Comparison of two risk assessment methods to assess occupational health risk in key industries of dichloromethane in Shenzhen City / 中国职业医学

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVE: To compare the applicability of two risk assessment methods to assess the occupational health risk of key industries of dichloromethane in Shenzhen City. METHODS: The Singapore ministry of manpower risk(MOM) method and the comprehensive index method were used to evaluate the risk of 123 positions in 47 key industries of dichloromethane in Shenzhen City. Then the risk classification results of the two assessment methods were compared. RESULTS: The results of MOM method showed that the median and the 0 th to 100 th percentile [M(P_0-P_(100))] of risk of dichloromethane in electronics industry was 2(2-3), and the risk level was low to medium. The M(P_0-P_(100)) of risk of dichloromethane in printing industry was 2(2-4), and the risk level was low to high. The results of the comprehensive index method showed that the M(P_0-P_(100)) of risk of dichloromethane in electronics industry and printing industry were 3(3-4), and the risk level was medium to high. There was no significant difference in the assessment results of occupational health risk of dichloromethane between the electronic industry and the printing industry by MOM evaluation method(P>0.05). The occupational health risk assessment of dichloromethane in printing industry was higher than that in electronic industry by the comprehensive index method(P<0.01). Both evaluation methods were not consistent in the electronics industry and the printing industry(k values were-0.01 and 0.04, all P>0.05). After merging the evaluation results of the two industries, there was no consistency in the evaluation results of the two evaluation methods(k value=0.01, P>0.05). CONCLUSION: The risk level of dichloromethane in printing industry is higher than that in printing industry in Shenzhen City. The comprehensive index method may comprehensively and objectively assess the occupational health risk level of dichloromethane in key industries in Shenzhen City.