Trachelectomy for reproductive-aged women with early-stage cervical cancer: minimally invasive surgery versus laparotomy.

BACKGROUND: A recent trial demonstrated decreased survival in women with early-stage cervical cancer who underwent radical hysterectomy via minimally invasive surgery compared with laparotomy; however, outcomes following trachelectomy have yet to be studied. OBJECTIVE: To examine trends, characteristics, and survival of reproductive-aged women with early-stage cervical cancer who underwent minimally invasive trachelectomy. STUDY DESIGN: This is a retrospective study examining the National Cancer Database between 2010 and 2015. Women aged <50 years who underwent trachelectomy for stage IA2-IB cervical cancer were grouped by mode of surgery. Clinicopathologic characteristics and outcomes were compared between minimally invasive surgery and laparotomy groups. RESULTS: A total of 246 women were included, 144 (58.5%, 95% confidence interval, 52.4%-64.7%) of whom had trachelectomy with a minimally invasive surgery approach. Median age was similar between the minimally invasive surgery and laparotomy groups (median, 31 vs 29 years, P = .20). There was a significant increase in the use of minimally invasive surgery from 29.3% in 2010 to 75.0% in 2015 (P < .001). Specifically, minimally invasive surgery became the dominant approach for trachelectomy by year 2011 (54.8%). Hospitals registered in the West (75.0% vs 25.0%) were more likely, whereas those registered in the Midwest (46.9% vs 53.1%) were less likely, to perform minimally invasive surgery (P = .02). Median follow-up was 37 months (interquartile range, 23-51) for the minimally invasive surgery group and 40 months (interquartile range, 26-67) for the laparotomy group. During follow-up, there were 11 (5.3%) deaths, 4 (3.5%) in the minimally invasive surgery group and 7 (7.6%) in the laparotomy group (P = .25). CONCLUSION: Minimally invasive surgery has become the dominant modality for trachelectomy in reproductive-aged women with stage IA2-IB cervical cancer after year 2011. Survival of women with stage IA2-IB cervical cancer who underwent trachelectomy is generally good regardless of surgical modality. Although our study showed no difference in survival between the minimally invasive surgery and laparotomy approaches, effects of MIS on survival remain unknown and further study is warranted.

Results from Survey to Assess Current Trends in Surgical Practice in the Management of Women with Early Stage Cervical Cancer within the BGCS Community with an Emphasis on Routine Frozen Section Examination.

In the UK, more than 3,200 new cases of cervical cancer are diagnosed each year. Early stage cervical cancer (IA2-IB1) treatment comprises central surgery mainly in the form of radical hysterectomy or fertility sparing surgery including trachelectomy as well as systematic pelvic lymphadenectomy to detect metastases and adjust treatment accordingly. Given the variation in determining the lymph node (LN) status, a major prognosticator, we reviewed the current UK practice of LN assessment in women undergoing surgery for early cervical cancer. A 7-question, web-based survey, screened by the BGCS committee, was circulated amongst BGCS members. The overall response rate was 51%. Only 12.5% of the respondents routinely performed frozen section examination (FSE); the main reasons for not doing FSE were the pressure on theatre time (54.5%) and the lack of available facilities (48.5%). When positive pelvic nodal disease was detected, in 21 out of 50 (42%) the planned radical hysterectomy (RH) was aborted. More than 70% of the respondents routinely performed RH without any prior resort to pelvic lymphadenectomy. Pretreatment surgical para-aortic LN assessment was performed by 20% of the respondents. The survey confirms the diversity of the UK practice patterns in the surgical treatment of early cervical cancer.

Nationwide trends and in-hospital complications of trachelectomy for surgically resectable cervical cancer in Taiwanese women: A population-based study, 1998-2013.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the nationwide trends in the utilization of trachelectomy among Taiwanese women with surgically resectable cervical cancer over the past decade, and to compare associated demographic characteristics, in-hospital complications and related outcomes using a population-based dataset from 1998 to 2013. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We conducted a population-based, cohort study using inpatient admission claims data of Taiwan's National Health Insurance program. Women who underwent trachelectomy for cervical cancers were compared by age at surgery (younger than 40 years, 40-59 years, and 60 years or older). RESULTS: Our study cohort consisted of 156 women. The overall utilization increased considerably during the study period, particularly in younger women aged 30-39 years. Compared with older women who had trachelectomy, women younger than 40 years were diagnosed more frequently in the later years of study (2007-2013, 69.9% vs 37.3%), were treated more frequently at medical centers (89.0% vs 60.2%) by physicians aged 55 years or older (50.7% vs 22.9%) with high case volume (50.7% vs 26.5%), were less likely to undergo concomitant surgeries for bilateral oophorectomy (1.4% vs 21.7%) and lysis of peritoneal adhesion (2.7% vs 24.1%), and were more likely to undergo lymph node excision (74.0% vs 47.0%) (P < 0.05 for all). During a median of follow-up of 5.4 (2.4-9.5) years, 5.1% received future hysterectomy after trachelectomy (n = 8) with a median time-to-future hysterectomy of 0.6 (0.2-5.0) years. The estimated risks of disease recurrence for cervical cancer and readmission within 30-days (n = 35) were 3.8% and 22.4%, respectively. Women's age at trachelectomy had no apparent association with the length of hospital stay (P = 0.11), in-hospital mortality, readmission within 30-days (P = 0.33), future hysterectomy (P = 0.14), and in-hospital complications (P = 0.47). CONCLUSION: Substantial increase in the trend of delayed childbearing may have influenced the decision-making of Taiwanese women with cervical cancer in favor of trachelectomy over hysterectomy over the past 16-years from 1998 to 2013. When considering the uterine preservation for future fertility, women should be counseled about the risk of disease recurrence for cervical cancer before making surgical decision for trachelectomy over hysterectomy.

The characterization of trachelectomy for benign and precancerous indications in Taiwan: A population-based study, 1998-2013.

OBJECTIVE: The study aimed to update the utilization trend and characterize the trachelectomy for benign and precancerous indications in Taiwanese women by comparing associated women, surgeon, and hospital-related characteristics. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We conducted a population-based trend study using inpatient admission claims data from Taiwan's National Health Insurance program from 1998 to 2013. After excluding those who had prior subtotal hysterectomy, women who underwent trachelectomy for benign and precancerous indications were compared by age at surgery (younger than 40 years, n = 130; 40 and 59 years, n = 429; and 60 years or older, n = 439). Trend analysis by age groups and indication was performed for the utilization of trachelectomy. A separate descriptive analysis was also performed to evaluate the surgeon's total trachelectomy case volume during the study period. RESULTS: A total of 998 women who underwent trachelectomy for benign and precancerous indications were included in the study cohort. The overall utilization increased considerably by 100% over the study period. The most common indications for trachelectomy were genital prolapse (75.2%) and precancerous cervical lesion (21.0%). The majority of trachelectomies were performed with concomitant colporrhaphy for genital prolapse among older women without comorbid illness or any prior catastrophic illness. Most women (62.9%) were operated by a relatively small number of surgeons with high case volume (12.6%) during the study period. Compared to women older than 40 years, younger women had less comorbidities, more likely to be treated at private medical institution by surgeons of high case volume, and were less likely to undergo concomitant anterior and posterior colporrhaphy. CONCLUSIONS: The overall utilization of trachelectomy for benign and precancerous indications has increased over the past 16-years from 1998 to 2013, particularly among older Taiwanese women without comorbid illness or any prior catastrophic illness.