Comparison between sliding window and step and shoot / 医疗卫生装备

ABSTRACT

Objective To compare and analyze DMLC(Sliding Window,SW)and SMLC(Step and Shoot,SS)for delivering IMRT.Methods 5 patients with nasopharyngeal carcinoma were treated with radical intensity modulated radiation therapy using Varian 23EX and Helios tool on a Varian Eclipse system.Different modalities to deliver IMRT were considered for Sliding Window(SW) and Step and Shoot(SS) techniques using a different number of intensity levels(e.g.5,10 and 20).The total beam-on-time,total delivery time and a number of dose-volume parameters regarding PTV and OARs were considered.Results Comparing with the DVH,it was found that SW was the best of the four modalities in the dose distribution of PTV,but SS was better when considering the protection of OARs.The total beam-on-time(MUs) requirement for SS was 9～23% less than SW,but the total delivery time(in minutes)was about twice as long.Conclusion With the number of intensity level of 10 or more,no differences between SS and SW can be appreciated in the dose distribution of PTV and OARs sparing.Referring to the quality assurance,only leaf position needed to be checked in SS,whereas both leaf position and leaf speed need to be checked in SW,so it is proposed to use SS10 for delivering IMRT.