In Silico Analysis of ACE Inhibitory Peptides from Chloroplast Proteins of Red Alga Grateloupia asiatica.

Inhibition of angiotensin I-converting enzyme (ACE) is one of the key factors to repress high blood pressure. Although many studies have been reported that seaweed protein hydrolysates showed the ACE inhibitory activity, the comprehensive understanding of the relationship was still unclear. In this study, we employed chloroplast genome for in silico analysis and compared it with in vitro experiments. We first extracted water-soluble proteins (WSP) from red alga Grateloupia asiatica, which contained mainly PE, PC, APC, and Rbc, and prepared WSP hydrolysate by thermolysin, resulting that the hydrolysate showed ACE inhibitory activity. Then, we determined the complete chloroplast genome of G. asiatica (187,518 bp: 206 protein-coding genes, 29 tRNA, and 3 rRNA) and clarified the amino acid sequences of main WSP, i.e., phycobiliproteins and Rubisco, to perform in silico analysis. Consequently, 190 potential ACE inhibitory peptides existed in the main WSP sequences, and 21 peptides were obtained by in silico thermolysin digestion. By comparing in vitro and in silico analyses, in vitro ACE inhibitory activity was correlated to the IC50 value from in silico digestion. Therefore, in silico approach provides insight into the comprehensive understanding of the potential bioactive peptides from seaweed proteins.

Expression and Purification of DGD2, a Chloroplast Outer Membrane-Associated Glycosyltransferase for Galactolipid Synthesis.

Galactolipids are characteristic lipids of the photosynthetic membranes. They are highly enriched in the chloroplast and are present in photosystem structures. There are two major types of galactolipids, i.e., monogalactosyldiacylglycerol and digalactosyldiacylglycerol (DGDG) in chloroplastic membranes, which amount to ∼50 and ∼20 mol % of the total chloroplast lipids, respectively. Under phosphate-limiting conditions, the amount of DGDG increases dramatically for rescuing phosphate from phospholipids. In Arabidopsis thaliana, the gene digalactosyldiacylglycerol synthase 2 (DGD2) encodes a membrane-associated glycosyltransferase. The gene expression is highly responsive to phosphate starvation and is significantly upregulated in this case. To understand the molecular mechanism of DGD2, we established a protocol for DGD2 expression and purification in an Escherichia coli-based system. The work involved optimization of the expression condition and the purification protocol and a careful selection of buffer additives. It was found that a removal of around 70 C-terminal residues was necessary to produce a homogeneous monomeric protein sample with high purity, which was highly active. The purified sample was characterized by an activity assay for enzyme kinetics in which a range of membrane mimetics with different lipid compositions were used. The results demonstrate that DGD2 activity is stimulated by the presence of negatively charged lipids, which highlight the importance of the membrane environment in modulating the enzyme's activity. The study also paves way for future biophysical and structural studies of the enzyme.

Bottom-up proteomics of envelope proteins extracted from spinach chloroplast via high organic content CE-MS.

A high organic content CE-MS/MS (HOCE-MS/MS) method was developed for the proteomic analysis of envelope proteins extracted from spinach leaves. Separation was performed in a 1-m long hydroxypropyl cellulose coated capillary, using 8% (v/v) formic acid in 70% (v/v) methanol and 22% water as the BGE. A flow-through microvial interface was used to couple the CE system with an Orbitrap Fusion Lumos mass spectrometer, and field-amplified sample stacking was used to improve the concentration sensitivity. Using this optimized method, 3579 peptides and 1141 proteins were identified using the Proteome Discoverer software with a 1% false discovery rate at the protein level. Relative to conventional aqueous CE, HOCE-MS did a better job of discovering hydrophobic peptides and provided more peptide and protein identifications. Relative to nano-LC-MS, it achieved comparable peptide and protein identification performance and detected peptides not identified by LC-MS: of the full set of peptides identified using the two techniques, 19% were identified only using HOCE-MS. It also outperformed nano-LC-MS with respect to the detection of low molecular weight peptides.

In Vivo Trapping of Proteins Interacting with the Chloroplast CLPC1 Chaperone: Potential Substrates and Adaptors.

The chloroplast stromal CLP protease system is essential for growth and development. It consists of a proteolytic CLP core complex that likely dynamically interacts with oligomeric rings of CLPC1, CLPC2, or CLPD AAA+ chaperones. These ATP-dependent chaperones are predicted to bind and unfold CLP protease substrates, frequently aided by adaptors (recognins), and feed them into the proteolytic CLP core for degradation. To identify new substrates and possibly also new adaptors for the chloroplast CLP protease system, we generated an in vivo CLPC1 substrate trap with a C-terminal STREPII affinity tag in Arabidopsis thaliana by mutating critical glutamate residues (E374A and E718A) in the two Walker B domains of CLPC1 required for the hydrolysis of ATP (CLPC1-TRAP). On the basis of homology to nonplant CLPB/C chaperones, it is predicted that interacting substrates are unable to be released; that is, they are trapped. When expressed in the wild type, this CLPC1-TRAP induced a dominant visible phenotype, whereas no viable mutants that express CLPC1-TRAP in the clpc1-1 null mutant could be recovered. Affinity purification of the CLPC1-TRAP resulted in a dozen proteins highly enriched compared with affinity-purified CLPC1 with a C-terminal STREPII affinity tag (CLPC1-WT). These enriched proteins likely represent CLP protease substrates or new adaptors. Several of these trapped proteins overaccumulated in clp mutants or were found as interactors for the adaptor CLPS1, supporting their functional relationship to CLP function. Importantly, the affinity purification of this CLPC1-TRAP also showed high enrichment of all CLPP, CLPR, and CLPT subunits, indicating the stabilization of the CLPC to CLP core interaction and providing direct support for their physical and functional interaction.

Affinity Purification of Chloroplast Translocon Protein Complexes Using the TAP Tag.

Chloroplast biogenesis requires the import of thousands of nucleus-encoded proteins into the plastid. The import of these proteins depends on the translocon at the outer (TOC) and inner (TIC) chloroplast membranes. The TOC and TIC complexes are multimeric and probably contain yet unknown components. One of the main goals in the field is to establish the complete inventory of TOC and TIC components. For the isolation of TOC-TIC complexes and the identification of new components, the preprotein receptor TOC159 has been modified N-terminally by the addition of the tandem affinity purification (TAP) tag resulting in TAP-TOC159. The TAP-tag is designed for two sequential affinity purification steps (hence "tandem affinity"). The TAP-tag used in these studies consists of a N-terminal IgG-binding domain derived from Staphylococcus aureus Protein A (ProtA) followed by a calmodulin-binding peptide (CBP). Between these two affinity tags, a tobacco etch virus (TEV) protease cleavage site has been included. Therefore, TEV protease can be used for gentle elution of TOC159-containing complexes after binding to IgG beads. In the protocol presented here, the second Calmodulin-affinity purification step was omitted. The purification protocol starts with the preparation and solubilization of total cellular membranes. After the detergent-treatment, the solubilized membrane proteins are incubated with IgG beads for the immunoisolation of TAP-TOC159-containing complexes. Upon binding and extensive washing, TAP-TOC159 containing complexes are cleaved and released from the IgG beads using the TEV protease whereby the S. aureus IgG-binding domain is removed. Western blotting of the isolated TOC159-containing complexes can be used to confirm the presence of known or suspected TOC and TIC proteins. More importantly, the TOC159-containing complexes have been used successfully to identify new components of the TOC and TIC complexes by mass spectrometry. The protocol that we present potentially allows the efficient isolation of any membrane-bound protein complex to be used for the identification of yet unknown components by mass spectrometry.

Targeted Quantification of Isoforms of a Thylakoid-Bound Protein: MRM Method Development.

Targeted mass spectrometric methods such as selected/multiple reaction monitoring (SRM/MRM) have found intense application in protein detection and quantification which competes with classical immunoaffinity techniques. It provides a universal procedure to develop a fast, highly specific, sensitive, accurate, and cheap methodology for targeted detection and quantification of proteins based on the direct analysis of their surrogate peptides typically generated by tryptic digestion. This methodology can be advantageously applied in the field of plant proteomics and particularly for non-model species since immunoreagents are scarcely available. Here, we describe the issues to take into consideration in order to develop a MRM method to detect and quantify isoforms of the thylakoid-bound protein polyphenol oxidase from the non-model and database underrepresented species Eriobotrya japonica Lindl.

Proteomics Provides Insight into the Interaction between Mulberry and Silkworm.

Mulberry leaves have been selected as a food source for the silkworm (Bombyx mori) for over 5000 years. However, the interaction mechanisms of mulberry-silkworm remain largely unknown. We explore the interaction between mulberry and silkworm at the protein level. Total proteins were extracted from mulberry leaves and silkworm feces on day 5 of the fifth larval instar and analyzed on shotgun liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry, respectively. In total, 2076 and 210 foliar proteins were identified from mulberry leaves and silkworm feces, respectively. These proteins were classified into four categories according to their subcellular location: chloroplast proteins, mitochondrial proteins, secretory-pathway proteins, and proteins of other locations. Chloroplast proteins accounted for 68.3% in mulberry leaves but only 23.2% in the feces. In contrast, secretory-pathway proteins had low abundance in mulberry leaves (7.3%) but were greatly enriched to the largest component in the feces (60.1%). Most of the foliar secretory-pathway proteins in the feces were found to be resistant to silkworm feeding by becoming involved in primary metabolite, proteinase inhibition, cell-wall remodeling, redox regulation, and pathogen-resistant processes. On the contrary, only six defensive proteins were identified in the fecal chloroplast proteins including two key proteins responsible for synthesizing jasmonic acid, although chloroplast proteins were the second largest component in the feces. Collectively, the comparative proteomics analyses indicate that mulberry leaves not only provide amino acids to the silkworm but also display defense against silkworm feeding, although the silkworm grows very well by feeding on mulberry leaves, which provides new insights into the interactions between host-plant and insect herbivores.

The distinct functional roles of the inner and outer chloroplast envelope of Pea (Pisum sativum) as revealed by proteomic approaches.

Protein profiles of inner (IE) and outer (OE) chloroplast envelope membrane preparations from pea were studied using shotgun nLC-MS/MS and two-dimensional electrophoresis, and 589 protein species (NCBI entries) were identified. The relative enrichment of each protein in the IE/OE pair of membranes was used to provide an integrated picture of the chloroplast envelope. From the 546 proteins identified with shotgun, 321 showed a significant differential distribution, with 180 being enriched in IE and 141 in OE. To avoid redundancy and facilitate in silico localization, Arabidopsis homologues were used to obtain a nonredundant list of 409 envelope proteins, with many showing significant OE or IE enrichment. Functional classification reveals that IE is a selective barrier for transport of many metabolites and plays a major role in controlling protein homeostasis, whereas proteins in OE are more heterogeneous and participate in a wide range of processes. Data support that metabolic processes previously described to occur in the envelope such as chlorophyll and tocopherol biosynthesis can be ascribed to the IE, whereas others such as carotenoid or lipid biosynthesis occur in both membranes. Furthermore, results allow empirical assignation to the IE and/or OE of many proteins previously assigned to the bulk chloroplast envelope proteome.

Cloning and chloroplast-targeted expression studies of insect-resistant gene with ricin fusion-gene under chloroplast transit peptide in cotton

Background: Transgenic plants inhabiting single Bt gene are prone to develop insect resistance and this resistance has been reported in case of some important yield-devastating insect larvae of commercial crops, such as cotton and rice. Therefore, it has become essential to adapt new strategies to overcome the problem of insect resistance and these new strategies should be sophisticated enough to target such resistant larvae in broad spectrum. Among these, plants may be transformed with Bt gene tagged with some fusion-protein gene that possesses lectin-binding capability to boost the binding sites for crystal protein gene within insect mid-gut in order to overcome any chances of insect tolerance against Bt toxin. Enhanced chloroplast-targeted Bt gene expression can also help in the reduction of insect resistance. Results: In the present investigation, a combined effect of both these strategies was successfully used in cotton (G. hirsutum). For this purpose, plant expression vector pKian-1 was created, after a series of cloning steps, carrying Cry1Ac gene ligated with chloroplast transit peptide towards N-terminal and Ricin B-Chain towards C-terminal, generating TP-Cry1Ac-RB construct. Conclusions: Efficacy of pKian-1 plasmid vector was confirmed by in-planta Agrobacterium-mediated leaf GUS assay in tobacco. Cotton (G. hirsutum) local variety MNH-786 was transformed with pKian-1 and the stable integration of TP-Cry1Ac-RB construct in putative transgenic plants was confirmed by PCR; while fusion-protein expression in cytosol as well as chloroplast was substantiated by Western blot analysis. Whereas, confocal microscopy of leaf-sections of transgenic plants exposed that hybrid-Bt protein was expressing inside chloroplasts.

The purification of the Chlamydomonas reinhardtii chloroplast ClpP complex: additional subunits and structural features.

The ClpP peptidase is a major constituent of the proteolytic machinery of bacteria and organelles. The chloroplast ClpP complex is unusual, in that it associates a large number of subunits, one of which (ClpP1) is encoded in the chloroplast, the others in the nucleus. The complexity of these large hetero-oligomeric complexes has been a major difficulty in their overproduction and biochemical characterization. In this paper, we describe the purification of native chloroplast ClpP complex from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, using a strain that carries the Strep-tag II at the C-terminus of the ClpP1 subunit. Similar to land plants, the algal complex comprises active and inactive subunits (3 ClpP and 5 ClpR, respectively). Evidence is presented that a sub-complex can be produced by dissociation, comprising ClpP1 and ClpR1, 2, 3 and 4, similar to the ClpR-ring described in land plants. Our Chlamydomonas ClpP preparation also contains two ClpT subunits, ClpT3 and ClpT4, which like the land plant ClpT1 and ClpT2 show 2 Clp-N domains. ClpTs are believed to function in substrate binding and/or assembly of the two heptameric rings. Phylogenetic analysis indicates that ClpT subunits have appeared independently in Chlorophycean algae, in land plants and in dispersed cyanobacterial genomes. Negative staining electron microscopy shows that the Chlamydomonas complex retains the barrel-like shape of homo-oligomeric ClpPs, with 4 additional peripheral masses that we speculate represent either the additional IS1 domain of ClpP1 (a feature unique to algae) or ClpTs or extensions of ClpR subunits.

Purification of an Arabidopsis chloroplast extract with in vitro RNA processing activity on psbA and petD 3'-untranslated regions.

The mature 3'-end of many chloroplast mRNAs is generated by the processing of the 3'-untranslated region (3'-UTR), which is a mechanism that involves the removal of a segment located downstream an inverted repeat sequence that forms a stem-loop structure. Nuclear-encoded chloroplast RNA binding proteins associate with the stem-loop to process the 3'-UTR or to influence mRNA stability. A spinach chloroplast processing extract (CPE) has been previously generated and used to in vitro dissect the biochemical mechanism underlying 3'-UTR processing. Being Arabidopsis thaliana an important genetic model, the development of a CPE allowing to correlate 3'-UTR processing activity with genes encoding proteins involved in this process, would be of great relevance. Here, we developed a purification protocol that generated an Arabidopsis CPE able to correctly process a psbA 3'-UTR precursor. By UV crosslinking, we characterized the protein patterns generated by the interaction of RNA binding proteins with Arabidopsis psbA and petD 3'-UTRs, finding that each 3'-UTR bound specific proteins. By testing whether Arabidopsis CPE proteins were able to bind spinach ortholog 3'-UTRs, we also found they were bound by specific proteins. When Arabidopsis CPE 3'-UTR processing activity on ortholog spinach 3'-UTRs was assessed, stable products appeared: for psbA, a smaller size product than the expected mature 3'-end, and for petD, low amounts of the expected product plus several others of smaller sizes. These results suggest that the 3'-UTR processing mechanism of these chloroplast mRNAs might be partially conserved in Arabidopsis and spinach.

One- and two-dimensional blue native-PAGE and immunodetection of low-abundance chloroplast membrane protein complexes.

Blue native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (BN-PAGE) is a powerful method for separating protein complexes from biological membranes under native conditions. BN-PAGE provides much higher resolution than gel filtration or sucrose density gradient centrifugation, and it can be used to estimate the molecular mass of protein complexes. First, membrane protein complexes need to be solubilized with a mild nonionic detergent such as digitonin or dodecyl maltoside. Coomassie brilliant blue G-250, a negatively charged dye that binds to the surface of the solubilized complexes, is then added so these can be resolved according to their size by non-denaturing (native) electrophoresis. BN-PAGE can be combined with a second dimension SDS-PAGE step (two-dimensional (2D)-BN/SDS-PAGE), so that the subunits making up these complexes are also separated according to their size. Here, we present our 2D-BN/SDS-PAGE method, and subsequent immunoblotting method, for the detection of relatively low-abundance proteins from plant chloroplasts.

Preparation of multiprotein complexes from Arabidopsis chloroplasts using tandem affinity purification.

Since its first description in 1998 (Rigaut et al., Nat Biotech 17:1030-1032, 1999), the TAP method, for Tandem Affinity Purification, has become one of the most popular methods for the purification of in vivo protein complexes and the identification of their composition by subsequent mass spectrometry analysis. The TAP method is based on the use of a tripartite tag fused to a target protein expressed in the organism of interest. A TAP tag has two independent binding regions separated by a protease cleavage site, and therefore allows two successive affinity purification steps. The most common TAP tag consists of two IgG binding repeats of Protein A from Staphylococcus aureus (ProtA) separated from a calmodulin-binding peptide by a Tobacco Etch Virus (TEV) protease cleavage site. Using the TAP method, native protein complexes can be purified efficiently with a reduced contaminant background when compared to single step purification methods. Initially developed in the yeast model system, the TAP method has been adapted to most common model organisms. The first report of the purification of protein complexes from plant tissue by the TAP method was published in 2004 by Rohila et al. (Plant J 38:172-181, 2004). The synthetic TAP tag gene described in this study has been optimized for use in plants, and since then, has been successfully used from single gene analyses to high-throughput studies of whole protein families (Rohila et al., PLoS ONE 4:e6685, 2009). Here, we describe a TAP tag purification method for the purification of protein complexes from total Arabidopsis extracts, that we employed successfully using a TAP-tagged chloroplast outer envelope protein.

Studying chloroplast protein interactions in vitro: an overview of the available methods.

The analysis of protein-protein interactions is essential for the understanding of the molecular events in enzymatic pathways, signaling cascades, or transport processes in the chloroplast. A large variety of methods are available, which range from qualitative assays allowing for screening for new interaction partners, and semiquantitative assays allowing for a rough description of the interaction between two partners, to quantitative assays that permit detailed determination of kinetic and thermodynamic parameters. We summarize the available technologies, describe their range of applications and pitfalls, and give some examples from chloroplast research. The described techniques are generic and thereby important and useful to study the interaction network of proteins in Arabidopsis thaliana. In addition, we refer the reader to detailed protocols published elsewhere for each method.

Preparation of stroma, thylakoid membrane, and lumen fractions from Arabidopsis thaliana chloroplasts for proteomic analysis.

For many studies regarding important chloroplast processes such as oxygenic photosynthesis, fractionation of the total chloroplast proteome is a necessary first step. Here, we describe a method for isolating the stromal, the thylakoid membrane, and the thylakoid lumen subchloroplast fractions from Arabidopsis thaliana leaf material. All three fractions can be isolated sequentially from the same plant material in a single day preparation. The isolated fractions are suitable for various proteomic analyses such as simple mapping studies or for more complex experiments such as differential expression analysis using two-dimensional difference gel electrophoresis (2D-DIGE) or mass spectrometry (MS)-based techniques. Besides this, the obtained fractions can also be used for many other purposes such as immunological assays, enzymatic activity assays, and studies of protein complexes by native-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (native-PAGE).

Preparation of plastoglobules from Arabidopsis plastids for proteomic analysis and other studies.

Plastoglobules are particles specifically located inside different types of plastids. They mainly contain lipids and proteins and are physically attached to thylakoids. Proteomic studies have underlined the role of plastoglobules in diverse plastid metabolic pathways, such as those producing vitamin K, vitamin E, and carotenoids, and have implicated them in plant response to stress. This chapter describes the isolation of pure and intact plastoglobules from Arabidopsis leaves. The procedure starts with the isolation of intact chloroplasts by centrifugation on a Percoll gradient. Plastoglobules are then separated from the plastid membranes by flotation on a sucrose gradient. Finally, the purity of the plastoglobule fraction is verified by immunoblotting.

The workflow for quantitative proteome analysis of chloroplast development and differentiation, chloroplast mutants, and protein interactions by spectral counting.

This chapter outlines a quantitative proteomics workflow using a label-free spectral counting technique. The workflow has been tested on different aspects of chloroplast biology in maize and Arabidopsis, including chloroplast mutant analysis, cell-type specific chloroplast differentiation, and the proplastid-to-chloroplast transition. The workflow involves one-dimensional SDS-PAGE of the proteomes of leaves or chloroplast subfractions, tryptic digestions, online LC-MS/MS using a mass spectrometer with high mass accuracy and duty cycle, followed by semiautomatic data processing. The bioinformatics analysis can effectively select best gene models and deals with quantification of closely related proteins; the workflow avoids overidentification of proteins and results in more accurate protein quantification. The final output includes pairwise comparative quantitative analysis, as well as hierarchical clustering for discovery of temporal and spatial patterns of protein accumulation. A brief discussion about potential pitfalls, as well as the advantages and disadvantages of spectral counting, is provided.

Use of phosphoproteomics to study posttranslational protein modifications in Arabidopsis chloroplasts.

The posttranslational modification of proteins is important for the regulation of enzymatic activity, protein half-life, and interaction with other molecules. One of the best understood posttranslational modifications is the reversible phosphorylation of proteins at serine, threonine, or tyrosine residues. These phosphoamino acids are relatively stable in acidic solutions, and their comprehensive identification by mass spectrometry is, therefore, feasible. Phosphoproteomics-type experiments require some modifications in the sample preparation, mass spectrometry setup, and software-based data interpretation compared to standard proteomics workflows. Furthermore, phosphoproteome analyses are incompatible with long organelle isolation procedures prior to analysis, because of the highly dynamic nature of regulatory phosphorylations. In this chapter, we provide a detailed step-by-step overview of the complex experimental setup required for successful chloroplast phosphoproteome analysis, report our experience with existing methods, and comment on their application in the field.

Studying translation in Arabidopsis chloroplasts.

Chloroplasts as descendents of a cyanobacterial endosymbiont have retained, during evolution, their own genome together with the gene expression machinery, including the translation apparatus. Therefore, chloroplast protein synthesis is not only a key process in organello biogenesis and maintenance, but it also represents the major regulatory step in chloroplast gene expression. In fact, several independent evidences have shown that the accumulation of template messengers is not limiting in the expression of chloroplast genes. On the contrary, translation regulatory processes based on selection of translatable mRNA by either nucleus-encoded activation factors or sensors of the assembly status of chloroplast multiprotein complexes have been reported. Additionally, we have shown that organelle translation rate triggers an organelle-to-nucleus signaling cascade aimed to modulate nuclear gene expression according to the organelle's needs. Therefore, the study of chloroplast translation appears to be essential for the comprehension of several aspects of chloroplast activity. Here, we describe the in vivo pulse-chase and the polysome isolation approaches. Taken together, the two methods allow one to assess rates of protein synthesis and degradation as well as defects during the initial steps of protein synthesis.

Determining the location of an Arabidopsis chloroplast protein using in vitro import followed by fractionation and alkaline extraction.

Chloroplasts have one of the most complicated structures among organelles. They have three membrane systems, the outer and inner envelope membranes and the thylakoid membrane, which enclose three aqueous spaces: the intermembrane space between the two envelope membranes, the stroma, and the thylakoid lumen. Each of the chloroplast's sub-organellar compartments houses a distinct set of proteins that perform distinct functions. Determining the sub-organellar location of a protein in the chloroplast is vital for understanding or verifying the function of the protein. Here, we present protocols for determining the sub-organellar location of a chloroplast protein. The protein of interest is synthesized and labeled with [(35)S]methionine by an in vitro translation system, and imported into isolated chloroplasts. The location of the protein is then identified by fractionation of the chloroplasts through differential and sucrose step-gradient centrifugations. The various sub-chloroplast fractions are analyzed by SDS-PAGE and autoradiography, so no specific antibody against the protein of interest is required. For membrane proteins, an alkaline extraction protocol is provided to further determine whether the protein is a peripheral or an integral membrane protein. The fractionation and extraction procedures presented can also be used in conjunction with immunoblotting, if an antibody against the protein of interest is available, enabling analyses of endogenous proteins.