James V. Neel and Yuri E. Dubrova: Cold War debates and the genetic effects of low-dose radiation.

This article traces disagreements about the genetic effects of low-dose radiation exposure as waged by James Neel (1915-2000), a central figure in radiation studies of Japanese populations after World War II, and Yuri Dubrova (1955-), who analyzed the 1986 Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident. In a 1996 article in Nature, Dubrova reported a statistically significant increase in the minisatellite (junk) DNA mutation rate in the children of parents who received a high dose of radiation from the Chernobyl accident, contradicting studies that found no significant inherited genetic effects among offspring of Japanese A-bomb survivors. Neel's subsequent defense of his large-scale longitudinal studies of the genetic effects of ionizing radiation consolidated current scientific understandings of low-dose ionizing radiation. The article seeks to explain how the Hiroshima/Nagasaki data remain hegemonic in radiation studies, contextualizing the debate with attention to the perceived inferiority of Soviet genetic science during the Cold War.

[Fractionated UV-C irradiation effects on the changes of transcribed and satellite DNA methylation profile and unstable chromosomal aberration yield].

Interaction between changes of functionally different DNA methylation pattern and chromosomal aberration yield under fractionated UV-C exposure at the doses-of 6.2-9 kJ/m2 have been investigated. Two ways of meristematic tissue renewal after irradiation have been revealed on the grounds of statistical analysis. To estimate changes in the methylation pattern of transcribed and satellite DNA the restriction analysis was carried out. The restriction reaction was followed by PCR with ITS1(19b), ITS4(20b) and ISSR(14b) primers. The obtained data indicate specific changes in the methylation pattern of transcribed and satellite DNA parts under fractionated irradiation with different fraction ranges. Possible role of these changes in the progressing irradiation damage and inducible protection reactions is discussed.

Radiation-induced genomic instability is associated with DNA methylation changes in cultured human keratinocytes.

The mechanism by which radiation-induced genomic instability is initiated, propagated and effected is currently under intense scrutiny. We have investigated the potential role of altered genomic methylation patterns in the cellular response to irradiation and have found evidence for widespread dysregulation of CpG methylation persisting up to 20 population doublings post-irradiation. Similar effects are seen with cells treated with medium from irradiated cells (the 'bystander effect') rather than subjected to direct irradiation. Using an arbitrarily primed methylation sensitive PCR screening method we have demonstrated that irradiation causes reproducible alterations in the methylation profile of a human keratinocyte cell line, HPV-G, and have further characterised one of these sequences as being a member of a retrotransposon element derived sequence family on chromosome 7; MLT1A. Multiple changes were also detected in the screen, which indicate that although the response of cells is predominantly hypermethylation, specific hypomethylation occurs as well. Sequence specific changes are also reported in the methylation of the pericentromeric SAT2 satellite sequence. This is the first demonstration that irradiation results in the induction of heritable methylation changes in mammalian cells, and provides a link between the various non-radiological instigators of genomic instability, the perpetuation of the unstable state and several of its manifestations.

Repair rates of R-band, G-band and C-band DNA in murine and human cultured cells.

Repair of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPDs) in cultured neonatal human fibroblasts and in Mus spretus x M. castaneus F1 neonatal skin fibroblasts was analyzed after UVC-irradiation by cleavage with T4 endonuclease V cyclopyrimidine dimer glycosylase, alkaline-agarose gel electrophoresis, and Southern blotting. The blots were sequentially probed with 32P-labeled Alu, or B2, to preferentially illuminate R-band DNA, by L1 to preferentially illuminate G-band DNA, and by satellite DNA to illuminate C-band DNA. These three different DNA populations showed slightly different global nucleotide excision repair rates that are in the order of speed, R-band DNA > G-band DNA > C-band DNA. Fibroblasts from out-bred neonatal mice and humans showed similar band-specific repair rate ratios and the global repair rate of murine fibroblasts was almost as rapid as that of the human fibroblasts. The mass distribution of the human Alu-probed signal was further analyzed. Gel mobility data was fitted to a logistic equation to include all M(r) values. Hypothetical distributions of DNA randomly cleaved to a particular number-average molecular weight were fit to the logistic gel mobility function to determine how such a randomly cleaved distribution of a particular cleavage frequency would be displayed along the experimental gel. This revealed a rapidly repaired kinetic fraction that represented 17% of the Alu-probed signal (R-band DNA), almost none of the L1 probed signal (G-band DNA), and reflects transcription coupled repair of active genes. The remaining Alu-probed DNA showed a random distribution of UVC-induced CPDs throughout all stages of global nucleotide excision repair. The Alu-probed CPDs disappeared with an excellent fit to first order kinetics and with a half-life of seven hours.

Monitoring of radiation-induced germline mutation in humans.

Estimating the genetic hazards of radiation and other mutagens in humans depends on extrapolation from experimental systems. Recent data have shown that minisatellite loci provide a useful and sensitive experimental approach for monitoring radiation-induced mutation in humans. This review describes the progress made in validating this approach and presents the results of recent publications on the analysis of minisatellite mutation rates in the irradiated families.

Radiation-induced DNA breaks in different human satellite DNA sequence areas, analyzed by DNA breakage detection-fluorescence in situ hybridization.

Human blood leukocytes were exposed to X rays to analyze the initial level of DNA breakage induced within different satellite DNA sequence areas and telomeres, using the DNA breakage detection-FISH procedure. The satellite DNA families analyzed comprised alphoid sequences, satellite 1, and 5-bp classical satellite DNA sequences from chromosome 1 (D1Z1 locus), from chromosome 9 (D9Z3 locus), and from the Y chromosome (DYZ1 locus). Since the control hybridization signal was quite different in each of the DNA targets, the relative increase in whole fluorescence intensity with respect to unirradiated controls was the parameter used for comparison. Irradiation of nucleoids obtained after protein removal demonstrated that the alkaline unwinding solution generates around half the amount of signal when breaks are present in the 5-bp classical DNA satellites as when the same numbers of breaks are present the genome overall, whereas the signal is slightly stronger when the breaks are within the alphoids or satellite 1 sequences. After correction for differences in sensitivity to the alkaline unwinding-renaturation, DNA housed in chromatin corresponding to 5-bp classical satellites proved to be more sensitive to breakage than the overall genome, whereas DNA in the chromatin corresponding to alphoids or satellite 1 showed a sensitivity similar to that of the whole genome. The minimum detectable dose was 0.1 Gy for the whole genome, 0.2 Gy for alphoids and satellite 1, and 0.4 Gy for the 5-bp classical satellites. Telomeric DNA sequences appeared to be maximally labeled in unirradiated cells. Thus telomeric ends behave like DNA breaks, constituting a source of background in alkaline unwinding assays.

Effectiveness of 0.28 keV carbon K ultrasoft X-rays at producing simple and complex chromosome exchanges in human fibroblasts in vitro detected using FISH.

PURPOSE: To study the effects of carbon K ultrasoft X-rays, which produce a single photoelectron with a track length of < 7 nm, on the production of structural chromosome-type changes. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Untransformed human fibroblasts (HF12) were irradiated in G1 phase. Aberrations were analysed using fluorescence in situ hybridization using multi-coloured chromosome specific DNA probes for chromosomes 1 and 2 and an alpha-satellite pan-centromeric probe. RESULTS: CK X-rays have a high efficiency per unit absorbed dose for producing simple and complex exchanges. Mean absorbed doses of 0.33-1.31 Gy produce simple exchanges with a predominantly linear dose dependency, and visibly complex exchanges increased by more than the power 2 of the dose, with no evidence of a linear component. The proportion of exchanges that are visibly complex ranged from 9% to 46%. CONCLUSIONS: The linear response for simple exchanges provides further support to the hypothesis that damaged DNA may be able to interact with undamaged DNA. The high proportion of complex exchanges may be due to the increased efficiency of double-strand break induction and to the high density of tracks per unit absorbed dose targeting pre-existing sites, some of which may be close to the incident nuclear membrane.

Tandem 5'-GA:GA-3' mismatches account for the high stability of the fold-back structures formed by the centromeric Drosophila dodeca-satellite.

The centromeric dodeca-satellite of Drosophila forms unusual DNA structures in which its purine-rich strand (GTACGGGACCGA)n folds into very stable intramolecular hairpins. These intramolecular hairpins contain groups of tandem 5'-GA:GA-3' mismatches that, as judged by gel electrophoresis analysis and UV-melting studies, have a determinant contribution to their stability. Duplexes of the dodeca-satellite purine-rich strand, carrying tandem 5'-GA:GA-3' mismatches, are as stable as equivalent fully Watson-Crick duplexes containing tandem 5'-TA:TA-3' Watson-Crick pairs in place of the non-Watson-Crick G.A pairs. On the other hand, duplexes carrying any of the other three possible tandem combinations of purine.purine mismatches, including G.A pairs on the opposite orientation 5'-AG:AG-3', are very unstable. The high stability of the dodeca-satellite hairplus suggests that the tandem G.A pairs are on the sheared configuration although they are found within the less favourable 5'-G-(G-A)-C-3' sequence context. Other centromeres DNA sequences, including the AAGAG satellite of Drosophila and the mammalian CENP-B box sequence, have the potential of forming intramolecular hairpins stabilised by similar purine.purine interactions.

Stage specificity, dose response, and doubling dose for mouse minisatellite germ-line mutation induced by acute radiation.

Germ-line mutation induction at mouse minisatellite loci by acute irradiation with x-rays was studied at premeiotic and postmeiotic stages of spermatogenesis. An elevated paternal mutation rate was found after irradiation of premeiotic spermatogonia and stem cells, whereas the frequency of minisatellite mutation after postmeiotic irradiation of spermatids was similar to that in control litters. In contrast, paternal irradiation did not affect the maternal mutation rate. A linear dose-response curve for paternal mutation induced at premeiotic stages was found, with a doubling dose of 0.33 Gy, a value close to those obtained in mice after acute spermatogonia irradiation using other systems for mutation detection. High frequencies of spontaneous and induced mutations at minisatellite loci allow mutation induction to be evaluated at low doses of exposure in very small population samples, which currently makes minisatellite DNA the most powerful tool for monitoring radiation-induced germ-line mutation.

Radiation-induced germline instability at minisatellite loci.

PURPOSE: To review the results of recent studies on radiation-induced germline instability at mammalian minisatellite loci. RESULTS: Evidence has been obtained recently that germline mutation at minisatellites is remarkably sensitive to ionizing radiation, in both mice and humans. In mice, an elevated mutation rate was found after acute irradiation of pre-meiotic spermatogonia, with a doubling dose of 0.33 Gy, a value close to those obtained in mice after acute spermatogonia irradiation using other systems for mutation detection. In humans, analysis of germline mutation rate at minisatellites among children born in areas of the Mogilev district of Belarus, which was heavily polluted after the Chernobyl accident, has shown a twofold higher mutation rate in exposed families compared with non-irradiated families from the United Kingdom. Within the Belarus cohort, the mutation rate was significantly greater in families exposed to a higher parental radiation dose, consistent with radiation induction of germline mutation. The data in this study also demonstrate the indirect nature of radiation-induced germline mutation at mammalian minisatellite loci suggesting a strong similarity with the phenomenon of genomic instability in somatic cells. CONCLUSIONS: Minisatellite loci provide a powerful system for the efficient monitoring of germline mutation in humans and are capable of detecting induced mutations in relatively small population samples.

Further evidence for elevated human minisatellite mutation rate in Belarus eight years after the Chernobyl accident.

Analysis of germline mutation rate at human minisatellites among children born in areas of the Mogilev district of Belarus heavily polluted after the Chernobyl accident has been extended, both by recruiting more families from the affected region and by using five additional minisatellite probes, including multi-locus probe 33.6 and four hypervariable single-locus probes. These additional data confirmed a twofold higher mutation rate in exposed families compared with non-irradiated families from the United Kingdom. An elevated rate was seen at all three independent sets of minisatellites (detected separately by multi-locus probes 33.15, 33.6 and six single-locus probes), indicating a generalised increase in minisatellite germline mutation rate in the Belarus families. Within the Belarus cohort, mutation rate was significantly greater in families with higher parental radiation dose estimated for chronic external and internal exposure to caesium-137, consistent with radiation induction of germline mutation. The spectra of mutation seen in the unexposed and exposed families were indistinguishable, suggesting that increased mutation observed over multiple loci arises indirectly by some mechanism that enhances spontaneous minisatellite mutation.

Enhancement of genomic instability by 17beta-estradiol in minisatellite sequences of X-ray-transformed mouse 10T1/2 cells.

The female hormone 17beta-estradiol is involved in the development of breast cancer, an effect usually attributed to its capacity to stimulate the replication of preneoplastic and malignant cells. In this study, we report that 17beta-estradiol enhances the onset of genomic rearrangements, a type of genomic instability, in minisatellite sequences of malignant 10T1/2 mouse cells. Two malignant clones, X-ray-9 and F-17a, previously transformed in vitro by X-rays (600 cGys), and two non-transformed 10T1/2 mouse cell subclones (10T1/2b and 10T1/2c) were divided into two groups. The first group was incubated in the presence of 10(-5) M of 17beta-estradiol (dissolved in ethanol) for 5 days, while the second group was incubated for the same period in culture media containing 0.1% of ethanol. After the incubation both groups of cells were then subcloned, and their DNA was extracted and analyzed with the DNA fingerprinting assay using the probe M (core sequence: 5'-AGGC). A high frequency of genomic rearrangements was observed in the transformed subclones treated with 17beta-estradiol. Nine deletions or additions in minisatellite alleles were observed in six F-17a subclones, while 28 of those genomic rearrangements were found in the 12 X-ray-9 malignant subclones. On the other hand, for the non-transformed 10T1/2b and 10T1/2c cells, no genomic rearrangements were induced by the hormone. After the withdrawal of 17beta-estradiol from the transformed clone X-ray-9, no new genomic rearrangements were detected; while a second incubation with the hormone induced new deletions or additions in minisatellite alleles. This preferential enhancement of genomic instability in malignant 10T1/2 mouse cells suggests that 17beta-estradiol may accelerate the accumulation of mutations, and therefore may represent a mechanism by which the female hormone contributes to breast cancer development.

Genetic analysis of children of atomic bomb survivors.

Studies are under way for the detection of potential genetic effects of atomic bomb radiation at the DNA level in the children of survivors. In a pilot study, we have examined six minisatellites and five microsatellites in DNA derived from 100 families including 124 children. We detected a total of 28 mutations in three minisatellite loci. The mean mutation rates per locus per gamete in the six minisatellite loci were 1.5% for 65 exposed gametes for which mean parental gonadal dose was 1.9 Sv and 2.0% for 183 unexposed gametes. We detected four mutations in two tetranucleotide repeat sequences but no mutations in three trinucleotide repeat sequences. The mean mutation rate per locus per gamete was o% for the exposed gametes and 0.5% for the unexposed gametes in the five microsatellite loci. No significant differences in the mutation rates between the exposed and the unexposed gametes were detected in these repetitive sequences. Additional loci are being analyzed to increase the power of our study to observe a significant difference in the mutation rates at the 0.05 level of significance.

Human minisatellite mutation rate after the Chernobyl accident.

Germline mutation at human minisatellite loci has been studied among children born in heavily polluted areas of the Mogilev district of Belarus after the Chernobyl accident and in a control population. The frequency of mutation was found to be twice as high in the exposed families as in the control group. Mutation rate in the Mogilev families was correlated with the level of caesium-137 surface contamination, consistent with radiation induction of germline mutation.

In vivo enhancement of genomic instability in minisatellite sequences of mouse C3H/10T1/2 cells transformed in vitro by X-rays.

The level of genomic instability was determined during tumor development in vivo. Genomic rearrangements, a marker of genomic instability, was measured in mouse C3H/10T1/2 cells transformed in vitro by X-rays with a DNA fingerprinting assay. Three transformed clones isolated from type III foci were divided into two groups. Cells from the first group were injected s.c. into syngeneic and nonimmunosuppressed C3H mice. After 3 to 5 months, the tumors were excised, and the neoplastic cells were isolated and subcloned. Cells from the second group were incubated in vitro for 25 passages (about 6 months) to approximate the number of cell divisions occurring in the tumor, and then they were subcloned. DNA was extracted from subclones grown in vitro and in vivo and analyzed with the DNA fingerprinting assay. A high frequency of genomic rearrangements (50-100%) was found in subclones derived from tumors that arose in vivo, whereas the frequency was very low (< 10%) among subclones passaged in vitro, suggesting that genetic instability may be enhanced by factors present in the C3H mouse. In one clone (F-17) genomic instability appeared to be activated and down regulated. The high frequency of instability found in tumor cell subclones did not appear to result from an in vivo selection of a more tumorigenic subpopulation of cells present in the original clone prior to injection in the animal. This enhancement of genomic instability occurring in vivo could be required to complete the process of transformation to tumorigenicity and allow the neoplastic cells to adapt to a new environment.

Radiation induction of germline mutation at a hypervariable mouse minisatellite locus.

Paternal 60Co gamma-irradiation was tested for the induction of germline mutation at the mouse hypervariable minisatellite locus, Ms6hm. Male C3H/HeN mice were exposed to 3 Gy 60Co gamma-ray and mated with C57BL/6N females. Matings were made at 1-7, 15-21 and 71-77 days post-treatment to test spermatozoa, spermatids and spermatogonia stages. Reciprocal crosses were also made with irradiated C57BL/6N males. Southern analysis was carried out on DNA from parents and F1 mice. The paternal mutation frequencies per gamete of the Ms6hm locus were 8.3, 13, 28 and 15% for the C3H/HeN control, exposed spermatozoa, spermatids and spermatogonia stages, respectively. The paternal mutation frequencies per gamete were 7.7% for the C57BL/6N control and 13% for the C57BL/6N exposed spermatozoa stage. The increase in the paternal germline mutation frequency was statistically significant for C3H/HeN spermatids irradiation (p < 0.005). The induced mutation frequencies were of the order of 10(-1), and was too high to be accounted for by the direct action of radiation on the locus. These results suggest the presence of a previously unexpected mechanism of radiation induction of germline mutation. In addition, we demonstrate that the hypervariable minisatellite locus can serve as a sensitive monitor for genetic damages to germline cells.

Demonstration by DNA fingerprint analysis of genomic instability in mouse BALB 3T3 cells during cell transformation.

We employed DNA fingerprint analysis to monitor DNA rearrangements in BALB 3T3 cells transformed spontaneously or by treatment with 3-methylcholanthrene (MCA) and UV-C. The effect of 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate (TPA) in combination with MCA was also examined. Twenty-three spontaneously transformed cells, 28 induced transformed cells (18 by 1 microgram/ml MCA, six by 5 micrograms/ml MCA, and four by UV-C), and 31 non-transformed subclones were isolated from parental BALB 3T3 A31-1-1 cells. The DNAs were digested with HinfI and subjected to DNA fingerprint analysis with three multi-locus minisatellite probes, Per-6, Core, and Ins. Per-6 was the most effective probe for detecting DNA rearrangements. Rearranged bands detected by the Per-6 probe were observed in 9/31 (29%) of non-transformed subclones, 14/23 (61%) of spontaneously transformed cells, 16/18 (89%) of cells transformed by 1 microgram/ml of MCA, 6/6 (100%) of cells transformed by 5 micrograms/ml MCA, and 4/4 (100%) of UV-C-transformed cells. Higher numbers of DNA rearrangements (> or = 3) occurred most frequently in the induced transformed cells. TPA enhanced the frequency of DNA rearrangements in cells transformed by MCA. These data indicate that (1) genomic DNA in BALB 3T3 cells is unstable and susceptible to rearrangement, (2) its instability is elevated during cell transformation, and (3) MCA and UV-C induce DNA rearrangements, and TPA enhances the effect of the former, probably via the recombination process. DNA fingerprint analysis is valuable for monitoring genomic instability during cell transformation.