Comparison of removal torques between laser-etched and modified sandblasted acid-etched Ti implant surfaces in rabbit tibias

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to analyze the effects of two different implant surface treatments on initial bone connection by comparing the Removal Torque Values (RTQs) at 7 and 10 days after chemically modified, sandblasted, large-grit and acid-etched (modSLA), and Laser-etched (LE) Ti implant placements. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty modSLA and 20 LE implants were installed on the left and right tibias of 20 adult rabbits. RTQs were measured after 7 and 10 days in 10 rabbits each. Scanning electron microscope (SEM) photographs of the two implants were observed by using Quanta FEG 650 from the FEI company (Hillsboro, OR, USA). Analyses of surface elements and components were conducted using energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS, Horiba, Kyoto, Japan). RESULTS: The mean RTQs were 12.29 ± 0.830 and 12.19 ± 0.713 Ncm after 7 days (P=.928) and 16.47 ± 1.324 and 16.17 ± 1.165 Ncm after 10 days (P=.867) for LE and modSLA, respectively, indicating no significant inter-group differences. Pore sizes in the LE were 40 µm and consisted of numerous small pores, whereas pore sizes in the modSLA were 5 µm. In the EDS analysis, Ti, O, and C were the only three elements found in the LE surfaces. Na, Ca, Cl, and K were also observed in modSLA, in addition to Ti, O, and C. CONCLUSION: The implants showed no significant difference in biomechanical bond strength to bone in early-stage osseointegration. LE implant can be considered an excellent surface treatment method in addition to the modSLA implant and can be applied to the early loading of the prosthesis clinically.

Evaluation of the stability of sandblasted, large-grit, acid-etched implants with tapered straight body design

PURPOSE: Implant surface modification and implant design are the principle targets for achieving successful primary stability. The aim of this study was to measure implant stability quotient (ISQ) values of sandblasted, large-grit, acid-etched (SLA) implants with tapered straight body design during the healing period, and to determine the various factors affecting implant stability. MATERIALS AND METHODS: To measure implant stability, resonance frequency analysis (RFA) was performed in 26 patients (13 women and 13 men) with 44 SLA implants with tapered straight body design. Implant stability (ISQ values) was evaluated at baseline and healing abutment connection (12 weeks), and the correlations between RFA and insertion torque (IT), bone quality, and jawbone were determined. RESULTS: The mean ISQ value of the implants was 69.4 ± 10.2 at the time of implant placement (baseline) and 81.4 ± 6.9 at the time of healing abutment connection (P 0.05). CONCLUSION: ISQ values of SLA implants with tapered straight body design were high at baseline and healing abutment connection. It was concluded that SLA implants with tapered straight body design show improved primary and secondary stability, and that immediate or early loading may be applicable.

Evaluación de torque de remoción en implantes dentales 3i, B&W y tree-oss. estudio experimentalen conejos / Evaluation of removal torque in 3i, B&W and tree-oss dental implants. an experimental study in rabbits

Objetivo: evaluar el torque de remoción de tres implantes con superficies diferentes, a los 60 días de inserción. Materiales y métodos: se midió la frecuencia de resonancia inicial y final y torque de remoción a los 60 días en 18 implantes: Biomet 3i (Palm Beach Gardens, FL, Estados Unidos); n=6; B&W (Buenos Aires, Argentina), n=6; Tree-Oss (Buenos Aires, Argentina), n=6; todos de 8,5 mm de longitud y 4 mm de diámetro. Los datos fueron sometidos al test no paramétrico de Mann-Whitney, al de Kruskal-Wallis y al de Wilcoxon. Resultados: la media de torque de remoción fue de 82,58 Ncm para implantes Biomet 3i; de 78,08 Ncm para B6W; y de 69 Ncm para Tree-Oss, sin diferencias estadísticamente significativas (p=0,220). La media de ISQ inicial y final fue de 57, 17 y 70,33 para Biomet 3i; de 56,33 y 62,07 para B6W y de 58,17 y 54,5 para Tree-Oss. Conclusión: los tres grupos de implantes presentan valores de torque de remoción similares, sin diferencias estadísticamente significativas pero con diferencias significativas en relación a ISQ final.

Aim: to evaluate the removal torque of three implants with different surfaces placed in rabbit femur, 60 days afterinsertion and to compare the implant stability quotient rightafter insertion and 60 days later.Materials and methods: Initial and final resonance frequency analysis and removal torque were measured at day60, in 18 parallel wall implants: Biomet 3i (Palm Beach Gardens, FL, USA), n=6; B&W (Buenos Aires, Argentina), n=6; Tree-Oss (Buenos Aires, Argentina), n=6; of 8.5 mm in lengthand 4 mm in diameter, placed in the femur of 6 rabbits. Datacollected were analyzed by nonparametric Mann-Whitney, Kruskal-Wallis and Wilcoxon tests. Results: The mean removal torques were 82,58 Ncm forBiomet 3i, 78,08 Ncm for B&W and 69 Ncm for Tree-Oss. Differences were not statistically significant (p=0.220). Inassessing initial and final ISQ, the averages obtained for Biomet3i were 57.17 and 70.33, respectively; for B&W 56.33 and62.67, and 58.17 and 54.5 for Tree-Oss. Conclusion: It is concluded that the three groups presented similar removal torque values with no statistically significant differences between them, but there were significant differences in relation to final ISQ.

Retrospective clinical study of an implant with a sandblasted, large-grit, acid-etched surface and internal connection: analysis of short-term success rate and marginal bone loss / 대한악안면성형재건외과학회지

BACKGROUND: The purpose of this retrospective study was to evaluate the clinical utility of an implant with a sandblasted, large-grit, acid-etched (SLA) surface and internal connection. METHODS: Six patients who received dental implants in the Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Chonnam National University Dental Hospital, were analyzed by factors influencing the success rate and marginal bone loss. Factors included patient’s age, sex, implant installation site, whether bone graft was done, type of bone graft materials, approaching method if sinus lift was done, and the size of the fixture. In addition, the marginal bone loss was analyzed by using a radiograph. RESULTS: All implants were successful, and the cumulative survival rate was 100 %. Average marginal bone loss of 6 months after the installation was 0.52 mm and 20 months after the functional loading was 1.06 mm. Total marginal bone resorption was 1.58 mm on average. There was no statistically significant difference in mesial and distal marginal bone loss. CONCLUSIONS: The short-term clinical success rate of the implant with an SLA surface and internal connection was satisfactory. Moreover, the marginal bone loss was also consistent with the implant success criteria.

Titanium specimens with different surface character affect the proliferation and IL-6 and Cbfα1 expres-sion in osteoblasts / 实用口腔医学杂志

Objective:To investigate the effects of titanium spcimens with different surface character on the proliferation and mRNA expression of IL-6 and Cbfα1 in osteoblasts.Methods:Titanium surface was treated by smooth pretreatment(PT),sandblast and acid etch(SLA)and anodic oxidation(AD)respectively.The morphology and the elements analysis of the spcimens were inspected and detected by SEMand EDS.The surface contact angle was measured by contact angle meter.MC3T3-E1 cells were cultured on the titanium surface and cells cultured on tissue culture plate were served as the control group.The proliferation was measured by MTT assay.The mRNA expression of IL-6 and Cbfα1 was quantified by RT-qPCR.Results:The sample surface in PT group showed scrat-ches,in SLA group showed multiple three dimensional structure,in AD group exhibited porous structure.The elements of the sample surface of group PT,SLA and AD were Ti,Ti/Al and Ti/O respectively;the contact angles were 54.47°±3.33°,75.42°±8.32° and 38.91 °±4.00°respectively(P<0.05).The cells in AD group showed higher proliferation than those in PT and SLA groups(P<0.05).In AD group IL-6 mRNA expression decreased and Cbfα1 mRNA increased more than in PT and SLA groups(P<0.05). Conclusion:Titanium spcimens treated with AD may promote cell proliferation,decrease IL-6 mRNA expression and increase Cbfα1 mRNA expression in MC3T3 cells.Implats treated with AD might have some advantages in early osseointegration.

Effects of different surface treatments on shear bond strength of diatomite-based dental ceramic / 国际生物医学工程杂志

Objective To investigate the effects of different surface treatments on shear bond strength between diatomite-based dental ceramic and IPS e.max veneering ceramic.Methods Diatomite-based dental ceramic was randomly divided into acid-etched group,sandblasting group and untreated group,and then sintered with IPS e.max veneering ceramic,respectively.Shear bond strength were detected,and the interface microstructures and elemental distribution were observed by scanning electron microscope-energy dispersive spectrometer (SEM-EDS).Results Shear bond strength of acid-etched group was significantly higher than that of untreated group (P＜0.01).SEM observation results showed that the interface of acid-etched group bonded closely.There was no statistical difference of the shear bond strength between the sandblasting group and untreated group (P＞0.05).Conclusions Acid-etched treatment can significantly enhance the bond strength of diatomite-based dental ceramic and IPS e.max veneering ceramic.

Comparison of removal torques between laser-treated and SLA-treated implant surfaces in rabbit tibiae

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to compare removal torques and surface topography between laser treated and sandblasted, large-grit, acid-etched (SLA) treated implants. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Laser-treated implants (experimental group) and SLA-treated implants (control group) 8 mm in length and 3.4 mm in diameter were inserted into both sides of the tibiae of 12 rabbits. Surface analysis was accomplished using a field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM; Hitachi S-4800; Japan) under x25, x150 and x1,000 magnification. Surface components were analyzed using energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). Rabbits were sacrificed after a 6-week healing period. The removal torque was measured using the MGT-12 digital torque meter (Mark-10 Co., Copiague, NY, USA). RESULTS: In the experimental group, the surface analysis showed uniform porous structures under x25, x150 and x1,000 magnification. Pore sizes in the experimental group were 20-40 mm and consisted of numerous small pores, whereas pore sizes in the control group were 0.5-2.0 mm. EDS analysis showed no significant difference between the two groups. The mean removal torque in the laser-treated and the SLA-treated implant groups were 79.4 Ncm (SD = 20.4; range 34.6-104.3 Ncm) and 52.7 Ncm (SD = 17.2; range 18.7-73.8 Ncm), respectively. The removal torque in the laser-treated surface implant group was significantly higher than that in the control group (P=.004). CONCLUSION: In this study, removal torque values were significantly higher for laser-treated surface implants than for SLA-treated surface implants.

The influence of surface treatment on the implant roughness pattern

An important parameter for the clinical success of dental implants is the formation of direct contact between the implant and surrounding bone, whose quality is directly influenced by the implant surface roughness. A screw-shaped design and a surface with an average roughness of Sa of 1-2 µm showed a better result. The combination of blasting and etching has been a commonly used surface treatment technique. The versatility of this type of treatment allows for a wide variation in the procedures in order to obtain the desired roughness. OBJECTIVES: To compare the roughness values and morphological characteristics of 04 brands of implants, using the same type of surface treatment. In addition, to compare the results among brands, in order to assess whether the type of treatment determines the values and the characteristics of implant surface roughness. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Three implants were purchased directly from each selected company in the market, i.e., 03 Brazilian companies (Biomet 3i of Brazil, Neodent and Titaniumfix) and 01 Korean company (Oneplant). The quantitative or numerical characterization of the roughness was performed using an interferometer. The qualitative analysis of the surface topography obtained with the treatment was analyzed using scanning electron microscopy images. RESULTS: The evaluated implants showed a significant variation in roughness values: Sa for Oneplant was 1.01 µm; Titaniumfix reached 0.90 µm; implants from Neodent 0.67 µm, and Biomet 3i of Brazil 0.53 µm. Moreover, the SEM images showed very different patterns for the surfaces examined. CONCCLUSIONS: The surface treatment alone is not able to determine the roughness values and characteristics.

Histomorphometric study of dental implants with double acid-etched and anodic oxidized surface in the rabbit tibia

Effects of various surface treatments for titanium on surface micro roughness, static wettability, fibronectin adsorption / 대한치과보철학회지

Purpose: This study aims to get the fundamental data which is necessary to the development direction of implant surface treatment hereafter, based on the understanding the surface structure and properties of titanium which is suitable for the absorption of initial tissue fluid by researching effects of additional surface treatments for sandblasted with large grit and acid-etched(SLA) titanium on surface micro-roughness, static wettability, fibronectin adsorption. Materials and Method: In the Control groups, the commercial pure titanium disks which is 10mm in diameter and 2mm in thickness were treated with HCI after sandblasting with 50micrometer Al2O3. The experiment groups were made an experiment each by being treated with 1) 22.5% nitric acid according to SLA+ASTM F86 protocol, 2) SLA+30% peroxide, 3) SLA+NaOH, 4) SLA+Oxalic acid, and 5) SLA+600degree C heating. In each group, the value of Ra and RMS which are the gauges of surface roughness was measured, surface wettability was measured by analyzing with Sessile drop method, and fibronectin adsorption was measured with immunological assay. The significance of each group was verified by (SPSS, ver.10.0 SPSS Inc.) Kruskal-Wallis Test.(alpha=0.05) And the correlation significance between Surface micro-roughness and surface wettability, surface roughness and fibronectin adsorption, and surface wettability and fibronectin adsorption was tested by Spearman's correlation analysis. Result: All measure groups showed the significant differences in surface micro-roughness, surface wettability, and fibronectin adsorption.(p0.05) Conclusion: Surface micro-roughness and surface wettability rarely affected the absorption of initial tissue fluid on the surface of titanium.

The effects of salivary contamination of acid-etched enamel on bracket bond strength / 대한치과교정학회지

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of salivary contamination of etched enamel on shear bond strength of a bracket adhered to etched enamel. Eighty extracted human permanent premolars were used in this study. These samples were divided into two groups. Buccal surface of samples were etched in vitro with 38% phosphoric acid for 15 seconds and 60 seconds. Each group was divided into four subgroups. Etched enamel surfaces were contaminated with saliva for 0, 1, 20, 60 seconds, washed and dried. Test surfaces were examined using scanning electron microscope(SEM). The shear bond strength of each sample was determined with a universal testing instrument(lnstron Co. Model 4201). Results were as follows; 1. Salivary contamination for 1, 20, 60 seconds did not affect shear bond strength when compared with the uncontaminated enamel group. 2. There was no significant difference(P>.05) in shear bond strength between 15 sec. and 60 sec. etching in uncontaminated enamel groups. 3. When samples were examined using SEM, organic materials coated enamel surface masked the etched pattern partially.