The Comparison of Medical and Surgical Treatment for Gallbladder Dyskinesia

ABSTRACT

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to compare outcomes for surgical treatment with those for medical treatment of GB dyskinesia. METHODS: Retrospective analysis of medical records and telephone interviews of 67 patients diagnosed with GB dyskinesia was done at Pohang St. Mary's Hospital between January 2004 and December 2009. Group 1 (n=18) patients received laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Group 2 (n=49) patients received medical treatment. GB dyskinesia was the diagnosis if the patient had typical biliary colic symptoms without GB stones or other GI disease, and if the ejection fraction was less than 35% on Tc-99m-DISIDA scans. RESULTS: The average age of patients diagnosed with GB dyskinesia was 45.8 years old. The sex ratio was 1552 (malefemale). The average symptom duration was 25.4 days. All had RUQ and, or epigastric pain. There were no significant between group differences in age, sex ratio, symptom duration, symptoms, follow up period, and ejection fraction. In group 1, patient symptoms improved after treatment in 16 cases (88.9%); in group 2, patient symptoms improved in 19 cases (38.8%). Surgical treatment was significantly more effective than medical treatment. The reasons for choosing medical treatment were predominantly the preference of the doctors. CONCLUSION: Surgical treatment is a more effective treatment for GB dyskinesia than medical treatment. Therefore, laparoscopic cholecystectomy should be considered as the 1st line treatment of choice for GB dyskinesia.