Comparing the Effect of Treatment on Fractures of the Clavicle by Reconstruction Plate with by Kirschner Wire / 医学研究杂志

ABSTRACT

Objective To evaluate and analyze the effect of treatment on fractures of the clavicle with reconstruction plate or with Kirschner wire.Methods Of 56 clavicular fracture cases for treatment with surgical procedures,22 cases were fixated with reconstruction plate.34 cases were fixated with Kirschner wire.Results All 56 cases were followed up for 10~48 months,on average 21 months.Reconstruction plate fixation group2 cases concomitant with delayed fracture healing were multiple trauma patients.The mean union time in this group was 3.6 months(range from 3 to 5 months).Kirschner wire fixation group3 cases with wires migration.The mean union time in this group was 2.3 months(range from 2 to 3 months).According to Kalarsson's shoulder function evaluating criteria,all cases were excellent.Conclusion Surgical technique with Kirschner wire is simple and credible treatment for clavicular uncomminuted fractures.,it complys with the conception of minimally invasive technique and is a recommendable way.