Diversity of circular RNAs and RNA ligases in archaeal cells.

Circular RNAs (circRNAs) differ structurally from other types of RNAs and are resistant against exoribonucleases. Although they have been detected in all domains of life, it remains unclear how circularization affects or changes functions of these ubiquitous nucleic acid circles. The biogenesis of circRNAs has been mostly described as a backsplicing event, but in archaea, where RNA splicing is a rare phenomenon, a second pathway for circRNA formation was described in the cases of rRNAs processing, tRNA intron excision, and Box C/D RNAs formation. At least in some archaeal species, circRNAs are formed by a ligation step catalyzed by an atypic homodimeric RNA ligase belonging to Rnl3 family. In this review, we describe archaeal circRNA transcriptomes obtained using high throughput sequencing technologies on Sulfolobus solfataricus, Pyrococcus abyssi and Nanoarchaeum equitans cells. We will discuss the distribution of circular RNAs among the different RNA categories and present the Rnl3 ligase family implicated in the circularization activity. Special focus is given for the description of phylogenetic distributions, protein structures, and substrate specificities of archaeal RNA ligases.

Diversity and roles of (t)RNA ligases.

The discovery of discontiguous tRNA genes triggered studies dissecting the process of tRNA splicing. As a result, we have gained detailed mechanistic knowledge on enzymatic removal of tRNA introns catalyzed by endonuclease and ligase proteins. In addition to the elucidation of tRNA processing, these studies facilitated the discovery of additional functions of RNA ligases such as RNA repair and non-conventional mRNA splicing events. Recently, the identification of a new type of RNA ligases in bacteria, archaea, and humans closed a long-standing gap in the field of tRNA processing. This review summarizes past and recent findings in the field of tRNA splicing with a focus on RNA ligation as it preferentially occurs in archaea and humans. In addition to providing an integrated view of the types and phyletic distribution of RNA ligase proteins known to date, this survey also aims at highlighting known and potential accessory biological functions of RNA ligases.

Archaeal 3'-phosphate RNA splicing ligase characterization identifies the missing component in tRNA maturation.

Intron removal from tRNA precursors involves cleavage by a tRNA splicing endonuclease to yield tRNA 3'-halves beginning with a 5'-hydroxyl, and 5'-halves ending in a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate. A tRNA ligase then incorporates this phosphate into the internucleotide bond that joins the two halves. Although this 3'-P RNA splicing ligase activity was detected almost three decades ago in extracts from animal and later archaeal cells, the protein responsible was not yet identified. Here we report the purification of this ligase from Methanopyrus kandleri cells, and its assignment to the still uncharacterized RtcB protein family. Studies with recombinant Pyrobaculum aerophilum RtcB showed that the enzyme is able to join spliced tRNA halves to mature-sized tRNAs where the joining phosphodiester linkage contains the phosphate originally present in the 2',3'-cyclic phosphate. The data confirm RtcB as the archaeal RNA 3'-P ligase. Structural genomics efforts previously yielded a crystal structure of the Pyrococcus horikoshii RtcB protein containing a new protein fold and a conserved putative Zn(2+) binding cleft. This structure guided our mutational analysis of the P. aerophilum enzyme. Mutations of highly conserved residues in the cleft (C100A, H205A, H236A) rendered the enzyme inactive suggesting these residues to be part of the active site of the P. aerophilum ligase. There is no significant sequence similarity between the active sites of P. aerophilum ligase and that of T4 RNA ligase, nor ligases from plants and fungi. RtcB sequence conservation in archaea and in eukaryotes implicates eukaryotic RtcB as the long-sought animal 3'-P RNA ligase.

Branchiostoma floridae has separate healing and sealing enzymes for 5'-phosphate RNA ligation.

Animal cells have two tRNA splicing pathways: (i) a 5'-P ligation mechanism, where the 5'-phosphate of the 3' tRNA half becomes the junction phosphate of the new phosphodiester linkage, and (ii) a 3'-P ligation process, in which the 3'-phosphate of the 5' tRNA half turns into the junction phosphate. Although both activities are known to exist in animals, in almost three decades of investigation, neither of the two RNA ligases has been identified. Here we describe a gene from the chordate Branchiostoma floridae that encodes an RNA ligase (Bf RNL) with a strict requirement for RNA substrates with a 2'-phosphate terminus for the ligation of RNAs with 5'-phosphate and 3'-hydroxyl ends. Unlike the yeast and plant tRNA ligases involved in tRNA splicing, Bf RNL lacks healing activities and requires the action of a polynucleotide kinase (PNK) and a cyclic phosphodiesterase (CDPase) in trans. The activities of these two enzymes were identified in a single B. floridae protein (Bf PNK/CPDase). The combined activities of Bf RNL and Bf PNK/CPDase are sufficient for the joining of tRNA splicing intermediates in vitro, and for the functional complementation of a tRNA ligase-deficient Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain in vivo. Hence, these two proteins constitute the 5'-P RNA ligation pathway in an animal organism.

Deinococcus radiodurans RNA ligase exemplifies a novel ligase clade with a distinctive N-terminal module that is important for 5'-PO4 nick sealing and ligase adenylylation but dispensable for phosphodiester formation at an adenylylated nick.

Deinococcus radiodurans RNA ligase (DraRnl) is a template-directed ligase that seals nicked duplexes in which the 3'-OH strand is RNA. DraRnl is a 342 amino acid polypeptide composed of a C-terminal adenylyltransferase domain fused to a distinctive 126 amino acid N-terminal module (a putative OB-fold). An alanine scan of the C domain identified 9 amino acids essential for nick ligation, which are located within nucleotidyltransferase motifs I, Ia, III, IIIa, IV and V. Seven mutants were dysfunctional by virtue of defects in ligase adenylylation: T163A, H167A, G168A, K186A, E230A, F281A and E305A. Four of these were also defective in phosphodiester formation at a preadenylylated nick: G168A, E230A, F281A and E305A. Two nick sealing-defective mutants were active in ligase adenylylation and sealing a preadenylylated nick, thereby implicating Ser185 and Lys326 in transfer of AMP from the enzyme to the nick 5'-PO(4). Whereas deletion of the N-terminal domain suppressed overall nick ligation and ligase adenylylation, it did not compromise sealing at a preadenylylated nick. Mutational analysis of 15 residues of the N domain identified Lys26, Gln31 and Arg79 as key constituents. Structure-activity relationships at the essential residues were determined via conservative substitutions. We propose that DraRnl typifies a new clade of polynucleotide ligases. DraRnl homologs are detected in several eukaryal proteomes.

Plant tRNA ligases are multifunctional enzymes that have diverged in sequence and substrate specificity from RNA ligases of other phylogenetic origins.

Pre-tRNA splicing is an essential process in all eukaryotes. It requires the concerted action of an endonuclease to remove the intron and a ligase for joining the resulting tRNA halves as studied best in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Here, we report the first characterization of an RNA ligase protein and its gene from a higher eukaryotic organism that is an essential component of the pre-tRNA splicing process. Purification of tRNA ligase from wheat germ by successive column chromatographic steps has identified a protein of 125 kDa by its potentiality to covalently bind AMP, and by its ability to catalyse the ligation of tRNA halves and the circularization of linear introns. Peptide sequences obtained from the purified protein led to the elucidation of the corresponding proteins and their genes in Arabidopsis and Oryza databases. The plant tRNA ligases exhibit no overall sequence homologies to any known RNA ligases, however, they harbour a number of conserved motifs that indicate the presence of three intrinsic enzyme activities: an adenylyltransferase/ligase domain in the N-terminal region, a polynucleotide kinase in the centre and a cyclic phosphodiesterase domain at the C-terminal end. In vitro expression of the recombinant Arabidopsis tRNA ligase and functional analyses revealed all expected individual activities. Plant RNA ligases are active on a variety of substrates in vitro and are capable of inter- and intramolecular RNA joining. Hence, we conclude that their role in vivo might comprise yet unknown essential functions besides their involvement in pre-tRNA splicing.

Characterization of bacteriophage KVP40 and T4 RNA ligase 2.

Bacteriophage T4 RNA ligase 2 (Rnl2) exemplifies a subfamily of RNA strand-joining enzymes that includes the trypanosome RNA editing ligases. A homolog of T4 Rnl2 is encoded in the 244-kbp DNA genome of vibriophage KVP40. We show that the 335-amino acid KVP40 Rnl2 is a monomeric protein that catalyzes RNA end-joining through ligase-adenylate and RNA-adenylate (AppRNA) intermediates. In the absence of ATP, pre-adenylated KVP40 Rnl2 reacts with an 18-mer 5'-PO(4) single-strand RNA (pRNA) to form an 18-mer RNA circle. In the presence of ATP, Rnl2 generates predominantly AppRNA. Isolated AppRNA can be circularized by KVP40 Rnl2 in the absence of ATP. The reactivity of phage Rnl2 and the distribution of the products are affected by the length of the pRNA substrate. Whereas 18-mer and 15-mer pRNAs undergo intramolecular sealing by T4 Rnl2 to form monomer circles, a 12-mer pRNA is ligated intermolecularly to form dimers, and a 9-mer pRNA is unreactive. In the presence of ATP, the 15-mer and 12-mer pRNAs are converted to AppRNAs, but the 9-mer pRNA is not. A single 5' deoxynucleotide substitution of an 18-mer pRNA substrate has no apparent effect on the 5' adenylation or circularization reactions of T4 Rnl2. In contrast, a single deoxyribonucleoside at the 3' terminus strongly and selectively suppresses the sealing step, thereby resulting in accumulation of high levels of AppRNA in the absence of ATP. The ATP-dependent "capping" of RNA with AMP by Rnl2 is reminiscent of the capping of eukaryotic mRNA with GMP by GTP:RNA guanylyltransferase and suggests an evolutionary connection between bacteriophage Rnl2 and eukaryotic RNA capping enzymes.

Combinatorial minimization and secondary structure determination of a nucleotide synthase ribozyme.

We previously isolated from random sequences ribozymes able to form a glycosidic linkage between a ribose sugar and 4-thiouracil in a reaction that mimics protein-catalyzed nucleotide synthesis. Here we report on two serial in vitro selection experiments that defined the core motif of one of the nucleotide synthase ribozymes and provided improved versions of this ribozyme. The first selection experiment started from a degenerate sequence pool based on the previously isolated sequence and used a selection-amplification protocol that allowed the sequence requirements at the 3' terminus of the ribozyme to be interrogated. Comparing the active sequences identified in this experiment revealed the complicated secondary structure of the nucleotide synthase ribozyme. A second selection was then performed to remove nonessential sequence from the ribozyme. This selection started with a pool with variation introduced in both the sequence and the length of the nonconserved loops and joining regions. This pool was generated using a partial reblocking/deblocking strategy on a DNA synthesizer, allowing the combinatorial synthesis of both point deletions and point substitutions. The consensus ribozyme motif that emerged was an approximately 71 nt pseudoknot structure with five stems and two important joining segments. Comparative sequence analysis and a cross-linking experiment point to the probable location of nucleotide synthesis. The prototype isolate from the second selection was nearly 35 times more efficient than the initial isolate and at least 10(8) times more efficient than an upper limit of an as-yet undetectable uncatalyzed reaction, supporting the idea that RNA-catalyzed nucleotide synthesis might have been important in an RNA world.

Distinct functions of two RNA ligases in active Trypanosoma brucei RNA editing complexes.

Trypanosome RNA editing is a unique U insertion and U deletion process that involves cycles of pre-mRNA cleavage, terminal U addition or U removal, and religation. This editing can occur at massive levels and is directed by base pairing of trans-acting guide RNAs. Both U insertion and U deletion cycles are catalyzed by a single protein complex that contains only seven major proteins, band I through band VII. However, little is known about their catalytic functions, except that band IV and band V are RNA ligases and genetic analysis indicates that the former is important in U deletion. Here we establish biochemical approaches to distinguish the individual roles of these ligases, based on their distinctive ATP and pyrophosphate utilization. These in vitro analyses revealed that both ligases serve in RNA editing. Band V is the RNA editing ligase that functions very selectively to seal in U insertion (IREL), while band IV is the RNA editing ligase needed to seal in U deletion (DREL). In combination with our earlier findings about the cleavage and the U-addition/U-removal steps of U deletion and U insertion, these results show that all three steps of these editing pathways exhibit major differences and suggest that the editing complex could have physically separate regions for U deletion and U insertion.

Three-dimensional structure analysis of PROSITE patterns.

Pattern matches for each of the sequence patterns in PROSITE, a database of sequence patterns, were searched in all protein sequences in the Brookhaven Protein Data Bank (PDB). The three-dimensional structures of the pattern matches for the 20 patterns with the largest numbers of hits were analysed. We found that the true positives have a common three-dimensional structure for each pattern; the structures of false positives, found for six of the 20 patterns, were clearly different from those of the true positives. The results suggest that the true pattern matches each have a characteristic common three-dimensional structure, which could be used to create a template to define a three-dimensional functional pattern.

Accessing rare activities from random RNA sequences: the importance of the length of molecules in the starting pool.

BACKGROUND: In the past few years numerous binding and catalytic motifs have been isolated from pools of random nucleic acid sequences. To extend the utility of this approach it is important to learn how to design random-sequence pools that provide maximal access to rare activities. In an effort to better define the relative merits of longer and shorter pools (i.e. pools with longer or shorter random-sequence segments), we have examined the inhibitory effect of excess arbitrary sequence on ribozyme activity and have evaluated whether this inhibition overshadows the calculated advantage of longer pools. RESULTS: The calculated advantage of longer sequences was highly dependent on the size and complexity of the desired motif. Small, simple motifs were not much more abundant in longer molecules. In contrast, larger motifs, particularly the most complex (highly modular) motifs, were much more likely to be present in longer molecules. The experimentally determined inhibition of activity by excess sequence was moderate, with bulk effects among four libraries ranging from no effect to 18-fold inhibition. The median effect among 60 clones was fivefold inhibition. CONCLUSIONS: For accessing simple motifs (e.g. motifs at least as small and simple as the hammerhead ribozyme motif), longer pools have little if any advantage. For more complex motifs, the inhibitory effect of excess sequence does not approach the calculated advantage of pools of longer molecules. Thus, when seeking to access rare activities, the length of typical random-sequence pools (< or = 70 random positions) is shorter than optimal. As this conclusion holds over a range of incubation conditions, it may also be relevant when considering the emergence of new functional motifs during early evolution.

The secondary structure and sequence optimization of an RNA ligase ribozyme.

In vitro selection can generate functional sequence variants of an RNA structural motif that are useful for comparative analysis. The technique is particularly valuable in cases where natural variation is unavailable or non-existent. We report the extension of this approach to a new extreme--the identification of a 112 nt ribozyme secondary structure imbedded within a 186 nt RNA. A pool of 10(14) variants of an RNA ligase ribozyme was generated using combinatorial chemical synthesis coupled with combinatorial enzymatic ligation such that 172 of the 186 relevant positions were partially mutagenized. Active variants of this pool were enriched using an in vitro selection scheme that retains the sequence variability at positions very close to the ligation junction. Ligases isolated after four rounds of selection catalyzed self-ligation up to 700 times faster than the starting sequence. Comparative analysis of the isolates indicated that when complexed with substrate RNAs the ligase forms a nested, double pseudo-knot secondary structure with seven stems and several important joining segments. Comparative analysis also suggested the identity of mutations that account for the increased activity of the selected ligase variants; designed constructs incorporating combinations of these changes were more active than any of the individual ligase isolates.