For older women, the majority of hip fragility fractures and radiographic vertebral fragility fractures occur among the densitometrically osteoporotic population: a literature analysis.

ABSTRACT

It has been frequently cited that 'the majority of fragility fractures (FF) occur at non-osteoporotic bone mineral density (BMD)'. For the reports with T-score measured around the time of a hip fracture, we conducted a systematic literature search in December 2022, and resulted in 10 studies with five for Caucasian women and five for East Asian women. Femoral neck (FN) T-score was reported in five Caucasian studies and three East Asian studies, three of five Caucasian studies had a mean T-score ≤-2.5, and one study had the majority of their patients measuring a mean T-score ≤-2.5. All three East Asian studies reported a mean FN T-score ≤-2.7. Total hip T-score was reported in two Caucasian studies and three East Asian studies, the two Caucasian studies both had a mean T-score ≤-2.5, and all three East Asian studies had a mean T-score ≤-2.6. A new literature search conducted in April 2024 results in additional three studies, with results being consistent with the data described above. A trend was noted that 'younger' patients suffer from hip fractures at a 'higher' T-score. For the highly cited articles where the notion the majority of FF occur at non-osteoporotic BMD was derived from, authors reported prospective epidemiological studies where BMD was not measured at the timepoint of hip fracture, instead, BMD was measured at the study baseline. These epidemiological studies suggest that >50% of hip fractures likely occur in women with an osteoporotic FN or hip T-score. However, a pattern was seen that older men suffer from hip fracture at a notably higher T-score than older women. For the cases of radiographic vertebral FF, despite varying criteria being used to classify these FFs, the majority of female patients had spine densitometric osteoporosis. Literature shows, compared with the cases of hip fracture, distal forearm fracture occurs at a 'younger' age and 'higher' BMD, suggesting distal forearm fracture is more likely associated with a 'higher' trauma energy level.