A Comparative Analysis of Methods for Titering Reovirus.

BACKGROUND: A key challenge in the process of virus amplification is the need for a simple and convenient method for measuring virus titers. OBJECTIVE: Real-time unlabeled cell analysis (RTCA) was used to establish a standard curve of correlation between half-cell index time (CIT50) and virus titer. At the same time, the virus titer from tunable resistance pulse detection (TRPS) technology was compared with the traditional median tissue culture infectious dose (TCID50) method to evaluate the feasibility and application value of the RTCA technique and TRPS technology. METHODS: Cell index (CI) values for L929 cells under different culture conditions were detected, and the appropriate initial cell inoculation density was screened. The half-cell index (CI50) values of reovirus infected L929 cells with TCID50 titers were analyzed by RTCA, the CI50-TCID50 standard curve was created, and a regression equation was developed. RTCA, TCID50, and TRPS methods were used to detect the reovirus titer obtained by the amplification, and the sensitivity and feasibility of the CIT50-TCID50 standard curve method were analyzed. The virus titer was detected by TRPS technology and the TCID50 method. RESULTS: L929 cells were best propagated at an initial density of 6 × 103 cells/well. After infecting L929 cells with different titers of reference reovirus, the linear correlation of CIT50 and TCID50 was y = -2.1806x + 71.023 (R2 = 0.9742). The titer resulting from the RTCA assay was 7×109.6821 pfu/mL, from the TRPS assay was 4.52×1010 pfu/mL, and from the TCID50 assay was 7×109.467 pfu/mL. CONCLUSION: The CIT50-TCID50 standard curve method established by the RTCA technique can be used to quantitatively detect reovirus titer with L929 cells. Compared with the TCID50 method, it takes a relatively short time and has high sensitivity and accuracy. The TRPS technology requires even less time to quantify the virus, but its precision is lower than that of the TCID50 method and RTCA technology. This study provides new technical methods for assessing the virulence of infectious live reovirus particles. Lay Summary: After amplification of the virus, we need to detect the virus titers (the virulence of the virus). The traditional method is to use the virus to infect cells, and then the virus titers can be calculated by 50% of the cells infected. However, this traditional method is time consuming. The ways of RTCA (a real-time cell analysis technique) and TRPS (a nano-bioparticle analysis technique) help us to detect viral titers. The consistency of these three methods determines their feasibility and accuracy. If they are feasible, then these two simple technologies will provide new ideas for detecting viral titers.

Erythroid Progenitor Cells in Atlantic Salmon (Salmo salar) May Be Persistently and Productively Infected with Piscine Orthoreovirus (PRV).

Piscine orthoreovirus (PRV-1) can cause heart and skeletal muscle inflammation (HSMI) in farmed Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). The virus targets erythrocytes in the acute peak phase, followed by cardiomyocytes, before the infection subsides into persistence. The persistent phase is characterized by high level of viral RNA, but low level of viral protein. The origin and nature of persistent PRV-1 are not clear. Here, we analyzed for viral persistence and activity in various tissues and cell types in experimentally infected Atlantic salmon. Plasma contained PRV-1 genomic dsRNA throughout an 18-week long infection trial, indicating that viral particles are continuously produced and released. The highest level of PRV-1 RNA in the persistent phase was found in kidney. The level of PRV-1 ssRNA transcripts in kidney was significantly higher than that of blood cells in the persistent phase. In-situ hybridization assays confirmed that PRV-1 RNA was present in erythroid progenitor cells, erythrocytes, macrophages, melano-macrophages and in some additional un-characterized cells in kidney. These results show that PRV-1 establishes a productive, persistent infection in Atlantic salmon and that erythrocyte progenitor cells are PRV target cells.

Mouse fibroblast L929 cells are less permissive to infection by Nelson Bay orthoreovirus compared to other mammalian cell lines.

In recent years, bats have been identified as a natural reservoir for a diverse range of viruses. Nelson Bay orthoreovirus (NBV) was first isolated from the heart blood of a fruit bat (Pteropus poliocephalus) in 1968. While the pathogenesis of NBV remains unknown, other related members of this group have caused acute respiratory disease in humans. Thus the potential for NBV to impact human health appears plausible. Here, to increase our knowledge of NBV, we examined the replication and infectivity of NBV using different mammalian cell lines derived from bat, human, mouse and monkey. All cell lines supported the replication of NBV; however, L929 cells showed a greater than 2 log reduction in virus titre compared with the other cell lines. Furthermore, NBV did not induce major cytopathic effects in the L929 cells, as was observed in other cell lines. Interestingly, the related Pteropine orthoreoviruses, Pulau virus (PulV) and Melaka virus (MelV) were able to replicate to high titres in L929 cells but infection resulted in reduced cytopathic effect. Our study demonstrates a unique virus-host interaction between NBV and L929 cells, where cells effectively control viral infection/replication and limit the formation of syncytia. By elucidating the molecular mechanisms that control this unique relationship, important insights will be made into the biology of this fusogenic virus.

Oncolytic viral therapy for cervical and ovarian cancer cells by Sindbis virus AR339 strain.

PURPOSE: Recently, the application of replication-competent viruses has been studied as anticancer agents. Sindbis virus (SIN) is an RNA virus that belongs to the Alphavirus genus in the Togaviridae virus family. The AR339 strain of SIN has not been reported to induce any serious disease to humans. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: In this study, we evaluated the feasibility of the replication-competent SIN AR339 strain as an agent for cervical and ovarian cancer therapy. RESULTS: SIN infection was able to induce cytopathic effects and apoptosis in two cervical cancer cells (HeLaS3 and C33A) and three ovarian cancer cells (HOC-1, HAC-2, and OMC-3) but not in normal human keratinocytes in vitro. The analysis of cell viability, virus protein synthesis, and viral growth showed the cancer-specific cytotoxicity and virus growth of SIN. In nude mice, i.t. and i.v. inoculation of SIN resulted in significant regression of established cervical tumors implanted at their backs. Histologic studies revealed that systemic treatment with the single injection of SIN induces necrosis within tumors at a remote site. In the metastasis model of ovarian cancer, suppression of ascites formation was observed in nude mice with i.p. SIN treatment. By using an in vivo green fluorescent protein imaging system, we also showed that systemic treatment with SIN targeted tumors specifically. CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggested that SIN AR339 strain has a possibility as a novel agent for human cervical and ovarian cancer therapy.

Increased ubiquitination and other covariant phenotypes attributed to a strain- and temperature-dependent defect of reovirus core protein mu2.

Reovirus replication and assembly are thought to occur within cytoplasmic inclusion bodies, which we call viral factories. A strain-dependent difference in the morphology of these structures reflects more effective microtubule association by the mu2 core proteins of some viral strains, which form filamentous factories, than by those of others, which form globular factories. For this report, we identified and characterized another strain-dependent attribute of the factories, namely, the extent to which they colocalized with conjugated ubiquitin (cUb). Among 16 laboratory strains and field isolates, the extent of factory costaining for cUb paralleled factory morphology, with globular strains exhibiting higher levels by far. In reassortant viruses, factory costaining for cUb mapped primarily to the mu2-encoding M1 genome segment, although contributions by the lambda3- and lambda2-encoding L1 and L2 genome segments were also evident. Immunoprecipitations revealed that cells infected with globular strains contained higher levels of ubiquitinated mu2 (Ub-mu2). In M1-transfected cells, cUb commonly colocalized with aggregates formed by mu2 from globular strains but not with microtubules coated by mu2 from filamentous strains, and immunoprecipitations revealed that mu2 from globular strains displayed higher levels of Ub-mu2. Allelic changes at mu2 residue 208 determined these differences. Nocodazole treatment of cells infected with filamentous strains resulted in globular factories that still showed low levels of costaining for cUb, indicating that higher levels of costaining were not a direct result of decreased microtubule association. The factories of globular strains, or their mu2 proteins expressed in transfected cells, were furthermore shown to gain microtubule association and to lose colocalization with cUb when cells were grown at reduced temperature. From the sum of these findings, we propose that mu2 from globular strains is more prone to temperature-dependent misfolding and as a result displays increased aggregation, increased levels of Ub-mu2, and decreased association with microtubules. Because so few of the viral strains formed factories that were regularly associated with ubiquitinated proteins, we conclude that reovirus factories are generally distinct from cellular aggresomes.

Combined sequential treatment with interferon and dsRNA abrogates virus resistance to interferon action.

Many viruses have evolved mechanisms to resist the action of interferon (IFN). These include production of viral gene products that sequester double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) and of small helical RNA. These potentially prevent activation of dsRNA-dependent pathways of IFN action or block expression of cellular genes activated exclusively by dsRNA that may contribute to the antiviral state. Thus, dsRNA might be rate limiting in the development of an IFN-mediated antiviral state. In support of this hypothesis, dsRNA added exogenously to IFN-treated cells in the form of poly(rI):poly(rC) is shown to establish in a dose-dependent manner an antiviral state against two viruses otherwise highly refractory to IFN action, avian reovirus (ARV) and Newcaste disease virus (NDV). Cells exposed singly to high doses of IFN or dsRNA reduced the plaque-forming capacity of these viruses on chicken embryo cells 2-fold. When used in combination, there was up to a 100-fold reduction. In order to abrogate IFN resistance, dsRNA must be added after, not before, an IFN-mediated latent antiviral state is established. dsRNA added exogenously is thought to achieve the threshold required for activation of dsRNA-dependent pathways of IFN action or to induce some dsRNA-stimulated gene whose product acts synergistically with that of some IFN-stimulated gene. The combined sequential treatment with IFN and dsRNA may be useful in overcoming the anti-IFN activity of viruses of clinical interest or in other clinical conditions.

Detection and identification of mammalian reoviruses in surface water by combined cell culture and reverse transcription-PCR.

Reoviruses are a common class of enteric viruses capable of infecting a broad range of mammalian species, typically with low pathogenicity. Previous studies have shown that reoviruses are common in raw water sources and are often found along with other animal viruses. This suggests that in addition to the commonly monitored enteroviruses, reoviruses might serve as an informative target for monitoring fecal contamination of drinking water sources. Mammalian reoviruses were detected and identified by a combined cell culture-reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) assay with novel primers targeting the L3 gene that encodes the lambda3 major core protein. Five of 26 (19.2%) cytopathic effect-positive cell culture lysates inoculated with surface water were positive for reoviruses by RT-PCR. DNA sequence analysis of RT-PCR products revealed significant sequence diversity among isolates, which is consistent with the sequence diversity among previously characterized mammalian reoviruses. Sequence analysis revealed persistence of a reovirus genotype at a single sampling site, while a sample from another site contained two different reovirus genotypes.

Outbreak of Orthoreovirus-induced meningoencephalomyelitis in baboons.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Spontaneous viral encephalitis is rare in the baboon; yet, during a 13-month period (1993-1994), eight juvenile baboons (Papio cynocephalus spp.) developed acute, progressive nonsuppurative meningoencephalomyelitis caused by an unknown agent. Clinical signs of disease included disorientation and truncal ataxia that rapidly progressed to hemiparesis or paraparesis. Clinicopathologic findings were not remarkable and appreciable gross lesions were not seen at necropsy. Microscopic examination revealed CNS lesions that were characterized by lymphoplasmacytic perivascular cuffing, microglial nodules, demyelination, axonal degeneration, vacuolization, and hemorrhage. Subsequently, a novel syncytium-inducing mammalian orthoreovirus was isolated from the brain tissue of five baboons with clinical signs of infection. METHODS: To confirm the etiologic role of the orthoreovirus, two juvenile baboons were inoculated with the virus, then were monitored for 6 weeks. RESULTS: Lesions similar to those seen in spontaneous cases were found in the CNS, and orthoreovirus was isolated from the brain of both animals. CONCLUSION: Analysis of the outbreak indicated juvenile baboons were most susceptible to disease and the virus had a possible incubation time of 46 to 66 days, but did not indicate a source of the virus or mode of transmission.

Optimal conditions for the growth, purification and storage of the avian reovirus S1133.

In spite of their importance as avian pathogens causing important losses in poultry farming, the biochemistry of avian reoviruses has been little investigated. In order to facilitate the handling of these agents in the laboratory, a study was carried out to establish the best conditions both for growing the avian reovirus S1133 in primary cultures of chicken embryo fibroblasts and for purification and storage of viral suspensions. The results indicate that the conditions used currently for the manipulation of mammalian reoviruses are not always the best for handling their avian counterparts. In particular, avian reoviruses are much less stable than mammalian reoviruses, and specific conditions for the purification and storage of avian reoviruses therefore should be used. Furthermore, the instability of avian reovirions may have important implications for the life cycle and pathogenesis of the virus within the animal host.

Respiratory mucosal immunization with reovirus serotype 1/L stimulates virus-specific humoral and cellular immune responses, including double-positive (CD4(+)/CD8(+)) T cells.

Respiratory virus infections are a serious health challenge. A number of models that examine the nature of the respiratory immune response to particular pathogens exist. However, many pathogens that stimulate specific immunity in the lung are frequently not effective immunogens at other mucosal sites. A pathogen that is an effective respiratory as well as gastrointestinal immunogen would allow studies of the interaction between the mucosal sites. Reovirus (respiratory enteric orphan virus) serotype 1 is known to be an effective gut mucosal immunogen and provides a potential model for the relationship between the respiratory and the gut mucosal immune systems. In this study, we demonstrate that intratracheal immunization with reovirus 1/Lang (1/L) in C3H mice resulted in high titers of virus in the respiratory tract-associated lymphoid tissue (RALT). High levels of reovirus-specific immunoglobulin A were determined in the RALT fragment cultures. The major responding components of the bronchus-associated lymphoid tissue were the CD8(+) T lymphocytes. Cells from draining lymph nodes also exhibited lysis of reovirus-infected target cells after an in vitro culture. The present study also describes the distribution of transiently present CD4(+)/CD8(+) double-positive (DP) T cells in the mediastinal and tracheobronchial lymph nodes of RALT. CD4(+)/CD8(+) DP lymphocytes were able to proliferate in response to stimulation with viral antigen in culture. Furthermore, these cells exhibited lysis of reovirus-infected target cells after in vitro culture. These results establish reovirus 1/L as a viable model for future investigation of the mucosal immune response in the RALT and its relationship to the common mucosal immune system.

Extensive sequence divergence and phylogenetic relationships between the fusogenic and nonfusogenic orthoreoviruses: a species proposal.

The orthoreoviruses can be divided into subgroups based on either their restricted host range or the unusual ability of certain members of this group of nonenveloped viruses to induce cell-cell fusion from within. Phylogenetic relationships cannot be inferred based on these biological properties because fusogenic reoviruses are present in both the avian and mammalian subgroups. To address this issue, the complete nucleotide sequences of the three S-class genome segments encoding the major sigma-class core, outer capsid, and nonstructural proteins of four fusogenic reoviruses were determined and used to establish the phylogeny of the orthoreoviruses. The viruses analysed included two strains of avian reovirus and the only known fusogenic mammalian reoviruses, Nelson Bay virus and baboon reovirus. Comparative sequence analysis of these fusogenic reoviruses and the prototypical nonfusogenic mammalian reoviruses indicated a highly diverged genus with both conserved and unique sequence-predicted structural motifs in the major sigma-class proteins. Phylogenetic analysis provided the basis for the first taxonomic subdivision of the orthoreoviruses into species classes based on inferred evolutionary relationships. It is proposed that the orthoreoviruses consist of at least four species that separate into three clades. The nonfusogenic mammalian reovirus species represent a single clade, and the fusogenic reoviruses separate into two distinct clades. The first clade of fusogenic reoviruses contains the avian reovirus- and Nelson Bay virus-type species, with the second clade being occupied by the single baboon reovirus isolate that represents a fourth orthoreovirus species.

Mutations in reovirus outer-capsid protein sigma3 selected during persistent infections of L cells confer resistance to protease inhibitor E64.

Mutations selected in reoviruses isolated from persistently infected cultures (PI viruses) affect viral entry into cells. Unlike wild-type (wt) viruses, PI viruses can grow in the presence of ammonium chloride, a weak base that blocks acid-dependent proteolysis of viral outer-capsid proteins in cellular endosomes during viral entry. In this study, we show that E64, an inhibitor of cysteine proteases such as those present in the endocytic compartment, blocks growth of wt reovirus by inhibiting viral disassembly. To determine whether PI viruses can grow in the presence of an inhibitor of endocytic proteases, we compared yields of wt and PI viruses in cells treated with E64. Prototype PI viruses L/C, PI 2A1, and PI 3-1 produced substantially greater yields than wt viruses type 1 Lang (T1L) and type 3 Dearing (T3D) in E64-treated cells. To identify viral genes that segregate with growth of PI viruses in the presence of E64, we tested reassortant viruses isolated from independent crosses of T1L and each of the prototype PI viruses for growth in cells treated with E64. Growth of reassortant viruses in the presence of E64 segregated exclusively with the S4 gene, which encodes viral outer-capsid protein sigma3. These results suggest that mutations in sigma3 protein selected during persistent infection alter its susceptibility to cleavage during viral disassembly. To determine the temporal relationship of acid-dependent and protease-dependent steps in reovirus disassembly, cells were infected with wt strain T1L or T3D, and medium containing either ammonium chloride or E64d, a membrane-permeable form of E64, was added at various times after adsorption. Susceptibility to inhibition by both ammonium chloride and E64 was abolished when either inhibitor was added at times greater than 60 min after adsorption. These findings indicate that acid-dependent and protease-dependent disassembly events occur with similar kinetics early in reovirus replication, which suggests that these events take place within the same compartment of the endocytic pathway.

Reovirus-induced apoptosis of MDCK cells is not linked to viral yield and is blocked by Bcl-2.

In this study, we investigated the relationship between reovirus-induced apoptosis and viral growth. Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) epithelial cells infected with prototype reovirus strains type 1 Lang (T1L) or type 3 Dearing (T3D) were found to undergo apoptosis, and T3D induced apoptosis of MDCK cells to a substantially greater extent than T1L. By using T1L x T3D reassortant viruses, we found that differences in the capacities of these strains to induce apoptosis are determined by the viral S1 and M2 gene segments. These genes encode viral outer-capsid proteins that play important roles in viral entry into cells. T1L grew significantly better in MDCK cells than T3D, and these differences in growth segregated with the viral L1 and M1 gene segments. The L1 and M1 genes encode viral core proteins involved in viral RNA synthesis. Bcl-2 overexpression in MDCK cells inhibited reovirus-induced apoptosis but did not substantially affect reovirus growth. These findings indicate that differences in the capacities of reovirus strains to induce apoptosis and grow in MDCK cells are determined by different viral genes and that premature cell death by apoptosis does not limit reovirus growth in MDCK cells.

Dimethylthiourea reduces pancreatic islet-cell damage in DBA/1 sucking mice with reovirus type-2 infection.

Reovirus type 2 (Reo-2) infection in DBA/1 sucking mice causes pancreatic islet-cell destruction, which results in a diabetes-like syndrome. To investigate the role of reactive oxygen species (ROS), the protective effect of dimethylthiourea (DMTU) was examined, this substance being an effective scavenger of hydroxyl radicals. The degree of cellular infiltration in and around pancreatic islets was the same in mice receiving either virus only or virus and DMTU. The latter had no effect on (1) the number or type of white blood cells, (2) lymphocyte function-associated antigen 1-alpha-positive splenocytes, or (3) viral multiplication in the pancreas. However, treatment with DMTU inhibited the elevation of blood glucose concentrations and reduced pancreatic islet-cell damage (beta-cell degranulation and necrosis). These results suggest that ROS play a role in the pathogenesis of Reo-2-induced diabetes-like syndrome.

Experimental inoculation of mice with trypsin-resistant and trypsin-sensitive avian reoviruses.

Groups of sucking Swiss albino mice were inoculated by the intracerebral (i.c.), intraperitoneal (i.p.) or oral route with a trypsin-sensitive avian reovirus (TR1) or a trypsin-resistant (R2) reovirus. The viruses caused a number of effects, the most severe occurring after i.c. inoculation and the least after oral inoculation. They included incoordination and tremors, oiliness of the hair, and retarded growth. Patterns of viral persistence in tissues were similar for the two viruses, with high titres in the brain on days 3 and 6 after i.c. or i.p. injection. Both viruses were still present in the brain 21 days after i.c. injection. No virus was found in any tissue when TR1 was given orally. All groups "seroconverted" except the one infected orally with TR1, but neutralization titres were low. The effects resembled those described for mammalian reoviruses in mice. The results indicate that, for short periods, wild mice may be capable of transmitting avian reoviruses between poultry flocks. Furthermore, in the production of monoclonal antibodies to avian reoviruses in mice, it is possible that pathological changes will occur.

The reovirus M1 gene determines the relative capacity of growth of reovirus in cultured bovine aortic endothelial cells.

Since blood-borne viruses often interact with endothelial cells before tissue invasion, the interaction between viruses and endothelial cells is likely to be important in viral pathogenicity. Two reovirus isolates (type 1 Lang and type 3 Dearing) differ in their capacity to grow in cultured bovine aortic endothelial cells. The mammalian reoviruses have 10 double-stranded RNA gene segments in their genome. By using 24 reassortant viruses, observed differences in the capacity of different strains to grow in cultured endothelial cells were mapped to the M1 gene (P = 0.00019), which encodes the viral core protein mu 2. No differences were detected in binding or proteolytic processing of viral outer capsid proteins of parental virions between the two reovirus isolates. Northern blot analysis showed a decreased production of viral mRNA in endothelial cells infected with type 3 Dearing reovirus, but not type 1 Lang. Thus, we have identified a viral gene (the M1 gene) responsible for determining the difference in growth capacity of the two reovirus isolates in cultured endothelial cells. Reovirus is an attractive model in which to study the interaction of viruses with endothelial cells at a molecular genetic level.