCBL), featuring a structured format with discussions in small breakout groups. This aimed to increase student participation and improve learning outcomes. Method: A survey with open and closed questions was distributed among 149 students and 36 tutors that had participated in sessions of both CBL formats. A statistical analysis compared exam scores of topics taught via CBL'10 and cCBL. Results: Students and tutors both evaluated the switch to cCBL positively, reporting that it increased student participation and enhanced consolidation and integration of the wider subject area. They also reported that the cCBL sessions increased constructive discussion and stimulated deep learning. Moreover, tutors found the more structured cCBL sessions easier to facilitate. Analysis of exam results showed that summative assessment scores of subjects switched to cCBL significantly increased compared to previous years, whereas scores of subjects that remained taught as CBL'10 did not change. Conclusions: Compared to our initial, tutor-led CBL format, cCBL resulted in improved educational outcomes, leading to increased participation, confidence, discussion and higher exam scores.

Curricular course for medical students at a hematology and oncology specialty practice, 2010-2022.

Aim: For several years now, medical students have also been taught general practice at academic medical teaching practices. Specialty practices have not yet been included in the curricular education. Since 1998, we have conducted a block seminar in hematology twice per semester for eighth-semester medical students. This block seminar was offered from 1998-2001 to students at the Philipps University in Marburg and since 2001 to students at the Johannes Gutenberg University in Mainz. Since 2010 our block seminar has been part of the curriculum at the Johannes Gutenberg University. Method: Standardized course evaluation by students who had attended our block seminar between January 2010 and March 2022. Courses that were held virtually due to corona were not included in the analysis. The questionnaire used to evaluate courses in the medical degree program at the Johannes Gutenberg University served as the evaluation instrument. Results: Since 1998 more than 1,000 students have attended our seminar. The systematic evaluation of the course by 500 students who participated in the curricular, classroom-based seminar sessions since 2010 shows that the highest ratings possible are given for practical relevance, learning atmosphere, teaching and effectiveness. Conclusion: High quality in teaching curricular courses to medical students at a specialty practice is possible. Insights into the possibilities connected with working in the outpatient setting at a medical practice broadens students' experience. This teaching format facilitates external university instructors in terms of teaching and, at the same time, relieves the university in terms of staff and financial budget.

A small-group activity to enhance learning of cardiovascular drugs for health science students.

This small-group activity provides two cases in cardiovascular pharmacology to engage students in a medical or other health professions curriculum. The goal of this activity is to apply students' basic knowledge of physiology and pharmacology to clinical case scenarios. Students were provided with the cases 1 week in advance and were encouraged to use their lecture notes and/or other references of their choosing to answer as many of the questions as possible and prepare to discuss the answers with their classmates at the session. Facilitators were provided with detailed notes and a video that explain the answers and provide suggestions for engaging and challenging the students. For the 2021 academic year, 201 students (139 first-year medical students and 62 second-year pharmacy students) at UC San Diego participated in the small-group activity. Eighteen facilitators were recruited to lead this 110-min session. Students' performance was assessed on the final exam of their integrated cardiovascular physiology-pharmacology course. Students achieved 84% (SD 17.54) on questions related to the small-group session compared to 78% (SD 15.60) on other cardiovascular pharmacology questions not related to the activity. Student perceptions of the facilitators leading the small-group activity were very positive (average of 4.7 on a 5-point Likert Scale). Using this approach, we demonstrate that a small-group activity with clinical scenarios helps students master the pharmacology content related to cardiovascular drugs. The small-group activity included constructed response questions to foster conceptual understanding.

Effective online large-group teaching in health professions education.

Online large-group teaching (OLGT), employed to reach a large group of learners in separate physical locations, allows asynchronous learning and facilitates social distancing. While online large-groups can be a powerful and resource-lean means of health professions education, it has challenges and potential pitfalls that may affect the learning process and outcomes. Through a sociomateriality framework, this article describes strategies for effective online large-group teaching in health professions education in three key strands. Firstly, to optimize learning, OLGT sessions should match learning needs with appropriate OLGT platforms, incorporate strategies to sustain learner attention, and accommodate learners of different abilities. Secondly, to develop a learning culture, OLGT must not only focus on cognitive aspects of learning but also build a community of practice, nurture digital professionalism and professional identity. Thirdly, we discuss the avoidance of pitfalls such as cognitive overload of both tutors and learners, technical issues and security risks, mitigating inequities in access to online learning, and the use of program evaluation to plan for sustained improvements. We conclude with a case vignette that discusses the challenges of OLGT and the application of the above strategies in a teaching scenario.

Near-peer-assisted learning for training undergraduate medical students in clinical ophthalmology skills.

OBJECTIVE: This study aims to formally evaluate near-peer-assisted learning (NPAL) for teaching clinical ophthalmology skills to second-year undergraduate medical students through their fellow medical interns. METHODS: Interns posted at the department of ophthalmology were included as tutors after an initial sensitization and assessment. Second-year undergraduate students were included as tutees. Sessions were conducted for pre-identified clinical skills in batches of 3-5 tutees each. Perceptions of tutors and tutees were captured on a 5-point Likert scale (Kirkpatrick level-1) and evaluated. Tutors were assessed by directly observed procedural skills (DOPS) and tutees by pre- and post-session scores and performance of the respective clinical skills (Kirkpatrick level-2). RESULTS: A total of 21 of 24 tutors and 82 of 100 tutees responded to the evaluation questionnaire. Tutors perceived themselves as knowledgeable and useful as instructors; scores of second DOPS session significantly improved compared to the first (p = 0.001) for all clinical skills. Tutees found the NPAL sessions effective for learning clinical skills. Pre- and post-test scores significantly improved (p = 0.001), and all clinical skills were satisfactorily performed in the end-of-term exam. CONCLUSION: NPAL was perceived as an effective teaching-learning method by both tutees and tutors, and all clinical skills were performed successfully. NPAL can serve as a useful adjunct to traditional teaching for clinical training of small groups and can help alleviate teaching pressures on already burdened clinical faculty in Indian Medical colleges.

Twelve tips for small group teaching 2.0 - Rebooted for remote and HyFlex learning.

Small group teaching (SGT) is not just the delivery of teaching to a small number of learners - it is, instead, underpinned by learner-learner interaction, discussion, and collaboration. The advent of readily available technology, combined with the need to maintain learner and teacher safety during the COVID-19 pandemic, has led to a surge in remote learning, and significant increases in synchronous hybrid learning environments, also known as HyFlex learning, in which some learners join remotely and others do so in-person. Teaching in this manner brings new challenges and opportunities and, when compared to face-to-face SGT, requires teachers to employ a complementary repertoire of skills. Against this backdrop, and with the pressing need to up-skill teachers in this domain, we take a fresh look at previously published tips for SGT and reboot these strategies in the context of remote and HyFlex SGT. The challenges of adapting these tips in a changed environment will be considered, and refashioned strategies for their application will be offered.

Effectiveness and perception of demonstration-observation- assistance-performance (DOAP) versus video-assisted learning (VAL) in training advanced cardiac life support (ACLS) among medical interns - A comparative study.

BACKGROUND: Demonstration-Observation-Assistance-Performance (DOAP) and Video-Assisted Learning (VAL) are small-group teaching/learning methods (TLM) in medical education. Comparison studies between the two are scanty. There is a gap in knowledge, skills, and attitude among medical interns toward Advanced Cardiac Life Support (ACLS). The author studied the effectiveness of DOAP and VAL in training ACLS using mannequins and automated external defibrillator (AED)-simulators among interns in 2021. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This descriptive study was done in the Emergency Department of a tertiary teaching hospital in South India. Out of 80 medical interns, 39 and 41 were allocated to ACLS training by DOAP (Group 1) and VAL (Group 2), respectively, by convenient sampling with random allocation, with the use of mannequins and AED-Simulators (10 interventions in each small group; three-five participants in each session). Pre-validated pre-test and posttest multiple-choice questionnaires (MCQs) and attitude questionnaires, OSCE by two blinded assessors, and perception by Likert-based questionnaire were analyzed with appropriate statistical analysis. RESULTS: The mean pretest and posttest MCQs and Attitude and OSCE scores of DOAP and VAL showed no statistically significant difference between them (MCQ pre-test 44.51 (11.43); 42.54 (6.56); p = 0.350 and MCQ posttest, 78.97 (8.59); 77.22 (11.29); p = 0.438; OSCE 40.51 (2.43) and 40.63 (1.92); p = 0.804; Attitude: 11 (3), 11 (2); p = 0.567; 14 (2), 14 (3); p = 0.095). MCQ post-tests showed improved scores (p < 0.001) in both the methods and the standardized mean difference based on the MCQ scores for the DOAP group was 3.02, and for the VAL group 3, showed the effectiveness of both methods. Perception scores showed learners' interest and positive feedback to both methods and ACLS. CONCLUSION: Both DOAP and VAL were equally effective TLMs in imparting knowledge, skills, and attitude to medical interns with positive feedback. In DOAP, the learner performs under supervision and clarifies doubts. As repeatable and cost-effective, VAL is useful in resource-limited settings. Both can be used as complementary methods in training ACLS. The attitude of learners towards ACLS improved with training.

A task-based learning strategy in preclinical medical education.

Preclinical task-based learning (TskBL) is a simulated learning approach in which the focus for students is a real task done by a medical professional. TskBL includes standardized patient encounters and is helpful to provide early clinical exposure. Our study aimed at planning, implementing, and assessing TskBL among first-year medical students and comparing it to the conventional method of tutorials in the physiology MBBS curriculum. This is a nonequivalent group quasi-experimental study approved by the institutional ethics committee. TskBL was conducted for seven topics among first-year medical students of Kasturba Medical College, Mangalore for three academic years. Participants were divided into a TskBL group and a control group. Both groups attended the theory classes in physiology, practical sessions, and clinical examinations concerning the tasks. After this, the TskBL group underwent TskBL, and the control group underwent tutorials. Pretest and posttest assessments were conducted by using a multiple choice question (MCQ) test and objective structured clinical examinations (OSCEs).The mean TskBL scores for MCQ (exception: hypertension, myasthenia gravis, and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease) and OSCE (exception: anemia and hypertension) were significantly higher than the tutorial group. Pretest and posttest scores revealed significantly higher MCQ and OSCE scores for TskBL (exception: MCQ score for hypertension and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease). The tutorial group did not show a significant improvement in test scores for all the tasks. The TskBL strategy could be used for topics that are likely to be encountered by the students during clinical attachments. Small group teaching can include TskBL in preference to tutorials to provide early clinical exposure in medical schools.

Using a Mock Rounds Model and Neurology Patients to Teach Neurological Exam Skills in a Medical Neurobiology Course.

First-year medical student groups rotated through classrooms, each containing a Neurology patient and physician, as a "Neuro Day" event to make direct clinical connections with the basic sciences. Inspired by post-graduate Clerkships, this event provided timely first-hand experiences focusing on pathological neurologic exam findings. Qualitative and quantitative data were collected from end-of-course surveys. The results show how the event served to reinvigorate enthusiasm for learning Clinical Neurobiology outside the traditional lecture environment and could empower patients as educators within a teaching community.

Effective Large Group Teaching for General Surgery.

Large group settings display no signs of disappearing. Most surgeons charged with this education have received no formal training. Lecturing remains the most common method of educating large groups. Even though factors required for an excellent lecture are known, their inconsistent application results in variation of effectiveness. Long-standing principles of rhetoric and recent advances in neuroscience, cognitive science, learning models, and teaching theory play a role in achieving effectiveness. This article makes recommendations for creating and delivering lectures, including active learning opportunities and modern innovations in information technology supporting teaching methods. Effective lecturing skills are acquired by persistent deliberate practice.

Virtual teaching of undergraduate primary care small groups during Covid-19.

The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic required Higher Educational Institutions to redesign and implement new ways of delivering core-learning outcomes for medical students. Much of this change resulted in a transition to virtual teaching across medical schools. Medical education in primary care is often delivered as part of GP-facilitated small group teaching and with this came unique challenges for the transition to online education.Transition to virtual small group teaching utilised blended learning and flipped classroom methodologies alongside the use of virtual teaching platforms. This quality improvement project describes the educational approaches used when transitioning medical education, and compares student experience from receiving small group teaching using face-to-face and virtual teaching methods before and during the COVID-19 pandemic, respectively. Analysis of student feedback found an ongoing delivery of high-quality primary care education using virtual small group teaching, and that there was no attrition in student experience when compared to face-to-face teaching delivered before COVID-19 for the same learning outcomes.These findings are reassuring and suggest that the transition to virtual small group teaching, using methods such as flipped classrooms and blended learning, enables continued and sustained delivery of high-quality education and student experiences in primary care.

Entrustable Professional Activities for Small-Group Facilitation: A Validation Study Using Modified Delphi Technique.

:: Entrustable professional activities (EPAs) provide a novel approach to support teachers' structured professionalization and to assess improvement in teaching competence thereafter. Despite their novelty, it is important to assess EPAs as a construct to ensure that they accurately reflect the work of the targeted profession. BACKGROUND:: The co-creation of an EPA framework for training and entrustment of small-group facilitators has been discussed in the literature. Although a rigorous design process was used to develop the framework, its content validity has not been established yet.Approach: A modified Delphi technique was used. Three survey rounds were conducted from December 2019 to April 2020. Expert health professions educationalists were recruited using purposive sampling and snowball techniques. In Round 1, a rubric consisting of seven items was used to assess the quality of nine pre-designed EPAs. In Round 2, competencies required to perform the agreed-upon EPAs were selected from 12 competencies provided. In Round 3, consensus was sought on sub-activities recommended for agreed-upon EPAs. Quantitative data were analyzed using multiple statistical analyses, including item-wise and rubric-wise content validity indices, asymmetric confidence interval, mean, standard deviation, and response frequencies. Qualitative data were thematically analyzed using content analysis. FINDINGS:: Three of the nine proposed EPAs achieved statistical consensus for retention. These EPAs were: (1) preparing an activity, (2) facilitating a small-group session, and (3) reflecting upon self and the session. Nine of the 12 pre-determined competencies achieved consensus and were then mapped against each agreed-upon EPA based on their relevance. Finally, results indicated consensus on five, six, and four sub-activities for EPA 1, EPA 2, and EPA 3, respectively. CONCLUSIONS:: The final framework delineates three EPAs for small-group facilitation and their associated sub-activities. The full description of each EPA provided in this article includes the title, context, task specification, required competencies, and entrustment resources. Program developers, administrative bodies, and teaching staff may find this EPA framework useful to structure faculty development, to entrust teachers, and to support personal development.