Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus Leader Protease Cleaves G3BP1 and G3BP2 and Inhibits Stress Granule Formation.

Like other viruses, the picornavirus foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV; genus Aphthovirus), one of the most notorious pathogens in the global livestock industry, needs to navigate antiviral host responses to establish an infection. There is substantial insight into how FMDV suppresses the type I interferon (IFN) response, but it is largely unknown whether and how FMDV modulates the integrated stress response. Here, we show that the stress response is suppressed during FMDV infection. Using a chimeric recombinant encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV), in which we functionally replaced the endogenous stress response antagonist by FMDV leader protease (Lpro) or 3Cpro, we demonstrate an essential role for Lpro in suppressing stress granule (SG) formation. Consistently, infection with a recombinant FMDV lacking Lpro resulted in SG formation. Additionally, we show that Lpro cleaves the known SG scaffold proteins G3BP1 and G3BP2 but not TIA-1. We demonstrate that the closely related equine rhinitis A virus (ERAV) Lpro also cleaves G3BP1 and G3BP2 and also suppresses SG formation, indicating that these abilities are conserved among aphthoviruses. Neither FMDV nor ERAV Lpro interfered with phosphorylation of RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR) or eIF2α, indicating that Lpro does not affect SG formation by inhibiting the PKR-triggered signaling cascade. Taken together, our data suggest that aphthoviruses actively target scaffolding proteins G3BP1 and G3BP2 and antagonize SG formation to modulate the integrated stress response.IMPORTANCE The picornavirus foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) is a notorious animal pathogen that puts a major economic burden on the global livestock industry. Outbreaks have significant consequences for animal health and product safety. Like many other viruses, FMDV must manipulate antiviral host responses to establish infection. Upon infection, viral double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) is detected, which results in the activation of the RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR)-mediated stress response, leading to a stop in cellular and viral translation and the formation of stress granules (SG), which are thought to have antiviral properties. Here, we show that FMDV can suppress SG formation via its leader protease (Lpro). Simultaneously, we observed that Lpro can cleave the SG scaffolding proteins G3BP1 and G3BP2. Understanding the molecular mechanisms of the antiviral host response evasion strategies of FMDV may help to develop countermeasures to control FMDV infections in the future.

Conservation of L and 3C proteinase activities across distantly related aphthoviruses.

The foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) leader (L) proteinase is an important virulence determinant in FMDV infections. It possesses two distinct catalytic activities: (i) C-terminal processing at the L/VP4 junction; and (ii) induction of the cleavage of translation initiation factor eIF4G, an event that inhibits cap-dependent translation in infected cells. The only other member of the Aphthovirus genus, equine rhinitis A virus (ERAV), also encodes an L protein, but this shares only 32% amino acid identity with its FMDV counterpart. Another more distantly related picornavirus, equine rhinitis B virus (ERBV), which is not classified as an aphthovirus, also encodes an L protein. Using in vitro transcription and translation analysis, we have shown that both ERAV and ERBV L proteins have C-terminal processing activity. Furthermore, expression of ERAV L, but not ERBV L, in BHK-21 cells resulted in the efficient inhibition of cap-dependent translation in these cells. We have shown that the ERAV and FMDV L proteinases induce cleavage of eIF4GI at very similar or identical positions. Interestingly, ERAV 3C also induces eIF4GI cleavage and again produces distinct products that co-migrate with those induced by FMDV 3C. The ERBV L proteinase does not induce eIF4GI cleavage, consistent with its inability to shut down cap-dependent translation. We have also shown that another unique feature of FMDV L, the stimulation of enterovirus internal ribosome entry site (IRES) activity, is also shared by the ERAV L proteinase but not by ERBV L. The functional conservation of the divergent ERAV and FMDV proteinases indicates the likelihood of a similar and important role for these enzymes in the pathogenesis of infections caused by these distantly related aphthoviruses.

Inhibition of L-deleted foot-and-mouth disease virus replication by alpha/beta interferon involves double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase.

We previously demonstrated that the ability of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) to form plaques in cell culture is associated with the suppression of alpha/beta interferon (IFN-alpha/beta). In the present study, we used Escherichia coli-expressed porcine and bovine IFN-alpha or -beta individually to demonstrate that each was equally effective in inhibiting FMDV replication. The block in FMDV replication appeared to be at the level of protein translation, suggesting a role for double-stranded RNA-dependent protein kinase (PKR). In support of these findings, treatment of porcine and bovine cells with 2-aminopurine, an inhibitor of PKR, increased the yield of virus 8.8- and 11.2-fold, respectively, compared to that in untreated infected cells. In addition, results of FMDV infection in mouse embryonic fibroblast cells derived from gene knockout mice lacking the gene for RNase L(-/-) or PKR(-/-) or both indicated an important role for PKR in the inhibition of FMDV replication.

Sequence analysis of the RNA polymerase gene of foot-and-mouth disease virus serotype Asia1.

The complete nucleotide (nt.) sequence of the RNA polymerase (3D) gene and 81 nt. in the 3'-untranslated region of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) serotype Asial (IND63/72) was determined and compared with the sequence of other FMDV serotypes. The 3D genomic region was 1410 nt. long encoding 470 amino acids with an inframe stop codon (TAA) at nt. position 1411-1413. The deduced amino acid sequence of the protein showed 8 conserved motifs as reported in other picornaviruses, 2 of which are 100% identical across the serotypes. Antigenic regions in the polymerase protein were predicted and found to be located at the N-terminus of the protein. The phylogenetic analysis showed that the FMD viruses were segregated into different clusters based on geographical origin; the Asia1 virus did not cluster tightly with any of the geographical groups.

Structural and biochemical features distinguish the foot-and-mouth disease virus leader proteinase from other papain-like enzymes.

The structures of the two leader protease (Lpro) variants of foot-and-mouth disease virus known to date were solved using crystals in which molecules were organized as molecular fibers. Such crystals diffract to a resolution of only approximately 3 A. This singular, pseudo-polymeric organization is present in a new Lpro crystal form showing a cubic packing. As molecular fiber formation appeared unrelated to crystallization conditions, we mutated the reactive cysteine 133 residue, which makes a disulfide bridge between adjacent monomers in the fibers, to serine. None of the intermolecular contacts found in the molecular fibers was present in crystals of this variant. Analysis of this Lpro structure, refined at 1.9 A resolution, enables a detailed definition of the active center of the enzyme, including the solvent organization. Assay of Lpro activity on a fluorescent hexapeptide substrate showed that Lpro, in contrast to papain, was highly sensitive to increases in the cation concentration and was active only across a narrow pH range. Examination of the Lpro structure revealed that three aspartate residues near the active site, not present in papain-like enzymes, are probably responsible for these properties.

Development of replication-defective adenovirus serotype 5 containing the capsid and 3C protease coding regions of foot-and-mouth disease virus as a vaccine candidate.

A recombinant replication-defective human adenovirus serotype 5 vector containing FMDV capsid, P1-2A, and viral 3C protease coding regions was constructed. Two viral clones were isolated, Ad5-P12X3CWT, containing the wild-type (WT) 3C protease that processes capsid polyprotein precursor into mature capsid proteins, and Ad5-P12X3CMUT, containing a point mutation in the protease coding region that inhibits processing. In 293 cells infected with either virus, synthesis of the FMDV capsid polyprotein precursor occurred, but processing of the polyprotein into structural proteins VP0, VP3, and VP1 occurred only in 3CWT virus-infected cells. Immunoprecipitation with monospecific and monoclonal antibodies indicates possible higher order structure formation in Ad5-P12X3CWT virus-infected cells. The viruses were used to elicit immune responses in mice inoculated intramuscularly (im). Only virus containing the 3CWT elicited a neutralizing antibody response. After boosting, this neutralizing antibody response increased. Swine inoculated im with Ad5-P12X3CWT virus developed a neutralizing antibody response and were either completely or partially protected from contact challenge with an animal directly inoculated with virulent FMDV. This adenovirus vector may be an efficient system for the delivery of FMDV cDNA into animals, leading to a high level of neutralizing antibody production and protection from FMDV challenge.

A universal virus inactivant for decontaminating blood and biopharmaceutical products.

Removal of virus infectivity from blood and biopharmaceutical products prepared from blood is an issue of considerable importance. Irrespective of the methods that are chosen it is vital that the biological activity of the product is not impaired. For blood and unfractionated plasma or serum, the problem is even more challenging. Selective inactivation of the genome is the key step in the preparation of killed virus vaccines. Imines have been used for more than 30 years for the preparation of inactivated foot-and-mouth disease virus vaccines without any evidence of survival of virus infectivity. Moreover, the immunogenicity of the virus is unimpaired. Viruses belonging to all the recognised families can be inactivated by imines. The biological properties of several proteins, including the cell growth-promoting factors in calf serum, are not impaired using conditions which ensure the inactivation of > 10(15) infectious units of poliovirus and foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV). Moreover, both viruses can be inactivated by imines at 4 degrees C, thus providing a method for removing infectivity from protein preparations which are unstable at higher temperatures. The mechanism by which FMDV is inactivated has been studied. We found that the RNA extracted from the virus after inactivation at 4 degrees C was not degraded and contained no hidden breaks but nevertheless was non-infectious. However, it could be amplified by PCR using primers corresponding to the gene coding for a portion of the viral RNA polymerase, but not from that coding for VP1, one of the structural proteins, showing that alteration of a base or bases had occurred in that region.

Structure of the foot-and-mouth disease virus leader protease: a papain-like fold adapted for self-processing and eIF4G recognition.

The leader protease of foot-and-mouth disease virus, as well as cleaving itself from the nascent viral polyprotein, disables host cell protein synthesis by specific proteolysis of a cellular protein: the eukaryotic initiation factor 4G (eIF4G). The crystal structure of the leader protease presented here comprises a globular catalytic domain reminiscent of that of cysteine proteases of the papain superfamily, and a flexible C-terminal extension found intruding into the substrate-binding site of an adjacent molecule. Nevertheless, the relative disposition of this extension and the globular domain to each other supports intramolecular self-processing. The different sequences of the two substrates cleaved during viral replication, the viral polyprotein (at LysLeuLys/GlyAlaGly) and eIF4G (at AsnLeuGly/ArgThrThr), appear to be recognized by distinct features in a narrow, negatively charged groove traversing the active centre. The structure illustrates how the prototype papain fold has been adapted to the requirements of an RNA virus. Thus, the protein scaffold has been reduced to a minimum core domain, with the active site being modified to increase specificity. Furthermore, surface features have been developed which enable C-terminal self-processing from the viral polyprotein.

A structural model of picornavirus leader proteinases based on papain and bleomycin hydrolase.

The leader (L) proteinases of aphthoviruses (foot-and-mouth disease viruses) and equine rhinovirus serotypes 1 and 2 cleave themselves from the growing polyprotein. This cleavage occurs intramolecularly between the C terminus of the L proteinases and the N terminus of the subsequent protein VP4. The foot-and-mouth disease virus enzyme has been shown, in addition, to cleave at least one cellular protein, the eukaryotic initiation factor 4G. Mechanistically, inhibitor studies and sequence analysis have been used to classify the L proteinases as papain-like cysteine proteinases. However, sequence identity within the L proteinases themselves is low (between 18% and 32%) and only 14% between the L proteinases and papain. Secondary structure predictions, sequence alignments that take into account the positions of the essential catalytic residues, and structural considerations have been used in this study to investigate more closely the relationships between the L proteinases and papain. In spite of the low sequence identities, the analyses strongly suggest that the L proteinases of foot-and-mouth disease virus and of equine rhinovirus 1 have a similar overall fold to that of papain. Regions in the L proteinases corresponding to all five alpha-helices and seven beta-sheets of papain could be identified. Further comparisons with the proteinase bleomycin hydrolase, which also displays a papain topology in spite of important differences in size and amino acid sequence, support these conclusions and suggest how a C-terminal extension, present in all three L proteinases, and predicted to be an alpha-helix, might enable C-terminal self-processing to occur.

A ribozyme targeted to cleave the polymerase gene sequences of different foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) serotypes.

Vaccinations against foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) has dramatically reduced the number of disease outbreaks. Nevertheless, there are still many outbreaks in different regions around the world. In an effort to find new ways to control the disease, ribozymes able to cleave FMDV were designed and tested. In this work we tested the ability of FRZ4, a ribozyme targeted to the viral polymerase gene, to cleave polymerase sequences of several FMDV. Homology analysis was used to choose target sequences which consist of two conserved GUC which lie 15 bases apart and, their flanking sequences. These were the basis for the FRZ4 ribozyme gene sequence that contains two catalytic domains. We show that polymerase sequences from A, Asia 1, C and two different O1 Israeli isolates could be specifically cleaved by FRZ4. It is suggested that FRZ4 can cleave polymerase gene sequences from any FMDV serotype.

Construction of a chimeric Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus containing the leader gene of foot-and-mouth disease virus.

The foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) leader coding region (Lb) was cloned into a full-length cDNA of the DA strain of Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus (TMEV) replacing the complete L coding region of TMEV. This construct, pDAFSSC1-Lb, was engineered to contain cleavage sites, at the 3' end of the Lb coding region, for both the FMDV Lb and the TMEV 3C proteases. Transcripts derived from this construct were translated in a cell-free system. Analysis of the translation products showed efficient synthesis and processing of TMEV structural and nonstructural proteins as well as a major band that comigrated with FMDV Lb and was reactive with Lb antiserum. A small plaque virus was recovered from BHK-21 cells transfected with RNA derived from pDAFSSC1-Lb. RT-PCR of RNA isolated from DAFSSC1-Lb virus demonstrated a product corresponding in size and sequence to FMDV Lb. DAFSSC1-Lb virus grew slower than parental virus, DAFSSC1, and to a lower titer. The pattern of viral proteins synthesized in DAFSSC1-Lb virus-infected cells was very similar to the pattern in DAFSSC1 virus-infected cells except that significant amounts of FMDV Lb were produced. In addition, extracts from DAFSSC1-Lb-virus-infected cells cleaved an exogenous source of the translation initiation factor, p220, while DAFSSC1-virus-infected extracts did not. Chimeric viruses that contain coding regions from different picornaviral genera may be valuable tools in investigating the function of particular viral proteins and in studying disease pathogenesis.

Antigenicity of a viral peptide displayed on beta-galactosidase fusion proteins is influenced by the presence of the homologous partner protein.

Several beta-galactosidase fusion proteins have been constructed containing the entire VP1 protein from foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) [Corchero et al. (1996) J. Biotechnol. in press]. The antigenicity of the major immunodominant site A (13 amino acids in length) within the VP1 protein has been studied in competitive ELISA using a panel of seven monoclonal antibodies elicited against the whole virus and recognizing B-cell epitopes within this site. None of the fusion proteins is able to reproduce the antigenic profile of FMDV, all of them being less immunoreactive than the virus particles. On the other hand, significant differences in the reactivity of site A are displayed on the different fusion proteins, being for some antibodies about 10-fold. This indicates that the reactivity of a small peptide included in its natural place inside the heterologous domain can be significantly influenced by the position of the homologous partner in the fusion protein.

Foot-and-mouth disease virus 2A protease mediates cleavage in attenuated Sabin 3 poliovirus vectors engineered for delivery of foreign antigens.

Poliovirus vectors are being studied as potential vaccine delivery systems, with foreign genetic sequences incorporated as part of the viral genome. The foreign sequences are expressed as part of the viral polyprotein. Addition of proteolytic cleavage sites at the junction of the foreign polypeptide and the viral proteins results in cleavage during polyprotein processing. The ability of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) 2A to mediate proteolytic cleavage in the context of poliovirus vectors was studied. The results demonstrate that FMDV 2A is able to generate cleavage of the foreign antigen from the viral polyprotein. A second cleavage event between the FMDV 2A peptide and the foreign protein was also observed.

Long-term, large-population passage of aphthovirus can generate and amplify defective noninterfering particles deleted in the leader protease gene.

During serial undiluted passage of a clonal population of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV C-S8c1) in BHK-21 cells, two species of defective RNA were generated and selected. Sequence analysis revealed that they included deletions within the L-coding region, and retained the correct reading frame for viral protein synthesis. These deleted RNAs directed the synthesis of capsid protein VP1, were packaged in particles sedimenting with standard virus, required homologous infectious helper virus in order to produce viral particles, but did not interfere with the replication of helper virus. While detection of defective particles in FMDV required more than 100 serial passages, once produced, these defective RNAs could be stably maintained upon further passages in the FMDV C-S8c1 quasispecies. Furthermore, a high fitness, monoclonal-antibody-resistant virus was able to replace the standard virus and support the amplification of the deleted particles. This is the first description of naturally occurring, defective particles of FMDV.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray diffraction studies of the Lb proteinase from foot-and-mouth disease virus.

Different crystal forms of the C23A mutant from the leader proteinase of foot-and-mouth disease virus were obtained by the hanging drop vapor diffusion technique, using MgCl2 and PEG 6000 as precipitants. Well-developed crystals, with cubic morphology growing to approximately 1.0 mm3 in size, presented a large unit cell parameter of 274.5 A and diffracted to, at most, 5 A resolution. A second type of crystal had a tetragonal appearance and these were obtained in droplets soaked in a silica gel matrix. These crystals, with an approximate size of 0.3 X 0.3 X 0.7 mm3, diffracted to approximately 4.0 A resolution, but presented a strong anisotropic mosaicity around the longest crystal axis. Crystals with a needlelike morphology and reaching sizes of about 0.2 X 0.3 X 1.2 mm3 diffracted beyond 3.5 A resolution and were stable to X-ray radiation for approximately one day when using a conventional source at room temperature. These crystals are orthorhombic with space group I222 (or I2(1)2(1)2(1)) and unit cell dimensions a = 65.9 A, b = 104.3 A, and c = 124.0 A, and appear well suited for high-resolution studies. Density packing considerations are consistent with the presence of two molecules in the asymmetric unit and a solvent content of approximately 54%.

[Nucleotide sequence of the RNA polymerase gene attenuated by a variant of foot-and-mouth disease virus and its comparison with the virulence of related variants of subtype A22]. / Nukleotidnaia posledovatel'nost' gena RNK-polimerazy attenuirovannogo varianta virusa iashchura i ee sravnenie s virulentnymi rodstvennymi variantami podtipa A22.

The nucleotide sequence of RNA-polymerase gene and 3'-terminal untranslated genome region of attenuated foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) strain A(22)645 has been determined. RNA-polymerase gene and predicted amino acid sequences of attenuated FMDV strain A(22)645 were compared with those of the original virulent FMDV strain A(22)550. The examined genome region of strain A(22)645 differed from that of strain A(22)550 by 22 nucleotides and 3 amino acids. Three mutations occurred within nucleotide residues 883 to 1026, which encode an extremely conserved amino acid domain corresponding to RNA polymerization and nucleoside triphosphate binding functions. Mutation in 920n caused substitution of conserved amino acid Asn for Ser in the core motif for nucleotide binding Gxxx-TxxxN(S/T). It is possible that change in functional motif caused the alteration of phenotypic virus and loss of pathogenicity for cattle. This may be finally confirmed only after comparative analysis of complete genomes of the examined virus strains.

Identification of the active-site residues of the 3C proteinase of foot-and-mouth disease virus.

To identify the active-site residues of the 3C proteinase of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV), we introduced mutations into the 3C coding region and examined the activity of mutant enzymes on various substrates. Based on alignment of FMDV 3C with other picornavirus 3C proteinases and with the trypsin family of serine proteinases, mutations were introduced at residues presumed to be part of the catalytic triad, involved in substrate binding, or present in nonconserved regions. Wild-type and mutant 3C proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli and tested for their ability to cleave synthetic substrates corresponding to different portions of the viral genome. Substitutions at His-46 (catalytic triad), Asp-84 (catalytic triad), or His-181 (substrate binding) produced enzymes unable to process P1, P2, or P3 substrates in trans, whereas a change in the conserved Asp-98 had no effect on enzyme activity. Substitution of Ser for Cys-163 (catalytic triad) yielded an enzyme that retained activity on some substrates, while a substitution of Gly at this position resulted in a completely inactive enzyme. The kinetics of trans processing of translation products from a transcript encoding the P1 and P2 coding regions and the 2C/3A cleavage site with wild-type 3C or a transcript encoding P1 with 3C mutants revealed that the order of cleavage was VP3-VP1, VP0-VP3, VP1-2A, 2C-3A, and 2B-2C. Mutations in 3C that resulted in a partially active enzyme were individually introduced into full-length FMDV cDNA and RNA transcripts were translated in a cell-free system and used to transfect cells. In all cases the virus that was rescued had reverted to the wild-type 3C codon.

Identification of critical amino acids within the foot-and-mouth disease virus leader protein, a cysteine protease.

The Leader protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) is the first component of the virus polyprotein. It is synthesized in two forms, Lab and Lb, both of which display the ability to cleave the L/P1 junction in trans and to induce the cleavage of the cap-binding complex component eIF-4G (p220). The L protease has weak homology to the family of cysteine proteases, which have a catalytic dyad composed of a cysteine and a histidine. Mutations have been introduced into FMDV cDNA to modify each of the four cysteine residues and the three conserved histidine residues within the Lb species. The activities of the mutant L proteins have been determined. Modification of a single cysteine residue (residue 51) or of a single histidine residue (residue 148) abolished the abilities of L to cleave the L/P1 junction and to inhibit cap-dependent protein synthesis. In contrast, modification of each of the other cysteine residues and other conserved histidine residues had no apparent effect on these activities.

Effect of expression of the aphthovirus protease 3C on viral infection and gene expression.

Cells transformed with specific regions of the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) genome have been constructed and analyzed with respect to viability and susceptibility to FMDV infection. Constitutive expression of an active protease 3C under the control of the tk promoter has been documented by the ability of transformed cells to catalyze the processing of a P1 capsid precursor. High-level, transient expression but not low-level, constitutive expression, of 3C caused a 10-fold reduction in the yield of FMDV and was detrimental to the expression of the cotransfected reporter luciferase gene. No such effect was observed in assays involving cells transfected with a deleted, inactive form of 3C. The negative effect of 3C was not observed when the same reporter gene was integrated and expressed in a constitutive fashion nor when its translation was directed by the internal ribosome entry site element of FMDV in transient expression assays. The results show that cells with a low level of expression of the aphthoviral 3C can be stably maintained and can provide a useful tool to study polyprotein processing.