Pressure-Sensitive and Osmolyte-Modulated Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation of Eye-Lens γ-Crystallins.

Biomolecular condensates can be functional (e.g., as membrane-less organelles) or dysfunctional (e.g., as precursors to pathological protein aggregates). A major physical underpinning of biomolecular condensates is liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of proteins and nucleic acids. Here we investigate the effects of temperature and pressure on the LLPS of the eye-lens protein γ-crystallin using UV/vis and IR absorption, fluorescence spectroscopy, and light microscopy to characterize the mesoscopic phase states. Quite unexpectedly, the LLPS of γ-crystallin is much more sensitive to pressure than folded states of globular proteins. At low temperatures, the phase-separated droplets of γ-crystallin dissolve into a homogeneous solution at as low as ∼0.1 kbar whereas proteins typically unfold above ∼3 kbar. This observation suggests, in general, that organisms thriving under high-pressure conditions in the deep sea, with pressure of up to 1 kbar, have to cope with this pressure sensitivity of biomolecular condensates to avoid detrimental impacts to their physiology. Interestingly, our experiments demonstrate that trimethylamine- N-oxide, an osmolyte upregulated in deep-sea fish, significantly enhances the stability of the condensed protein droplets, pointing to a previously unrecognized aspect of the adaptive advantage of increased concentrations of osmolytes in deep-sea organisms. As the birth place of life on earth could have been the deep sea, studies of pressure effects on LLPS as presented here are relevant to the possible formation of protocells under prebiotic conditions. A physical framework to conceptualize our observations and further ramifications of biomolecular LLPS at low temperatures and high hydrostatic pressures is discussed.

Extended Law of Corresponding States Applied to Solvent Isotope Effect on a Globular Protein.

Investigating proteins with techniques such as NMR or neutron scattering frequently requires the partial or complete substitution of D2O for H2O as a solvent, often tacitly assuming that such a solvent substitution does not significantly alter the properties of the protein. Here, we report a systematic investigation of the solvent isotope effect on the phase diagram of the lens protein γB-crystallin in aqueous solution as a model system exhibiting liquid-liquid phase separation. We demonstrate that the observed strong variation of the critical temperature Tc can be described by the extended law of corresponding states for all H2O/D2O ratios, where scaling of the temperature by Tc or the reduced second virial coefficient accurately reproduces the binodal, spinodal, and osmotic compressibility. These findings highlight the impact of H2O/D2O substitution on γB-crystallin properties and warrant further investigations into the universality of this phenomenon and its underlying mechanisms.

Disability for function: loss of Ca(2+)-binding is obligatory for fitness of mammalian ßγ-crystallins.

Vertebrate ßγ-crystallins belonging to the ßγ-crystallin superfamily lack functional Ca(2+)-binding sites, while their microbial homologues do not; for example, three out of four sites in lens γ-crystallins are disabled. Such loss of Ca(2+)-binding function in non-lens ßγ-crystallins from mammals (e.g., AIM1 and Crybg3) raises the possibility of a trade-off in the evolutionary extinction of Ca(2+)-binding. We test this hypothesis by reconstructing ancestral Ca(2+)-binding motifs (transforming disabled motifs into the canonical ones) in the lens γB-crystallin by introducing minimal sets of mutations. Upon incorporation of serine at the fifth position in the N/D-N/D-X-X-S/T(5)-S motif, which endowed a domain with microbial characteristics, a decreased domain stability was observed. Ca(2+) further destabilized the N-terminal domain (NTD) and its serine mutants profoundly, while the incorporation of a C-terminal domain (CTD) nullified this destabilization. On the other hand, Ca(2+)-induced destabilization of the CTD was not rescued by the introduction of an NTD. Of note, only one out of four sites is functional in the NTD of γB-crystallins responsible for weak Ca(2+) binding, but the deleterious effects of Ca(2+) are overcome by introduction of a CTD. The rationale for the onset of cataracts by certain mutations, such as R77S, which have not been clarified by structural means, could be explained by this work. The findings presented here shed light on the evolutionary innovations in terms of the functional loss of Ca(2+)-binding and acquisition of a bilobed domain, besides imparting additional advantages (e.g., protection from light) required for specialized functions.

Electrostatic origin of in vitro aggregation of human γ-crystallin.

The proteins α-, ß-, and γ-crystallins are the major components of the lens in the human eye. Using dynamic light scattering method, we have performed in vitro investigations of protein-protein interactions in dilute solutions of human γ-crystallin and α-crystallin. We find that γ-crystallin spontaneously aggregates into finite-sized clusters in phosphate buffer solutions. There are two distinct populations of unaggregated and aggregated γ-crystallins in these solutions. On the other hand, α-crystallin molecules are not aggregated into large clusters in solutions of α-crystallin alone. When α-crystallin and γ-crystallin are mixed in phosphate buffer solutions, we demonstrate that the clusters of γ-crystallin are prevented. By further investigating the roles of temperature, protein concentration, pH, salt concentration, and a reducing agent, we show that the aggregation of γ-crystallin under our in vitro conditions arises from non-covalent electrostatic interactions. In addition, we show that aggregation of γ-crystallin occurs under the dilute in vitro conditions even in the absence of oxidizing agents that can induce disulfide cross-links, long considered to be responsible for human cataracts. Aggregation of γ-crystallin when maintained under reducing conditions suggests that oxidation does not contribute to the aggregation in dilute solutions.

Partially folded aggregation intermediates of human gammaD-, gammaC-, and gammaS-crystallin are recognized and bound by human alphaB-crystallin chaperone.

Human gamma-crystallins are long-lived, unusually stable proteins of the eye lens exhibiting duplicated, double Greek key domains. The lens also contains high concentrations of the small heat shock chaperone alpha-crystallin, which suppresses aggregation of model substrates in vitro. Mature-onset cataract is believed to represent an aggregated state of partially unfolded and covalently damaged crystallins. Nonetheless, the lack of cell or tissue culture for anucleate lens fibers and the insoluble state of cataract proteins have made it difficult to identify the conformation of the human gamma-crystallin substrate species recognized by human alpha-crystallin. The three major human lens monomeric gamma-crystallins, gammaD, gammaC, and gammaS, all refold in vitro in the absence of chaperones, on dilution from denaturant into buffer. However, off-pathway aggregation of the partially folded intermediates competes with productive refolding. Incubation with human alphaB-crystallin chaperone during refolding suppressed the aggregation pathways of the three human gamma-crystallin proteins. The chaperone did not dissociate or refold the aggregated chains under these conditions. The alphaB-crystallin oligomers formed long-lived stable complexes with their gammaD-crystallin substrates. Using alpha-crystallin chaperone variants lacking tryptophans, we obtained fluorescence spectra of the chaperone-substrate complex. Binding of substrate gamma-crystallins with two or three of the four buried tryptophans replaced by phenylalanines showed that the bound substrate remained in a partially folded state with neither domain native-like. These in vitro results provide support for protein unfolding/protein aggregation models for cataract, with alpha-crystallin suppressing aggregation of damaged or unfolded proteins through early adulthood but becoming saturated with advancing age.

Comparative analysis of crystallins and lipids from the lens of Antarctic toothfish and cow.

Animal model systems of senile cataract and lens crystallin stability are essential to understand the complex nature of lens transparency. Our aim in this study was to assess the long-lived Antarctic toothfish Dissostichus mawsoni (Norman) as a model system to understand long-term lens clarity in terms of solubility changes that occur to crystallins. We compared the toothfish with the mammalian model cow lens, dissecting each species' lens into a cortex and nuclear region. In addition to crystallin distribution, we also assayed fatty acid (FA) composition by negative ion electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The majority of toothfish lens crystallins from cortex (90.4%) were soluble, whereas only a third (31.8%) from the nucleus was soluble. Crystallin solubility analysis by SDS-PAGE and immunoblots revealed that relative proportions of crystallins in both soluble and urea-soluble fractions were similar within each species examined and in agreement with previous reports for bovine lens. From our data, we found that both toothfish and cow crystallins follow patterns of insolubility that mirror each animals lens composition with more γ crystallin aggregation seen in the toothfish lens nucleus than in cow. Toothfish lens lipids had a large amount of polyunsaturated fatty acids that were absent in cow resulting in an unsaturation index (I(U)) four-fold higher than that of cow. We identified a novel FA with a molecular mass of 267 mass units in the lens epithelial layer of the toothfish that accounted for well over 50% of the FA abundance. The unidentified lipid in the toothfish lens epithelia corresponds to either an odd-chain (17 carbons) FA or a furanoid. We conclude that long-lived fishes are likely good animal models of lens crystallin solubility and may model post-translational modifications and solubility changes better than short-lived animal models.

Investigation of gammaE-crystallin target protein binding to bovine lens alpha-crystallin by small-angle neutron scattering.

alpha-Crystallin, one of the main constituent proteins in the crystalline lens, is an important molecular chaperone both within and outside the lens. Presently, the structural relationship between alpha-crystallin and its target proteins during chaperone action is poorly understood. It has been hypothesised that target proteins bind within a central cavity. Small-angle neutron-scattering (SANS) experiments in conjunction with isotopic substitution were undertaken to investigate the interaction of a target lens protein (gammaE-crystallin) with alpha-crystallin (alpha(H)) and to measure the radius of gyration (Rg) of the proteins and their binary complexes in solution under thermal stress. The size of the alpha(H) in D(2)O incubated at 65 degrees C increased from 69+/-3 to 81+/-5 A over 40 min, in good agreement with previously published small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and SANS measurements. Deuterated gammaE-crystallin in H(2)O buffer (gammaE(D)/H(2)O) and hydrogenous gammaE-crystallin in D(2)O buffer (gammaE(H)/D(2)O) free in solution were of insufficient size and/or too dilute to provide any measurable scattering over the angular range used, which was selected primarily to investigate gammaE:alpha(H) complexes. The evolution of the aggregation size/shape as an indicator of alpha(H) chaperone action was monitored by recording the neutron scattering in different H:D solvent contrasts under thermally stressed conditions (65 degrees C) for binary mixtures of alpha(H), gammaE(H), and gammaE(D). It was found that Rg(alpha(H):gammaE(D)/D(2)O)>Rg(alpha(H):gammaE(H)/D(2)O)>Rg(alpha(H)/D(2)O) and that Rg(alpha(H):gammaE(H)/D(2)O) approximately Rg(alpha(H)/D(2)O). The relative sizes observed for the complexes weighted by the respective scattering powers of the various components imply that gammaE-crystallin binds in a central cavity of the alpha-crystallin oligomer, during chaperone action.

Biophysical properties of gammaC-crystallin in human and mouse eye lens: the role of molecular dipoles.

The eye lens is packed with soluble crystallin proteins, providing a lifetime of transparency and light refraction. gamma-Crystallins are major components of the dense, high refractive index central regions of the lens and generally have high solubility, high stability and high levels of cysteine residues. Human gammaC belongs to a group of gamma-crystallins with a pair of cysteine residues at positions 78 and 79. Unlike other gamma-crystallins it has relatively low solubility, whereas mouse gammaC, which has the exposed C79 replaced with arginine, and a novel mouse splice variant, gammaCins, are both highly soluble. Furthermore, human gammaC is extremely stable, while the mouse orthologs are less stable. Evolutionary pressure may have favoured stability over solubility for human gammaC and the reverse for the orthologs in the mouse. Mutation of C79 to R79, in human gammaC, greatly increased solubility, however, neither form produced crystals. Remarkably, when the human gammaD R36S crystallization cataract mutation was mimicked in human gammaC-crystallin, the solubility of gammaC was dramatically increased, although it still did not crystallize. The highly soluble mouse gammaC-crystallin did crystallize. Its X-ray structure was solved and used in homology modelling of human gammaC, and its mutants C79R and R36S. The human gammaD R36S mutant was also modelled from human gammaD coordinates. Molecular dynamics simulation of the six molecules in the solution state showed that the human gammaCs differed from gammaDs in domain pairing, behaviour that correlates with interface sequence changes. When the fluctuations of the calculated molecular dipoles, for the six structures, over time were analysed, characteristic patterns for soluble gammaC and gammaD proteins were observed. Individual sequence changes that increase or decrease solubility correlated well with changes in the magnitude and direction of these dipoles. It is suggested that changes in surface residues have allowed adaptation for the differing needs of human and mouse lenses.

Interaction of lens alpha and gamma crystallins during aging of the bovine lens.

Heterologous, noncovalent interactions of lens crystallins, such as between alpha and gamma crystallin, are thought to play a key role in the transparent properties of the lens. To determine possible interactions between these two types of crystallins, bovine gamma B crystallin in its native state was purified from whole fetal lenses or from the nucleus of aged bovine lenses, and the purified protein was passed over immobilized alpha crystallin, using a surface plasmon resonance instrument (BIAcore 3000) to obtain refractive units (RU) of gamma B binding at equilibrium. The results demonstrate low binding of gamma B crystallin purified from fetal lenses, but higher binding of the same gamma species purified from aged lenses. Together, these results demonstrate that under equilibrium conditions, gamma B crystallin from the aging bovine lens shows increased noncovalent associations with alpha crystallins, consistent with the possibility that such interactions play an important role in the transparent properties of the aged lens.

Contributions of hydrophobic domain interface interactions to the folding and stability of human gammaD-crystallin.

Human gammaD-crystallin (HgammaD-Crys) is a monomeric eye lens protein composed of two highly homologous beta-sheet domains. The domains interact through interdomain side chain contacts forming two structurally distinct regions, a central hydrophobic cluster and peripheral residues. The hydrophobic cluster contains Met43, Phe56, and Ile81 from the N-terminal domain (N-td) and Val132, Leu145, and Val170 from the C-terminal domain (C-td). Equilibrium unfolding/refolding of wild-type HgammaD-Crys in guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) was best fit to a three-state model with transition midpoints of 2.2 and 2.8 M GuHCl. The two transitions likely corresponded to sequential unfolding/refolding of the N-td and the C-td. Previous kinetic experiments revealed that the C-td refolds more rapidly than the N-td. We constructed alanine substitutions of the hydrophobic interface residues to analyze their roles in folding and stability. After purification from E. coli, all mutant proteins adopted a native-like structure similar to wild type. The mutants F56A, I81A, V132A, and L145A had a destabilized N-td, causing greater population of the single folded domain intermediate. Compared to wild type, these mutants also had reduced rates for productive refolding of the N-td but not the C-td. These data suggest a refolding pathway where the domain interface residues of the refolded C-td act as a nucleating center for refolding of the N-td. Specificity of domain interface interactions is likely important for preventing incorrect associations in the high protein concentrations of the lens nucleus.

S-methylated cysteines in human lens gamma S-crystallins.

The proteins of the eye lens, which do not turn over throughout life, undergo many modifications, some of which lead to senile cataract. We describe a modification, S-methylation of cysteine, that may serve to protect the lens from detrimental modifications. The modification was detected as a +14 Da peak in electrospray ionization mass spectra of human lens gammaS-crystallins. Derivatization of gammaS-crystallin with iodoacetamide showed reaction at only six of the seven cysteines, indicating the modification blocked reaction at one cysteine. Further analysis of the modified gammaS-crystallin as tryptic peptides located the modification primarily at Cys 26, with smaller amounts at Cys 24. Tandem mass spectrometry and exact mass measurements showed that the modification was S-methylation. Methylation of proteins has been documented at several other amino acid residues, but S-methylation of cysteine residues has previously been detected only as part of a methyltransferase DNA repair mechanism or at trace amounts in hemoglobin. The high levels of S-methylated cysteines in lens nuclei and the specificity for Cys 26 and Cys 24 suggest the reaction is enzymatically mediated. This modification is particularly important because it blocks disulfide bonding of gammaS-crystallins and, thereby, inhibits formation of the high-molecular weight assemblies associated with cataract. Evidence of more S-methylation in soluble than in insoluble gammaS-crystallins supports the contention that S-methylation of gammaS-crystallin inhibits protein insolubilization and may offer protection against cataract.