SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infection during the Delta-dominant epidemic and neutralizing antibodies against Omicron in comparison with the third dose of BNT162b2: a matched analysis

ABSTRACT

BackgroundLongitudinal data are lacking to compare booster effects of Delta breakthrough infection versus the third vaccine dose on neutralizing antibodies (NAb) against Omicron. MethodsParticipants were the staff of a national research and medical institution in Tokyo who attended serological surveys on June 2021 (baseline) and December 2021 (follow-up); in between, the Delta-dominant epidemic occurred. Of 844 participants who were infection-naive and had received two doses of BNT162b2 at baseline, we identified 11 breakthrough infections during the follow-up. One control matched to each case was randomly selected from those who completed the booster vaccine and those who were unboosted by the follow-up. We used the generalized estimating equation model to compare live-virus NAb against Wuhan, Delta, and Omicron across groups. ResultsPersons who experienced breakthrough infection showed marked increases in NAb titers against Wuhan (4.1-fold) and Delta (5.5-fold), and 64% had detectable NAb against Omicron at follow-up, although the NAb against Omicron after breakthrough infection was 6.7- and 5.2-fold lower than that against Wuhan and Delta, respectively. The increase was apparent only in symptomatic cases and as high as in the third vaccine recipients. In contrast, these titers largely decreased (Wuhan, Delta) or remained undetected (Omicron) at follow-up in infection-naive and unboosted persons. ConclusionsSymptomatic breakthrough infection during the Delta predominant wave was associated with significant increases in NAb against Wuhan, Delta, and Omicron, similar to the third BNT162b2 vaccine. Given the much lower cross-NAb against Omicron than other virus types, however, infection prevention measures must be continued irrespective of vaccine and infection history while the immune evasive variants are circulating. Key pointsSymptomatic, not asymptomatic, SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infection after the second BNT162b2 vaccination during the Delta-predominant wave enhanced neutralizing antibodies against Wuhan, Delta, and Omicron comparable to the three vaccine doses, although immunity against Omicron was much lower than Wuhan and Delta.