Durability and determinants of anti-SARS-CoV-2 spike antibodies following the second and third doses of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine

BackgroundEpidemiological data regarding differences in durability and its determinants of humoral immunity following 2- and 3-dose COVID-19 vaccination are scarce. MethodsWe repeatedly assessed the anti-spike IgG antibody titers of 2- and 3-dose mRNA vaccine recipients among the staff of a medical and research center in Tokyo. Linear mixed models were used to estimate trajectories of antibody titers from 14 to 180 days after the last immune-conferred event (vaccination or infection) and compare antibody waning rates across prior infection and vaccination status, and across background factors in infection-naive participants. ResultsA total of 6901 measurements from 2964 participants (median age, 35 years; 30% male) were analyzed. Antibody waning rate (per 30 days [95% CI]) was slower after 3-dose (25% [23-26]) than 2-dose (36% [35-37]). Participants with hybrid immunity (vaccination and infection) had further slower waning rates: 2-dose plus infection (16% [9-22]); 3-dose plus infection (21% [17-25]). Older age, male sex, obesity, coexisting diseases, immunosuppressant use, smoking, and alcohol drinking were associated with lower antibody titers, whereas these associations disappeared after 3-dose, except for sex (lower in female participants) and immunosuppressant use. Antibody waning was faster in older participants, females, and alcohol drinkers after 2-dose, whereas it did not differ after 3-dose across except sex. ConclusionsThe 3-dose mRNA vaccine conferred higher durable antibody titers, and previous infection further enhanced its durability. The antibody levels at a given time point and waning speed after 2-dose differed across background factors; however, these differences mostly diminished after 3-dose.

Neutralizing antibodies following three doses of BNT162b2 vaccine, breakthrough infection, and symptoms during the Omicron predominant wave

BackgroundData on the role of immunogenicity following the third vaccine dose against Omicron infection and coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)-compatible symptoms of infection are limited. MethodsFirst we examined vaccine effectiveness (VE) of the third-dose against the second dose during the Omicron wave among the staff at a tertiary hospital in Tokyo. In a case-control study of a cohort of third vaccine recipients, we compared the pre-infection levels of live-virus neutralizing antibodies (NAb) against Omicron between breakthrough cases and their controls, who had close contact with COVID-19 patients. Among these cases, we examined the association between pre-infection NAb levels and the number of COVID-19-compatible symptoms experienced during the Omicron wave. ResultsAmong the 1456 participants for VE analysis, 60 (4%) breakthrough infections occurred during the Omicron wave (January to March 2022). The third-dose VE for infection, relative to the second dose was 54.6% (95% CI: 14.0-76.0). Among the recipients of the third vaccine, pre-infection NAb levels against Omicron did not significantly differ between the cases and controls. Among the cases, those who experienced COVID-19-compatible symptoms had lower pre-infection NAb levels against Omicron than those who did not. ConclusionsThe third vaccine dose was effective in decreasing the risk of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 infection during the Omicron wave compared with the second dose. Among third-dose recipients, higher pre-infection NAb levels may not be associated with a lower risk of Omicron infection. Contrarily, they may be associated with fewer symptoms of infection. SummaryThe third vaccine dose reduced SARS-CoV-2 infection risk during the Omicron wave. Higher neutralizing antibody levels may not reduce Omicron infection risk in third-dose patients. On the contrary, it may be associated with fewer symptoms of infection.

SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infection during the Delta-dominant epidemic and neutralizing antibodies against Omicron in comparison with the third dose of BNT162b2: a matched analysis

BackgroundLongitudinal data are lacking to compare booster effects of Delta breakthrough infection versus the third vaccine dose on neutralizing antibodies (NAb) against Omicron. MethodsParticipants were the staff of a national research and medical institution in Tokyo who attended serological surveys on June 2021 (baseline) and December 2021 (follow-up); in between, the Delta-dominant epidemic occurred. Of 844 participants who were infection-naive and had received two doses of BNT162b2 at baseline, we identified 11 breakthrough infections during the follow-up. One control matched to each case was randomly selected from those who completed the booster vaccine and those who were unboosted by the follow-up. We used the generalized estimating equation model to compare live-virus NAb against Wuhan, Delta, and Omicron across groups. ResultsPersons who experienced breakthrough infection showed marked increases in NAb titers against Wuhan (4.1-fold) and Delta (5.5-fold), and 64% had detectable NAb against Omicron at follow-up, although the NAb against Omicron after breakthrough infection was 6.7- and 5.2-fold lower than that against Wuhan and Delta, respectively. The increase was apparent only in symptomatic cases and as high as in the third vaccine recipients. In contrast, these titers largely decreased (Wuhan, Delta) or remained undetected (Omicron) at follow-up in infection-naive and unboosted persons. ConclusionsSymptomatic breakthrough infection during the Delta predominant wave was associated with significant increases in NAb against Wuhan, Delta, and Omicron, similar to the third BNT162b2 vaccine. Given the much lower cross-NAb against Omicron than other virus types, however, infection prevention measures must be continued irrespective of vaccine and infection history while the immune evasive variants are circulating. Key pointsSymptomatic, not asymptomatic, SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infection after the second BNT162b2 vaccination during the Delta-predominant wave enhanced neutralizing antibodies against Wuhan, Delta, and Omicron comparable to the three vaccine doses, although immunity against Omicron was much lower than Wuhan and Delta.

Sex-associated differences between body mass index and SARS-CoV-2 antibody titers following the BNT162b2 vaccine among 2,435 healthcare workers in Japan

Obesity may downregulate vaccine-induced immunogenicity, but the epidemiological evidence for the COVID-19 vaccine is limited, and the sex-associated difference is unknown. It was observed that a higher body mass index was associated with lower titers of spike IgG antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 in men but not in women.