Cerebral palsy litigation: change course or abandon ship.

The cardinal driver of cerebral palsy litigation is electronic fetal monitoring, which has continued unabated for 40 years. Electronic fetal monitoring, however, is based on 19th-century childbirth myths, a virtually nonexistent scientific foundation, and has a false positive rate exceeding 99%. It has not affected the incidence of cerebral palsy. Electronic fetal monitoring has, however, increased the cesarian section rate, with the expected increase in mortality and morbidity risks to mothers and babies alike. This article explains why electronic fetal monitoring remains endorsed as efficacious in the worlds' labor rooms and courtrooms despite being such a feeble medical modality. It also reviews the reasons professional organizations have failed to condemn the use of electronic fetal monitoring in courtrooms. The failures of tort reform, special cerebral palsy courts, and damage limits to stem the escalating litigation are discussed. Finally, the authors propose using a currently available evidence rule-the Daubert doctrine that excludes "junk science" from the courtroom-as the beginning of the end to cerebral palsy litigation and electronic fetal monitoring's 40-year masquerade as science.

Effects of fetal exposure to lipopolysaccharide, perinatal anoxia and sensorimotor restriction on motor skills and musculoskeletal tissue: implications for an animal model of cerebral palsy.

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a disorder of locomotion, posture and movement that can be caused by prenatal, perinatal or postnatal insults during brain development. An increased incidence of CP has been correlated to perinatal asphyxia and maternal infections during gestation. The effects of maternal exposure to low doses of bacterial endotoxin (lipopolysaccharide, LPS) on motor behavior and hind leg muscle morphology were examined in young adult rats. Prenatal exposure to LPS was also studied in association with perinatal anoxia (PA) and/or combined with subsequent sensorimotor restriction (SR) and all possible combinations of the three conditions. Rats exposed to LPS, PA and SR alone or combined (LPS + PA, LPS + SR, PA + SR, and LPS + PA + SR) showed deficits in balance and coordination when tested on the Rotarod. The SR groups, with or without other insults, (SR, LPS + SR, PA + SR, and LPS + PA + SR) exhibited the greatest motor deficits, characterized by the reduced ability to perform the horizontal ladder and suspended bar tests on postnatal day 29 (P29) and P45. Histological assessment revealed substantial morphological alterations in the slow ankle extensor soleus muscle of all SR rats. Soleus myofibers presented a reduction in cross-sectional area (CSA), an increase in sarcomere length and a decrease in sarcomere density. The CSA of the fast flexor tibialis anterior muscle was only decreased by the association of all treatments (LPS, PA, SR), but no differences were found in sarcomere length and density when compared to control. A slow-to-fast fiber type transition was only observed in the soleus and tibialis anterior muscles in the SR groups. These results suggest that exposure to LPS during the prenatal period, PA, SR alone or in combination has various degrees of consequences on motor behavior and muscle morphology. These data corroborate the concept that early experience-dependent movements play the most important role in shaping motor behavior and that reduced or anomalous sensorimotor experience can contribute to the development of aberrant motor behavior and muscle morphology.

[Cerebral palsy--perinatal aspects].

Cerebral palsy is a group of non-progressive but often changing motor impairment syndromes resulting from lesions or anomalies occurring in the early stages of fetal development and childhood. This condition is responsible for significant emotional, financial and social difficulties for the patient and the family, and professionals providing specific care for these people. This review describes the incidence, risk factors and the etiopathogenesis of this condition. A lot of evidences of the relations between intrauterine infection, prematurity, prenosenost, intrapartalna asphyxia, multiple pregnancy and assisted reproductive techniques are decribed. In the review is has been demonstrated the most important aspects of perinatal cerebral palsy.

Neonatal management and long-term sequelae.

Intrauterine or fetal growth restriction is best defined by using customised birth weight percentiles based upon the growth potential for an individual infant. Growth restriction in utero may be classified as asymmetric or symmetric depending upon the duration of the process. Asymmetric growth restriction is caused by placental insufficiency, maternal hypertensive conditions, long-standing maternal diabetes, smoking, living at altitude or multiple gestation. Symmetric growth restriction may be due to congenital infections, chromosomal or other abnormalities, fetal alcohol syndrome, low socioeconomic status or be constitutional. The underlying cause of growth restriction often predicts the potential adverse effects on the foetus and newborn and later effects in childhood and adulthood. With placental insufficiency, there may be chronic or acute on chronic fetal hypoxia with birth asphyxia and hypothermia, neonatal hypoglycaemia, polycythaemia and coagulopathy. Management is directed at prevention or early treatment of these conditions. In contrast, symmetrically growth-restricted infants should be examined carefully to look for congenital infections and malformations that may need specific interventions. Infants with constitutional short stature generally do not need any specific management. Feeding of growth-restricted infants is important to overcome deficiencies incurred in utero. Most infants show catch-up growth although about 10% do not. Those with excessive catch-up growth may be at greatest risk of developing insulin resistance in adulthood leading to diabetes, obesity and heart disease. The so-called fetal origins of disease may actually have a postnatal onset related more to excessive weight gain in infancy. There is still controversy over the indications for growth hormone treatment in growth-restricted infants who remain of short stature in early childhood. Intrauterine growth restriction is also associated with a five- to seven-fold increased risk of cerebral palsy probably due to chronic placental insufficiency.

Infant neurodevelopment following fetal growth restriction: relationship with antepartum surveillance parameters.

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the relationship between fetal Doppler parameters, biophysical profile score (BPP) and neurodevelopmental delay at 2 years of corrected age in infants who had been growth-restricted in utero. METHODS: This was a prospective observational study including 113 pregnancies complicated by intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) (abdominal circumference<5th percentile and elevated umbilical artery (UA) pulsatility index). The relationships of UA, middle cerebral artery and ductus venosus (DV) Doppler features, BPP, birth acidemia (artery pH<7.0+/or base deficit>12), gestational age at delivery, birth weight and neonatal morbidity (i.e. bronchopulmonary dysplasia, >Grade 2 intraventricular hemorrhage, or necrotizing enterocolitis) with a 2-year neurodevelopmental delay were evaluated. Best Beginnings Developmental Screen, Bayley Scale of Infant Development II (BSID) and Clinical Adaptive/Clinical Linguistic Auditory Milestone Stage were used. BSID<70, cerebral palsy, abnormal tone, hearing loss and/or blindness defined neurodevelopmental delay. RESULTS: Seventy-two of the 113 pregnancies completed assessment; there were 10 stillbirths, 19 neonatal deaths, three infant deaths and nine pregnancies with no follow-up. Twenty fetuses (27.8%) had UA reversed end-diastolic velocity (REDV), 34 (47.2%) abnormal DV Doppler features and 31 (43.1%) an abnormal BPP. Median gestational age at delivery and birth weight were 30.4 weeks and 933 g, respectively. Twelve infants had acidemia and 28 neonatal morbidity. There were 38 (52.8%) infants with neurodevelopmental delay, including 37 (51.4%) with abnormal tone, 20 (27.8%) with speech delay, 23 (31.9%) with an abnormal neurological examination, eight (11.1%) with a hearing deficit and six (8.3%) with cerebral palsy. Gestational age at delivery was associated with cerebral palsy (r2=0.52, P<0.0001; 92% sensitivity and 83% specificity for delivery at <27 weeks). UA-REDV was associated with global delay (r2=0.31, P=0.006) and birth weight with neurodevelopmental delay (r2=0.54, P<0.0001; 82% sensitivity and 64% specificity for BW<922 g). CONCLUSIONS: Although UA-REDV is an independent contributor to poor neurodevelopment in IUGR no such effect could be demonstrated for abnormal venous Doppler findings or BPP. Gestational age and birth weight remain the predominant factors for poor neurodevelopment in growth-restricted infants.

Cerebral palsy and restricted growth status at birth: population-based case-control study.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the association between growth status at birth and subsequent development of cerebral palsy in preterm and term infants. DESIGN: Population-based case-controlled study. SETTING: Cerebral palsy register in Western Sweden. Subjects Cohort of 334 singletons born between 1983 and 1990, with cerebral palsy diagnosed from age 4, and 668 singletons matched for gestation, gender and delivery unit. METHOD: Growth status at birth was determined using small for gestational age (SGA) categories, with customised birthweight percentiles (SGAcust) based on the Swedish population. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Proportion of babies that were SGAcust, comparing cases and controls in three gestational age categories: early preterm (24-33 weeks), late preterm (34-36 weeks) and term (37+ weeks). RESULTS: Of the 334 children with cerebral palsy, 87 (26.6%) were born early preterm, 27 (8.1%) late preterm and 218 (66%) at term. Children who had been born at term were more likely to have been SGA <1st customised percentile (SGAcust1) than their matched controls (OR 6.6, 95% CI 2.3-18.6). In contrast, children with cerebral palsy born preterm were not more likely to have been SGAcust1 (OR 0.9, 95% CI 0.4-1.9), and this applied to early preterm as well as late preterm births. For less severely small babies (SGA between 1st and 5th customised percentiles), the association with cerebral palsy remained significant for term births (OR 5.2, 95% CI 2.7-10.1) but was again not significant for preterm births. CONCLUSIONS: Term singletons with severely SGA birthweights had a five- to seven-fold risk of developing cerebral palsy compared with gestational age-matched infants with birthweights within normal limits. For children born preterm, SGA was not more likely to be present in cases than in controls. These findings support the concept of cerebral palsy as a multifactorial condition and highlight the importance of antenatal surveillance of fetal growth.

Secondary cytomegalovirus infection can cause severe fetal sequelae despite maternal preconceptional immunity.

OBJECTIVES: To describe our experience in cases with sonographic signs of fetal infection and with maternal serological 'immunity' to cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection. METHODS: This was a bicenter study of six pregnant women referred for evaluation of suspected fetal infection. All cases had confirmed maternal serology for past exposure to CMV but no evidence of recent secondary CMV infection. All underwent sonographic evaluation as well as complete investigation for CMV infection. RESULTS: The mean age of the women was 29 (range, 23-35) years and the mean gestational age at diagnosis was 23.5 weeks (range, 20-31) weeks. Sonographic findings included microcephaly, ventriculomegaly, periventricular calcifications and cystic lesions, echogenic bowel, hydrops and hepatosplenomegaly. Amniocentesis was performed in all cases for fetal karyotyping and viral assessment, and all were found by polymerase chain reaction to be positive for CMV infection. Four pregnancies were terminated following the parents' request. One pregnancy continued until intrauterine fetal death occurred 2 weeks after diagnosis. Postmortem was denied in all cases but one. One infant was delivered with evidence of severe cerebral palsy. CONCLUSION: In the presence of sonographic findings suggestive of fetal CMV infection, prompt investigation of amniotic fluid should follow even if maternal serology does not support recent maternal seroconversion.

Prevalence and pathogenesis of congenital anomalies in cerebral palsy.

BACKGROUND: It has been hypothesised that cerebral palsy (CP) and other congenital anomalies are attributable to feto-fetal transfusion problems in a monochorionic multiple gestation. Thus more than one organ could be compromised leading to the coexistence of two or more anomalies in a fetus. Such anomalies in a singleton birth may be attributable to early demise of the co-conceptus as a vanishing twin. AIM: To determine whether the coexistence of congenital anomalies and CP is greater than a chance finding by comparing the prevalence of congenital anomalies in children with CP with that in the general population of children. METHODS: A population-based register of children with CP born in 1966-1991 in the counties of Merseyside and Cheshire, UK, comprised the index population. Coexisting congenital anomalies were recorded. For comparison the population prevalence of congenital anomalies was obtained from eight congenital malformation registers in the UK. RESULTS: Children with CP were found to have highly significant increases in risk for microcephaly, isolated hydrocephaly, congenital anomalies of the eye, congenital cardiac anomalies, cleft lip and/or palate and congenital dislocation of the hips and talipes (p<0.001) and atresias of the oesophagus (p<0.001) and intestines (p<0.01). The relative risks ranged from 3.1 (95% CI 1.9 to 4.8; p<0.001) for congenital malformations of the cardiac septa to 116.09 (95% CI 84.0 to 162.3; p<0.001) for microcephaly. CONCLUSIONS: Congenital anomalies in children with CP are found much more frequently than expected by chance. A common pathogenic mechanism may account for the coexistence of disparate congenital anomalies. A hypothesis is proposed for such a common pathogenic mechanism.

Cerebral palsy and fetal inflammatory response syndrome: a review.

Cerebral palsy (CP) is the most common cause of severe physical disability in childhood. The precise etiological factor for the development of the majority of cases of CP has not been identified, however, prematurity is considered to be the leading identifiable risk factor. During the last decade, intrauterine infection/inflammation has been identified as the most common cause of preterm delivery and neonatal complications. When microorganisms or their products gain access to the fetus they stimulate the production of cytokines and a systemic response termed FIRS (Fetal Inflammatory Response Syndrome). Subsequently, FIRS was implicated as a cause of fetal or neonatal injury that leads to CP and chronic lung disease. Several authors found an increase in the risk for CP in infants born to mothers with clinical chorioamnionitis, especially in preterm neonates. A relationship between CP and intra-amniotic inflammation was demonstrated, intrauterine infection may lead to activation of the cytokine network which in turn can cause white matter brain damage and preterm delivery, as well as the future development of CP. This white matter insult is identified clinically as periventricular leucomalacia (PVL) which is associated with the subsequent development of impaired neurological outcomes of variable severity including CP.

Brain damage in preterm infants: etiological pathways.

Preterm newborns represent a high-risk population for brain damage, primarily affecting the white matter, and for related neurodevelopmental disabilities. Determinants of brain damage have been extensively investigated, but there are still many controversies on how these factors can influence the developing brain and provoke damage. The concept of etiological pathway, instead of a single determinant, appears to better explain pathogenetic mechanisms: the brain damage may represent the final outcome of exposure to several combinations of risk factors in the same pathway or in different pathways and can change according to the gestational age. The aim of this article is to review the current knowledge on the pathogenesis of brain damage in preterm infants, within the frame of two main theoretical models, the ischemic and the inflammatory pathway. The relationship between the two pathways and the contribution of genetic susceptibility to ischemic and/or inflammatory insult, in modulating the extent and severity of brain damage, is also discussed.

Postnatal laboratory timers of antenatal hypoxemic-ischemic brain damage.

OBJECTIVE: Markers were sought to identify the antenatal starting times and rates at which brain damage advanced in children with hypoxemic-ischemic cerebral palsy. STUDY DESIGN: Fetal bradycardia's onset marked the damage's start. Using this baseline, the following were tested as additional timers of the damage's onset: serial blood counts of neonates' normoblasts, platelets, lymphocytes,differences at birth between base excess values in umbilical arterial and venous bloods,brain damage patterns. RESULTS: Each timer had a broad antenatal time frame within which it could identify specific damage starting times. The broad time frames are as follows: Blood lymphocyte counts: 0.45 to 13.8 hours before birth, blood normoblast counts: 0.45 to 55.0 hours before birth, blood platelet counts: 0.5 to >72 hours before birth. Brain damage patterns: 0.4 to >0.7 hour before birth. Hyperventilating and hyperoxygenating neonates greatly accelerated the damage's advance. CONCLUSIONS: Commonly obtained laboratory values and brain images can identify when such brain damage began and the rate at which it advanced.

The causal pathway model and cerebral palsy.

This article reviews possible prenatal, perinatal, and postnatal causes of cerebral palsy. The interactive effects of various causes are evaluated. Groups of intervention strategies are then presented based on the causal pathway model.

Antenatal risk factors for cerebral palsy.

Two of every 1000 live-born children develop cerebral palsy (CP). The aetiology of CP is often unclear and because CP is a symptom complex rather than a disease, clinically defined at 4-5 years of age, it is not surprising that there are considerable problems associated with epidemiological studies of its aetiology. The only reason for the CP concept is that it emanates from an insult to a growing, developing brain and a dynamic clinical picture from static pathology. Evidence suggests that 70-80% of CP cases are due to prenatal factors and that birth asphyxia plays a relatively minor role (<10%). Some antenatal risk factors are repeatedly observed to be related to CP: low gestational age, male gender, multiple gestation, intrauterine viral infections and maternal thyroid abnormalities. Recently, intrauterine infection/inflammation with a maternal response (consisting of chorioamnionitis) and a fetal inflammatory response (consisting of funicitis or elevated interleukin-6 in fetal plasma) has been found to be related to white matter injury and CP. Some risk factors are associated with CP at all gestational ages whereas others mostly affect term or preterm infants, e.g. intrauterine growth restriction seems to be a risk factor in term infants. There also seems to be an association between autoimmune and coagulation disorders and CP.

Intrauterine infection and the development of cerebral palsy.

Cerebral palsy is a serious motor disorder that appears in early life. The expectation that improved obstetrical and neonatal care would decrease the rate of this condition has not been realised. Recent evidence indicates that white matter brain lesions, often termed periventricular leukomalacia (PVL), are the most important identifiable risk factors for the development of cerebral palsy. The hypothesis under examination is that inflammatory cytokines released during the course of intrauterine infection play a central role in the genesis of preterm parturition, fetal PVL, and cerebral palsy. We examined the relationship between umbilical cord plasma concentrations of cytokines at birth and the occurrence of PVL in preterm gestation and demonstrated that umbilical cord plasma concentrations of interleukin (IL)-6 was a significant independent predictor of PVL-associated lesions. We also demonstrated that preterm neonates born to mothers with elevated amniotic fluid concentrations of pro-inflammatory cytokines were at increased risk for the subsequent development of PVL and cerebral palsy. Histological chorioamnionitis and congenital neonatal infection-related morbidity were more common in neonates with PVL than those without PVL in this study. We have also been able to induce PVL-like brain white matter lesions in the fetal rabbit after experimental ascending intrauterine infection. In support of this hypothesis, we were able to demonstrate overexpression of tumour necrosis factor-alpha and IL-6 in histological sections of neonatal brains with PVL. Moreover, the presence of funisitis, a histological counterpart of the fetal inflammatory response syndrome, and elevated concentrations of amniotic fluid IL-6 and IL-8 were strong and independent risk factors for the subsequent development of cerebral palsy at the age of 3 years in our recent study. Therefore, clinical and experimental data provide strong support for the hypothesis. There are significant implications of our findings. First, cytokine determinations in amniotic fluid provide information about the risk of PVL and cerebral palsy before birth. Second, the process responsible for some cases of PVL and cerebral palsy begins during intrauterine life, implying that effective strategies for the prevention of cerebral palsy associated with PVL must begin in utero.

Fetal or infant death in twin pregnancy: neurodevelopmental consequence for the survivor.

AIM: To determine the neurodevelopmental morbidity in the surviving twin after fetal or infant death of the co-twin. METHODS: Twin pregnancies with an antepartum or infant death delivered between 1981 and 1992 were identified from the Northern Perinatal Mortality Survey. Information on the neurodevelopmental morbidity of infant survivors of a deceased co-twin was obtained by a questionnaire sent to the community paediatrician or general practitioner. RESULTS: A total of 111 children who survived infancy after the fetal death of the co-twin (group 1) and 142 from liveborn twin pairs in which one twin died in infancy (group 2) were traced. Responses were received from 97 (87%) and 130 (92%) respectively. In group 1, the cerebral palsy prevalence was 93 (95% confidence interval (CI) 43 to 169) per 1000 infant survivors; it was more common in like-sex pairs (8/70) with a prevalence of 114 (95% CI 51 to 213) compared with 45 (95% CI 1 to 228) per 1000 infant survivors in unlike-sex pairs (1/22). The overall prevalence of neurodevelopmental morbidity (including developmental delay) was 175 (95% CI 106 to 266) per 1000. In group 2, the cerebral palsy prevalence was 154 (95% CI 84 to 223) per 1000 infant survivors in like-sex (16/104) and 77 (95% CI 9 to 251) in unlike-sex (2/26) survivors; the overall prevalence of neurodevelopmental morbidity was 246 (95% CI 172 to 320) per 1000. CONCLUSIONS: The risk of cerebral palsy is increased in the surviving twin after a fetal or infant co-twin death compared with the general twin population. Like-sex twins are at greater risk than unlike-sex. The probable cause, in addition to the consequences of prematurity, is twin-twin transfusion problems associated with monochorionicity.

Neonatal risk factors for cerebral palsy in very preterm babies: case-control study.

OBJECTIVE: To identify neonatal risk factors for cerebral palsy among very preterm babies and in particular the associations independent of the coexistence of antenatal and intrapartum factors. DESIGN: Case-control study. SETTING: Oxford health region. SUBJECTS: Singleton babies born between 1984 and 1990 at less than 32 weeks' gestation who survived to discharge from hospital: 59 with cerebral palsy and 234 randomly selected controls without cerebral palsy. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Adverse neonatal factors expressed as odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals. RESULTS: Factors associated with an increased risk of cerebral palsy after adjustment for gestational age and the presence of previously identified antenatal and intrapartum risk factors were patent ductus arteriosus (odds ratio 2.3; 95% confidence interval 1.2 to 4.5), hypotension (2.3; 1.3 to 4.7), blood transfusion (4.8; 2.5 to 9.3), prolonged ventilation (4.8; 2.5 to 9.0), pneumothorax (3.5; 1.6 to 7.6), sepsis (3.6; 1.8 to 7.4), hyponatraemia (7.9; 2.1 to 29.6) and total parenteral nutrition (5.5; 2.8 to 10.5). Seizures were associated with an increased risk of cerebral palsy (10.0; 4.1 to 24.7), as were parenchymal damage (32; 12.4 to 84.4) and appreciable ventricular dilatation (5.4; 3.0 to 9.8) detected by cerebral ultrasound. CONCLUSION: A reduction in the rate of cerebral palsy in very preterm babies requires an integrated approach to management throughout the antenatal, intrapartum, and neonatal periods.

The undesirable consequences of controlling for birth weight in perinatal epidemiological studies.

OBJECTIVE: To compare the effects of controlling for birth weight with those of controlling for gestational age at delivery in perinatal epidemiological studies using two examples. SETTING: Western Australia. SUBJECTS: Population data: all white births born at 20-46 weeks of gestation in Western Australia during 1985-91 inclusive (n = 147564). Example 1: All Western Australian births from 1980-89 born either at 33-36 weeks inclusive (n = 13607), or born with a birth weight of 2050-2900 g (n = 34107). Example 2: 160 singleton cases of spastic cerebral palsy born to white mothers in Western Australia from 1975-80 and whose gestational age was known, compared with (a) 480 controls individually matched for gender and birth weight and (b) singletons with known gestational age liveborn to white mothers in Western Australia from 1980-81, or 1979-82 if < 30 weeks' gestational age at birth (n = 32031). MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The risks of cerebral palsy associated with two separate exposures in groups defined by birth weight were compared with those in groups defined by gestational age. The origin of the differences are explained using total population data. The estimates of risk differ when exposure and outcome are both associated with appropriateness of fetal growth. The difference varied with gestational age, being greatest in the moderately preterm (33-36 weeks' gestation). CONCLUSION: Epidemiological studies in which appropriateness of fetal growth is an important variable should be based on gestational age at birth rather than birth weight, whatever the neonatal size or maturity.